
Chris Niebauer Transcript: The Left Brain Illusion of Self: Split-Brain Research, Consciousness, and Nonduality
Summary
The discussion contrasts simple conscious experience with the thinking mind, which uses language and abstractions to interpret the world. It explores how mindfulness can loosen the grip of rumination and how the distinction between thinking and consciousness matters in an age of AI.
Questions This Interview Explores
- How can I distinguish consciousness from thinking?
- Why can trying harder to control thoughts or fall asleep make the problem worse?
- How can mindfulness help with intrusive thoughts and rumination?
- What is the difference between a machine that can think and one that is conscious?
Key takeaways
- Thought is a useful tool, but it can become a source of suffering when it dominates experience.
- Language and concepts are not the same as the reality they describe.
- Mindfulness brings attention back to direct, present-moment experience.
- Trying to force the mind into calm can create more inner conflict.
- Consciousness has value beyond intelligence, productivity, or problem-solving.
Transcript
Rick: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer. Buddha at the Gas Pump is an ongoing series of conversations with spiritually awakening people. We’ve done nearly 700 of them now, and if this is new to you and you’d like to check out previous ones, please go to batgap.com, B-A-T-G-A-P, and look under the Past Interviews menu.
This program is made possible through the support of appreciative listeners and viewers. So, if you appreciate it and would like to help support it, there are PayPal buttons on the site, and there’s a page explaining alternatives to PayPal.
Another thing that I’ve been announcing lately with good results is that I’m working on a project to get properly proofread transcripts of all the BATGAP interviews. I’ve got a growing team of volunteers who’ve been helping with this, and I’m using some AI-based software that’s really accurate, called Whisper. It’s made by the same people who make ChatGPT, but it still needs a little proofreading after Whisper generates the transcript.
One of the main motivations for doing this is that YouTube now translates subtitles into over 100 languages. If you have subtitles, then obviously they need to be accurate for it to do a good job. So, if you feel like helping with that, get in touch. People say it’s kind of fun.
All right. My guest today is Chris Niebauer. Chris earned his PhD in cognitive neuropsychology at the University of Toledo, specializing in the differences between the left and right sides of the human brain. He is the author of No Self, No Problem: How Neuropsychology Is Catching Up to Buddhism and the No Self, No Problem Workbook: Exercises and Practices from Neuropsychology and Buddhism to Help You Lose Your Mind.
I read—or rather, listened to—both books in the last couple of weeks, and obviously I’ve lost my mind. He was a professor at a state university in Pennsylvania for 22 years, where he taught courses on consciousness, mindfulness, left- and right-brain differences, and artificial intelligence. His website is chrisneibauerphd.com. Don’t worry about the spelling; I’ll put a link to it on his page at batgap.com.
Oh, and one other little housekeeping point. My video editor, who is a lot younger than me, reminds me that it’s really good for the popularity of one’s YouTube channel if people like and subscribe. So, if you like these videos, like them. Click the little thumbs-up button. And if you like the channel in general, please subscribe. We reached 100,000 subscribers a few weeks ago, or maybe a month ago. So that was nice. Google sent me a little plaque.
Okay, so here we go. Chris, welcome.
Chris: Hey, Rick. Nice to be here. Thanks.
Rick: Yeah, I very much enjoyed listening to your books. Also, you have hundreds of short videos on your YouTube channel, sometimes two or three minutes, sometimes 10 minutes, and I listened to many of those. As is my habit, I was listening while riding my bike, washing the dishes, walking in the woods, cutting the grass, so I didn’t take a lot of notes. But I have a feeling we’re just going to fill up two hours very easily with an interesting conversation.
You were telling me before we started recording that your style is very impromptu as well, and you just kind of like to wing it, and good things come out. So let’s wing it.
Chris: Sounds good.
Rick: Okay. So why don’t you just start by giving us a synopsis of what lights your fire? What interests you, based upon everything you’ve learned over the years and the kinds of things you talk about on your YouTube channel and so on? Then we’ll use that as a springboard.
Chris: Sure. I’ve always been interested in consciousness, even as an undergrad. Before consciousness was really popular—I don’t know if you might remember—it would get maybe one chapter. If you found the right introduction to a psychology book, the right one, you’d have to search, and then it would have one chapter on consciousness.
One of the things I think is probably the main confusion in this area is confusing thinking—the thinking mind, which is so dependent on language—with raw consciousness, just simple consciousness, that can’t avoid a thought. That’s been something I’ve been pursuing, and I’m actually working on another book right now that talks about these two worlds we live in.
Abstract Thinking and Direct Conscious Experience
One is the abstract world of thinking, and it creates all kinds of interesting abstractions that we often mistake for being real: things like governments and workplaces and universities. These are all just abstract concepts. Then there’s what I would call the real world, which is very simple conscious experiences. One of the reasons [inaudible] and mindfulness are so powerful is that they get us out of the thinking, abstract world and bring us back to something that is so powerful and joyful, and that is these simple conscious experiences.
So many of us start our day having a sip of tea, and that gets us set up so we can go into these abstract worlds of work and politics and sort of deal with them. So that’s what I’ve been working on pretty recently.
Rick: Yeah, I’ve been interested in consciousness most of my life, too, and meditating for a long time, as you have. I remember in one of your books—or maybe it was one of your YouTube videos—you mentioned a book by Daniel Dennett that was supposed to be all about consciousness. As I think you said, it turned out to be a bit disappointing because it was really all about thinking and really nothing much about consciousness.
In fact, I don’t even know if he would regard consciousness as remotely what I think you and I would agree it probably is, which is fundamental, not merely a product of the brain.
Chris: I used to bring that into my class, and this goes all the way back to the ’90s, when I was still in grad school. We had a seminar on his book. What a wonderful title, Consciousness Explained. I remember being a kid on Christmas morning. I was like, “This has got to be the best.” I couldn’t wait to get into it.
Then I was met with one disappointment after another, because if he had called it Thinking Explained, it would have been a perfect book. It really got into psychology and neuropsychology, and it really did take thinking apart about as well as you could at the time. But again, he dismissed consciousness, and I think what he really wanted to dismiss was thinking.
You could see it, and I think you’ve got the most profound example of confusing thinking and consciousness, which we see so often in Western science. I use that often as the most profound example of confusing thinking and consciousness. If you dismiss consciousness, which, like you just said, is so fundamental and so simple in some ways, that’s where we’re going when we meditate. That’s where we’re going when we practice mindfulness. I mean, mindfulness and meditation overlap, if they’re not the exact same thing, because they’re getting us out of that thinking mind and into what we might call simple conscious experiences, often sensory experiences.
Rick: I think Daniel Dennett is considered one of the so-called “four horsemen,” along with Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, and who was the other guy? I don’t know, one other. They’re all these sort of neo-atheists, and they think that basically, when your body dies, that’s it. Kaput. There’s nothing that outlasts it.
Therefore, they would assume consciousness is not a foundational thing in the universe, but rather a product of the brain. But anyway, that’s a bit of a tangent. I think one really good way of understanding or commenting on Daniel Dennett’s point is that obviously thinking and all the things we perceive are things we’re conscious of. They are not consciousness itself. Without consciousness, we wouldn’t be aware of them.
You make a good point here and there in your books. You said to your students, if they could be given a choice between being a multimillionaire or being conscious, but they couldn’t have both, which would they choose?
Chris: Yeah, for 20 years now. It’s one of those questions I could ask students, and it comes up on podcasts. It’s a great thing to ponder because it helps us become grateful for something we already have. We are already conscious, and we recognize that there’s nothing you could tempt me with. You could give me all the money, all the power, and I still wouldn’t trade my consciousness for it. I wouldn’t become a zombie. I’d be a billionaire zombie because I realized that consciousness is the most valuable thing.
It’s a question that gets people to reevaluate how important thinking is versus consciousness. Consciousness is at the base of what it means not just to be human, because I think plenty of other species are conscious, but it actually does define the human experience.
Rick: And the mosquito experience. I mean, any experience.
Chris: But we’ve trivialized consciousness. I don’t think it’s a coincidence that neuroscientists became obsessed with zombies. Every consciousness book pondered the zombie question because it helped shine a light on what was really valuable.
But there’s still this kind of conflict between, “What if I could be a genius?” We still, particularly in Western society, value intelligence so much. So it gets a little bit trickier when you’re like, “Okay, well, what if I made you an Einstein? You had this ability to think at the highest level of thought.” You can see people getting tempted because we’ve been taught to value thinking—the classic Descartes, “I think, therefore I am,” where our existence itself was defined by thinking.
At the core, we still value that so much that it becomes very tempting to become a genius, even if it’s at the cost of our own happiness. There’s an old TV show your listeners might be familiar with, House. I always liked House because it’s such an interesting—
Rick: Yeah. Hugh Laurie. That was great.
Chris: Yeah, because he was a genius, but he was addicted to drugs. He was miserable.
Rick: Yeah, he was kind of a dick.
Chris: He was. But over the years, when I would ask students, it was very easy to tempt them. They would much rather be House than someone who was intellectually average but very happy. And that puts a very interesting question on the table. What do we really value? Would we rather be happy, or intelligent but miserable, or maybe just average intelligence but really at peace?
Rick: Okay, a couple of thoughts in there. One is, I mean, I don’t think they’re actual zombies. But if they were, even the zombies you see in zombie movies, they’ve got to be conscious because otherwise they wouldn’t be able to perceive. Well, I don’t know. That’s a good question.
There are these robots, you know, that Boston—what is it? Boston Analytics? They can dance and do backflips and all this stuff. But I guess you could argue they are not conscious, obviously. So is that what a zombie would be? A human body that is dead and therefore not conscious, but somehow functioning the way a robot functions?
Artificial Intelligence and the Value of Consciousness
Chris: I think that’s an amazing question that we really need to ponder right now, because humans have dominated the thinking sphere of the planet for 50,000 years. We’ve been at the top of the thinking chain. And suddenly AI comes along, and now it can outthink us. But the question is: Is it conscious? AI was actually beating us at strategy games like chess back in the ’80s. We just can’t compete in terms of thinking anymore. So now we’ve got to reach a little deeper. Maybe that puts the spotlight back on consciousness. So, are we conscious? Is AI conscious? I don’t really know. I think that’s a really good question.
If you go back to Turing, to Alan Turing’s original paper on computer machinery and intelligence, he was so far ahead of his time. You can find the paper online. It’s free; you can download it. The question he asked is, “Can a machine think?” There’s a place where he talks about objections, and he even made the distinction between thinking and consciousness back in the ’50s. He said the question he was asking was, “Can a machine think?” And he said, “Well, is a machine conscious?” He said that’s a whole different question, and he sort of avoided it. He avoided answering it, but he recognized that it was a completely different question to ask.
I think that’s where we’re at right now. Because if we lose the thinking challenge, then where does consciousness come up? And if you look at what I do with my books, what is No Self, No Problem really about? What is the workbook really about? They’re about us going beyond our obsession with thinking and recognizing that our human existence is so much richer, so much fuller than simply thinking all the time.
Rick: I think what might be useful at this point is to throw in a little Advaita Vedanta. Obviously, Advaita Vedanta has been around for a long time, but these days, exponents of it often use the movie-screen analogy: consciousness is like the movie screen, and all the experiences we have are like the images projected onto the screen. You can have the screen without the images, but you can’t have the images without the screen.
With regard to robots and machines and so on, I guess the question—and Advaita would add that consciousness is fundamental—is that Brahman, existence, consciousness, bliss, which gets into the happiness question that we’ll talk more about, is this totality, really. If we want to think of it that way, it’s the substratum, or basis, or foundation of the universe, and everything else is an appearance. So if we want to ask if a machine can be conscious, what we’re asking, essentially, I think, is—we would say that a machine is consciousness because everything is consciousness. A rock is consciousness, which probably doesn’t know that it’s conscious.
You have to have a sophisticated instrument for self-referral, for recognition of one’s being conscious. Even an amoeba behaves that way. Maybe the amoeba doesn’t know it’s conscious, but it is conscious because it can avoid unpleasant things and seek out food, and so on. I’m talking a little bit too long, and you might say, “Well, we could train a machine to do that, too.” So what would be the difference between an amoeba and a machine that can seek out and avoid things?
I’ll wrap this up. What I’m trying to get at is that everything is consciousness, but as things evolve, they become more and more capable of reflecting consciousness, of being a sense organ of the infinite, if you will. At a certain stage, particularly the human stage, one can realize one’s essential nature and live in that realization while still functioning as an individual. That would be sort of the apex of evolution, in a way, or at least a very significant milestone. Anyway, there are a bunch of thoughts in there, and I could say more, but I better stop and let you respond.
Chris: Well, what really separates us—and again, if you look at the human species, Homo sapiens—I mean, we’ve been on the planet for what, 200,000 or 300,000 years? There are all kinds of different forms of humans. I mean, Homo erectus, Neanderthals, and then people who’ve had DNA tests are surprised. They’re like, “Wow, there were maybe eight different forms of humanity on the planet at the same time.” Then Homo sapiens won out. No one’s really sure why. One hypothesis is that we started to think.
What we typically engage in—this linguistic problem-solving, what I associate with the left side of the brain—kicked in about 50,000 years ago and really set us on a different path. I really enjoyed that. If you’ve ever seen 2001: A Space Odyssey, I think it fits so well with our ancestors. They’re at a water source, and some other group comes along and kicks them out of the area. One of them is sitting there and thinking for the very first time. And the very first thought was, “That’s a bone, but maybe I could use that bone as a weapon.” That’s exactly what he did. He took that bone and got the water source back. But then he throws the bone into space, and all of a sudden it becomes the satellite.
I thought that was a brilliant way of showing that the same thing our ancestors did—we’re taking the world and we’re able to use thought to create something that it wasn’t even intended to be. That’s, in a way, a very interesting form of creativity. But in another way, it’s taking reality and changing it into something it isn’t. That’s what the left side of the brain seems to excel at. That’s what thinking seems to be; its primary goal is to take the world and change it into something it isn’t.
So we’ve got language, and it’s a wonderful tool because we’re using it right now to communicate. That’s something we wouldn’t want to get rid of. But there’s a tipping point somewhere, and it may have been about 200 years ago, when we weren’t using thinking as a tool anymore. Thinking became an end unto itself. All of a sudden, language started to replace reality itself. So right now, I would say that our left-brain culture embraces language over reality.
And then, of course, we’ve got the whole Zen movement, which has reminded us over and over again that a finger pointing to the moon isn’t the moon. You can see how we’ve gone so far that language has become dominant and is even overtaking reality itself. But we’ve also observed the countermeasures: practices of meditation and mindfulness to help bring us back to the real world rather than thinking about it.
The Inner Voice and Rumination
When I do videos, or when I would do my mindfulness class, one of the main problems I’ve really watched escalate over the last 20 years is that inner voice, that voice in the head. People aren’t using it as a tool any longer. Instead of being a tool that you can use for maybe an hour a day to solve specific problems, it keeps you up at night. All of a sudden, you can’t sleep because it just keeps ruminating over something that might happen.
When I would do a video about intrusive thoughts, I would watch the views double. If you look at how many books are out right now, they’re all about how we deal with intrusive thoughts. This wonderful tool that we invented—but now it’s become a tool that’s using us. We’re getting lost in words and valuing words over reality itself. In my work, what I try to do is bring back a little bit of balance.
Alan Watts was very influential for me. I think he summed up the dilemma of Western society when he said, “A person who thinks all the time thinks nothing but thoughts. They live in a world of illusion.” That captures our existence, our modern existence, where we live more in this left-brain loop of repetitive thoughts than we do in reality. I think that explains the interest in mindfulness and meditation now.
Rick: Yeah. You may be aware that the Yoga Sutras define thinking as sort of an excitation of consciousness, the chitta vrittis. Chitta means mind, and vrittis are like excitations or fluctuations. The second verse of the Yoga Sutras says that yoga, or union, or samadhi, is the cessation of these fluctuations. In other words, the mind settles down and becomes less excited.
But why is the mind excited all the time to begin with? Obviously, in today’s society we’re bombarded. There’s a lot coming at us all the time, all sorts of stimulation that even a couple hundred years ago people couldn’t have dreamed of. It gets very deeply ingrained, which is another ancient concept: we have impressions, or samskaras, that have been created by our experiences and get lodged in the nervous system. They result in a sort of action-impression-desire cycle that just keeps us spinning on the hamster wheel of mental excitation, chasing after things, reinforcing those impressions, and so on and so on.
What you’re getting at with mindfulness, and what other meditation-type techniques attempt to do, is break that cycle and allow the mind to settle down to a state of quiescence, where there aren’t inappropriate or unnecessary fluctuations or excitations. Then the aim is to integrate and stabilize such a state so that you can be engaged in activity while still maintaining inner silence. There’s no conflict there once the integration has been accomplished.
⛰️ Letting go of the struggle with thought
Chris: Most people ask, “Well, how do you get this going? What’s the starting point?” In the workbook, I was very specific about that. We hear so many stories of instantaneous enlightenment, and I think that probably isn’t very useful.
Rick: It’s not very common.
Chris: Yeah, it isn’t very common, but I remember when The Power of Now became popular. Of course, it puts this amazing spiritual carrot in front of everyone because he really transformed. It was an overnight transformation, and then that becomes very desirable. It actually influenced me. I did a self-published first book, and it was very much all about forgetting—just forgetting enlightenment altogether. I called it The Neurotic’s Guide to Avoiding Enlightenment. So it was this idea of, like, if you’re in the spiritual class, and what it reflected was my own mistakes.
I often tell people that in my early 20s, I was just an absolute neurotic mess, and that voice in the head was torturous. It created so much suffering, and the harder I tried to get out of it, the deeper I actually got into it. That was really my first insight about how the mind works. It’s nothing that you would find in many intro to psych books, or even advanced psych books. I stumbled across a very few people who talked about this kind of oppositional force that the mind operates on. Alan Watts talked about it; all the talks we talked about it, but it really wasn’t very much. And Viktor Frankl mentioned something about our pursuit of happiness toward happiness itself.
Suddenly, it was a very important mechanism of the mind that I wanted to get people to recognize. If I say, “Don’t think of the number 13,” then the number 13 comes up. But this happens to us so often. You have to get up early in the morning for a big, important interview, and you’re lying in bed, and all of a sudden you can’t sleep. The harder you try to sleep, the more you’re up all night. Then it’s New Year’s, and you’re trying to stay up till midnight, and you fall asleep at 10. At least I do.
But this is a very important part of the architecture of how the mind operates. You get this inner conflict of people pushing the mind around with the mind, and trying to meditate: “You must be calm, you must…” My students know this: I was always telling them to have a good day. And I was sort of like, “Well, let’s not put any pressure on it. Let’s just have the day we’re going to have.” So my students would start saying, “Have a day. The day you have is the day you’re going to have.”
You can see this was all tied into that kind of happiness movement that started in the ’60s in psychology, where there’s this quest to really embrace the positive emotions, but somehow we’re going to trick the system. We’re going to somehow get rid of all emotions and just experience the positives. The harder I tried to make that happen, the deeper I suffered, the more I got into my neurosis.
How Resistance Can Fuel Anxiety
When I discovered that—and I can remember this—it was just an epiphany. I discovered that it was my not wanting to be neurotic that literally was my neuroticism. Me not wanting to be anxious was my anxiety. That absolutely floored me when I realized that the best thing I could possibly do was give up on it.
When I discovered that—and I can remember this—it was just an epiphany. I discovered that it was my not wanting to be neurotic that literally was my neuroticism. Me not wanting to be anxious was my anxiety. That absolutely floored me when I realized that the best thing I could possibly do was give up on it.
Rick: Yeah. I think you were quoting Alan Watts or somebody, but maybe you made up this analogy. I think you used the analogy of water that’s wavy: you’re not going to get the waves to settle down by pushing on them. That’s just going to create more waves. I think it works that way with the mind, too. I think the mind moves around for a reason. It’s seeking happiness. All the ancient scriptures say that there’s a great reservoir of happiness deep within us. If we could somehow allow the mind to turn in that direction, it could effortlessly move inward and settle down. But there’s a trick to that: you can’t force it.
Chris: And this is the situation so many of us find ourselves in in Western culture, where we’re trying to fix a thinking problem with more thinking.
Rick: Right.
And you can’t fix a thinking problem with more thinking. In the books, what I try to do is throw so many different non-thinking forms of consciousness at people. This is what we do in class, in the mindfulness class: you explore. I always thought of it as a buffet. Here are all these different modes of consciousness that are not based on thinking. Find one that you really enjoy.
Chris: And you can’t fix a thinking problem with more thinking. In the books, what I try to do is throw so many different non-thinking forms of consciousness at people. This is what we do in class, in the mindfulness class: you explore. I always thought of it as a buffet. Here are all these different modes of consciousness that are not based on thinking. Find one that you really enjoy.
Because if you’re doing yoga but you’re running some mental movie about what you’re going to do over the weekend, well, that’s not yoga. It doesn’t matter what form you’re doing or what position your body’s in. Yoga is the awareness of being in the body at that moment without thought. That’s where the union comes in, because that connects you to consciousness.
That’s really what I’ve been doing. Once I discovered that you can’t fix a thinking problem with more thinking, it instantly unplugged the whole loop. It just unplugged the whole thing. I think I had a moment of peace for the first time in years, and I thought, “Well, this is very interesting. This seems to be a very interesting trick that I had discovered.” Of course, lots of people had discovered it. But that was the problem I was having with meditation. When I would start meditating, I kept thinking, “How am I going to stop myself from thinking? How am I going to…”
You can’t fix a thinking problem with more thinking.
Rick: Yeah. I mean, if that’s how you’ve been instructed to meditate, or if you cooked up your own kind of meditation and you have this bias against having thoughts, you’re going to be frustrated, because thoughts will arise. But there are ways of meditating where that’s not a problem.
I’m thinking also of examples of athletes who aren’t doing a whole lot of thinking. LeBron James or Mikaela Shiffrin, or somebody else at the top of their game. They’re not intellectualizing their way around the basketball court or down the ski slope. I think this is an interesting question. Comment on that, and then I’ll throw something back at you, if you wish.
Chris: Yeah, it just reminded me of my son, who’s been—in fact, he’s at a soccer game right now. He’s obsessed with soccer, and it’s all good. He knows, we’ve talked about it, that the best game he plays is when he’s not thinking about it. I remember the coach’s very passionate little speech before the game, and he ended it with, “No mental mistakes.” I thought, “Oh my goodness, they’re doomed now.” The more you’re focused on not making a mental mistake, the less you’re focused on the actual game.
One of the things I would do with my class is body scanning. The students love it; so many of them love body scanning. It’s just simple body awareness. But we don’t do it very often because that person is mostly caught up here in that left-brain voice in the head.
Of course, that’s essential to sports: to stop thinking about it. If you’re caught up in thinking about it, you’re not doing it. So many of the brilliant people in sports are simply not thinking. They call it being in the zone. That’s why the saying is, “Just do it. Don’t think about it.” But it’s a tricky thing, because if you go out there and think you can stop thinking by thinking about how to stop thinking, then it gets you caught in a whole different loop.
I studied martial arts my whole life. So many times, I was confronted with a situation where I thought, “How do I stop thinking? If I could just be here instead…” And it’s a lot more difficult when people are throwing kicks at you and you’re trying to avoid the kicks. You know that the best moves you’ve ever had are the ones that came from a greater source of intelligence, rather than this thinking mind.
But the trick is, the thinking… There was this old— I was lost one time, and I stopped to get directions, and the person said, “You can’t get there from here.” I just started laughing. But there’s a certain sense of truth to that. When we talk about how to get out of the thinking mind, you can’t get out of thinking with more thinking.
I think that for so many of us, particularly in Western culture, if you do study—I became particularly interested in the Pirahã, a very small group in an Amazon rainforest that lives almost as close to our ancestors as we could possibly imagine. They’re hunter-gatherers, and there are so many remarkable things about them. When Westerners observe them, they’re by far the happiest people on the planet, in terms of just smiling and laughing. That’s very fascinating, because they’re confronted with horrific things that most of us couldn’t tolerate: disease, death, people around them dying. It’s commonplace for someone to die early. And yet they’re the happiest people on the planet.
In a way, it almost became, “Why aren’t we studying these people more?” They seem to hold some secret. If they hold any secret, it’s that they simply are not obsessed with thought. In fact, so much of our culture in Western society is such that we couldn’t even imagine a world without numbers. Numbers are everywhere. You go to work, and there are numbers; we have numbers for time; houses have numbers; we’re looking at our phones, and they’re filled with numbers.
The interesting thing about them is they don’t have numbers. They’re so resistant to thinking that all the abstract things in our world simply don’t exist for them. Dan Everett, one of the people who studied them, tried to get them to count to 10. The adults in the village couldn’t learn it after about eight months of trying—a very simple task, something we would literally take for granted as one of the things we could learn. The idea of thinking in terms of numbers and abstractions was so unusual to them.
We don’t really get how numbers are incredible abstractions. Even something like three: I can’t become conscious of three itself. I can become conscious of examples of three, but not in its abstract sense. And yet these abstractions pervade our culture. If a workplace had to not use numbers for a day, the whole place would probably… When I was a professor, it was always numbers: student ratings are how we judge things. You can go on Amazon and ask, “What’s your rating of the book? Is it 4.7? Is it 4…?”
Our obsession with this abstraction has taken us away, I think, from the real world. When you see examples of this in cultures like the Pirahã, the trick is using the mind sparingly, thinking when you need to. You’ll probably only need to think a couple of hours a day, I would guess, at best. I think a couple of hours a day would be fine for the average Westerner.
Rick: Well, some interesting points here. I remember you talking about that tribe in the book. Originally, some Christian missionary discovered them or something and went in there to try to convert them to Christianity. They asked him, “Well, have you met Jesus?” And he said, “No.” “Do you know anybody who has met Jesus?” He said, “No.” I don’t suppose they could even conceive of 2,000 years ago because they lived so much in the present. Then he ended up leaving Christianity because of the impression they had made upon him.
But, you know, obviously we live in a very complex world, and most of us aren’t going to run off and live in the rainforest. Hopefully, we are not going to dismantle our society to the point where it becomes that “primitive.” Again, I don’t mean to use that as a pejorative term, but Pandora’s box has been opened, and we know so much, and we have all these technologies. I don’t think we’re going to abandon them.
So the trick is, you know, how can we become as innocent as babes? Or, to quote Jesus, “Except ye be as little children, ye shall not enter the kingdom of heaven.” How can we do that while living in such a complex, demanding world? I think it can be done. I’m just asking the question here.
Chris: Yeah, I mean, that’s the trick. We’re not going to—okay, I’m sitting in this structure, so protected, and I’ve got food. I could walk 10 feet to a refrigerator filled with food, so I don’t have to go out into the woods and hunt. Clearly, we can’t go back to this state. So the real trick is: How do we find some middle path?
To me, again, anytime I do a long lecture, I always start off with the recognition of all the tricks of the left brain. The trick of the left brain is confusing the map for the territory. That’s how the left brain works. It gets us to confuse the word with the actual thing, and that’s why words can be so powerful. But words are only powerful if you mistake them for something real.
Of course, the left brain—I go into this with split-brain patients, and a number of other types of patients, particularly people with right-brain strokes—and it just shows the left brain’s capacity to tell stories. We are such a storytelling society. It’s such a facet of our culture. It’s like the fish in the ocean: We don’t even see the ocean. And yet stories permeate every aspect of our existence in this particular society.
Again, to contrast that with the Pirahã, they don’t tell stories. They’re not storytellers; they don’t tell their kids stories; they have no creation myths. They’re so in the here and now that they don’t get distracted by this kind of seductive storytelling ability of the left brain.
So what do we do? One of the things you can try to do—and I have a bunch of different exercises, because I think it’s much more important to experience these things than to philosophize about them—is recognize this. Sometimes I call it Mind 1.0, this left-hemisphere program that we’ve got running, and recognize its infinite capacity for storytelling.
If you just go out in public and walk around the grocery store, you can start observing that voice in the head, reading all these stories about everyone around you. Like, “That person is poor,” “That person looks like they’re rich,” “That person looks happy,” “That person looks like they might be mad at me.” It just goes on.
Observing the Left-Brain Interpreter
The trick, and really the goal of what I do, and a lot of other people, and I think it’s actually very close to what we might call spirituality, is to become the watchers, become the observers of these stories. Michael Gazzaniga, who did all the split-brain research, called the left brain the interpreter. This interpretive device is always linguistic, so that’s the voice in the head. It’s on from morning to night, and it’s trying to predict the future. It’s really a survival mechanism. It’s very effective—at least, it was right just enough to keep our species alive, to allow us to survive.
But it’s also wrong. It’s wrong so often. For a lot of us, we forget the misses, and we only remember the hits. As a very first practice, I have students, over the entire semester, keep a journal. Anytime they have some intrusive thought, it’s this interpreter saying, “Okay, here’s what’s going to happen tomorrow at work. I know that email I sent upset my boss, and he’s going to be so mad at me.” That’s the world so many of us live in, and we take those thoughts so seriously.
Over the course of the semester, we would give all those thoughts a confidence rating: How sure are you about this? You’ve got these medical tests, and you’re worried about them. How sure are you that those thoughts are accurate? By the end of the semester, we would look at their accuracy. The highest accuracy was about 50%, and some people were at 20%. These thoughts, this predictive mechanism in our left brain, are wrong far more often than they’re right.
So, you know, when you go to a doctor and you say, “Oh, that person is rich,” they could be poor. You don’t know. That Mercedes could mean they’re in debt. You just never know. In becoming the observer of this left-brain interpreter, you become more like what they have in the East: the “I don’t know” mind, the “I don’t know” consciousness.
To me, that was a really important first step, particularly for students who, again, are 20-year-olds and seem to be experiencing perhaps an unprecedented level of anxiety. It could be related to things like COVID and the pandemic and all this, but it could be other factors. It could be the seriousness with which we take these left-brain interpretations.
Even after all these years of meditating and exploring, the left-brain interpreter hasn’t changed very much. It still does its thing. It’s just that I don’t take it seriously at all. I mean, I rarely listen to it. I find myself laughing at it more often than anything, because it’s so simplistic.
The left brain usually focuses on one variable. When you get into how the left and right brain have been characterized, the left brain is a serial processor. That’s so characteristic of language: serial, one thing at a time. That’s the way we talk. I can’t talk if I say 10 words all at once; it would be confusing. So it’s really useful that language is organized around one thing, one thought at a time. That’s the way the left brain works.
The right brain is a parallel processor. It’s doing multiple things; its attention is far more vast and capable of processing multiple things at once. So when we get into these interpretations, they’re often so simplistic, and they don’t capture reality at all. They’re like cartoon versions of reality. The more you start to see that, the more absurd these interpretations become. Then it becomes very natural to take them less seriously.
That’s the program I have in these books. It’s all about coming up with ways to recognize this. Again, I liken it to a computer program because it’s so automatic. You could do really simple things to prove this. You could say, “I’m going to say a pattern, but in your head, don’t complete it.” And I say, “Three, two,” and people just heard “one.” That automatic aspect of it is tied in with our automatic judgments of people.
We see someone and think, “That person looks very confident,” or “That person looks insecure,” or “They seem like an extrovert or an introvert.” It’s always this cartoon-like, simplistic judgment. Some people claim that has stopped. I think it was Gary Weber, maybe, who has a couple of really nice videos where the whole voice just quit—no voice in the head at all—and he just uses it whenever it’s appropriate. He was worried: How is this going to work? We’re so used to having it go 24/7.
People like that are evidence. Jill Bolte Taylor was just a wonderful example. Even though she had to go through a stroke to show the world what happens when the left brain goes down, everything changed. It was a radical shift from left-brain chatter in the head, judgment, and worry to this state of nirvana, where she saw the connections, felt the peace, and everything seemed to be right. That shift from the left to the right hemisphere doesn’t have to be huge or dramatic. It can be really, really just a tiny little shift, I think, and we’d be in far better shape.
Rick: Yeah, I interviewed Gary about 10 years ago. I think he lives in Pennsylvania, actually, somewhere around Hershey or someplace. We hung out a little bit at one of the SAND conferences.
My sticking point with him is that he was emphatic that he hadn’t really had a thought ever since the day he was doing a shoulder stand or some asana, and his mind stopped. I said, “Gary, you’re talking to me. You must be having thoughts that precede your words.”
That links back to something I was going to suggest about 10 minutes ago, which is that if I raise my arm, there was a thought that preceded that. Now, it’s not an intellectual thought: “I think I’ll raise my arm now. Okay, here we go.” Up it goes. You don’t do all that, but there is some kind of mental impulse that gives rise to the physical action.
I think what happens to people is that there are way too many mental machinations going on all the time, unnecessarily. Like we were referring to with athletes, you can do most things quite spontaneously without a whole lot of cogitation. The mind can be cultured to function that way—to do less and accomplish more, perhaps, or to abide by nature’s principle of least action.
People’s minds are too excited, and there can be a culturing where the mind becomes very still. You feel like you’re just resting in silence, and yet you might be dynamically active—driving, talking to people, running through a busy airport, or whatever. So, okay, there’s that point. I forget what the other points are, but I’ll let you comment on that.
Chris: Well, another issue with the left brain, which comes about through a couple of different observations with split-brain patients, but also patients with right brain damage, is that the left brain needs to be right. This need to be right means it doesn’t even question whether it’s right; it just absolutely assumes it is. And so, when the left brain created these stories—just to go back to the split-brain patients—again, this is a condition where, you know, most of us have two very different sides to the brain, but they’re interconnected by 100 million nerve fibers. In these split-brain patients, they had severed those fibers, disconnecting the two sides.
That may sound really strange, that we have two very different mental processing centers. But, on the other hand, a lot of us make comments that sound like this. We say, “Well, part of me wants this new job, but part of me doesn’t.” That sounds kind of strange. But when you think about it, well, you know, we have two—really, two brains—and they’re very different anatomically. They process the world in really different ways. So maybe it doesn’t seem that strange that we may say, “Part of me likes this relationship, and another part of me doesn’t.”
When they isolated the two sides of the brain, the left brain was responsible for most of language, certainly the generation of speech. They would give commands to the right brain. They’d give a command to the right brain, something simple like “stand,” and the patient would stand. Now, the left brain was totally in the dark about why we just got up. But it made the story up. The ease with which the left brain created these stories, and the believability of the story, meant that the left brain was totally confident that I stood up because, you know, my leg fell asleep and I needed to stretch. That was totally wrong. The real reason was that a command went to the right brain to stand.
At best, the left brain should have said, “I don’t know. I’m clueless.” But you don’t see us humans doing that. We don’t. We rarely get into that “I don’t know” mind and “I don’t know” state. The left brain creates a story, and we believe it.
Now, it’s even more radical in a different group of patients. The right brain, which usually keeps the left brain’s stories in line, has been referred to as the devil’s advocate or the anomaly detector. These left brain stories are kept in a reality check, to some extent, by the right brain. But in patients who have right brain damage, the left brain is free to create story after story. The point I’m trying to make is that it’s absolutely confident in those stories, and absolutely certain that it’s right.
When people have right brain damage, particularly to this level—and remember, the brain is cross-wired to the body, so the right brain processes, monitors, and controls the left half of the body—they’ve had a right brain injury. Now the whole left side of their body is paralyzed. You can ask these patients questions like, “Well, can you raise your left hand?” And they’ll say, “Well, I could, but I don’t feel like it.” The left brain is making up a story, totally confident, and not in touch with reality at all. The real reason, or the real explanation, is, “No, I can’t. I’m paralyzed.”
It went so far—and this is from a well-known neuroscientist, V.S. Ramachandran, who documented these cases. In one case, he said, “Well, point to me using your left hand. Point to my face.” The patient hallucinated. She actually had a hallucination. She said, “Dr. Ramachandran, my finger—can’t you see it? I’m pointing to your face right now.” Of course, her paralyzed hand was there the whole time. But her story was so inventive, and she believed it to such a profound level, that she hallucinated to corroborate the story.
So, when we get back to dealing with day-to-day life and how we get along with others, which is obviously an issue, the recognition that there is a part of you in the left brain that makes up stories, is absolutely convinced that it’s right, and never questions them can be incredibly liberating. How do we deal with differences of beliefs? We all have these left brain beliefs, but we’re not all in agreement. How do we coexist? One way, of course, is to get into these fascinating debates. But again, to go back to the point about these stories, you simply don’t take them too seriously.
My daughter’s in college right now, and we go through some wonderful debates. I always think it’s important to debate someone that you love because, you know, it’s going to keep that connection, and it helps you realize, “Look, these are just stories my left brain is telling. I’m not going to take them too seriously.” So we can have some really fun discussions. On the surface, it may look like we’re getting into a deep argument, but it’s never met with that left brain seriousness. It’s always playful.
I think if you were going to really characterize the left and right sides of the brain, the left brain takes things seriously, and that’s why language works so well: we take it seriously. The right brain is so much more playful. It’s so much less literal. This is why it has metaphor and sarcasm. Sarcasm is such a great example of, like, yes, there’s this thing happening, but I’m not taking that seriously. I’m not taking that literally.
So, how do we coexist when we have this tendency to be captivated by this left brain loop? Again, small steps: observe the interpreter, recognize that it’s not who you are. The biggest mistake we can make is to think that we are our thoughts.
The biggest mistake we can make is to think that we are our thoughts.
When I talk to people who are suffering from intrusive thoughts, the first thing I’ll tell them is, “Well, stop your intrusive thoughts,” and they get a little upset with you. But I’m like, isn’t that the best piece of evidence that it’s not who you are? If it were, the Buddha made a similar argument, you know, 2,500 years ago: if you could control all these things, then maybe that would be who you are. But the very fact that you can’t control them shows pretty explicitly that they’re not who you are.
That insight alone creates a little bit of space between the thoughts themselves and consciousness. For so many, consciousness is tied up so much with that left brain interpreter. Then you have these little practices: “Okay, there’s another intrusive thought.” You’ve probably heard the old Zen story of someone who had an anger problem. He goes to the teacher, and the teacher says, “Well, show me your anger problem.” He says something like, “Well, I can’t control it.” And the teacher says, “Well, if you can’t control it, why are you worried about it? It’s not who you are.”
Little lessons like that, I found, are really helpful: taking these little lessons from the East and applying them in a neuropsychological framework, shifting consciousness from the left brain to the right brain. It seems like it’s been pretty successful.
Rick: Yeah. The first time I did LSD, when I was 17, the main takeaway from the experience—and there were many—was that I had always assumed prior to that that everybody saw the same world. All of a sudden, I realized, “Whoa, you can radically alter the way you see the world, and everybody’s seeing it quite differently.”
So, you know, I kind of realized that what I want to accomplish in life is to see the world as it actually is and not through some kind of distorted filter. But what you’re saying about the left brain always wanting to be right—society these days seems to be more deeply entrenched than ever in polarized camps that are convinced their particular perspective is right and the other guys are horribly wrong.
I’m not suggesting we put LSD in the water supply, but it would be nice if people could bring in more of this right brain stuff and just chill a little bit, and realize that, you know, we’re all feeling different parts of the elephant. It’s the same elephant, but people are feeling it quite differently.
One thing I liked about Jill Bolte Taylor’s work, whom I interviewed a few weeks ago, is the idea in her book, Whole Brain Living, that there are different parts of the brain—four of them, which she identifies—that each serve very different functions. Most people don’t have them all fully developed; they have some sort of lopsided development where one or another part of the brain predominates.
But her contention was that the evolutionary future of humanity will involve the full, holistic, and balanced development of all four parts of the brain. If that’s achieved, not necessarily for all of humanity but even for one person, then one could expect to function in a way where one performs all one’s individual functions and, at the same time, is grounded in universality—which was character four in her model, the interface with unbounded awareness.
I think that would be a very harmonious way of living, and one in which one could be comprehensive in one’s perspective, so as to harmonize all sorts of paradoxical viewpoints within one’s understanding and experience. That’s not to say that you would be wishy-washy and give everything equal credence. You would probably still have a political preference or philosophical preference or whatever, but you would be more forgiving and flexible with regard to other perspectives.
Chris: Well, a couple of really interesting things with that. Again, when we get to the inflexible part, it’s fascinating that this is such a left-hemisphere processing trait. When we talk about language, language has rules, and grammar is a really important part of language. I don’t know what went wrong with me, but that never really developed in my left brain. So when I did my first book, which was self-published, I just had so much fun with grammar. I broke the rules of grammar all the time. Instead of having ellipses, or three dots, I’d just have five commas or something. It didn’t do that well, but the people who did read it—you could see their left brains reacting, like, “You can’t break these rules.”
One of the things the left brain does, too—and there’s a whole series of research from the ’80s about left-brain inconsistency—is something that plays a big role in the self-illusion. We feel like there’s one consistent, coherent self, and that rule is really useful to test and evaluate how authentic it is. One of the things we can do—and I actually have this as an exercise—is something like “How many yous in a day?” If you become observant, particularly of the interpreter, you’ll see that the interpreter is very whimsical. It changes really radically, and we’re always trying to maintain that coherence. If we lose our temper, we’ll say things like, “Something came over me,” or “Something got into me.” We come up with these explanations to try to maintain that coherence, and sometimes we can’t.
I would actually encourage people to explore this. It’s very much like Jill Bolte Taylor’s model, and other multiple-selves models that have been around for a while: we’re not one coherent self. Alan Watts talked about this, too. He said, “Look, you never made a deal to be some coherent self. You’re free. You can sign a contract that says, ‘I will be a consistent self from morning to night,’ and you can explore how many selves actually come and go.”
The Flow of Social Selves
Right now, I’ve got some kind of self that’s podcast self, and I’m not going to talk like this two hours from now. My family is used to podcast self. They get some of that. But there’s dad self; there are all these social roles that we play, and then there are the emotions. When you start observing this and dispel the illusion of some kind of consistent, coherent self, it’s really like a river. There’s a flow to it, and there could almost be an infinite number of selves in a very short time. You go to work, and you’re talking, and someone else enters the room, and all of a sudden your self is altered a little bit. There’s a different person who’s talking.
When you become the observer of all these different selves, it starts to seem almost like a mystery. How did I ever buy into this notion that there was some coherent self from morning to night? What I’m getting at is that when that’s recognized, and we’re in a debate and maybe you take a very different view and we’re arguing about it, you realize that even if we’re on different sides of a debate, it’s not tied in with my identity. The way I would word it is, “Well, look, there’s this self that has an idea that disagrees with some part of you. But tomorrow, that may change.” So I can only hold on to it so much. The same self can change; it’s much more like a flowing river. We could be arguing next week, taking the exact opposite sides. I could be taking your side, and you could be taking my side.
There’s a wonderful play of debate that I think we’ve lost. The reason we’ve lost it is because, again, of left-hemisphere seriousness. But it’s also tied in with the idea of a single, coherent self that’s identified with all these beliefs. Beliefs can change. In the same way that we don’t control our thoughts, we don’t control our beliefs either. I could tell your audience, “Look, I’ll give you a million dollars if you believe there’s a monster outside,” and they’ll be like, “I can’t do it.” Well, if you can’t do it, then you don’t control your beliefs.
Beliefs are just kind of thought bubbles, or collections of thought that get grouped together. If you recognize that you don’t control your thoughts, you also recognize that you don’t control your beliefs. Therefore, you’re not going to take them too seriously. But that doesn’t mean we can’t have some fun in a debate and make it playful and enjoyable. If I get into a debate with, say, my daughter or someone, we always end it with something fun, because we always go back to reminding them, “Look, the whole thing is just fun. We’re just play.”
Again, to go back to Alan Watts, he reminded us so much that there’s a difference between work, which we take seriously, and play. That’s why we play music. One of the best ways, I think, to get out of left-brain seriousness is music. A lot of us do this already. In fact, I had an assignment I gave my class. It was very spontaneous. I said, “Let’s do a paper: What music means to me.” I was completely blown away by the responses. You could see that the responses were things like, “Music is the meaning of my life,” and “Music was foundational to my sanity.”
Again, all the tonality reflects a lot of right-brain processes—not to say the left brain isn’t involved in music. In fact, the whole brain seems to be involved in music. But when you’re really deep into music, you’re probably not thinking very much. Music is one of the quick go-to ways to get out of the thinking mind, and it brings so much joy and peace to people. I had students saying, “I would marry music if I could.” I get that. I’ve been a musician; that was my original intent in life, to be a musician. I don’t do it seriously in the sense that I expect something out of it. I don’t expect to be a professional musician. I do it absolutely; it’s as close as I can get to meditation.
In my view, if you’re doing meditation for an external purpose, to go somewhere or to be something that you’re not, you’re not really doing meditation. Meditation should be an end unto itself, and that’s the way music is for me. We all have something like that; we just don’t cultivate it. In a left-brain, goal-oriented system, everything has to have some future goal to it. Everything has to be about, “I’m improving myself,” or “I’m making more money.” Again, we recognize that it just never ends. We can get out of those moments here and there by getting into music, poetry, and all the things that Western culture seems to devalue. If you think of anything you would tell your parents you want to do, and they’re disappointed, it’s probably something the right brain is really good at.
Rick: Yeah, I wanted to play drums when I was four years old, and my parents told me I needed to learn piano first to get a foundation in music. I hated practicing piano. I wanted to play the drums. Finally, when I was 14, ten years later, I was playing “Wipeout” on the kitchen counter. My father was in the bathroom on the other side of the wall. When he came out, he said, “I think we should get you a set of drums.” So he got the drums, and I was in a band in about three days.
Anyway, you were saying a minute ago that we don’t choose our beliefs. You’ve probably seen The Social Dilemma, that documentary that was on Netflix and still is. Obviously, you can’t believe on the spot that there’s a monster outside. But if you spend enough time on YouTube, allowing its algorithms to feed you the things that you seem to be attracted to, you may end up believing the Earth is flat, or that Trump won the election, or whatever else it is that you’ve fixated on through your preferences. So people do, in a sense, choose their beliefs through a million little incremental choices that end up being more and more deeply ingrained as you give your attention to those choices. Don’t you think?
Chris: Well, that’s a great point. I think it was Ian McGilchrist who often talked about the left brain being kind of in a hall of mirrors, in a sense. And it is. In the book, I encourage people to purposely choose whatever you believe. So many people, in the morning, get up and listen to a lot of podcasts. You want to listen to something that’s consistent with what you believe, and that reinforces all of your beliefs. But it’s interesting that sometimes you can choose the opposite. It’s a really interesting thing to pick things that are the exact opposite of what you would normally pick. I think that’s a good way to keep the hemispheres balanced, so you don’t go too far into this hall of mirrors.
Again, this way of describing the two sides of the brain is that the left brain forms beliefs, but the right brain is the devil’s advocate. That devil’s advocate is a really important mechanism. Sometimes people think skepticism is a negative quality, but I find skepticism can be very spiritual. People become skeptical of the self and realize, “Wow, the self isn’t what I thought it was.” There’s a whole movement of people becoming skeptical of what we would call the physical world. There’s this movement toward what we would call idealism, where people start thinking, “Well, maybe we live in these conceptual worlds, but we mistake the physical world for what it is, when it’s really just consciousness.”
And then there’s the whole practice of neti neti: you’re tearing away, like, “Not this, not that.” I think skepticism can be very much identified with the right brain, because the right brain is always keeping the left brain closer to reality. I encourage people: be someone else’s right brain. Sometimes people can get into these closed systems. When you get into that kind of left-brain closed system, there’s a tipping point, and it can get harder and harder to get out the more you get into it.
I’ve always been interested in strange beliefs, so I’ve done a lot of research on them. It was sort of an academic hobby of mine. What I found is that the best mechanism for that is to surround yourself with what you might consider to be external sources if your right brain isn’t working, if your right brain isn’t keeping your left brain in check. This is, of course, why I think debate and conversation are so important. Remember, the left brain is always going to want to be right over finding truth. I think the right brain is more interested in truth than in being right. Truth is a big word, and we can use it cautiously here.
Rick: Yeah, you mentioned something called the RTPJ, if I got that acronym right: the part of the right brain that does nothing else but consider things from others’ perspectives. You’re probably aware of the work of Byron Katie, who has this little formula where, you know, “Do you know that to be true?”
Chris: Absolutely.
Rick: Are you absolutely sure that’s true? And where would you be without that certainty? Then flip it around and try to see it from the other perspective. It’s a good exercise because, again, like you say, the left brain likes to be right. And I guess maybe—we live a—you said another interesting thing in your book, which was that since the left brain is dominant in most people because most of us are right-handed, 80% of us or something, maybe that correlates with our cultural tendency to be certain of our opinions and perspectives. Is that what you meant to say? And do you want to elaborate on that?
Chris: Yeah, I mean, I think it is. I won’t say it’s our natural tendency to want to be right, but I think in a culture that emphasizes the left brain and depends so much on the left brain, we get these tendencies. I don’t know why a John Cougar song just came to mind. I forget the lyrics. It was like, “A thousand young poets screaming out their words to a world that only wants to be heard,” which is to say, we’re so confident in our opinions that we’re all shouting them, and we’ve become talkers rather than listeners. And I think—
Rick: I remember that Buffalo Springfield song, “For What It’s Worth”: “Singing songs and carrying signs, mostly say, ‘Hooray for my side.’”
Chris: Yeah, perfect. And we may not be able to stop that. Again, I think if we tried to stop it, that might even make it worse because of the nature of the left brain and its tendency for opposition. So the way out of that, again, is to play with it more, have a more playful attitude toward it, and not take it as seriously. You have a side and I have a side. We could be in a room with people who are all disagreeing, and as long as it’s not taken really seriously, that’s kind of the way things were not that long ago.
I sort of have this memory of my family debating politics and stuff. They would debate and debate, and get a little intense. But then it was over, and everyone was done. I think that’s absolutely possible to get back to. But it’s about getting the right brain going again. So many of the exercises I try to include in the books are subtle, little things. To me, that would be a way of changing our value systems and valuing things like poetry. You can’t just pretend to value it. It all starts with being the gap between thoughts. It’s such a precious moment for so many people when they first recognize, “I can be conscious without thought.” There’s something about that state. I always talk about it as—we’re people walking around in an airport with hundreds of pounds of luggage, carrying it around, not even knowing why we’re carrying it. It’s not even ours.
The moment you become the gap between thoughts, it’s like putting the luggage down. That’s why it’s often described as joyful. And that’s why, like Jill Bolte Taylor, when she shifted immediately from left-brain to right-brain awareness, it was like putting all that luggage down. And then you think, “Why was I carrying it?”
The moment you become the gap between thoughts, it’s like putting the luggage down. That’s why it’s often described as joyful. And that’s why, like Jill Bolte Taylor, when she shifted immediately from left-brain to right-brain awareness, it was like putting all that luggage down. And then you think, “Why was I carrying it?”
The moment you become the gap between thoughts, it’s like putting the luggage down.
Rick: There’s a nice analogy for that, actually, in spiritual circles. Once you get on the train, put your suitcase down. The train is going to carry it for you. The reality that tries to explain is that God is the doer, or the gunas of nature, or cosmic intelligence, or whatever. You’re actually not the doer. Therefore, if you take yourself to be the doer, you’re kind of a thief. You’re attributing something to yourself that doesn’t belong to you, and you’re making life a lot harder than it needs to be.
Chris: Mm-hmm. People wonder where creativity comes from, and thinking plays a very small role in the creative process. Initially, of course, you might want to focus your thoughts on a particular problem. Certainly, you’re not going to come up with physics solutions unless you think about physics for years. But there’s this almost consensus that once you’ve thought about it, you need to just stop thinking. Then you walk away, and there’s this intelligence that no one seems to be able to describe. It’s not a thinking type of intelligence, but the answer just comes to you.
For a lot of people, they say, “Well, it’s unconscious.” I’ve never been one to buy much into unconsciousness. To me, the thinking mind is a buy-in that isn’t thought or processed at the level of thinking. The thinking mind has deemed it unconscious. But when you stop thinking all the time, the remarkable thing is that you realize there’s a certain consciousness that’s been in the background, and it’s completely aware. No one who teaches yoga or meditation would say that you’re becoming conscious in these states. It’s a very focused, alert form of consciousness.
Rick: Yeah. That consciousness can become so lively that it can actually persist during sleep, deep sleep. I know people who haven’t slept in decades. Their bodies sleep. They may snore, but that inner awareness is never lost. And there are degrees of that.
I want to get back to something we were saying a minute ago about beliefs. The attitude I try to cultivate, both with people and ideas, is to give them the benefit of the doubt, but also to take them with a grain of salt. The proportions vary. You can throw any idea at me. Is the earth flat? Okay, I like to hear your arguments, but the evidence is really strong, so mostly all salt there. Or, have aliens been visiting the earth? Now, that one I’m more interested in. I think there’s a lot of evidence that that may be the case. But I don’t think—I’m almost making an absolute statement here—I don’t feel like I would ever adamantly say, “No, this absolutely cannot exist,” or, “Yes, this absolutely exists.” And that’s a scientific attitude.
A scientist, if he’s really a scientist—and a lot of scientists aren’t these days—will never dig his heels in and insist that his particular understanding of things could not be revised.
A scientist, if he’s really a scientist—and a lot of scientists aren’t these days—will never dig his heels in and insist that his particular understanding of things could not be revised.
Chris: It’s all tentative. But I agree. There are some—well, it would be in the same way that we don’t control our beliefs. If someone were to really forcibly argue that the earth is flat, I’d have a very difficult time. There’s nothing I could do with it.
Rick: Oh, there are whole conventions where they all get together and talk about it.
Chris: I used to bring that up in class because it was a sort of safe place to go. So many people are like—most people, I’ve never actually met a flat earther myself.
Rick: I interviewed a guy. I ended up taking down his interview for that and other reasons. I just didn’t feel he was someone I could comfortably refer people to anymore. But his Facebook page is all about these little memes of the earth being flat. You know, go ahead. Continue.
Chris: But is that any stranger than that one patient whose right brain was taken offline and she was hallucinating that her finger was pointing to the doctor? That belief is also pretty far out there.
Rick: Yeah, but in most cases, there’s some kind of pathology going on, I guess.
Chris: Yeah. Well, there was something more overt, and we don’t really know how far the left brain can go. There could be subtle deficits in people where maybe the right brain isn’t interacting as much. We’re not really sure. There’s the consensus issue. But it is interesting that when you go back to something like Copernicus, he had to publish On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres on his deathbed because so many people were antagonistic to the idea that we may not be the center of the universe.
Rick: Sure. Galileo was faced with house arrest and all kinds of—
Chris: Yeah. So that comes to mind, too. Like you mentioned Byron Katie, and I really do like her work. When I first encountered it, I thought, “Wow, what she’s doing here is putting the left brain on trial.” She’s just saying, “Do you know this with absolute certainty?” And we will say that. But if we’re hit with it over and over again, we have to admit, “No, I don’t know it with absolute certainty.” And that cracks things. That hard shell has a tiny crack in it at that point. That’s really the very first small step that people can take.
The left brain is doing all these things. One of the things it loves to do is categorize. Sometimes I start in all kinds of different places, but categories are abstractions that really don’t exist in reality, while we act as if they do.
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: You talk about strange beliefs, but categories are strange beliefs that so many of us buy into as if they’re part of actual physical reality, but they’re really not.
Rick: Like, give us an example.
Chris: Okay. Let me think how I would—well, let me do something from the research, because this was something Stephen Kosslyn, a really well-known cognitive neuroscientist in the ’90s—
Rick: What’s the name of the person?
Chris: Stephen Kosslyn. He may still be at Harvard. He was looking at his career at Harvard. Most of the world didn’t pay attention to this, but being a left-right brain person, I was completely drawn to it. It was revolutionary in many ways. Most people know that the left brain does categories and a whole kind of research on this, and the right brain does space, like coordinate spatial systems. If I reach for something, you need a precise distance measurement for that. This is pretty well established.
But Kosslyn came up with a really interesting task where there was just a line and a dot, and the dot could be anywhere above or below. That was the categorical task. The coordinate task, the one that required specific detail in terms of spatial location, required you to respond exactly where the dot was. You couldn’t collapse across a bunch of things; you had to be very precise.
He presented this task to the left and right sides of the brain. Now, again, these are both spatial tasks. The right brain should have been absolutely superior. But because this spatial task included categories—and the trick about a category is that this is what makes it such an abstraction, what makes it a mental process instead of something out in reality—in reality, there’s a dot, and it could be here, or here, or here, or here, or here, and these are all considered above.
Categories collapse across individual uniqueness, and they focus on only one thing they all have in common, which in this case is being above the line. So, the brain has to ignore all kinds of things and then focus on one thing. In doing so, it’s really something that exists only in the mind.
To everyone’s surprise, this spatial task, which should have been done by the right brain far more effectively, was performed better by the left brain—as long as these were spatial categories. The left brain is so categorical that it can actually beat the right brain at a spatial task if it deals with spatial categories. Again, the left brain collapses across individual particulars and looks at this as a group. In reality, this group only exists in my head. I mean, this dot’s really right here, and this dot’s really right here. The idea of saying that this is all above is a mental concept. It doesn’t exist in reality.
How Categorization Shapes Stereotyping
One of the researchers at the lab I was in did a really interesting study on stereotyping. What is stereotyping and racism other than categorizing people? You look at a few simple physical features that people have in common, and you group them. This group doesn’t exist in reality. He found that when the left hemisphere was aroused—he had subtle ways of measuring left-hemisphere arousal—people engaged in stereotypes to a far greater degree than when their right brain was aroused. When the right brain was aroused, they processed people individually. I thought that was a really interesting way to look at how the left brain views the world in a really different, cartoon-like way compared to how the right brain seems to be so much more individualistic.
Rick: Interesting. I mean, there’s obviously a lot of categorization taking place in today’s society. We keep coming back to today’s society, but racism is a type of categorization, as are homophobia and so many different things, including political categorization. It seems like if people were more right-brained, they would ease up on the tendency to do that and see people as unique individuals with their own worth, rather than make these blanket judgments and stereotypes.
Chris: Yeah. Take something as simple as, I could say we have a Yorkie, and I could categorize that. I could say he’s a Yorkie and put him in this big category with others. But that’s not true. I mean, it’s relatively true, and it might be useful if I went to the vet and they wanted to know what category this dog was in. But the truth, the reality, is that this dog is completely individual. There really isn’t any other dog like it, and it’s the same with all of us. All consciousness exploring is completely individual paths. Any way that we categorize ourselves, whether it’s based on our beliefs or some physical characteristic, we could almost, if we wanted to push it a little further, say these are all collective hallucinations of the left brain. They simply don’t exist in reality.
Rick: Yeah. Although I think, like many things, categorization serves its function. It’s valuable. I mean, I think, “I will buy a car.” Okay, car is a category. What kind of car? All right, I think I’ll get a Subaru. Yeah, I like Subarus. That’s a category. All right, what kind of Subaru? I think I’ll get an Outback. There’s no harm in having these categories so we can identify things. It would be really awkward or impractical to say, “Well, I think I will buy a mode of transportation,” and just leave it at that.
Chris: No, it’s a great example. Again, the goal of at least what I do is never to eliminate the usefulness, the brilliance of what the left brain does.
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: Categorization is one of the things we do so effectively. It’s one of the things that AI is having a tough time competing with: our ability to categorize so easily and do it in sometimes sophisticated ways. So, we keep categorization when it’s useful. But when we’re dealing with you as an individual, that left-hemisphere interpreter may impose some kind of categories on you. I’ve given an example in a book: maybe you’re a bookstore looking for an employee, and this huge, muscular person comes in and you think, “Oh, you probably haven’t read a book,” because you’re making some silly stereotype. That’s just the left brain doing its thing. It’s seeing the world in very simplistic ways. Again, it may not turn off, but as long as you don’t take it seriously, as long as you don’t act on it…
Rick: Yeah. I mean, a contemporary example that’s very unfortunate is the extent to which Black people, especially Black men, are subjected to traffic stops. There was some Republican, Tim Scott, I think his name was, running for president. He was talking in a speech about how frequently he is stopped by the police just because he fits a certain category in their minds, a certain stereotype.
Chris: And you can see how useful it would be for people to recognize, “I can be wrong.”
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: You get the left brain that can think about what the left brain is doing. Not only does it engage in stereotypes, but it’s the same part of the brain that’s convinced it’s right.
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: So, you put those two things together, and it can be a dangerous combination. But again, I think we’re at a very interesting time. We’ve got this left brain—and I just keep referring to it as the left brain, but you wouldn’t have to. Some people, like Eckhart Tolle, just call it the ego, and people like Bartholomew call it the mind. There’s a sense that waking up is just recognizing that it’s not always right, and it’s not who you are. Those recognitions go a long way.
Rick: Yeah. I think one good conclusion on this particular point, and then I want to get into something else that we haven’t discussed much yet, is that there’s no harm in what the left brain does. We need it. All this specific categorizing and judging and the kind of stuff it does just needs to be supplemented or counterbalanced with what the right brain does. I’m thinking of Jill’s character four, which is the interface with unbounded awareness. If we can really establish unbounded awareness as our normal experience in life and integrate it with all the specific individual functions we need in order to live, then we’ll live a balanced life. The negative aspects of the left brain won’t be there anymore. They’ll be modified or ameliorated by the unboundedness.
Let’s take an example. In work, routine work is essential for productivity in many professions. You can’t just do something different every day on an assembly line. But that becomes very confining and stultifying for the people who have to do the same thing over and over again. At Foxconn in China, they have nets on the building because people go nuts putting together iPhones for 12 hours a day, and they tend to jump off the building. Hopefully there could be some better way of making the iPhones. But if the people at least had access to their innermost nature, which is totally liberated, which is freedom, then it wouldn’t be so bad. They’d have that inner contentment, even if they had to do something repetitive or very specific over and over again.
Chris: Yeah, and it’s interesting the way you worded that, too, because this left hemisphere, which so many people identify as who they are, really is like a computer program. There’s no free will with it. It’s inflexible, and it’s more a reflection of the culture, as opposed to something unique or individual. The recognition of that program as a program, as something that has very little to do with who you are, and then you put the luggage down—and all of a sudden, very interesting things happen. This consciousness, this state of consciousness that was more in the background before, becomes far more center stage. It absolutely feels like coming home. It feels like this is who I’ve been the whole time.
I’ve been wearing this mask of personality, this mask of being Chris, identifying as what I did, as my age, as all these characteristics that were socially imposed. They were not things I chose. When you get to consciousness, the freedom of that seems like a whole new experience. It feels like you’re free. I think James put it this way: “My first act of freedom will be to believe in freedom.” It’s like you have that recognition that you’ve never—you could almost liken it to the movie The Matrix. That thought-created dream world of the left brain isn’t who you are. It’s like a program. It’s restrictive, inflexible, and totally prewired, predetermined.
When you put that down and realize that you are this mystery that the thinking mind can’t really put into words—because who has even been close to defining consciousness? It’s resisted all intellectual limitations where we can nail it down and say, “Well, here’s my definition of consciousness.” It doesn’t stop us from trying, and I’m perfectly fine with giving definitive definitions of consciousness. But it’s something that is known experientially. When you get to that, to me it seems absolutely synonymous with what we would call freedom.
Rick: Yeah, it is. The reason it’s called liberation is that it is literally unbounded, and it is what you are. So, you are free in your essential nature. But the isolated experiences of life impinge upon that, like movies playing on a movie screen, and identification takes place. The screen gets overshadowed by the movie, so you think you are Superman or Harry Potter or whatever individual images are constantly changing. You think you are constantly changing. But in fact, you are really the foundation upon which all the changing universe exists and in which it resides.
✨ Self, death, and the possibility of reincarnation
Chris: And it’s always there. It’s always been there. When those experiences start happening, because, you know, in my 20s, all this kind of got started with the death of my father, which was very surprising. And death just—it was like a shock to the system, what it did to people. And it became this enemy that I thought, well, not only am I terrified of it, but we’ve got to overcome it somehow.
And then, of course, the only thing that dies is that thinking mind and the interpretive stories that were created through a lifetime. But consciousness itself is absolutely eternal. Consciousness itself isn’t going to die. And so, when it comes to that, death is just a story. And when you want to talk about freedom, what greater freedom is there than recognizing that the only thing that dies is a story?
I mean, I’m 56. I’d be happy to live as long as my story is going to go; I’m good with that. But there’s absolutely nothing that worries or has some kind of fear of something that’s beyond a story. And so those are the radical transformative experiences: to be identified with the story is really suffering itself.
Rick: Yeah. What do you think about reincarnation?
Chris: That’s such an interesting one, because particularly when you write about the self being a story, and you say, “Well, the self is fiction,” some people say, “Well, the self doesn’t exist.” I don’t really mean that the self doesn’t exist. In a sense, it doesn’t exist as a real, coherent, solid entity. It exists as a story.
So the simple way to put it is, it’s more of a verb than a noun. Maybe I’m selfing. I have some self that I’m creating right now, and then I’ll have some other selfing that I’ll do later. These selves come and go. And so we talk about reincarnation, and we say, “Well, that self”—this thing that I took so seriously and was so identified with—“now seems rather trivial.” So that’s not going to be reincarnated.
But when we get to, “Okay, well, what is there?” we could actually start talking again, I think, about souls. And I think that’s—but then you say, “Well, what is a soul?” That’s where we get to the point where the thinking mind isn’t going to be able to nail it. It’s like consciousness: you’re not going to be able to articulate it, put it into a category, compare it and contrast it. By definition, it’s something that’s unknown.
But I think the notion of a soul—and this is where I’ve come to on this path—is that consciousness is fundamental, but also has this love of diversity. While it may be one consciousness, the evidence seems to be that it loves getting lost, and it loves playing hide-and-seek. The best way to forget who you are is to hide in all of us individuals and then get lost in egos. And that’s a very wild ride.
But everything about this reality seems to suggest that this consciousness not only loves to play who it isn’t, but loves diversity. You can’t even find two trees that are alike. If this was some kind of simulation, you could really imagine it being so easy to copy and paste everything. Every tree and every blade of grass would be the same, and we would probably buy into that world. But the interesting thing about the world, again, is this remarkable diversity.
The consciousness that I’m having right now seems to have a unique perspective. And so we might call them souls. Again, you have to be careful with this, because the ego could find a very clever way of hiding in this concept of a soul. But I think that whatever a soul is, it’s beyond our thinking mind’s capacity to conceptualize. But that’s not going to stop us from trying. That left brain is insistent, if anything else.
And so, when we get there, there’s a really interesting idea that comes up in different religions: the relation between the multiplicity and an individual, sort of like the Trinity, where the one and the three are the same. You see this in different places. So when we talk about the individual soul and its connection to the greater consciousness, it’s almost like we have to feel our way around instead of think.
For me, personally, this goes all the way back to when I was in church as a kid. I remember the priest was talking, giving a sermon about God creating everything, and I just wanted to ask him a question. But as a little kid in church, that’s just not something you do; you would never do such a thing. But I wanted to ask him, “If God created everything, what did God use except God?”
So, in that sense, we are a reflection of this eternal. And at the same time, it’s very paradoxical: we’re all taking these individual trips, and all the individual trips are remarkably individual. When you take a look at the ego, it seems like we’re all having the same—like we all go to the same boring job, we all have the same routine. And then we can categorize people and make it even more simplistic.
But when you shift that to getting out of that left-brain thinking, the originality of every moment seems so remarkably precious, so amazingly unique. We’re having this conversation right now. I mean, this is like the first time the universe has a conversation with us. We’re creating something; we’re like artists creating something completely new that’s never happened. And that, to me, is completely connected with that feeling of joy, and that feeling of living life as an artist rather than living life as that left-brain routine.
Rick: Yeah. That was a very astute question you wanted to ask as a little kid: “If God created everything, what did he have to create with other than God?” Because God alone is, supposedly. If God is omnipresent, then there can’t be anything other than God. If this pen is anything other than God, then there’s a hole in God, a pen-shaped hole right here.
I find myself spending a fair amount of time studying Vedanta, taking classes with Swami Sarvapriyananda and so on, and they’ve really thought this stuff out very nicely. I’ll just riff for a second here. On the one hand, there are scriptures like the Mandukya Upanishad and the Ashtavakra Gita, which emphasize that nothing ever happened. There is no universe, you know. The supposed snake was never a snake; it’s always been a rope. So you don’t need to get rid of the snake because there never was one, and so on.
On the other hand, they have this concept of Vyavaharika, which means transactional reality. The whole relative creation, with all of its diversity and so on, is not ultimately real, but you can’t just dismiss it as utterly unreal if you want to live. You have to interact with it and take it somewhat seriously.
And then, with the idea of reincarnation and all that, there’s the idea of the Jiva, which again is an individuated thing that is not ultimately real, but which has its transactional or relative reality, and which does, in fact, go from life to life, from body to body. So, in a sense, you could say that’s a self, but it’s not ultimately a self. There’s kind of a both-and resolution of this issue of whether or not we have a self. We do and we don’t.
Chris: That’s one of those paradoxes. I love paradoxes.
Rick: Me too. I have a T-shirt, in fact, that I was wearing today, but I took it off for this interview. It says “Paradox” on it.
Chris: Oh, yeah. And that’s the thing: there are so many ways and tricks to get out of the left brain, and one of them, again, is paradox. That’s why the koan comes up so often, because if I say, “Be spontaneous, be natural,” the left brain starts creating ways to be natural. It starts thinking, “Well, let’s come up with a list, and here’s five ways to be natural.” Of course, I’m just going way, way off the path in doing that. The right brain seems to have no problem with paradox.
And the universe has thrown us so many paradoxes. To me, it’s got to be like breadcrumbs to take us home, because we’ve got matter, and everything really seems on the surface, like all the stuff around us, like it’s solid matter. And physicists come along and say, “No, it’s not even real; it’s just potentials of energy that may come and go statistically. And, by the way, only 5% of the universe is even made up of what we consider matter, and 95% is dark matter and dark energy that are beyond our conceptualization. We have no clue what they are.”
Rick: Yeah, but don’t take that so seriously that you go stepping in front of buses.
Chris: Yeah, exactly. And time, to me, again, what a great paradox to throw at our existence. We live in the past and the future, but the only thing that really seems real is the present moment. Whether you’re looking at time or space, and the universe itself—not to even mention things like quantum mechanics—it seems like, what a strange thing to explore this world and find that it’s not waves, it’s not particles. I think Alan Watts called it “wavicles.”
And all of these things—I mean, if you really wanted to, I think in the book I give the idea of an escape room. If consciousness really wanted to lose itself and become what it is, and then find its way back home, it seems like this reality is very close to what we might call an escape room. We’ve left ourselves clues. We get lost in thought; we become these conceptualized selves, which we’re not, but they really feel like they are. Then we get deeper into maybe we’re souls taking individual trips, but it all seems to lead back to this consciousness.
Rick: Yeah. But paradox—key word there. It doesn’t have to be absolutely this or absolutely that, which people sometimes tend to make it. “Search” can be a candy mint and a breath mint if you’re old enough to remember those commercials. [Laughter]
Okay, I think—well, another question I want to ask: Irene’s sending over some questions that people have sent in. You said one thing in your book that I found interesting, which is that light actually is really only in your head or in the mind. It’s something that we interpret, or that our brain and our eyes and all that stuff interpret based on the way they interact with the electromagnetic field. But really, it’s only in the mind or in the head.
I’m kind of curious whether you have any reflections on the notion in spiritual circles that awakening can be like the brilliance of a thousand suns. I have a friend who—I don’t know if she’s still going through this—but she was going through a phase a while back where there was so much inner light that it was almost blinding, and yet it was only coming from within. As a kind of physiological response, she was actually squinting her eyes, even though it wasn’t coming from outside. So do you have any thoughts on that?
Chris: Some of that comes from 20 years of teaching sensation and perception. On the surface, it looked like I was teaching a very scientific class, based on what modern science knows about light. Although photons are kind of mysterious things, and we’re not exactly sure what light is, I would take the whole process from light hitting the back of the eye and getting transformed into neurological language, and then going back to the visual cortex. Right now, everything seems illuminated, but the typical explanation from neuroscience is that we’ve got it wrong. It seems like I’m in here, looking out at the world. But it’s actually light hitting the eye and becoming transformed into language that neurons can understand—neurological language. So, there can’t be any light. If you looked at my visual cortex, there’s no light there. My visual cortex would be completely dark.
And so the light has to be—I spent quite a bit of time lecturing on this in class, and it just hit me: “Light is consciousness.” I think I even went off on that in class at the time, and probably lost a lot of students on that one. But it was, “Light is consciousness.” Again, we always have this metaphor between light and insight, but I think it’s more profound than that. Consciousness illuminates the universe.
Rick: Yeah. Well, there are some interesting thoughts on that, too. I mean, isn’t that an early verse in the Bible, “Let there be light,” and it sort of parallels verses about the emergence of consciousness from the unmanifest? Photons travel, obviously, at the speed of light because they are light, and for photons, there is no time or space because they’re traveling at the speed of light. So, time and space have totally collapsed, and that’s what they say of consciousness. It’s beyond time and space. It’s omnipresent. I mean, a photon from the Andromeda Galaxy, from our perspective, since we’re sitting still, takes 2 million years to get here. But from the photon’s perspective, it’s here instantaneously because it’s traveling at the speed of light, and there is no distance or time. And so that is also true of consciousness.
In some interesting way that I’d like to understand more, there’s an equivalence, or at least a great similarity, between light and consciousness.
Chris: And that can be used, I think, as a practice. That’s what I was doing in class, and it didn’t hit me until that moment when I was really trying to explain light. I realized I can’t explain it, and that’s when it hit me that it’s really consciousness. In the same way that we can’t put consciousness into a conceptualization, the reason we can’t put light into a conceptualization is because there’s some interesting connection between the two.
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: It’s another breadcrumb we’ve left ourselves, I think.
Rick: It’s a big breadcrumb, yeah. It’s a whole loaf. Okay, a few questions came in. Jackie Goffstein in Colorado wants to know, “What excites you about the future of neuroscience?”
What neuroscience can—and can’t—explain
Chris: You know, I’m actually going to start off with the opposite and say, “What doesn’t excite me about neuroscience?” Neuroscience has been on this quest to find things like the self and consciousness. And no, it’s not conclusive. I absolutely think it would be fascinating if we ever had a neuropsychological theory of consciousness. That would just be remarkable. I don’t think it’s ever going to happen because I don’t think that’s the nature of consciousness.
Neuroscience has given us—of course, I use neuroscience as a foundation for looking at the left and right sides of the brain and how things create different worlds that we live in. I think the really exciting thing about neuroscience is that it’s going to reach a point where we’re going to recognize that we are not our brain. So, we’re going to examine the brain. I mean, what would it even look like?
Rick: In other words, we’re more like a radio transmitter/receiver, but we are not the radio.
Chris: Yeah. We’re going to change the notion of what the brain is there for. Ninety percent of neuroscience believes that somehow the brain creates consciousness.
Rick: Right.
Chris: And so the wonderful thing that excites me about neuroscience is that it’s going to take a while, but eventually it’s just going to exhaust itself on this possibility. Then we’re going to start looking in different places. Again, we’ll view the brain not as a creator of consciousness, but more like a filter—a filtering function for consciousness. When people have these mystical experiences, I think even Jill Bolte Taylor—I may be confusing her experience with someone else’s—but the way mystics typically describe it, they’re like, “How can the vastness of this experience ever fit back into my skull?”
Rick: [Laughter]
Chris: And so it seems like the filtering idea is going to take us in a much more interesting direction. But neuroscience is going to have to play its hand; it’s going to have to play itself out. Neuroscience has been so successful in some ways. We’ve localized so many different functions of thinking, so many different functions of the mind. We can find that this part seems to play a much more important role than this other part. So, it’s successful in that sense. But its lack of success with the big questions of who I am and what consciousness is—I just don’t think it’s going to happen.
Rick: Yeah, there are a lot of really brilliant people these days trying to overturn materialism: Bernardo Kastrup and Donald Hoffman, and the whole gang that’s part of the Galileo Commission, the Scientific and Medical Network, and all those people. It seems to be a groundswell of really qualified people arguing very intelligently that materialism is a deficient paradigm that is going to be overturned.
Chris: Yeah, and I love these 180s. It’s exactly the opposite of what the thinking mind had assumed. We’re just so convinced that materialism is the most obvious thing, something I don’t have to believe in because I get to experience it. But then you realize—and I think Bernardo does a really good job with this—he explains that, no, this stuff takes faith. There’s a lot of materialism that you don’t really have to believe in. It’s radical consciousness that has immediate experience on its side, and it takes a lot less faith to take that position.
Rick: Yep. Incidentally, I’ve interviewed all these people we’ve been mentioning in this interview. If people want to look them up, search for my interviews with Bernardo, Donald Hoffman, Ian McGilchrist, and many others. Okay, another question here. This one is from Kanta Dadlani in Bombay: “Despite the exhaustive research done and being done on the human brain, what makes it still so enigmatic that even Christoph Koch, the renowned neurophysiologist, has stated that it can never be understood? What do you attribute this to?”
Chris: I think the initial success of neuroscience almost made it feel—I’m going back to the ’90s, and I don’t know if people remember, but I think Congress even said the ’90s was the Decade of the Brain. So, I think that was some kind of formal recognition. I don’t know how meaningful that is, but it reflects how successful neuroscience actually was.
Let me give you an example. We had Freud, and Freud had these theories. Some of them may have been on track and kind of interesting. Then neuroscience came along. To talk about one really strange theory, V.S. Ramachandran talks about this: Freud had his own ideas about why some people might have foot fetishes, and it was all symbolic and all this stuff Freud might think of. But then neuroscience started poking around and found that there’s a representation of the body in the brain, and it’s very close to what we looked like as a fetus. When we were a fetus, we were curled up, so our feet and genitals were practically on top of one another. In the brain’s mapping of the body, those two areas ended up right next to each other.
So, neuroscience would have a completely different explanation for foot fetishes. It would simply say that the boundary between these two parts of the brain has greater connections, and that’s why some people are turned on by this and some people are not. You see a really interesting neuropsychological explanation come along that seems way more believable and way more successful than Freud just coming up with these stories. Neuroscience had so much success with that that it became almost like, “This is going to be invincible. This is going to explain everything.”
But no matter how deeply you look, you can take the brain apart as much as you want, and you’re going to find neurons, interconnections, neurotransmitters. That’s what you’re going to find. You’re not going to find consciousness. It’s the old story: you’re looking in the parking lot for your keys because there’s a light there, even though you know you lost them elsewhere. People ask, “Well, why are you looking over here?” And you say, “Well, this is where the light is.” So, we’re looking in the brain because it seems to be the place to look.
Rick: Well, by the same token, you don’t find the electromagnetic field by taking a radio apart. You can break it down into as small bits as you wish, and you may never guess that the whole purpose of this thing is to be an interface with an omnipresent field.
Chris: Yeah, and its previous success has led us down a path where you can see this. If you say, “Well, I’m a psychologist,” people are like, “Oh, okay.” But if you say, “I’m a neuropsychologist,” it gives you more status, because the brain has become so central.
Again, if you’re getting a transplant, most of the time you’d want to be the recipient, say, if you’re getting a heart. But if you’re getting a brain transplant, you want to be the person giving the brain. So, there’s still that sense that, if I were getting a brain transplant tomorrow, I don’t know—it would be pretty disturbing, because I would wonder, “Who am I going to wake up as?” There’s that to consider. But I’m still convinced that neuroscience—I don’t know if I want to say neuroscience is going to be a fad, because that’s a pretty bold statement—but I think it’s going to find its place not in answering the really big questions, but in answering more practical questions, things that might be related to clinical issues. The big question of consciousness, I just don’t think neuroscience is adequate. They’re looking in the wrong place.
Rick: Well, it won’t be adequate in and of itself, but as one of the tools in the toolkit, I think it’ll be essential. It’ll be interesting to understand the neurophysiological correlates of higher states of consciousness and things like that, as long as we don’t make the mistake of thinking the brain is creating consciousness, which—
Chris: I mean, all the stuff I talk about with the left brain has been super useful to me and others in helping us recognize who we’re not.
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: I was very careful with the subtitle, like, you know, “How Neuroscience Is Catching Up to Buddhism.”
Rick: Right.
Chris: You know, I was kind of particular with that because, in neuroscience, it is catching up, but it’s not there yet. I think some of the insights of the people who experientially got there—we haven’t caught up to neurologically explaining those insights.
Rick: Yeah. On the other hand, neuroscience has its own strength. The Buddha didn’t know that anything called a neuron existed, or that there was an amygdala or anything. There’s a lot of things he didn’t know that are useful to know, but obviously what he did know is ultimately useful. In that sense, neuroscience and all sciences are catching up. Okay, another question here. This one is from Mark Peters in Santa Clara, California. “It seems like social media and cell phone addiction are largely the left-brain interpreter or intrusive thoughts made manifest. Can you imagine what an externalized right-brain platform might look like?” All right, I guess what he’s saying is, if there were a technological counterpart to these left-brain contraptions, what would it be?
Chris: Hmm. Things are just coming to my head, like a drum circle, music. I mean, these are all…
Rick: Yeah, there you go. Those are good examples.
Chris: An instrument is external, but the music that we’re creating is coming from the internal, manifesting. And so, I look at a guitar, start to play, and it’s a creative moment. And it is, in exactly the same way that the left brain—and I like the question, too, because I really do feel like phones are the external manifestation of the left brain. I mean, if you look, it’s just a bunch of stories. It’s a bunch of interpretations. And so, yeah, I would say music. I would say nature.
Rick: Yeah, being in love, having a pet, nature, just sitting and looking at the stars or the Grand Canyon or something like that—those are all kind of right-brainy things.
Chris: Even something as simple as what we started off with: I was talking about sipping tea.
Rick: Yeah.
Chris: So, you know, the simple, conscious experience: You walk outside, the sun hits your face, the wind’s blowing, and you just become conscious of that experience. To me, that’s the externalization of the right brain’s processing. And, you know, you’re not caught up in the voice in the head at those moments. The thing is, when you come back to the interpreter, it devalues those moments. It comes back with, “Oh, we have to get things done. We have to do this.” And there’s a shift in values. And, again, I’m optimistic that the shift in values is already taking place because there’s too much happening with mindfulness, too much happening with meditation. You’ve got billionaires who just give it all up and go back into nature. I mean, these cases are happening, and it’s kind of like the beginning. It’s like the wave hasn’t totally formed, maybe, but you can feel the beginnings of it.
Rick: Yeah, good point. I should let you end on that point because that’s such a profound thing you just said. But there’s a quote here that I forgot to read out earlier from your book that I think is worth saying. I don’t know who said this—you can tell us: “If the brain were simple enough to understand, we would be too simple to understand it.” Which is great. It’s like this pull-yourself-up-by-your-own-bootstraps impossibility kind of thing. You know, I mean, if the brain were simple enough to understand, we would be too simple. Our understanding would be too rudimentary to understand the brain.
Chris: I think it was an engineer who actually came up with that. I can’t remember his name. But, you know, it’s a great paradox to kind of use as a koan. And it shows the limitations of understanding. So, you know, we go into the world, and just simple things like waking up in the morning—we do make choices. Do I want to think today? Do I want to not just ponder on problems, but—thinking mind, it likes to create problems—do I want to get into that world? Or do I want to get into the world of thoughtless nature? You know, it’s amazing how much happens in the universe without thinking. Grass grows. The planet revolves on its axis. I mean, these majestic elements of the universe.
Rick: I mean, you digest lunch. Imagine if you had to think your way through that.
Chris: Yeah, and the universe gets along really well without thinking. Now, again, the thinking mind is going to object and say, “Well, what do you want, to get rid of me altogether?” And again, no, that’s not the point. It’s to bring a little bit of balance back into our lives, where the drive to work can be a meditation. And so people ask me a lot about my formal meditation. You know, like I said, I had a hard time with sitting meditation. So I ended up doing Tai Chi for a very long time, and Qigong. But even these days, I don’t find myself putting time aside for meditation much. I enjoy the shift from being in my mind to simply living a conscious life. And so anything becomes a meditation.
Rick: Nice. Good. All righty. And just to reiterate that point you made a minute ago, about there seems to be some kind of wave building, which will enable us to be a more right-brained world. And I think we’ll, as we said earlier, hopefully be a balanced world in which we don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater. We maintain all of our technological sophistication, but we counterbalance it with what is so sorely needed in terms of spirituality, consciousness, heart, compassion, all those beautiful qualities. Any final thoughts?
Chris: I always like to end with something that’s kind of a cliché. It’s found its way around, you know; it’s become a meme of sorts, but that’s okay. I mean, I’m glad it’s a meme. And it’s a real simple statement: “Don’t believe everything you think.” And, you know, that’s kind of a great place to start. And it’s a great way to start the day because the thoughts are going to come, and whether you play with them or take them seriously is all about that. If you buy into the thoughts, it’s going to be a very serious life, and you’re going to be carrying that luggage around. Put the luggage down. Enter it with a kind of skepticism: maybe not all my thoughts are necessarily accurate. And then interesting things start to happen, where you shift into a state of just simple consciousness. Everyone’s natural state. This is who I was. I was an infant, and this was quite natural to me.
And then I had imposed a system of thinking on top of that. And that’s okay that that happened, and it’s okay even if I got pulled into taking things very seriously. I mean, even taking things seriously doesn’t necessarily have to be taking things seriously. So there are a lot of playful ways that you can bring into your life.
Rick: Yeah, and however stuck one might feel in a left-brain way of living, there’s hope. Evolution is never-ending, and whatever your age, whatever your circumstances, whatever your degree of conditioning, life goes on. And we can always move it in the right direction. We can’t attain instant liberation, as you were talking about in the beginning, necessarily, but we have a certain wiggle room. We can keep using our wiggle room to push things, guide things, or allow things to move in an evolutionary direction. And they will. “Seek and ye shall find,” and all that.
Chris: And even if you’re coming down hard—if your left brain is coming down hard on yourself, and you say, “Well, I’m a failure, and I’ve messed this up, and I keep getting off track”—there’s no way you can mess it up. I mean, if there’s only God playing at being you, then you’re giving God a very interesting experience. And so that recognition—you go into this like, you know, the universe has got your back. You can’t mess this up, and that ironically actually helps us not mess it up so much, which is very strange, but it seems to be true.
Rick: Yeah, there’s a verse in the Gita which says, “No effort is lost, and no obstacle exists.” Good. All right, well, thanks so much, Chris. I’ll put up a page on BatGap.com with a link to your website and your books, and people can find your YouTube channel there, too. Your YouTube channel has a ton of really interesting videos. And incidentally, there’s a tool—let me see what it… Oh, here it is. I’m going to open it up and tell people what it is so not everybody emails me to ask. It’s called—well, there are various ones, but the one I use is called MediaHuman YouTube to MP3. MediaHuman YouTube to MP3. And you can use it to download every video on a YouTube channel and automatically convert it into audio files, which is what I did with Chris’s channel because he has hundreds of videos on there.
Then you can take those audio files and get them onto your iPhone or whatever and listen to them while you’re driving and stuff. Because, I don’t know, I wouldn’t sit and watch hundreds of videos in front of my computer. Couldn’t do it. All right, so thanks so much, and thanks to those who have been listening or watching. My next interview will be in a couple of weeks with Lucy Grace, whom I interviewed a few years ago. She lives on an island off the coast of New Zealand. Everybody liked her a lot, so we’re going to revisit her and see how she’s doing. So I’ll talk to you later. Thanks, Chris. Bye.
Chris: Thanks, Rick. [Music]






