
Kittisaro and Thanissara Transcript: Warrior to Lover, Surrender, and Awakening
Kittisaro and Thanissara interview
Rough draft
Non-speech: [Music]
Rick Archer: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer. Buddha at the Gas Pump is an ongoing series of interviews with spiritually awakening people. I have done about 425 of them now and if this is new to you and you’d like to watch previous ones, go to batgap.com and look under the past interviews menu where you will see all the previous ones organized in various ways. This show is made possible by the support of appreciative listeners and viewers. So if you appreciate it and feel like supporting it in any amount, there’s a PayPal button on every page of the site and if you don’t like PayPal, there’s a donate page where you can see other ways of supporting it. My guests today are Kittisaro and Thanissara. I’m going to have them give us their own biographical background sketches rather than me just reading the thing they sent me because I think it’ll be more interesting if you hear them say it than if I read it. So which of you would like to go first?
Kittisaro: Hello, I don’t know if it’s here, it’s early afternoon but it’s nice for us to have a chance to be at Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Kittisaro. I grew up in Tennessee with a Jewish father and a Southern Baptist mother, so that was unusual. And my life took me from a Southern military school where I was into wrestling up to Princeton in the Northeast to Oxford.
Rick Archer: And you were quite the wrestler. You were winning these regional championships and stuff.
Kittisaro: Yeah, that was a very central part of who I felt I was. With my body now, it’s hard to…
Rick Archer: You don’t look like much of a wrestler.
Kittisaro: And that’s true, but I really loved it and we had a region called the Mid-South. I was Mid-South champion and then we went to a national tournament that I won and that was, of course, Princeton is a great university but they also had a very good wrestling team. So I went up there and got hurt very early on and needed a shoulder operation and then when it looked like I would need another one, I realized I had to let wrestling go. But I was going to go to medical school after Princeton and I unexpectedly got a chance to go to Oxford on a Rhodes scholarship and it’s when I went to Oxford that I then in my studies of Aldous Huxley then started learning a little bit about Buddhism. And I never made it back to medical school because in the middle of my thesis it was a huge topic – art, science and mysticism in the works of Aldous Huxley. But I was very interested in how these different modes of being inform each other and in the middle of it I heard about a great forest master in Thailand called Ajahn Chah and I met someone who offered to take me and I got a leave of absence from my scholarship and the thesis I was writing and I ended up staying a Buddhist monk for 15 years in that Thai forest tradition. Later we got invited to start monasteries in England and that’s when I met Thanissara and we after our monastic life we then fell in love and left the monastery and were married in ’92 and then have spent the last 23 years a lot of that time in South Africa running a hermitage there and more and more being invited to teach in this country. So at the moment we’re in Massachusetts leading a retreat.
Rick Archer: And obviously there are all kinds of other juicy details in there like getting typhoid fever and being flat on your back for three years and stuff like that. But maybe he’ll reference back to some of that stuff as we go. And how about you Thanissara?
Thanissara: Yeah, hi everyone. My name is Thanissara. My background is from London, originally from London. I was grew up in an Anglo-Irish family. My father and his family large immigrant family from Dublin and then my mother’s side from the east end And I was part of the working class so I didn’t really have a spectacular academic trajectory to go along. Left school quite young and started work and tried to earn some money to go to college and working as a domestic for a year or so in France and then managed to put a portfolio through and go to art school. And it was at art school that I started to come across alternative culture and moved out of the family home and moved into a commune and started to explore meditation and alternative states of consciousness and alternative lifestyles. I also went to Krishnamurti a lot. He was in Brockwood Park at that time. We all went to go listen to him. It was in the 1970s and I was very very attracted to read everything that he read but I had a dilemma about his pathless path because I couldn’t really kind of make that leap and around that time I started meditating doing a lot of these very strict Burmese style retreats with the Goenka U Ba Khin school and then around that time I met Ajahn Chah when he first came to England and then went to Thailand and considered ordaining. Eventually ordained back in England. Actually today is the anniversary 38 years ago when I first took my first robes actually in Britain and became a nun and stayed as a nun trained for 12 years in that forest school, helped build a couple of monasteries, co-founded. We were part of a team, a group building the first monasteries in the UK. Left, as Kittisaro said, when we fell in love together and decided you know also more I think deeper currents that were leading us out of the monastery and then we were invited to South Africa and as he said we taught there, taught in Europe and Israel the last 20 odd years, 25 years or so and then more recently probably the last eight years I’ve been teaching more in the US. I was part of the Spirit Rock community dharma leader training that went over two years looking at diversity and bringing the dharma out more into the culture and I also trained as a therapeutic process when I realized I sort of really needed to backtrack and look at sort of deeper levels of wounding and understand what happened. Teaching a lot, there’s a lot of psychodynamic material that comes up so we really want to have more skills around that. So now we’re setting up our own non-profit. We’ve set up our own non-profit in in Sebastopol in the west coast and about to launch our own training next year which will be around the synthesis of Mahayana, Theravada, psycho-spiritual work but particularly looking at application of that work for the planetary emergency that we’re in, how to respond to that and at the heart of that around the shift of consciousness needed, not just what we do but where we do it from, from a sort of separative consciousness to a more seamless understanding of reality.
Rick Archer: That’s great. There’s a line from a Paul Simon song which says, “My lack of education hasn’t hurt me none” and I would say that with regard to you you’re an excellent writer. I really enjoyed reading your books.
Thanissara: Thank you so much.
Rick Archer: That was Kodachrome by the way, that song. So, I love, one thing I like about your books is I love the sort of activist emphasis that you know, the sort of otherworldliness and renunciation quality that often comes across in spiritual circles. You’ve kind of moved beyond that and you’re very concerned about the world and as you were just sort of alluding to, I really think that the ultimate solution to the critical problems we face is a spiritual one and so let’s talk about that a bit today to maybe enliven that idea and collective consciousness even more.
Thanissara: Well, I think we first began to really open out and to engage Dharma practice when we were in South Africa. You know, we landed in a country that was still very impacted and still is impacted by colonialism and apartheid and that felt like it generated a lot of obviously a lot of racial division but within internally also developed to generated a lot of division and you know, extreme discrepancy between wealth and poverty and very profoundly under-resourced communities that we were in the midst of in the rural KwaZulu-Natal. At the heart of our time there in the late 1990s, we found ourselves in one of the centers of the pandemic of the AIDS crisis. So sitting on our Zafus and you know, teaching loving-kindness and insight meditation really wasn’t enough and people were literally knocking on our doors wanting help and so then we started to explore setting up projects and fundraising and training people to respond to the crisis when the government was in 10 years of denial. And I think also energized from that and coming back into the northern hemisphere and seeing that we had very quickly shifted into what we’ve always been aware of but suddenly realizing that we’re in a very serious situation with the climate and the increase of the warming of the biosphere and the implications of that. So that kind of led me into more you know on the streets activism going to and more recently going to Standing Rock and being engaged in trainings and looking at how we can bring the Buddhist community on board more as a collective. You know this is a very well-resourced community very in many ways entitled community and that it’s been very focused on individual awakening. So how could we more collectively respond. So that’s still happening and I think there’s been a lot of shifts around that at speed in response but perhaps not quite enough yet. But at the heart of it what you’re talking about and I think it’s very pertinent to people that will be watching Buddha at the gas pump is you know even if we change the systems clearly we need to change at systemic level and that’s happening already but if we don’t infuse those systems with a radical change of consciousness then you know the you know as the Buddha said the fundamental nature of greed, hatred and delusion whatever system it picks up that will be suffused through those structures and the power dynamic. You know we obviously have a problem with a very exaggerated and isolated inflated sense of self that is subsumed this this sense of entitlement and power over of nature of life of you know as a hierarchy of power that’s one of the primary systems that we’re in. You know people are humans over nature over animals masculine over the feminine you know white over people of color you know so there’s this kind of structure where we don’t actually experience ourselves as part of a web of life we’re not really in the web of life anymore so the realization that actually when we go into a meditative process and into the jitta or the heart that heart is not divided the heart of a pure awareness is you know sensitive and non-dual in its nature it’s the mano-viññāṇa the mind that goes out and discriminates and discerns and differentiates which is necessary and we use that mind that has generated this vastly differentiated world and these structures that have divorced us really from a deep sense of belonging and I think that lack of deep sense of belonging deep sense of the sacred inherent within all of life is one of our core diseases and is leading to this extreme destruction that we’re seeing. Yeah
Rick Archer: So just perhaps summarize what you just said whatever we see in the world whatever that is in any way influenced by human activity is a reflection of the ambient collective consciousness that is created by the contribution of all seven billion of us and if there’s you know if we’re seeing environmental devastation and economic inequity and all this all the other things you itemized then those are just like symptoms of something in the collective consciousness that we all are creating just as a boil on the skin might be a symptom of a you know some impurity in the blood or something and you know so that people might despair in hearing that because they might think well how are we going to get seven billion people to change their consciousness what difference can I make? Perhaps you could respond to that question.
Kittisaro: Well even when one person’s consciousness changes it can have a profound impact we’ve spent the last much of the last 23-24 years in South Africa and we were when we left the monastery we had no money we were homeless and being invited because of our meditative past I’d been a monk 15 years and Thanissara had been a nun for about the same length of time we would be invited to different places to teach the dharma and then an invitation came to come to South Africa and we were supposed to arrive right after their elections back in 94 and our friends in the UK at the time said oh don’t go there it’s going to be a bloodbath but when we meditated on it contemplated we thought we’re being invited for a good purpose to share and encourage to share the dharma encourage people to practice training the heart we thought why not go and so we arrived right after the elections and the country was in a euphoria at the time because the elections had gone surprisingly peacefully but being in that land and having the impact of one person like the leadership of Mandela who famously said when you harbor resentment it’s a little bit like drinking poison and hoping it will kill your enemies I mean he spent 27 years in a prison cell and someone who who just realized the need for for forgiving and for including and and it was so we shouldn’t sometimes when we so much try on the outer side to change things we’re coming from force from desire and not always in touch with the and appreciate the power of of our being and our presence and so that’s one thing I really appreciate about my monastic training when I was a wrestler I just relied on willpower and I could do more push-ups I could do 500 push-ups a day and climb rope and walk on my hands for 100 yards and work harder than anybody and I was insane with studies I you know to me getting to success was just through hard work and it was in my monastic life when I ran into typhoid fever and just got flattened you know I found that there’s some things you can’t just shift with with willpower and always I realized before I was always moving ahead to success as some place to get to and that’s this acquiring mind that generates a sense of the sacred is not here there’s a lack here it’s we’re going to get to the good stuff to success by pushing driving and getting rid of what we shouldn’t have and it was in this profound surrender to a situation that I wouldn’t have chosen and with the help of the buddha’s teachings to discover that actually all of this stuff that we take to be our life is arising and ceasing right inside this this wide background of awareness of consciousness and that rather than us going through life in the sense life is is manifesting through us and it changes at the core there can have profound impacts around and so you know to me that heartens me you know I still want to be sensitive to what’s going on in the world and try to encourage the good but I through seeing examples like for example we have a friend who was one of Mr. Mandela’s bodyguards and so you probably remember there was a lot of faction fighting in tribal warfare that was being even stirred up by the apartheid government because they wanted to be able to say see these blacks say they can’t rule they just kill each other and and so when Mandela was the president from 94 to 99 in the province where we were staying a lot of violence broke out in KZN, KwaZulu Natal in the town of Richmond there was one faction killing people in Mr. Mandela’s party the African National Congress and so Mandela being who he is he said I want to go there I want to speak to the people there so and so our friend his bodyguard one of his bodyguards went with him and they drove to Richmond and the place the streets were full of people and Mandela wanted to get out of the bulletproof presidential car and walk among the people and the bodyguard and the other vassals just said Mr. President you can’t do that they’ll kill you there had already been quite a few ANC members murdered and Mr. Mandela our friend recounts Mr. Mandela said if I can’t walk down the streets of my own city as the president of this country he said you might as well shoot me now and he got out of the car and the the people were so touched and stunned it sent this wave of of being moved that he was willing to make himself vulnerable and and trusting something deeper within the human nature and so so there’s one person and we say oh well how many Mandela’s are there well we shouldn’t devalue ourselves you know that what we do when we learn to trust and know this place where everything comes together where we sense our kinship with each other and with mother earth that more mysterious things can happen and so I think I think that is it helps me return from a place of despair to something I can do
Rick Archer: Yeah I would suggest that perhaps Mandela and King and Gandhi and people like that it’s not like one person had this incredible leverage and just change things single-handedly it’s that they themselves were representative of some kind of groundswell or shift that was taking place in collective consciousness and they served in the capacity or the role of you know leader of this representative of that and being able to make decisions and be something that people could recognize but that they were actually well I think I just said that they were an expression of some deep shift that was taking place in the collective.
Thanissara: They were also they had this they had a training that enabled them to channel that
Rick Archer: To
Thanissara: Fill that role at 27 years of transmuting what must have been an enormous amount of frustration and anger yeah and hatred and really you know turning the prison into a university knowing that eventually they would actually win and preparing for that but absolutely he’s not standing alone but also I think the question of it doesn’t need 7 billion of us right to make the shifts I think you know that theory of the tipping point I can’t remember what the percentage is but it’s not that much.
Rick Archer: Well there’s different percentages in different systems like in the heart 1% of the cells are called pacemaker cells and they regulate the beating of the whole heart and in some non-living systems such as a laser or a magnet or particularly a laser one square root of 1% of the photons have to align coherently and all the other photons will entrain with them so it could be that rather small percentages of the population need to undergo a profound shift in order for the whole population because they’re you know because they’re functioning at a more fundamental level and we know that if you can function at a more fundamental level it influences the more superficial levels more effectively than if you’re functioning on the surface
Thanissara: Yeah and you can see that with what’s happening now in say in the US and across the world where people are waking up very fast to the the collective planetary emergency that we’re in that there’s also an enormous amount of awakening happening yeah it’s like the intensity of the of the situation the crisis a deep crisis which really a crisis of consciousness of seeing ourself as separate really from the web of life I think that’s the fundamentally that dualistic conscious or separative consciousness where we don’t actually experience ourselves in an embodied way is as part of the within the deep sense of belonging web of life there is that sense of you know alienation and therefore all of the pathologies that have merged out of that we’re seeing that pathology at extreme degree now in the political leaders they’re lost, they’re degraded, they’re soulless, they’re purely off the power and the oligarchs the tiny percent you know trying to control and rule it all and then underneath you see this this ferment happening you know awakening and speeding up at great great you know at great speed.
Rick Archer: Yeah we’re also seeing you know the opioid epidemic and all these mass shootings and all that stuff which is seems to me symptomatic of something in almost symptomatic of the sort of craziness and despair and hopelessness that people feel.
Thanissara: Yeah
Rick Archer: Whereas if you can have the perspective that we’re expressing here that there is actually a mass awakening taking place then you’re not so depressed by the six o’clock news you know you feel like well something actually good is happening it’s not making the news because it’s too subtle but we really there’s really hope for
Thanissara: Yeah there is but we shouldn’t be too pollyannish about it the enormous challenge of what we’re facing and also the degradation to so many communities that are in peoples that are really so profoundly marginalized and unsupported that these extreme events are happening.
Rick Archer: Yeah I’m sure you would agree that you know it’s not sufficient just to sit on the cushion but it’s also not sufficient just to be the activist who doesn’t sit on the cushion I mean that the ideal blend is both if there can be sort of you know an awakening of one’s own consciousness then an expression of that in activity of some sort you’re going to be much more effective.
Kittisaro: You said it and you know that that’s true and we continually find the balance I mean so many people in the who care the carers and the activists get burned out and overwhelmed by by the monumental tasks at hand and that’s where the meditative skills of being as able also to reflect on this is how it is there’s the sense of overwhelm there’s the nervous system and that misfiring there’s exhaustion. I’m so grateful to the buddha’s teaching who reminded us that the sacred is always right at the heart of however it is here and now and that it’s not just when we get to the place where we think it should be so in those moments of overwhelm to have cultivated and still be cultivating that capacity to say this is how it is now and to to see the exhaustion and the sensations in the body of the nervous system freaking out a bit and to hear the thoughts scrambling and just to know them as they are feelings and phenomenon coming and going again within a spacious listening within awareness that’s not moving and to know how to engage but also know how to retreat this skillful shuttling of how to resource ourselves and when we do that we’re I can’t find it in the scriptures but it’s like I remember a story once that if a cow was stuck in the mud you could jump in the mud to keep a cow company but you might you know just get hurt and you both go down but you need a solid purchase and then to make contact from a solid purchase to be able to to pull this suffering creature out so in moments even when we’re overwhelmed if we come to the actuality of the sensations the feelings whatever’s happening in being overwhelmed that’s the solid purpose of purchase our our refuge our abiding in is on the truth of the matter and then we can recharge somewhat to then allow to respond from what is to how we maybe can can do something
Rick Archer: Yeah in other words if you don’t know how to swim don’t try to get a job as a lifeguard and in the Gita Lord Krishna says established in yoga perform action so first kind of get yourself grounded in being or whatever you want to call it and then on that foundation action can be more effective and more appropriate more right.
Thanissara: I think it’s more responsive because you’re learning to align with the innate intelligence of awareness the Buddho you know the knowing this pure knowing awareness it’s dynamic it’s intelligent and it’s connected with the depth intelligence of the dharma or reality then you start to listen to that then there’s a certain guidance or responsiveness that’s not just coming from the cognitive strategizing mind you can use that in service of so that’s that you know without that then I think our our responses and very colored by our agendas which are effective but I don’t think they really have the profound power of the transformative nature of what we’re talking about and what’s really needed to transform the consciousness in terms of how we respond where we come from what’s needed you know.
Rick Archer: No that’s great I guess another way of putting it is that you know there’s a profound vast unbounded intelligence orchestrating the universe and if we’re estranged from that isolated cut off from that then we’re kind of left to our own wits you know to sort of manage in life but if we can become attuned to that then that intelligence guides and governs our life.
Thanissara: I was very struck when I was at Standing Rock how the whole indigenous community that was represented
Rick Archer: There
Thanissara: Yeah how they actually moved from that place and how it was so so ancient from so ancestral that their activism and their engagement in taking on what was really quite extreme aggressive forces that it was very clear that they were completely trusting the power of ceremony and prayer and the spiritual and the sacred and their trainings were around that and the decolonization of the mind that’s kind of constantly going into the sense of me fighting against them the hierarchy of power you know to really explore that how that suffuses everything that we how we think what we’re doing so for me it was very radical to be there I felt a great honor to be there as someone learning from an ancient peoples that hold this peace and held it so profoundly the way they moved in the way that they responded but definitely that sense of that deep intelligence being informed by that was that it had a real sense of sacredness it suffused yeah now
Rick Archer: Some people might argue that you know well that was nice but the pipeline got built but yeah what would you say to that yeah
Thanissara: It’s not over they they’re still court cases going on but also it’s not you know they’ve been doing this for 500 years they’ve you know the first nation peoples indigenous peoples is they’ve learned a lot in terms of standing up to extreme power it’s not just you know a little bit of power that we that we could overturn this is a the power that has committed genocide upon them and across the lands and so they they’ve you know they’ve known it is to be profoundly brutalized and disenfranchised and they you know they’ve also been extremely marginalized but they’ve learned something that’s really profound and and that that was for me what was really important was to honor that learning and for them to recognize yes this isn’t the end of the this is a battle that wasn’t seemingly at first has been i don’t know if it’s completely lost because as i said there’s court cases going on but it but it’s not the end of the the war the longer struggle you know so yeah another thing is
Rick Archer: That
Thanissara: I mean there were 2 000 vets
Rick Archer: Yeah i i saw a documentary
Thanissara: Inspired i think it inspired it you know inspired activists to come from this very radically different place so that was what was so profound to me
Rick Archer: And the occupy movement was sort of along those same lines but um just on this point it’s a little tangential but i saw a documentary recently about how quickly solar and other alternative energies are moving along and the guy was saying at the rate they’re going um oil is not going to be viable much longer you know below a certain price or above a certain price and that that pipeline and many other types of oil you know canadian tar sands and and the back end oil is just going to become it’s going to get priced out of the market because
Thanissara: Yeah the money
Rick Archer: Even in dubai they’re they’re going to solar and they’ve got all the oil in the world that they’re sitting on yeah i think the
Thanissara: Economics of it was is going to be the main game changer actually as it often is and we are in this crunch of an energy revolution which is sort of in a way reflective of the consciousness revolution it’s very exciting
Rick Archer: It is yeah i just want to come back to the point that you know if we keep talking about this kind of thing um standing rock and energy resolution revolutions and things like that it’s because that those and the consciousness of the earth and and the whole thing of awakening and enlightenment and all that many people watching this show are interested in are inextricably intertwined if it’s like two legs of a stool you pull one and the rest are going to come along if there’s really an awakening going on then it’s going to change these these economic and social structures because those again are an expression of the collective consciousness
Kittisaro: Absolutely and there’s a another way an ordinary person can can contribute this this machine that’s chewing up the resources of the earth and and crushing over the creatures and and the peoples that stand in the way is built around this this uh insatiable consuming of everything and so when people are practicing as as we do in the contemplative world learning to tune into the sheer joy of standing and relaxing of breathing and aligning ourself with this uh cosmic rhythm and and tuning up the awareness to to notice the nature of form and and how that takes us back home to this deep place of belonging because at our deepest place we merge with that awareness that that holds everything when we when we learn how to take a holiday to to return in moments to a a place of wholeness by breath and body and awareness we’re living in a way that is not exploiting anybody not unnecessarily resources in the earth when we all try to move our diets to more plant based diets that that’s another way we can contribute to to turning the dial down on that rampant consumerism that keeps you know feeding this uh this chewing up of the resources of the earth right and so I just don’t I don’t want to forget that I want to include that that moments when we do that in moments also when we an important part of our work is when we come together collectively and have ceremonies together and and grow beyond our individual personalities and and invoke this power of unity and harmony there’s an energy that really is a blessing and transformative that I think helped us for example survive 23 years in South Africa at a time that it was very turbulent and quite challenging that I would like to to encourage us to realize we can balance the the activist work or honor the activist work but also honor what we do even in personal ways when we learn how to in Buddhism it’s called cultivate samadhi it’s states of unity that aren’t in in a wholesome pleasant abiding that’s not dependent on chewing up any external resources that’s that’s born of pausing listening uh welcoming and and that sort of skillful learning how to take a holiday learning how to find joy in in nature joy in walking and sitting and awareness is on a wider level when more people do that has a big impact on a on a culture that maybe has this idea that what really makes us healthy is consuming more and more and more now I’m just saying that that’s another powerful way to to address the crisis as we learn to need less and as we you know I was trying to make that
Rick Archer: That’s good I mean I every around Christmas time every year the news is all about the sales records and the people mobbing the stores and you know stampeding and fighting over some latest toy stuff like that and it just seems so crazy I know that in our case like our car is like I don’t know 16 17 years old and every now and then we think you know should we get a newer car but all we hardly ever do is drive around town and the car does that just fine so we figure well let’s hang on to it maybe it’ll last until really good electric cars come out that we can afford.
Thanissara: Yeah which they are beginning to and I think the other you know looking at Christmas for example you know it’s like all of us in this awakening world you know we could encourage a non-consumption Christmas you know for people as leaders and teachers to look at that do we really need to contribute to that and I think the other point that Kittisaro made that might have been muffled in the in the sound difficulty was the them shifting to more plant-based diets as a very profound contribution as one of the leading causes of climate destabilization and eco-destruction and also besides what it does for us and what it does for us so we can survive on the planet it’s just decolonizing our mind from this idea that we have the right to control animals or as a native expression is our relatives you know these are our relatives we just perceive them as animals and see them as though on the hierarchy so those kinds of mindsets that that doesn’t that we don’t have the right to do that really now that we’re so aware of what it involves in these huge agro farms so this sort of awareness where everything that we’re connected with as you say the car that you’re driving the flights we take I mean we’re all contributing to this economy through the use of oil and it can’t be avoided but I think the heightening of awareness begins to change our engagement in our activity is what mindfulness does and you find yourself one day you said I can’t do that like that anymore let me find another way and I think this is it’s a gradual thing but it needs to happen faster and I think it is actually it’s picking up steam it’s picking up speed and you see these tipping points happening you know like chain major fast food chains beginning to introduce vegan options into the into the hamburgers and so on and these sort of beyond meat organizations and these investments in looking at looking at dietary you know meat replacements and so on so yeah
Rick Archer: Things can change faster than people think I mean you know the Berlin Wall fell quite abruptly and the Soviet Union collapsed quite abruptly but also you know when we think of tipping points or well there’s negative tipping points of course in terms of methane being released from the Arctic but but ordinary tipping points like in or phase transitions are sometimes called in physics where like you have water at 99 degrees centigrade and nothing much seems to be happening one more degree and it’s turning to steam and boiling so there could be phase transitions like that in society as well that we might be closer to than we realize
Thanissara: It’s not unpredictable there’s a lot of wild cards out there we don’t know which way they’ll tip definitely including in the political realm you could tip into fascism
Rick Archer: Yeah or tip into something a lot more enlightened
Thanissara: Hopefully
Rick Archer: Yeah, I want to totally shift gears and go back to your typhoid fever and you’re also talking about Mandela in jail for 27 years and the fellow I interviewed from South Africa recently John Lockley talks about something called thwasa or something in the Sangoma tradition which is this sickness that people often get when they are marked to become a Sangoma you know a spiritual leader in that tradition it’s like kind of nature puts them through the ringer in terms of something they’ve got to work out there are stories in Christian tradition like that too St. Francis got very sick before undergoing the transition he did and there are many other examples so is there something like that in the Buddhist tradition that’s known
Kittisaro: Absolutely and it you know it wasn’t what my sense of self wanted my aspirations right but you know when I told you I was quite a willful person used to being able just to shift things through force of will but then when I when I hit typhoid fever after six months of diarrhea and got bit by a centipede and was urinating blood and got weaker but I was still pushing pushing but then the typhoid fever knocked me down and then my whole body was different for years it ulcerates all your insides and I was really really exhausted and had to pretty much lie down for three years and was quite ill for 10 but there’s a principle in Buddhism called devadūta which is called heavenly messenger and that in the Buddha’s own life it was these encountering things that his first reaction was to turn away from him recoil because he didn’t want to really look at and be with old age sickness and death but he caught himself and thought what what am I he talked like well the vanity left me when I realized you but but this body has the nature to age and sicken and die so what am I what am I reacting to and how it’s a heavenly messenger at the time I I didn’t know but when I couldn’t couldn’t shift it you know I could have just quit and blamed everybody but when my teachers and the Buddha talks about no there’s something important here surrender to this receive a teaching here and then this first noble truth this ennobling truth of of of Dukkha it’s not a static thing the Buddha said when there is that which is hard to bear like sickness it it he didn’t say it needs to be conquered he said it needs to be opened to and then when one opens to it just on the first level one deepens one’s capacity to be real to be realistic and and in in an opening to it there’s been a possibility of seeing how we keep feeding it and perpetuating so this insight into how suffering is continued by wanting things to be different and that that somehow when there is that opening to that and in moments of of questioning what happens if I just let something be what if I if I’m able let go of just clinging to the idea of how it should be and clinging to this aversion this shouldn’t be this plan it’s not fair done all this work I’ve come all this way if we somehow let them be and then those moods just become what they are those feelings we touch into this sacred ground this ever-present background awareness within which all manifests and dissolved and that is a profound shifting of lineage we what we used to think was me worries my poor sickness we realize that’s true but only as ephemeral sensations we drop into this deeper abiding so that’s and and this this truth of the rebirth in a sense not being reborn out of in so another body but renewal is is the same principle in the cross in the in resurrection you know by opening to the suffering there’s a possibility of of the deep transformation similarly in this noble truth of suffering and in my case this opening to a sickness it it’s later became really important because when I couldn’t do any of the monastic routines I had to lie down all that time and the internal bleeding and I had a lot chronic inflammation and was very weak but the so I lying down meditation is a wonderful thing on each outbreath I would let go trying to get anywhere and just feel the support of the ground and when similarly when one softens volition of trying to change things one can recognize that part of being itself which just is yeah and so I had a chance really to to deepen in that which I’m grateful that the illness gave me an opportunity.
Rick Archer: Yeah I know a fellow who wrote a book called “Blessed by a Brain Tumor” he felt he learned a lot from it. Here’s a couple sentences from your book which pertain to this. He said “The Buddha realized that actually life is unfolding perfectly according to its own natural laws. At its core it is peaceful and luminous habitually wanting this moment to be other than it is however causes distress and we lose sight of our true nature.” And then a little bit later on “Suffering is something that is generated from the mind’s inability to accept reality.” Yeah kind of sounds like Byron Katie if you’re familiar with her. Yeah
Thanissara: It’s that that’s the Four Noble Truths at the heart of the Buddha’s teaching so profound sometimes it’s like oh yeah I’ve got that what’s the real profound stuff but to realize that a lot of the dukkha the suffering that is you know there’s pain and difficulty that comes to us but what we do with it is the reactivity around that is generated from the mind itself and that we can solve. So once we get that peace and as a practice and then feel the fruit of that it’s a direct doorway into the unconditioned into the unborn and the unoriginated so that nexus of dukkha being a gateway is a very different relationship to that experience than dukkha is something we abstract ourselves from and you know we go shopping we we have our addictive tendencies so it’s a very profound learning and it’s almost a learning that can only come about sometimes when we’re stuck and we can make no other move than to let go which is what a monastic life will do it will push you in the corner or you know deadly sickness and then of course when that letting go then all sorts of mysterious unfoldings and shifts of consciousness start to happen.
Kittisaro: And ironically the letting go sometimes makes a healing much more possible because one’s limited sense of how it should be and all that pushing and pulling and contraction really messes up our subtle energy channels because we think we’re separate but you know just even on the level of breath we realize this ocean of vitality that we can breathe in breathe what we breathe in the trees breathe out and what we breathe out the trees breathe in and that’s just breath. Now I don’t mean to mention these subtle connections to consciousness we’re hooked up with this whole undivided mystery and when one is wrestling with the will doing all this stuff that constricts the channels that feed us and when my teacher my western teacher who remembered me when I was I used to teach the monks yoga I used to I was so active and so he wanted me to get well and one day when he came up to my room when I was in this attic for a long time or out of the way of the monastery was a bit of a building in a site because we were repairing this old victorian house the abbot said Kittisaro I realize I’ve been putting all this pressure on you to get well because we wanted to get back to how you used to be and he said I give you permission to die and he says not we want you to die
Rick Archer: Right
Kittisaro: But and the the relief the the relief of joy and in more profoundly surrendering to a situation sometimes the very mysterious energy that can help transform that thing is allowed to flow and I didn’t die and little by little my energy returned and so I think these even though we’re so convinced it shouldn’t be this way and sometimes we feel guilty as an activist oh does it mean I just don’t care if I’m letting go for a moment of this horror at what people are doing or what has happened I think we we should trust to that in those moments of softening and letting go we’re touching down into a deeper reservoir that can also refresh a situation and so I would really encourage activists and we do that just to survive to learn to modulate being on the front lines to pausing and and feeling into the perfection of a moment even when it’s painful. Sure
Rick Archer: Well as you know I mean we die within seconds if we had to consciously willfully orchestrate and control all the functions in our body I mean we’d just be gone in a moment and there are but there are more functions such as behavior and thought and all kinds of things that actually can also be put in the lap of God as it were and manage much more skillfully than our puny intelligence can manage if we’re willing to let go and well there’s the bumper sticker you know let go and let God. An interesting question came in from Faisal Al Sarhi from Lebanon he asks he says around two months ago I participated in a Vipassana retreat as taught by S. N. Goenka I would say that that was a very dry patriarchal approach I did not resonate with it at all and it is said that the Theravada tradition has rarely produced any realized being in the last thousand years unlike Mahayana tradition which is rich and layered. Can you comment on this and before you do I just wanted to read a quote from Thanissara’s book she said when monasticism and spiritual practice are overly shaped by a warrior strategy mostly focused on overcoming the pull of the world they tend to offer only a partial ripening one that eventually undermines a fuller and more integrated awakening the times we are now in invite a shift from a transcendent metaphor which holds us to a lonely road where we throw away the world like an old rag to an integrative vision where awakening is collective and radiates into all spheres of life with a blessed healing touch for this the powerful dedicated and loyal warrior is invited to enter the path of love.
Thanissara: Wow I couldn’t have said it better myself thank you for the question I also we both began our journeys with a vipassana style called vipassana as taught by Goenkaji and I moved on from that partly because I did find it became a rigid it became rigid I think inwardly and outwardly for me not for everyone else a very powerful technique it was originally taught by Ledi Sayadaw as a Burmese forest master that methodology of taking attention through the body but it was taught as a healing method actually physical healing and that’s if you remember the story of Goenka he went to get healing for his migraines so it has a is a very powerful method but it’s also it’s not very integrated at all I would say yes that’s the problem I found that you leave the meditation retreat there’s no integration so the way of awakening we’re not really here to just become a good meditator a good Buddhist we’re here to awaken and these are methods these are pathways and there’s many many pathways offered and you know through the Mahayana through the Theravada I think it’s hard to like when Ajahn Chah was asked you know are you enlightened are you awakened and he said well it actually takes one to know one he would never speculate on that you know I would refute the idea that there’s no awakened Theravada masters I think we’ve seen some very contemporary ones in the forest school and in also many schools many different ways you know it depends how we define that too you know that’s a whole discussion.
Rick Archer: How we define awaken
Thanissara: You mean? Yeah how we define enlightenment and masters and so on. I
Rick Archer: Want to touch on that as we
Thanissara: Go along. So in my journey I found it wasn’t only Buddhist meditation which is core Buddhist teaching but also doing psychotherapeutic work, doing body work, doing somatic healing work, doing shamanic work you know different kinds of work to supplement so that there’s more integrated and fullness of embodied awakening so it’s not just a sort of transcendent that abdicates from the emotional plane, from the embodied plane, from the relational field. So my point in the book was that actually a lot of Theravada and you find it very strongly in the Mahayana too is the Buddhist metaphor is very much steeped in the warrior mode you know you sort of you know the the tremendous effort it takes for awakening but when you find it a Buddha’s life you use that you know in the archetypal journey of his life when he was trying to crush the body, not breathe, refused to eat food and he got to the point of near death and then appears the young compassionate maiden, Sthartha, who comes with milk rice and offers him nourishment and at that point he realizes he needs nourishment but it’s a really a metaphor for him opening to the depth feminine to the world of form and realizing that the way of awakening isn’t crushing form and the material realm, it’s actually opening to it and realizing reality suffused through the world of form. It’s not pulled out of that world of form so then then he was able through that path through that way of opening to then realize his full awakening and so I call it the shift from the warrior mode as you read to the lover archetype which is a necessary part of we coming into the marketplace not just trying to get out of samsara but we entering the marketplace with this recognition that the completion of the journey is to be to be in with love, you know love within our embodied experience, within our relational experience and that’s a whole other piece of work and concentration.
Rick Archer: Yeah it kind of relates to this theme that we keep coming back to which is surrendering to divine intelligence if you want to call it that rather than sort of trying to pound away through individual will and which in a sense can kind of accentuate and reify the ego it would seem to me.
Kittisaro: And it’s not I think one or the other to me as we develop maturity and agility and tuning in our practice, you know it’s not a question of surrender or will or warrior or love, I mean it’s learning how to you know that capacity to persevere and to focus and to inquire to really look into a situation is very important but if that’s the only you know gear that we know we can sometimes burn out you know that famous saying of Nisargadatta the great non-dual sage you know he said wisdom says I’m nothing, compassion says I’m everything and between these two banks the life of the awakened one flows. So I think we can learn how to when to go narrow, when to look into and see the nature but then also how to keep softening, relaxing, surrendering, welcoming and checking again how it all comes together, how it how it heals and that dance between the two I think is as our you know we’re still learning but I think we get more adept at how to intuitively know what is appropriate. Sometimes it’s really incredible to be able to persevere in emergency and have that energy but then you know if that’s all we know that can be so insensitive sometimes. Sometimes we just need to be able to soften and welcome and finally to answer that questioner the Vipassana expression of those Goenka retreats is quite a narrow picture of all of Theravada practice. There’s also a lot of devotion in certainly some of the like in our monastery of Ajahn Chah where you do lots of chanting and bowing. We are also regularly practicing surrendering and melting into that central place where everything emerges.
Rick Archer: Yeah, I was just going to say on this point that you were just making about softening and surrendering. It seems like you’re saying it’s not like you have to be able to not only that you have to be able to do both but you have to be able to do both simultaneously and you know here’s a nice quote from one of your books, “When we authentically align with that deeper prompting there was a response. This is a living and responsive universe. Signs will come, books or people or an event we feel drawn to attend. The important thing especially with the lover energy is to stay open, inwardly soft and receptive.” So I think you can do that in the midst of a very determined, dynamic, purposeful type of activity because if you don’t do that then that activity can become brutish, you know, you can just become sort of insensitive as you were saying and kind of forge ahead in a wrong direction but if you can sort of be applying yourself at the same time sensitive to feedback from the universe, to indicators that well maybe you better go a little bit this way then it can be more successful. Exactly, beautiful. Let’s keep talking about this theme, this is good. Interesting, here’s a point, let’s comment on this one and I’ll go to the next one. You say, “When we open to the Eros energy of life,” which I think is what we’re talking about here, the divine feminine, the softer quality, “what is initially intoxicating has then to be matured into a global and less personally focused compassion.” What do you mean by that?
Thanissara: Yes, that was written in a context of a whole piece and I can’t remember the whole piece that it was written in but the Eros energy is to do with our life force, our sexuality, our creativity, the imaginative, the intuitive and often that doesn’t get held or named very well in the in the Buddhist lexicon of warrior type approaches and I would connect that with the depth feminine and the sort of deep being embodied in life instead of that sense of being a bit afraid of life. You sometimes get that feeling that in Buddhist practice it’s a bit like “don’t tempt me with anything” and I think because it is close to sexuality and that’s because Buddhism has come through monastic celibate traditions for centuries that is a very kind of un-complex area. It’s not a very and because of our own sexual conditioning around our own sexuality in our contemporary society with this Judeo-Christianity was profound shaming. I was just reading an article having you know my family coming from Ireland and I was just reading an article about the legacy of pregnancies outside of marriages in that culture and the terrible shaming and death that happened of children born out of wedlock.
Rick Archer: Yeah, there was a great movie about that a couple years ago, I don’t know if you saw it.
Thanissara: The Magdalene Sisters which is chilling and so you know this is a you know we have these very neurotic and and distorted relationships or the selling of sex out there to sell a product or women’s bodies or you know this. So all of this has led to this very distorted relationship to this fundamental Eros energy which is actually needed for our life force and it’s needed for us to feel embodied and part of the part of this web of life, part of the the fecundity of the earth and so we’re kind of we’ve morphed into this abstraction. We live as a sort of abstracted species in realms of technology and and irrational and divorced again from that energy. So you know at first when we feel that it’s often when we fall in love and then we feel we’re sexually aroused or you know that whole love, sex, intimacy nexus and that’s you know that’s very personal and it’s about me and the other. But when I was talking about it maturing is that we start with that but in the spiritual practice and you know in the healthy monastic practice that is the ideal is that that energy is transmuted and transformed and brought into the heart center and then it becomes available and you see like a Dalai Lama emerge or you see like our teacher Ajahn Chah where that love energy was available for everyone regardless. And then it becomes a huge umbrella or huge tree as Ajahn Chah described himself as a huge tree which all sorts of birds can sit in or you know a huge umbrella that shapes and helps people like a Mandela so that you see the merging of the warrior, king, lover archetype that completely is able to transmute that Eros love energy for the welfare of you know the bodhicitta bodhisattva, the welfare of the whole.
Rick Archer: Which kind of I mean in a way Mandela was a monk since he lived in prison for 27 years.
Thanissara: I guess he was.
Rick Archer: He didn’t stay with his wife very long after he left and then of course you know Ajahn Chah and and others and the Dalai Lama are monks but what you’re saying is that you know the energy that they might or correct me if you’re not saying this that the energy they might have expended or used in a more personal relationship or even a sexual relationship was somehow sublimated or transmuted to use the word you just used and ended up causing their hearts to blossom and do a much more universal all-embracing way of functioning than it might have been had they just been family men.
Thanissara: Yeah but I don’t want to denigrate family people that you know also working on this path and able to use the family as a container, as their monastery, as their means of developing that energy because then we can get into this you know but it is the case that that’s a journey I think whatever container we’re in whether we’re family monastery or otherwise that’s a necessary journey that we that we make in awakening that we start to shift out of our personal fixations and are able to then open out as we mature into this collective
Kittisaro: And to start reflecting whatever our circumstance whether in a monastery or in a in the world in a sexual relationship or not that we can start to inquire into this energy that where we see beauty where we feel like we want intimacy but start to to recollect the kinship that we have with all beings that we all share this old age and sickness and death and disappointment and hope and that we and especially as we start to contemplate and realize this sense of separation is is rooted in the way that we think and how we relate to our thoughts and we start to touch into that abiding where everyone is there appearing in our mind keeps dissolving back into this silent ever-present listening then we can start to touch into and practice and cultivate an intimacy a well-wishing that is universal it doesn’t deny the special relationships that we have but it doesn’t limit our concern our compassion our sense of closeness just to those beings and so you know all the great religious spiritual traditions have encouraged this purification of love to a more universal blessing quality.
Rick Archer: Good point. My wife and I also lived in a monastic lifestyle for 15 years prior to getting married and as you can probably attest very often people living in those circumstances are among the most sort of self-centered and idiosyncratic people you’re likely to meet I mean it’s all about me you know my enlightenment and my routine and my you know comfort my quietness and all the stuff and when you actually enter into a relationship with another person you have to start thinking about the other person or it’s not going to work and if you have kids then you’re expanding your territory even further and then it might expand to the community and then maybe to the nation maybe to the world so being in the world is not necessarily limiting in terms of ones in fact it may be conducive to a more universal perspective.
Thanissara: Yeah monastics are an eccentric bunch I agree with that.
Rick Archer: I’ve seen it in various contexts I mean visiting a Christian monastery one time the organization I was working for was thinking of buying there’s some really kooky characters hanging around there that maybe they didn’t make it very well in society and that’s why they ended up there I think that may be part of it but also I think the lifestyle can make you even more kooky because it doesn’t necessarily give you the feedback you need which you might get in a more you know if you start like not getting along with somebody you can always gravitate to somebody else but if you’re if you’re married or in a relationship that you’re just in day and night then you really kind of have to work out your stuff.
Thanissara: Yeah it’s an imperfect container what I appreciated about it is it enabled depth it didn’t actually have a sometimes sophistication regards the relational field or understanding of psychology and psycho-spiritual bypassing in that territory.
Rick Archer: It’s also interesting to consider how so many of the leaders or gurus of these you know who very often coming from the east kind of fall flat in their faces after a while in the west because they just haven’t had the the social interaction experience in their spiritual upbringing that they kind of needed to have in order to function in western society.
Thanissara: Yeah that’s a big subject that definitely that yeah you know I think the patriarchal structures that the transmission has happened through which the transmission has happened of the Dharma of awakening modalities also contributes to a difficulty around a more natural organic process of feedback and checking and maybe those very same gurus in their own home systems had more containment and feedback processes that weren’t available in the west or the way westerners and the lack of boundaries in the way westerners misunderstood perhaps some of their their cultural the way they would have been held in a cultural context. But also this sense of the divine right of the guru is something that we don’t understand very well it’s become very unhealthy and distorting and abusive so there’s a lot of fallout a lot of learning around all of this definitely the last few decades.
Rick Archer: Yeah I mean the divine right of gurus works about as well as the divine right of kings I mean you really have to earn it and and very often they haven’t and yet they claim it and people follow them blindly thinking well I don’t understand this behavior but this guy is supposed to be enlightened so I guess I’m just going to go along with it. Then the whole thing just gets more and more off the deep end.
Thanissara: Exactly, I mean in the original structure the Karma Vinaya, the Karma Sangha that which Sangha Karma that guides the development of community there was always within that the system of called Pavarana, an invitation for feedback which is also a ceremony that you’re supposed to go through collectively every year but it means that whoever you are whether you’re an abbot whether you’re the head of the monastery whether you’re the newest member that you open yourself for feedback and I think that’s the system of checks and balances and health and if it’s very authentic but it calls it can tends to become rather stylized and formulized and so the actual real ability to do that in a process-orientated way is not always that available but I think that’s what helps keeps those systems healthy.
Kittisaro: And I really feel that I hope those systems remain because to me the option in a society of a place where one can lead a celibate renunciate life and focus with other kindred spirits is very important but I would like to you know also the Buddha talked about a four-fold Sangha and the importance of not only ordained men and women but also laymen and laywomen you know and how the two can support one another so I would hate to see those deep monastic contemplative opportunities disappear certainly they had a huge blessing on our life but I think we you know it is not the only way and however we’re practicing there can be shadows and just as Thanissara said the Buddha realized that and encouraged us to keep being aware that we might have blind spots that’s why he encouraged us to not be the kind of people that you can’t give feedback to but to be the kind of person who is interested in how’s this impacting you is there something I need to hear back from you.
Rick Archer: Yeah, a week ago today I gave a talk at the Science and Nonduality Conference about the ethics of enlightenment not that I’m supposed to be some kind of expert on this but I just put together a lot of thoughts and conferred with a bunch of friends and gave this talk which I’ll be posting on BatGap but part of the talk was a quote that I read from the Dalai Lama where he talks about you know if a teacher is behaving inappropriately you really need to call him on it and and if he doesn’t respond then publish it in the newspaper include his name you know we shouldn’t just let sweep this stuff under the rug and hope that things are going to be okay.
Thanissara: I think the difficulty with that advice I think it’s a very very good advice but a lot of people that are sometimes abused feel quite disempowered and there can be fear and very real concerns about you know if you’ve been in community for a few decades and you’ve got no other livelihood so you’re often not in a very powerful position to do that so really yes that should happen but really should be the leaders of the community that should also hold each other accountable because they have the power they hold the power.
Rick Archer: Something like that is happening in Hollywood now with this whole Harvey Weinstein scandal you know and all these actresses and women who had been abused by him and are you know speaking out finally and they had been afraid to do so for fear of losing their jobs because he was so powerful in Hollywood but now Hollywood itself the upper echelon is saying this is the end of an era we’re not going to tolerate this anymore so it seems like on several different fronts like that there’s a transparency that’s suddenly emerging and and a sort of a dissatisfaction with the status quo or this kind of old hanky panky going on any longer you know.
Thanissara: Yeah I think that if you if you spent millennia objectifying you know the guy one of my friends was talking about this the other day that from South Africa Peter Wurth who’s a former minister talking about how you know the whole system produces the guy at the top he is the he’s the powerful guy and you have in the system of the objectification of women then it’s your right like the like the king again it’s your right to pick and choose and you know you get away with this behavior but it’s just so it is the characters that display the behavior but it’s a systemic level that we also need to look at and I think the Me Too campaign that went out and went viral in response to Weinstein was very powerful because it really broke the silence you know that the thing of the those that feel victimized breaking the silence you know women or peoples that have been abused in various spheres of society whether through gender or what other reason that they’re in a marginal disempowered position to break the silence collectively so that it reveals and opens the shadow and then as you say this sort of tipping another tipping point so this toxic behavior is no longer acceptable yeah it’s not something that we’re going to withstand
Rick Archer: And these really these things really are breakthroughs I mean I think progress is being made and we’re not just going to you know once a certain norm has been established you know like gay marriage for instance it’s not going to be illegal made illegal again because you know it’s just you know that something has been established and say this whole thing about abusing women and so on it’s a lot of this stuff it’s the time for things to come to light I guess that’s what I want to say that a lot of stuff that’s been hidden is coming to light now and huge amounts yeah that’s very inspiring or you know
Thanissara: It has to yeah I think that’s part of our evolutionary crunch at the moment is that we’re being faced with systemic levels of these profoundly dysfunctional systems
Kittisaro: And I think something that helps us in the which is a warning you know that the Buddha gave an image he said if you’re riding on the back of a donkey and fall off no big deal you just dust yourself off it might be a little more painful but he said if you’re riding on the back of an elephant and you fall off you can break your back right he’s saying that when you’re in this position of leadership you know carrying a banner of a monk and a guru leader of something the megaphone of your power increases the karma so much that it’s just really important to to remember that you know that you know what you do that is good can be amplified but what you do that is unwholesome rooted in selfishness and aversion or just the insensitive greed and lust is is amplified exponentially
Rick Archer: Yeah
Kittisaro: And so our teacher Ajahn Chah kept saying he told us all we’re all going to be teachers he said it’ll happen he said but don’t be the kind of teacher gets so puffed up you can get through the door he said he said fundamentally you’re a practitioner and if it’s if it’s time for some sharing to happen or teaching or leadership okay one does that but that’s not who one is that’s not one’s identity one’s prime identity is this humble taking refuge again and again with this inner place of listening and awareness and I found that advice really is helping me to try to stay sane.
Rick Archer: Yeah, Amma always says it’s always good to have the attitude of a beginner.
Thanissara: Yeah, good.
Rick Archer: And just what you were saying there, Kittisaro, I mean there’s so many examples of these sort of larger than life out of control characters who are just sort of you know I don’t know it’s like like you said the bigger they are the harder they fall or something but I remember there’s some quote from who’s it Padmasambhava I believe he said even though my awareness is as vast as the sky my attention to karma is as fine as a grain of barley flour.
Thanissara: Oh, beautiful.
Rick Archer: Yeah, so it’s almost like the more vast your awareness becomes the more impeccable you need to be.
Kittisaro: Perfect. Yeah,
Rick Archer: Or one way of putting it is if a judge commits the same crime as a uneducated man perhaps his punishment will be greater because he really should know better, he knows the law.
Thanissara: Yeah, more responsibility the more aware you become.
Rick Archer: Interesting point. Now keep in mind as we go along that if I’m not asking some question and you have something in mind you want to talk about that’s different than what we’re talking about just let me know. But here’s something, I don’t know I just took all these notes I don’t know whose book is whose at this point but someone said one of you said for the most part the practice of Buddhist meditation introduced into Western culture from the late 1960s went hand in hand with spiritual bypassing. I wouldn’t necessarily just pin it on Buddhist meditation I think maybe the same was true of meditations coming out of Hindu traditions. So do you suppose is that because of what we’ve been talking about you think the patriarchal emphasis or is there some other reason for that or what?
Thanissara: I think there’s I think it’s quite complex why we want to bypass the actual journey of awakening and the messy side of it. I think we often get into these the systems commit at very deep levels we talked about you being a monastic we were monastic or people going into a spiritual path and then it’s very easy to start to generate an idealized persona and idealized an ideation of what enlightenment and spirituality is which is completely problematic you know we can land up being a rather aloof judgmental person that is feels above everyone and really not looking at our own inner issues or our own shadows our own wounds you know we we prefer not to go there and so what can actually happen is as we split away from very fundamental wounding and we’re not really addressing that deep areas of you know rage or unacceptable emotions we’ve done you rage jealousy pettiness resentment these aren’t very nice energies to admit that we have it doesn’t fit our spiritual persona but the danger in that is that one that we repress them and it can actually affect the body in very negative ways because that energy is still there we project them onto the self and we get the effect of you know feeling depressed or feeling dislocated then we project them onto other people like why you know you know you’re the ones that are angry and petty not me so that this time this term i think it was coined a little bit by John Welwood’s work which is really worth reading the Psychology of Awakening it’s one of his primary books is returning you know this is why i did a lot of in-depth therapeutic works i realized i bypassed quite a lot and i realized that i had these sort of you can feel it in your in your energy body you have these dislocations and splits within and then there’s sort of symptoms of that so going through a very deep awareness space psychotherapeutic process enabled me and it continues to enable me to get in touch with you know very early what we call primary patterning very early patterning when the developmental phases of your life when a lot of these very deep we might categorize as negative energies or the bad sense of self is developed through painful experience and it gets kind of locked into your energy body and then it gets layers over through all sorts of defenses which dislocates us and doesn’t allow the fullness of our energy to operate so actually returning into an opening into primary rage for example primary fear these kinds of energies you know in a therapeutic relationship with a safely held compassionate dynamic enables a sort of release and opening and an understanding and integration and the transformation of those energies so that the awakening becomes more integrated and more embodied and then there isn’t these side effects and these splits that start to happen where you can actually find I think it leads into this very discussion we’ve just had you know very awakened gurus on one level that can really talk the talk but in another level they land up abusing people or they land up in fits of rage and call it sort of crazy wisdom but actually they’re just enraged and they’ve never dealt with the fact that perhaps they have a lot of anger you know that like you know all of us don’t start off as buddhist gurus we start off as young babies and you know we develop these very deeply learned emotional experiences that it doesn’t necessarily even come with abusive or bad parenting even very small things not being fed on time and feeling abandoned and feeling lost and you know these these emotional learnings are very deep and you compensate, compensate, compensate. So I like the term just to wrap this up because it’s a big subject but I like the way Ajahn Chah spoke about awakening so it’s not we’re here to catapult ourselves into an ideal, don’t be a Buddha, don’t be a Bodhisattva if you’ve got to be anything be an earthworm because at least they go down through the mud so rather than a sort of up and out kind of metaphor which fits this more disembodied patriarchal religious metaphor that’s been going on for millennia like a down and through the material of our life and it gets kind of muddy and messy but it’s more authentic and then it allows us to really be more integrated and more whole.
Rick Archer: Yeah a lot of people coming around to that perspective also in the sort of you know Vedanta non-dual world that because the other thing didn’t work that well. We learn in the end. Yeah by necessity they’re coming around to that perspective here’s a nice sentence from your book you said one of the functions of an emotion such as sadness is to keep our heart tender and open it helps us feel what we need to feel to stay humane and my friend Michael Rodriguez recently wrote an article called the wisdom of heartbreak but in any case you know just it’s just well it’s just sort of a commentary on what you were just saying. Do you think that spiritual practice at least in you have known it can actually help a person keep things bottled up even yeah even though they’re trying to sort of open up to something deeper and vaster it actually sort of keeps them numbed in certain ways. Yeah
Thanissara: I don’t think I think the early transmission of these enlightenment processes that came from Asia I don’t think there was a lot of psychological sophistication in terms of the individuated ego self there was a lot there’s a very brilliant psychology of Buddhism but in terms of the particularity of the developmental processes that you find really unfolded in very well in developmental therapeutic psychologists I think that to marry in some of that wisdom is very very helpful both as wisdom but also as practice
Kittisaro: And I’d like to add that I think it really helps to have a good teacher who is aware of this tendency because if you’re really aspiring to calm and tranquility and insight and even the name of hindrance for desire and aversion you can you can concretize those emotions as bad things that you you need to get rid of our teacher Ajahn Chah said don’t be in a hurry to get rid of these things he said they will be your teachers and your sharpening stones so this active encouragement to also welcome from time to time these energies fully, to feel them to relax with them to to get to know them and as he said read the book of your heart is the most important rather than we have all these ideas about what the stages should look like and then we try to project ourself into some advanced stage and we’re not reading the moment to moment moods and tendencies which are really revealing how it is right now so I think a good teacher can help us a lot avoid some of those problems and I think that’s why spiritual friendship or is vital that to to help us see our blind spots sometimes we get stuck and it really takes a trustworthy person sometimes to help us see hey man what are you doing you’re just bottling it all up and laying it on me or them and sometimes that’s why congregation or church or sangha or kindred spirits is considered so important at least in the buddhist path to help us stay on track.
Rick Archer: I guess that if we wanted to put into a phrase everything we’ve been talking about here or a lot of what we’ve been talking about here it would be sacred feminine which is kind of a popular phrase these days everybody’s talking about it and here’s a quote from your book you said it’s also my understanding that it was not possible for the buddha or anyone else to open into enlightenment without going through the door of the sacred feminine so if we take that literally the buddha or anyone else it almost sounds like anybody who hasn’t done that anybody who’s still on the sort of hyper masculine warrior path so to speak by definition couldn’t be enlightened yet and they’re going to have to soften and go through the the door of the sacred feminine in order to be enlightened. Would you agree with that?
Thanissara: Well that might be a I don’t know that might be a bit too yeah well to
Kittisaro: Me willpower volition when you’re directing the attention to an object to you to this situation then what appears in one’s vision whether it’s a sensation whether it’s the cosmos whether it’s a state of peace is going to be something that is by nature shifting transmuting and changing and and if that when we only know willpower that’s the part that can claim and then what we take to be me and mine keeps changing so we create birth and death so that energy is useful for persistence and investigation but the buddha said you know absolutely without the word he used is which means without giving it back without that surrender and softening then we’re only with that which is generated through volition without that in a phrase for it is the sacred feminine the dying into and surrendering to the ultimate womb the ultimate receptacle which is that ground ground of awareness buddha said there’s no freedom unless there’s that so the two really i would agree the name of it we can discuss and come up with different names but there needs to be this this training of volition and then relinquishing of it training of it relinquishing of it which you can call the balance of male and female or yin and yang
Thanissara: Yeah i think in that way that’s beautifully put and i think in that way we’re looking at feminine not as gender-based—quite obviously it is gender based but also as an attribute within within all gender or non-gender those outside the gender binary it’s an attribute of that profound receptivity and therefore i probably would say although i don’t know you know i’m qualifying that but probably would say that that has to be a doorway to full awakening as it was for the buddha in my reading of the archetypal journey
Rick Archer: Yeah
Thanissara: That he undertook
Rick Archer: Yeah my understanding of his story which i most recently read in your book and he was volitional and willful and persevering you know to the nth degree like you know outdid everybody but then his realization finally came only when he shifted into a more surrendered mode and accepted the food from the woman and you know just kind of chilled a bit
Thanissara: Well that’s right and also accepted life
Rick Archer: Yeah, yeah
Thanissara: Accepted the body and also he had the memory of the child you know so it was a intuitive it’s like the psyche you know he’s through the moment you realize you can’t do it you know and then you gave up and then these things happened and then this very innocent young opening through his memory of being a child and having an opening and that led him then on the right track to his life of awakening and those are quite significant a child and a woman you know being sort of doorways for that softening and opening
Kittisaro: Take turning points that and signposts reminding me reminding him you’ve gone to an extreme you’re heading in the wrong direction and each of those turned him back to a place more of unification yeah
Rick Archer: I mean his whole thing was the middle way right yeah yeah and so what you were just saying Kittisaro a minute ago is you know we don’t want to be like surrendered to the point of no initiative or intention or you know just sort of I think I’ll just sit lie on the couch and wait for something to happen but on the other hand we you know if there’s this sort of like straining forcing pushing driving kind of energy relentlessly then that too is imbalanced so there’s some kind of a both and paradoxical embrace of of both qualities that that is most most effective well said yeah well it’s getting a little that’s how
Kittisaro: Our that’s how our practice matures it’s ongoing you know this agility this this tuning you know is I mean there was a famous story of a someone was very inspired at the time of the Buddha by the Buddha’s life he was wealthy he gave up his his inheritance to follow the Buddha and he wanted to be awakened just like the Buddha and he walked meditation back and forth and more effort more effort even to the point of his feet starting to bleed and then he just started thinking well I don’t think I can do it maybe in my I can go back and be a lay person and do good deeds and then in my next life I can be enlightened and the Buddha overheard his thoughts from a distance and appeared before him and said uh the guy’s name was Sonny’s that’s honest who you’re thinking of you’re giving up and he said yes I no one can try harder than this I I can’t do it I was thinking of making good karma in next life and the Buddha said didn’t you used to play a musical instrument and uh some said yeah he played a stringed instrument called a veena they
Rick Archer: Yeah
Kittisaro: It seems to be something like a lute or something the Buddha said how how was it when the string was too tight and he said didn’t make a nice sound it screeched yeah he said what about when it’s too loose he said what if when you tune it just right and and so he was encouraging sona and all of us to that as our practice carries deepens we learn to tune this uh this volition and softening and surrendering so that there’s a balance that can can be attuned to each situation
Rick Archer: Yeah
Kittisaro: We look how to through listening in
Rick Archer: Yes is that in the vedic tradition too you know the gita balance of mind is called yoga and it says this this yoga is not for him who eats too much or too little who sleeps too much or too little and you know just sort of moderation advice um okay I you know what we’re just about going to wrap it up but one more thing I found interesting in your book which I hadn’t known what others might like wish to know is that the buddha himself didn’t just sit under a tree with a beatific smile on his face I mean he was actually engaged in all kinds of things and all kinds of you know negotiations to try to stop a war and all sorts of interactions with all kinds of people he lived a very active engaged life with with people of of all types in the world
Thanissara: Yes and I think that’s um often doesn’t get uh the precedent he’s he set as someone that was talking with generals with kings with courtesans with paupers with lepers you know that this whole range that actually affected a profound systemic change by ordaining women by dissolving the hierarchy of caste in his in his ordination structures um that these sorts of very you know by taking on animal sacrifices and denouncing them that he was he was pretty active as powerfully effective in the in the society yeah um and the moment when he tried to stop the a tribal war against uh one tribe against his own peoples and then and then in the end he couldn’t actually he tried he tried he couldn’t and that was interesting too that it wasn’t that he was always successful you know and this great sadness that he had that his people’s got wiped out you know, at Kapilavastu so so you get this picture of a very human you know an awakened person that’s interacting with a very human relational field and those examples um don’t really you know you get this idea of a stone buddha and then not really how he was a flesh and blood person interacting um and how some of the teachings he did went well and some of them didn’t go so well and some of the disciples didn’t get the message and then they did crazy things and how people were trying to kill him and how people were constantly putting him down and arguing with him but how he met he met all of these circumstances so it’s a much more fully embodied, full-blooded Buddha kind of sense of an embodied um person yeah and this is a good template for us I think you know not just enlightenment sitting on a as a stone immovable person but actually engaged getting things wrong failing um considering readjusting starting again um but kind of impacting as well and looking at systemic levels not just as personal awakening yeah so yeah
Rick Archer: That’s kind of what we were talking about earlier you know people not being an activist without the the inner attainment and not just focusing on inner attainment to the exclusion of outer engagement and Buddha was an example of that which I hadn’t known before reading your book yeah all right well I know you’re in the middle of a retreat and you got a very tight schedule so we should probably wrap it up any final words you want to say before we do
Kittisaro: Well I just would I feel grateful that you and your organization Buddha at the Gas Pump has given us this opportunity to meet and discuss the spiritual path and this relationship to our own well-being and well-being of the collective and it really feels like an honor to us and so thank you for this opportunity
Rick Archer: Thank you and incidentally I’m sure you got it but I’ve actually gotten a couple of emails over the years from people saying how dare you put Buddha at the Gas Pump, Buddha is a god, this is profane to say this but the whole implication of the title is that you know in this day and age people of all sorts are awakening and quite ordinary looking people that you might be standing next to at a gas station could have profound inner awakening. I
Kittisaro: Tell you who wouldn’t have been upset is the Buddha wouldn’t be upset.
Rick Archer: He would have probably liked the title. He would have said what’s a gas pump. Great.
Thanissara: I also want to add my thanks Rick and your team and thank you all very much and the patience of getting all of the technology set up.
Rick Archer: Yeah thank you because there’s a lot involved sometimes in ironing all the technical difficulties and you’re really busy and you’ve been very patient in helping us work that out with you.
Thanissara: You’re the guys doing it but I also just you know we do live in these extraordinarily challenging times. It’s very intense and I just sort of to encourage us all even though we don’t know the outcomes of you know so it’s an incredible time to be around actually but to encourage us all that it’s not it’s not nothing to really work at the shifts of consciousness that we’ve been talking about and pointing to that these have an incredible impact and can ripple out and contribute to these as well as the engagement in activism that we’re doing contribute to these tipping points. I think we will see more and more in the next 10 years we’ll see increase of intensity and destruction but we’re also going to see an increase of these awakening this new world that’s trying to be born and so it’s exciting I’m glad we can share you’re talking about these themes and share this with your platform and your followers. Thank you for that.
Rick Archer: Yeah one final line from your book, “We should not underestimate the deep psychotic patriarchal dinosaur that in its belligerence and hatred would rather see a burnt and tortured earth than give up its quest for domination.” But you know what happened to the dinosaurs so I have a feeling that like you say there’s going to be some destruction and some collapsing of cherished structures and institutions and ways of living that really have proven their unworthiness to exist in a more enlightened world and it should be an interesting time to live through.
Thanissara: That’s right, correct, absolutely.
Rick Archer: Yeah well thanks let me just make a couple of concluding remarks. So I’ve been speaking with Kittisaro and Thanissara and hopefully got those pronunciations right after all this and I will be linking to their website from their page on batgap.com and to their books and so on. So if you happen to be listening to this while you’re driving in your car or something and you want to find them just go to batgap.com and then you’ll see their page or you can search for their page if you’re listening to this a year from now and you can follow the links there to get to their site to their books and so on. This is an ongoing series and if you’d like to be notified each time a new episode is posted then subscribe on youtube and or subscribe to the little email notification thing that I send out every time there’s a new interview you’ll see a place for that on BatGap and also I just mentioned audio podcast this exists as one of those as well as the videos so if you’d like to subscribe on iTunes or Stitcher or one of those platforms there’s a podcast link on batgap.com and a bunch of other stuff if you explore the menus. So thanks for listening or watching and we’ll see you next week and thank you Kittisaro and Thanissara.
Thanissara: Thank you so much Rick. It’s been a
Rick Archer: Pleasure. Enjoy the rest of your retreat and please apologize to the folks attending it if I’ve kept you overtime.
Thanissara: No, that’s all.
Rick Archer: Okay great. Thank you. Bye.
Non-speech: [Music]






