BatGap Logo
A warm cinematic montage shows Stephan Bodian in a charcoal cardigan at a table with notes, books, tea, and a meditation cushion, surrounded by scenes of driving through luminous clouds, leaving a Zen courtyard, pausing at a forked path with a heart flame, and joining a seated circle.

Stephan Bodian Transcript: Spiritual Integrity, Discernment, and Shadow Work

Stephan Bodian 2nd Interview

Summary

The discussion explores spiritual awakening as a shift in identity, and why that experience does not automatically ensure ethical behavior. It also examines the responsibilities of spiritual teachers, the harm caused by breaches of trust, and the need to uphold integrity in both absolute and everyday life.

Questions This Interview Explores

  • What does spiritual awakening mean as a change in identity?
  • Can someone be spiritually awakened and still act unethically?
  • Why are ethics important on a spiritual path?
  • Why does a teacher’s conduct have such a strong effect on students?

Key takeaways

  • Awakening is a shift from identifying as a separate individual to recognizing a wider, boundaryless awareness.
  • A powerful awakening can be frightening at first, and its integration may take time.
  • Integrity means aligning words and actions with truth at both the spiritual and everyday levels.
  • Spiritual insight does not remove the need for ethical care and attention to one’s actions.
  • Teachers have a responsibility to protect students’ trust because misconduct can undermine their faith in the path.

Transcript

Rick: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer. Buddha at the Gas Pump is an ongoing series of interviews with spiritually awakening people. I’ve done over 600 of them now, and if this is new to you and you’d like to check out previous ones, please go to batgap.com, B-A-T-G-A-P, and look under the Past Interviews menu. This program is made possible through the support of appreciative listeners and viewers, so if you appreciate it and would like to help support it, there’s a PayPal button on every page of the website, and there’s a page explaining some alternatives to PayPal if you want to pursue one of those. My guest today is Stephan Bodian. Stephan was on BatGap—when was it, Stephan?

Stephan: 2014?

Rick: Okay, way back. And he will introduce himself in a moment, but I listened to our previous interview during the week, and I thought, “Wow, we covered a lot of interesting stuff.” We’ll try to cover somewhat different stuff today, but you might want to watch that one also. You’ll find it on BatGap, and I will link to it from the BatGap page of this interview. So, Stephan, why don’t you just go ahead? Rather than me read a prepared bio that you sent, it might be more interesting if you just sketch out a little bit of your history.

Stephan: Yeah. Well, first of all, I’d like to say that I’m a teacher in the non-dual wisdom tradition of Zen, Advaita, and Dzogchen, Mahamudra, which are all traditions that I studied, although primarily Zen. I was a Zen monk for 10 years, then spent 10 years with Jean Klein. In 2001, Adyashanti told me to go teach, and I’ve been doing it ever since. I’m also a psychotherapist, so I bring together the understanding of the Western tradition of psychology and the Eastern spirituality that I’ve studied. Every year, I offer a six-month intensive program in non-dual spiritual realization called the School for Awakening, as well as classes and other things, and spiritual counseling.

For the purposes of what we’re going to talk about today, I began practicing Buddhism, Zen in particular, way back, as I often say, after having some psychedelic journeys that went a little awry, which is a common experience.

Rick: A lot of us got our start.

Stephan: Even before that, a lot of us got our start, and still do. But I had already been interested in Zen and Eastern spiritual traditions in high school, and then in college is when I started doing it seriously. I spent 10 years doing that, and one of the things that drew me to it and kept me going was my relationships with teachers.

We’re going to be talking today about ethics, spiritual integrity, how teachers go astray, and what happens in this very intimate relationship between a teacher and their students. First, I want to say that teachers have been crucial to my own spiritual journey. I have fallen in love with several teachers, to great effect, and it’s had a transformative effect on my life. I want to begin that way to give the understanding that, as far as I’m concerned, teachers are not necessarily essential, but have a really important role to play in the spiritual journey. Some people wake up without teachers, but when they do, they often need a teacher afterward to help them orient, which is why a lot of people come to me. Or a teacher galvanizes them and provides an example of what a realized person looks like, sounds like, and acts like—hopefully, as we’ll discuss—and that’s a very important function.

Rick: I might add that you were the editor of Yoga Journal for 10 years, which is how I first heard of you, way before I started doing this. I wasn’t a regular subscriber, but I would read it every now and then, and your name would pop up. One thing that you mentioned quite a few times in our first interview: You referred to your awakening—you had an awakening—but I didn’t actually probe you at all in that first interview about what exactly happened. A lot of people use and define that term in different ways, so perhaps it would help to have you explain what happened to you.

✨ Stephan’s awakening

Stephan: Yeah. Well, the way I define it—and then I’ll talk about my own spiritual awakening—the way I define it when I teach, at least from the tradition that I come from and from my own experience, is a fundamental shift in the locus of our identity. We thought we were this little someone, with all our foibles and all our memories and all our narratives and stories and beliefs and forms of suffering, and we wake up to realize that we are the vastness, the openness in which all of that’s arising, right? That fundamental shift is really what constitutes true spiritual awakening.

I practiced for many years. Frankly, I practiced Zen for 10 years, very intensively, and I had no idea what spiritual awakening was. No one ever told me. I actually got a few glimpses, but didn’t realize that that’s what they were, and no one was there to say, “Oh, you know, that’s kind of what we’re talking about here. Maybe just keep going in that direction.”

Then I left Zen and experimented with several other traditions, and then stumbled upon Jean Klein, who was one of the teachers that I truly fell in love with. If I had a guru, he was certainly my guru. Six months after I met Jean Klein, in the middle of a retreat, I had something I had to do. I had to leave the retreat. I was in my car, and suddenly something he had said went through my head—something he had said several times. He said, “The seeker is the thought. The looker is what he or she is looking for.”

You can read these things in many places, but being fresh to this path, never having heard of Ramana Maharshi or Nisargadatta Maharaj, just being with Jean Klein, this really struck me. As I was driving, it all—everything—turned inside out. I suddenly realized I was the space, which was eternal. There was absolutely no going away from it, and I was driving through myself, right? That was the nature of the realization.

It was a powerful recognition. It knocked my socks off, as they often do—not always, but often. It faded into the background, I would say. The ego and its habits reasserted themselves, but I never lost that, and it continued to mature over time. It was actually terrifying, the realization. I went through—I like to say this so people who have similar experiences feel like they’re not alone—I was terrified by it. I felt like the ground had been pulled out from under my world, and there was no ground. It scared the life out of me.

Rick: Yeah. In our last interview, we talked about Suzanne Segal a little bit, who wrote Collision with the Infinite and was a friend of yours. She went through like 10 years of terror because she had such a shift and had no idea what it was. She just assumed she couldn’t find a sense of personal self anymore, and it freaked her out.

Stephan: Exactly, exactly. The self was looking for the self. The mind kept looking for itself and couldn’t find it.

Rick: And in fact, it was Jean Klein who kind of resolved it for her.

Stephan: By saying, “Stop the mechanism of the mind that keeps looking,” basically. And she did, and that was the end of the terror.

Rick: Yeah. So one thing you made clear is that this was not just some intellectual realization or something. It was a deep, visceral, experiential shift. And you also said that, well, you still had the ego with its foibles and all, but there was kind of a new element, that your essential identity had shifted from just that ego to something much vaster. Kind of like you had been the wave all of your life, and all of a sudden you realized you’re the ocean, but you’re still a wave, yet you’re the ocean.

Stephan: Yeah—

Rick: Yeah—

Stephan: Yeah, exactly. I would say “boundaryless openness” is the way I like to describe it these days. But at the time, the vastness was just vast, non-locatable, and always present, always already present, never gone, always there, always awake, always present.

Rick: Does it ever persist during sleep, or do you just conk out during sleep?

Stephan: Sometimes, yeah. Sometimes I find myself awake in dreams.

Rick: Yeah, some people report that.

Stephan: Not always, but sometimes.

Rick: Yeah. I have a friend who has had an awakening like that, and she has to be really careful while driving, because if she looks at the sky or some such thing, the vastness becomes so overwhelming that she’s afraid she’s going to crash the car. You know, it’s like she doesn’t have—

Stephan: That’s very common.

Rick: Yeah, is it?

Stephan: That’s very common. I’ve actually heard that from many people.

Rick: Yeah.

Stephan: And it’s interesting; it happened while I was driving.

Rick: Yeah. I have a feeling that that’ll go away for her when there’s been more integration or something.

Stephan: Yeah, I suspect so.

🕊️ Ethics and spiritual integrity

Rick: All right, so at what point in the game did spiritual integrity become so important to you, and why?

Stephan: Well, I had the good fortune of having some wonderful teachers in the beginning. Suzuki Roshi, of course, was a beautiful teacher. I only got to spend a little over a year with him, but that had a very deep impact on me. Then my Zen teacher for about six years after that, Kobun, was also a beautiful teacher with utmost integrity, I would say, and he was like a big brother to me, really. We were very close.

Rick: And they died?

Stephan: But then—he didn’t die until 2002, actually. What happened was, I wanted to do more of what I called serious Zen practice. Kobun was a kind of renegade, an eccentric, an artist, a poet. He didn’t want to do traditional Zen practice; he had left that behind. He wanted to do what he called guerrilla Zen—G-U-E-R-R-I-L-L-A—you know—

Rick: Everyone does it in their own—

Stephan: Yeah, kind of, you know, infiltrate the world with Zen, not do anything traditional. I was hankering after something, you know, wearing the robes, doing the rituals, being in a monastery. So I went to his house to meet with Maezumi Roshi, who was a more traditional Zen teacher. I was very impressed with him at first. He seemed very grounded, very serious and intense. He was doing more traditional Zen practice, including koan study, which I was very interested in. So I decided to leave Kobun and go study with Maezumi Roshi down in L.A., and so I did that.

I felt very at home in the community. It was very casual, very friendly, and I connected with the people there. I was actually Maezumi Roshi’s attendant for a while, but over time I realized that Maezumi Roshi was an alcoholic. At the time, it didn’t really—there was a lot of drinking going on at the Zen Center in Los Angeles. In fact, after a long retreat, the custom was that you left the retreat and immediately got, you know, shit-faced drunk. That was pretty much what was expected.

I wasn’t a drinker, never had been, didn’t follow that path—not out of any sense of virtue, particularly. It just never appealed to me, and so it never felt quite right, but I didn’t see the problems with it, necessarily. We’d go, for example, soak in the center hot tub, and Roshi would come, and he’d be really drunk.

Rick: How did people rationalize that? Because in my mind, I mean—

Stephan: I don’t know.

I mean, once I got on the spiritual path, I soon started to feel much better all the time than alcohol or drugs had ever been able to make me feel, temporarily. So I completely lost the taste for them. If I had done them, I would have wanted to get over it as quickly as possible, to get back to the lovely state of consciousness I was in anyway, all the time. So I don’t get it. I don’t get it.

Rick: I mean, once I got on the spiritual path, I soon started to feel much better all the time than alcohol or drugs had ever been able to make me feel, temporarily. So I completely lost the taste for them. If I had done them, I would have wanted to get over it as quickly as possible, to get back to the lovely state of consciousness I was in anyway, all the time. So I don’t get it. I don’t get it.

Stephan: I don’t get it either, and I’m with you. I wanted to keep as much clarity as I possibly could. Drinking had never been a part of my life. I think it was rationalized as, “Roshi’s Japanese. This is what Japanese men do. Roshi is using it as an opportunity to teach us by saying outrageous things and poking at us in ways he wouldn’t feel comfortable doing if he weren’t drunk.” People used to really gather around Roshi when he was drunk because they rather enjoyed the way he would be with them, which was more uninhibited, more provocative. So within this center, there was a kind of rationale around it. I didn’t buy into it, but I also didn’t question it seriously.

In fact, one of the things I did, as I said, was be Roshi’s attendant for six months. Then, when Roshi went to visit Trungpa in Massachusetts, where Trungpa was on a year-long retreat in Charlemont, Massachusetts—

Rick: Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche, that guy?

Stephan: Chögyam Trungpa Rinpoche, yeah, yeah.

Rick: Who could probably drink Roshi under the table.

Stephan: Well, I think they were pretty well matched.

Rick: Okay, they have a little…

Stephan: Yeah, yeah. So Roshi asked me, even though I was no longer his attendant, to go back with him because he thought I could stay sober while those two were drinking. He had me go back and spend seven days with Trungpa and Roshi in Massachusetts. I got to see them: They’d get up at noon and start drinking throughout the day, and they’d drink until… Again, in that context, with Roshi drinking and Trungpa drinking, it seemed rather normal. This is what Buddhism had to offer back in those days.

Rick: Can you imagine the Buddha doing that?

Stephan: That’s right. Can you imagine the Buddha doing that? But Zen has always had—again, I’m not rationalizing this; I’m just telling you the way people thought—

Rick: The bad boy.

Stephan: Yeah, yeah, yeah, the crazy wisdom tradition, which we can talk about separately.

Rick: We’ll get to that.

Stephan: Yeah, yeah. But anyway, what finally ended up happening was that, at a certain point in my own practice, I realized, first of all, that sitting wasn’t enough for me in terms of my own unfolding. I began to notice psychological issues that I felt needed attention, and all I was being told by my teacher, Roshi, was to sit more. I realized that wasn’t cutting it. That really wasn’t doing it.

Leaving a Zen Center Over Ethical Concerns

I also felt there was something about the hierarchical structure of the center that felt, I would say, inappropriate and potentially abusive. I could also sense intuitively that there were things going on that didn’t feel right. I didn’t know what they were; I just intuitively had that sense. So, at a certain point, I left. I decided to leave. I went back to school to study psychology because I felt like I needed to understand my own psychology and the psychology of the people I worked with if I was going to be a Zen teacher.

Then, within two years, it became apparent—it was revealed—that Roshi had been having a two-year relationship with one of his senior students, a woman. Both were married, and both had children. At that point, I would say the emperor had no clothes. Shit hit the fan, and it was revealed that Roshi had been propositioning women in the interview room for years. He went into alcohol treatment, and the center basically fell apart. It didn’t completely dissolve, but people scattered, let’s put it that way. I looked back and thought, “Well, I guess my intuition was accurate. I was right.”

Rick: Well, that would make an impression on you.

Stephan: Yeah, it certainly did.

Rick: So maybe an overarching point here would be, if we want to use the word “enlightenment” just for convenience’ sake, there’s a phrase from Swami Sarvapriyananda he likes to say: “You can have ethics without enlightenment, but you can’t have enlightenment without ethics.” By ethics, we would mean a broad range of things, some of the stuff you just mentioned and other things. But do you agree with that statement by Swami Sarvapriyananda?

Stephan: I think fundamentally, yes. One of the first things I studied as a Zen student with that first teacher, Kobin, was the precepts. He felt that was appropriate for us to study.

Rick: And they are?

Stephan: We studied the ten grave prohibitory precepts of Zen and the three pure precepts. There are things like no killing, no stealing, no sexual misconduct.

Rick: Like the yamas and niyamas of Patanjali, that kind of thing.

Stephan: Yeah, yeah. They called them the ten grave prohibitory precepts—“Thou shalt not,” basically. And there are, of course, different ways of interpreting these precepts. They’re interpreted on a range of strictness. But what Kobin said, which really left an impression on me, was that the deepest interpretation of the precepts is what he called Bodhidharma’s precepts. Bodhidharma’s precepts basically say that the precepts are a description of enlightened behavior: The way to act ethically is how an enlightened person would act. So that’s the way I was being taught: An enlightened person acts this way, you see. And I think I agree. That’s the understanding: a truly awake person.

Now, we can have had awakenings, and we’re not always acting from our awakenings. So we can be genuinely awakened, but we’re not living it moment after moment, which may be the definition of enlightened. The question of what is awakened and what is enlightened is a very interesting one. It’s been talked about for millennia. But if we’re acting from the truth of our being, the truth of our nature, how can we possibly abuse other people? Because they’re not separate from us.

Now, we can have had awakenings, and we’re not always acting from our awakenings. So we can be genuinely awakened, but we’re not living it moment after moment, which may be the definition of enlightened. The question of what is awakened and what is enlightened is a very interesting one. It’s been talked about for millennia. But if we’re acting from the truth of our being, the truth of our nature, how can we possibly abuse other people? Because they’re not separate from us.

Rick: Yeah. Yes. Kind of the Golden Rule: Do unto others as you would have others do unto you. And obviously, if you’re enlightened, you should see others as you. You should, to quote—

Stephan: You will.

Rick:—the Gita, you see the self in all beings and all beings in the self.

Stephan: That’s right. That’s right. Yeah.

Rick: And I get the feeling, just from observation and things I read, that you can never completely let your guard down. There’s a famous quote from Padmasambhava. He said, “Although my awareness is as vast as the sky, my attention to karma is as fine as a grain of barley flour.” So even he, a great cosmic dude, was being vigilant to be impeccable.

Stephan: Exactly. Well, these are the two truths that run through Mahayana Buddhism, that run through Advaita Vedanta: the absolute and the relative truth. And both are true, you see. We have to act ethically. At the same time, Sung San Son Sinim, the Korean Zen master, said, “There is no right or wrong, but right is right and wrong is wrong,” which I think is beautifully put.

Rick: And here’s another one that’s in your notes: “You’re perfect as you are, and you could use a little improvement.”

Stephan: Suzuki Roshi.

Rick: Was that for me?

Stephan: Or he also said, “We’re constantly losing our balance against a background of perfect balance.” I think the background of perfect balance really is what we are fundamentally, but as individuals, as people, we’re constantly losing our balance. And we need to be aware of that.

Rick: Yeah.

Stephan: And humbled by that.

Rick: It’s kind of like riding a bicycle or skiing or anything. You could fall at any time. You get really good at it after a while; it becomes second nature, but you still have to be attentive to what you’re doing, or you could crash.

Stephan: Yeah, no, I would agree.

Rick: Okay, so we’ve touched on what integrity is. Perhaps, if you want, you can elaborate on it even more.

Yeah, let me say a little more about it. I really love the word integrity because it comes from the word integer, right? It kind of means one. So to me, integrity means you’re acting in alignment as one with the truth of your being, similar to what you were saying. If you’re awake, if you know who you really are, and you’re acting in alignment with that, you’re acting in integrity. Or you could say you’re acting in alignment with truth at every level.

Stephan: Yeah, let me say a little more about it. I really love the word integrity because it comes from the word integer, right? It kind of means one. So to me, integrity means you’re acting in alignment as one with the truth of your being, similar to what you were saying. If you’re awake, if you know who you really are, and you’re acting in alignment with that, you’re acting in integrity. Or you could say you’re acting in alignment with truth at every level.

If we’re devoted to truth, we need to be devoted to truth at every level, not just absolute truth but relative truth. We tell the truth. We don’t lie. We act in truthful ways. We act in integrity. If we can understand very simply that integrity means acting in alignment—we know who we are, and our words and our deeds, our actions, are aligned in that way—I think we know what that is if we check in.

Rick: Walking your talk.

Stephan: Walking your talk.

Rick: And there’s a great phrase from somewhere, the Upanishads or someplace. It says, “Speak the truth, but speak the truth that is sweet.” I mean, I remember a line from Winston Churchill. He came up to a woman at a party and said, “Madam, you’re the ugliest woman I’ve ever seen.” And she said, “Mr. Churchill, you’re drunk.” And he said, “Yes, but I am. But in the morning I’ll be sober, yet you’ll still be the ugliest woman I’ve ever seen.” So, you know, that’s not sweet truth.

Stephan: That’s not sweet truth.

Rick: No, and obviously we can—it’s sort of a crude example, but you can think of people…

Stephan: Well, it’s not really the truth at all. Saying what other people are is not telling the truth.

Rick: No.

Stephan: Saying what’s true for us, you know, is really the truth.

Rick: But it is an example because sometimes people become confrontational and downright rude in their attempt to be truthful, and that happens.

Stephan: Right, right.

Rick: Okay, so now let’s touch upon… We talked about why and how enlightenment and integrity go together, and we’ve given some examples of teachers who presumably had some attainment and yet were not acting in integrity. Let’s talk about why integrity is important in the teacher-student relationship, both for the teacher and the student. You outlined different kinds of teachers. We can get into that, but maybe we should cover that main point first.

Stephan: Well, when I was studying Zen, one of the teachers in that lineage was Robert Aitken, Aitken Roshi. He wrote a lovely book called The Mind of Clover, which is about the Zen precepts and understanding them. One of the things he says, which continues to reverberate for me, is that the teacher represents a whole world of meaning to his or her students. So when a teacher acts out of integrity, they’re not only betraying the student as a person; they’re betraying and undermining the student’s relationship to that view of reality, to that path, which can be something they’ve devoted their life to.

I saw that happen with Mayuzumi Roshi. I’ve seen it with other teachers. When the teacher acts out of integrity, people’s faith in the Dharma—in the truth of awakening, of suffering, the cause of suffering, and the path of practice as a means to freedom—all of this gets undermined. So a teacher has an enormous responsibility to students in that regard.

I saw that happen with Mayuzumi Roshi. I’ve seen it with other teachers. When the teacher acts out of integrity, people’s faith in the Dharma—in the truth of awakening, of suffering, the cause of suffering, and the path of practice as a means to freedom—all of this gets undermined. So a teacher has an enormous responsibility to students in that regard.

Rick: Yeah, and that’s huge. I mean, I know of examples of not only people losing interest in spirituality because of the behavior of some teacher, but actually a few examples of suicide, because people just became so disillusioned and discouraged about life in general, because their trust had been violated so deeply.

Stephan: Absolutely. It cuts to the very heart of the matter. We feel so deeply about our spiritual teachers and our spiritual teachings, which mean so much to us, and when that’s been undermined, it can be devastating at many levels.

Rick: Yeah.

Stephan: So, yes, I agree.

Rick: Which brings up another interesting point. A lot of times these days, people are eager to become spiritual teachers. I remember somebody here telling me they once overheard someone at an Adyashanti retreat saying, “You know, I can’t wait to get awakened so I can quit my job and become a spiritual teacher.” But I’ve heard that in the Zen tradition, it’s recommended that after awakening you wait a decade before undertaking teaching activities, and perhaps other traditions have similar things. I know in the Diamond Approach, for instance, Hamid Ali, A. H. Almaas, is not in a big rush to qualify people as teachers. You have to go through all sorts of rigorous training and qualification. So what about that? I mean, there are a number of examples these days of people just jumping in.

Stephan: I think that’s true. There’s a famous Zen master—who was it? I think it was Ummon Zen Master—who studied with his teacher for 40 years and finally achieved complete enlightenment. Then his teacher died. He spent two years at his grave, and at the age of 60, he wandered around testing his understanding for another 20 years, visiting other teachers, until he finally settled down at 80 to teach for another 40 years, until the age of 120. Now, it’s probably a legend, but still put forth as exemplary behavior, right?

So, yes, I would say that refining, deepening, and clarifying our understanding is very important, and so is dealing with potential shadow issues, just as I did. I’m not saying what I did was exemplary. I had no idea what I was doing. I was stumbling along. But I think it was a good idea to leave and go into therapy and study Western psychology, because I felt like the shadow needed to be dealt with. I went to Robert Lyman’s retreats, and I studied Jungian psychology because I felt like the shadow needed to be attended to. So the issue of the shadow is a really big one. I think it can be easily missed. “Spiritual bypassing,” of course, is a very popular expression these days, but I think there’s a lot to it.

Rick: Yeah. You know, this Association for Spiritual Integrity that I helped found—I think you’re a member of it.

Stephan: I am, indeed.

Rick: I’m thinking of Miranda McPherson, whom you probably know. She’s on our advisory board and was on our board of directors for a while. In any case, she’s been a spiritual teacher since her 20s—for decades. Even now, she systematically goes on retreats with other teachers and has periodic therapy. There’s nothing wrong with her; I mean, she’s clear and brilliant. But she just wants to make sure that everything is spotless, and that there aren’t any hidden nooks and crannies she’s unaware of. It helps her take her role as a teacher very, very seriously.

Stephan: That’s beautiful. I do the same. I go back into therapy from time to time. I’ve actually done Almaas’s Diamond Approach at the Ridgewood One School. I found that very helpful. I’ve been part of a group of colleagues, some fellow teachers and some not, that has been meeting regularly for 25 years, discussing the issues that come up for us and sharing our experiences. I feel that’s very important. I also have a number of close friends who are teachers. To me, this is a really important feedback system that most teachers don’t have. So, yes, all of the above: taking time, clarifying understanding, working with the shadow, having a peer group to check in with, and going into therapy.

Rick: Yeah, and I’m glad you bring that up because that guy who didn’t start teaching until he was 80 and then taught until he was 120—or something—if everybody did that, we wouldn’t have any spiritual teachers. So that’s an extreme example. I think the times are such that we need spiritual teachers. If I didn’t feel that, I wouldn’t be doing this show and interviewing people whom I’m not presuming to be at the pinnacle of possible spiritual development, but who are serving a valuable role as long as they keep their act together and act with integrity. I’ve had to take down about 30 interviews of people who weren’t acting with integrity, out of 600.

Stephan: Wow, that’s quite a bit. That’s 5%.

Rick: Wow, you’re good at math. In any case, who was it? Thich Nhat Hanh said, “The next Buddha may be the Sangha.” It does seem that, given the age of the Internet and just the way the world works these days, it’s good that we have this sort of proliferation of spirituality and spiritual teachers. But I think the kinds of things we’re discussing here might be important safeguards, so people can behave responsibly and continue on their own journey without the spiritual teachership going to their heads and tripping them up, not to mention the effect they might have on their students.

Stephan: Right, exactly.

Rick: Yeah.

Stephan: I think we do have a proliferation of teachers. I think people idealize the role of spiritual teacher. I love it; it’s what I love to do in this lifetime. I feel very blessed to have the opportunity. But I think people become spiritual teachers for a variety of reasons. Sometimes they’re chosen by their teacher to be the successor. Sometimes they’re born into it. Krishnamurti was chosen, but others, like tulkus in the Tibetan tradition, are born into it. Others pursue it for questionable reasons, perhaps.

I think you read my piece on narcissism in spiritual teachers. Narcissists are drawn to being spiritual teachers because they’re in front of the room, people give them special deference, and think very highly of them; they think you’re special, right? And students are drawn to charismatic, possibly narcissistic teachers because they can bask in the glow and feel special as well. So there can be this kind of back-and-forth, a shared narcissism, and this is a potential pitfall—something to be aware of.

Rick: Yeah, I think perhaps narcissism can be latent in a person, and then it gets enlivened by the adulation and attention they receive once they start teaching.

Stephan: That’s right.

Rick: You know, it’s like their little guru trip goes to their heads, so to speak.

Stephan: Absolutely. They buy their own PR.

Rick: Yeah, and pride goeth before a fall. Before we get too much farther, I want to read a question here that came in from Jamie in Canada, which I think relates to what we’re saying. There seems to be a new revolution of satsang teachers, and he mentions Adyashanti and Francis Lucille, who have made traditional Advaita Vedanta much more digestible in what is now called the direct path. However, do you think there’s value in going back and studying traditional Advaita—the Upanishads, Shankara’s works—which is more systematic?

Stephan: By all means. If you feel drawn, why not?

Rick: Yeah. The reason I thought that was relevant to our discussion so far is that when I hear “direct path,” I sometimes get the impression that people might interpret it as meaning that, boom, you can get directly enlightened and you’re done. I think for most people, the path may be direct and progressive. As you mentioned, you had years of progressive striving, then you had a direct realization, and then you’ve continued to progress since then. So I think one can dip into ultimate reality directly, even at the very beginning of one’s practice, but there will also continually be progression. I think the value of the traditional approach, which Jaime mentions, is that these traditions, as you have mentioned, emphasize the importance of all kinds of tools and ethical guidelines to enable you to progress safely over the long term.

Stephan: Absolutely. I think they have built-in guidelines. I remember interviewing S. N. Goenka for Yoga Journal, and he talked about the three aspects of the path according to Theravada Buddhism, which are shila, jhana, and prajna. Shila is ethics, number one. What he said was, you really can’t meditate unless you’re acting ethically, because your mind is going to be in too much turmoil to sit quietly and have the mind settle, which I thought was really interesting. Shila is the ground of the path. So the traditional paths incorporate all these elements, and I think that’s beautiful.

Rick: And they’re not just old, moralistic fuddy-duddies. They actually did this for a good reason, and it was time-tested.

Stephan: Time-tested and evolved over centuries into what it finally became. Absolutely. In terms of the direct path, there are several differences. These are important distinctions that I really emphasize when I teach. The main difference in the direct path is the view. In other words, as Jean Klein used to say, you can use progressive-path practices in the direct approach. The main thing is the view you have. If your view is that you’re practicing in order to get somewhere you’re not, to improve yourself and become a better human being, or to cultivate qualities that will finally get you to a point where you can—and so on—that’s the progressive path.

The direct approach is that you’re doing practices in order to discover what’s always already been the case, but which is obscured from view. You can still use the very same practices, you see. But the understanding is that it’s not somewhere out there. In fact, it’s not about this one becoming more enlightened; it’s about discovering your inherent wakefulness. And what I found in the direct-path approach is that after awakening is when practice really becomes important. Once you awaken, it’s like, “Okay, now how do I stabilize this, deepen this, clarify this, live this, embody this?” So, in a certain way, waking up is really just the beginning of the path in the direct approach.

Rick: Yeah. I know in my own experience, after a very tumultuous childhood and teenage life, when I finally learned to meditate, my very first sitting was deep and profound. I felt like I just dove right into the Self, capital S. I remember walking down Fifth Avenue afterward in a rainstorm, just feeling like I’d been delivered. All these people were standing under awnings, staring at me.

Most of my meditation experiences since then have been somewhat along those lines, although the first one was quite contrasting. But still, there’s continual refinement and progression, which I expect will happen to the day I die. So, if I understand this correctly, I think my own experience has been both direct and progressive, and it’s worked well.

Stephan: Absolutely. Yes, and again, like you said, it’s a lifelong process. I think it’s awakening. The process of awakening goes throughout a lifetime. I’m still waking up to different dimensions of reality that I hadn’t even seen so clearly before. So I feel incredibly grateful to be on this journey, but I never could possibly say that it’s done.

Rick: Right. Yeah, I don’t want to speculate too much, but I sometimes wonder whether it’s ever done for anybody. You know, even if Ramana Maharshi, wherever he is now, is somehow moving along. In fact, Saint Teresa of Avila said, “It appears that God himself is on the journey.” Before we leave Jamie’s question, he had one final one—and forgive me, Jamie, if you are a woman; I’m just not sure. He or she wants to know, “What is your all-time favorite non-duality book?”

Stephan: I can’t really put my finger on one. One which is not very well known and which comes from a very absolute perspective is Perfect Brilliant Stillness by David Carse. I think that’s the clearest articulation of the absolute view. And he’s someone who vehemently refused to be a teacher.

Rick: I know.

Stephan: So I bow to him.

Rick: He refused to be interviewed. I think I invited him early on after I started that.

Stephan: Yeah, I’m sure you did. And the book, in fact, is unobtainable now, so recommending it is probably a waste of time because you can’t get it.

Rick: Yeah, you might find a used copy on Amazon or something. I might as well ask another question here since we’re in a little bit of a question hiatus, and then we’ll get back to our outline. This is from Barbara in Poland. She says, “After my awakening, I found a teacher and attended regular satsangs with Francis Lucille and yoga with Billy Doyle. I am curious about relationships. After an awakening, sexual energy has been transformed into spiritual seeking. Now, two years later, I have found there is a need to be in a relationship again. I’m curious whether this desire comes from the separate self.”

Stephan: I would say only you can know that. I don’t think the movement to be in a relationship necessarily comes from a sense of being a separate self. Are you looking for something outside yourself to complete yourself? Then that would be a red flag. Are you looking for companionship on the path and someone to share the beauty of life with and the love that you are with? That’s a different story. So I would say, check out your deeper motives.

Rick: Nice answer. Okay, so moving along. Perhaps there’s a bit more we can say about the role of the teacher on the spiritual path. You outline different kinds of teachers, like pundit, mentor, friend, master, guru. And also how the role of teachers varies somewhat among different traditions: Zen, Buddhism, Vipassana, Kashmir Shaivism, Vedanta. I guess the key question is, do we still need teachers? Sometimes people say, “We don’t. Be your own guru. You don’t need a teacher.” So what do you think about all that?

Sure, sure. The relationship with a true guru ultimately is inside you. Only you can realize the truth for yourself. Only you can know what’s best for you on the path. But at the same time, a relationship with the teacher can ignite the fire of truth in you, can catalyze your own awakening, and can help guide you on the path.

Stephan: Sure, sure. The relationship with a true guru ultimately is inside you. Only you can realize the truth for yourself. Only you can know what’s best for you on the path. But at the same time, a relationship with the teacher can ignite the fire of truth in you, can catalyze your own awakening, and can help guide you on the path.

Is it necessary? I’ve met a number of people, again, who woke up without a teacher. But they came to find a teacher when they had difficulty integrating and living from their awakening subsequently. And there are even people like Ramana Maharshi, for example, who never had a teacher except Shiva, of course—Arunachala—and managed quite well on his own. But those are the rare exceptions.

Rick: Yeah, Amma is another example. Never really had a teacher. It’s rare.

Stephan: Yeah, it’s rare. I would say it’s rare.

Rick: It’s like anything. I mean, I don’t know if there are any world-class physicists who didn’t study at a university under expert physicists. It’s theoretically possible to get all the books and just do it, but you’re probably making it more difficult for yourself if you try to do that.

Stephan: Yeah, yeah. So just keep your eyes open and check out a teacher thoroughly before you start studying with him or her, and that will hold you in good stead.

Rick: Now, wasn’t that the Dalai Lama who said to spend a couple of years kind of checking out a teacher before you make a commitment?

Stephan: That’s right. He did, yeah.

Rick: And then, on the flip side of that, you left the teacher because you felt like something was wrong. There might be a lot of people who are in relationships with teachers who kind of feel on some level like something is wrong, but they just don’t cut the cord. And that can go incrementally way down the rabbit hole, to something like Jonestown, to take an extreme example. So perhaps we could consider not only checking out a potential teacher, but also how to recognize the red flags and leave if things seem to be going wrong.

Stephan: Exactly. I think that’s a major issue. Once you’re involved with a teacher, it’s very hard to see their shortcomings and the danger signs, the red flags. A classic example—I think it’s okay to name names since this is now very well known—is Sogyal Rinpoche, a Tibetan teacher. I knew about Sogyal’s transgressions 25 years ago, both as editor of Yoga Journal and because I had studied with Sogyal Rinpoche for several years and gone to his retreats.

This was at a time when he was not so well known, and I began to notice things that troubled me. First, his anger towards students seemed inappropriate, as did the way he treated women, interestingly enough. I actually wrote him a letter expressing my concerns, and never got an answer back. At that point, I stopped studying with him, after two years.

Subsequently, it came out that he had been sexually abusing women. That was when he was finally outed fully. It took that long, and his behavior was perhaps the most outrageous of any that I’ve ever read about. There’s even a book called Sex and Violence in Tibetan Buddhism about Sogyal Rinpoche. It took that long for the students who had studied with him so devotedly to be willing to say anything negative in public about the teacher. There was so much reluctance, so much hesitancy, so much fear. And there are various reasons for that.

Rick: Do you think that’s because they had so much invested in him, and they would have to admit that they had wasted a decade or whatever?

Stephan: Yeah, I think that’s a big part of it. And I think, as you said, down the rabbit hole. What happens is little by little—it’s like the classic story of the frog in water, and you turn up the temperature. The temperature got turned up gradually, gradually, gradually over time, and they were becoming accustomed to accepting more and more outrageous behavior in the name of enlightenment or the tradition.

And in the Tibetan tradition, there are the samaya vows, the vows that one takes in relationship to a teacher, considered sacrosanct. There’s the threat of going to some Vajra hell if you violate those vows. People take that stuff seriously in Tibetan Buddhism, unfortunately. So there’s a lot of dogma associated with that.

Rick: Yeah, the point you just made reminds me of a contemporary phenomenon with QAnon and various conspiracy theories, which is that the mind is very impressionable. YouTube and Facebook know this. You may have seen that documentary, The Social Dilemma, where you put your attention on something and it sort of seeps in a little bit. Then they give you something a little stronger, and that seeps in. You don’t even realize that it’s seeping in, but your mind is kind of being colored by this information, and you become susceptible to more and more improbable or outlandish ideas and take them as real.

Human psychology is such—and you can tell us more, being a psychologist or psychotherapist—that you can’t just turn that around and snap out of it. You almost have to come out of it as incrementally as you went into it. What do you think about that?

Stephan: I think that’s true. It used to be called brainwashing. We don’t use that word so much anymore, but you remember those deprogrammers? You don’t hear much about that anymore either, but 20 or 30 years ago, there were people who were hired as deprogrammers to get young people out of cults. This was probably in the ’70s and ’80s.

Rick: That was abusive too. I mean, there were a lot of examples.

Stephan: That was abusive too, but it was an attempt to deprogram, to take them out of those belief systems. Any belief system can become a kind of brainwashing. We take a certain amount on faith from our teachers. They’re pointing in a certain direction and saying, “Look, if you do this and this, this is what you’ll experience. Trust me, and you can keep going, and I’ll give you my word that eventually, if you do this and this, you’ll have certain experiences.” Most probably. I can’t guarantee it, but this is the direction to go, and we trust that.

But on the other hand, we can be fed all kinds of outlandish beliefs in the name of so-called truth. That’s brainwashing. So where does the one end and the other begin? Again, the word in all of this, in all that we’re talking about today, is discernment.

Rick: Yes.

Stephan: That’s the word. We need to develop discernment, the ability to discern truth from falsehood, to know our own heart and mind, and to know what’s appropriate and right for us, and trust that. I had the good fortune of trusting that again, with my Sumi Roshi and Sogyal Rinpoche. I can’t make any claims for myself. I had no choice. That’s what I had to do. It’s just what I was being told from inside, and I did it. So we need to learn to listen to or trust what we were already hearing.

You may remember Shankara’s book, The Crest Jewel of Discrimination . I think discrimination is somewhat synonymous with discernment. But I’ve come to feel that this quality is really critical on the spiritual path, and without it, one can get sucked off into all kinds of cul-de-sacs and diversions without even knowing it. It happens all the time.

Rick: You may remember Shankara’s book, The Crest Jewel of Discrimination. I think discrimination is somewhat synonymous with discernment. But I’ve come to feel that this quality is really critical on the spiritual path, and without it, one can get sucked off into all kinds of cul-de-sacs and diversions without even knowing it. It happens all the time.

Stephan: I agree. I agree.

Rick: Which is why I kind of like the juxtaposition of science and spirituality, because science brings certain qualities to the quest for knowledge, such as the insistence upon empirical verification and falsification, that spirituality could really use. And spirituality, on the other hand, can bring some valuable tools to science because it explores realms of reality that most scientists don’t even know exist.

Stephan: Absolutely. I totally agree. And the spiritual journey is a scientific one.

Rick: It is.

Stephan: This is about direct experience. I mean, it’s phenomenological in the sense that it’s our direct experience at that level. It’s not necessarily something that you can do experiments with, but it has to be something you know for yourself. Otherwise, it’s hearsay, theory.

Rick: Well, you can kind of do experiments in a way. I mean, let’s say that there’s a physics experiment where someone says, “Okay, we think there’s something called the Higgs boson,” and then a whole bunch of people get together and build the Large Hadron Collider. They spend billions of dollars and tons of time, and they eventually find the Higgs boson. So, you know, in spirituality, various teachers and scriptures say there are these possible attainments, and others have attained them. For you, that’s hypothetical at a certain point, but then they say, “Okay, we’ll do this, this, this, and this, and over time you, too, will experience it.” So that’s kind of a scientific approach.

Stephan: Yeah, I agree.

Rick: Okay. What is Zen sickness?

Stephan: Well, Zen sickness is to hang out in the absolute and not give any credence to the relative.

Rick: Oh, okay.

Stephan: To be intoxicated by your own awakening as well, and become inflated with your sense of the importance of what you’ve discovered. A kind of spiritual narcissism, you could say.

Rick: Yeah, yeah. There’s a teacher who recently came to my attention who was sort of messing around with the ladies, and when it finally came to light, he was sort of like, “Well, I am just the witness, and God is the doer, and I have no authorship of my actions,” and that kind of stuff.

Stephan: Exactly. And that’s, again, mixing absolute and relative. There’s no right and wrong, and right is right and wrong is wrong.

Rick: What do you mean by splitting the archetype?

Stephan: Splitting the archetype. See, in Jungian psychology, an archetype has two poles. So as soon as there is an enlightened one, there’s an undarkened one, you see. As soon as you constellate the enlightened one, then you’re—this is according to Jungian psychology. I’m not necessarily saying that I agree with this point of view, but I think it’s a provocative one, and I think a helpful one. As soon as you constellate the awakened, then there’s going to be the unawakened, the enlightened, the undarkened. So when a teacher takes himself to be special, to be enlightened, and the student to be undarkened, then it’s impossible for the student ever to become the other pole. The teacher has claimed one pole of the archetype, and the student is relegated to the other pole of the archetype and can never overcome that polarization, that discrepancy. Interesting, isn’t it?

And this is one of the things that I was drawn to. It was Jean Klein. Jean Klein said, “True transmission happens when a teacher who does not take themselves to be a teacher meets a student who does not take themselves to be a student. In that meeting, true transmission can happen.” See? So there’s no taking oneself to be awakened, no taking oneself to be undarkened. There’s simply a direct meeting, and in that moment there’s a potential for—you know, transmission doesn’t mean anything moves from one place to another. It’s really more the recognition within another person of what has always been the case that we share. Yeah?

So this is one of the things that drew me to Jean Klein. He said, “A teacher doesn’t have students.” As soon as someone takes themselves to be a teacher who has students—“My students”—as soon as I hear someone talking about “my students,” that may sound pretty benign, but my antennae go up. You don’t have any students. People come to you for guidance occasionally. That’s my experience. People come to me for guidance occasionally. Some people hang around for a while. Some people come and go. I don’t consider those “my students.” They’re just people. We’re all hanging out together, you see. As soon as I claim them as “my students,” then that whole archetype’s constellated: the teacher-student archetype.

Rick: I’m kind of thinking of a university as a comparison. I mean, if a university said, “Okay, none of you are ever going to graduate, and you could never possibly become professors yourselves, because we are the professors”…

Stephan: That’s right. It wouldn’t be a very popular university. So I should think a teacher would rejoice if a student has a profound spiritual awakening. I mean, I’ve even heard of examples—I can’t even think of one right now—where a student became the teacher’s teacher because he surpassed that teacher’s attainment. Do you remember anything like that?

Rick: This happened regularly in Zen.

Stephan: Okay, sure.

Rick: Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, I think that’s beautiful, and that shows a truly awakened person with the appropriate humility to recognize, again, without the Zen sickness, “Yeah, this nice student seems to be clearer than I am.” And, in fact, it was the same Ummon Zen master. I hope it was Ummon. My memory for the koans is not as good as it used to be. When he went off on his journey after he attended his teacher’s grave at the age of 60, he said, “Even if it’s a seven-year-old girl, if she has something to teach me, I’ll study with her. And if I have something to teach him, I’ll teach him.” That was his attitude. The distinctions don’t matter. So it’s that attitude. I learn from my students all the time, I must say. And hopefully every teacher does. “Wow, I love the way this person says that. That’s beautiful.” Or, “I really hadn’t understood that before. That’s amazing.”

Yeah, that’s really good. And, like you said, humility. Humility doesn’t mean belittling oneself or considering oneself inferior or anything. To my mind, it means not being rigid and being open to the possibility of learning or of anything. Not insisting that things happen any particular way, just sort of flowing.

Yeah, that’s really good. And, like you said, humility. Humility doesn’t mean belittling oneself or considering oneself inferior or anything. To my mind, it means not being rigid and being open to the possibility of learning or of anything. Not insisting that things happen any particular way, just sort of flowing.

Stephan: I agree. I agree.

Rick: Well, let’s talk about sex. I’m going through the outline of a book you were thinking of writing. You have a chapter called “Sex in the Forbidden Zone,” and since this is probably the biggest pitfall, or reason for spiritual teachers falling, we probably ought to talk about it. You know, it’s funny: when Irene heard we were going to be having this kind of discussion, she said, “Oh, people are so sick of that topic.” And, yeah, in a way, I think you and I are probably sick of it, too. But until this kind of stuff stops happening, I think it needs to continue to be looked at and not swept under the rug or some such thing. Anyway, let’s talk about that.

Stephan: Well, that article I sent you—I wrote this article called “In the Shadow of the Dharma.” Again, the word “shadow.” It was assigned to me by Tricycle magazine back in 2006. I wrote the article to their specifications. They liked the article and paid for it, then they decided not to run it because, according to the editor, he felt that this had already been dealt with before. This was 2006, right? So now, 15 years later, the same sort of stuff continues to happen within the Buddhist community and within other spiritual communities. It hasn’t stopped happening, right? So the article is available on my website, in the blog section, if you want to read it. It’s a long article, a 6,000-word article, in which I talk particularly about this issue of sex and teachers, which I think is eternally relevant because it seems like sex is endlessly beguiling and seductive, right?

And we’ll never stop being beguiled, right? You and I are old dudes, and maybe we don’t feel the pull as much as we used to, but it’s amazing how strong it continues to be, right?

So, you know, there are different levels of misguided behavior, we could say. Interesting distinctions have been made. There’s a wonderful guidebook—what is this book?—by a woman named Marie Fortune, who’s a United Church of Christ minister and has been very interested in this whole issue of transgressions by spiritual teachers, particularly clergy. I’m looking for the name of the book. Maybe I’ll find it; it’s probably down here. Yeah, here it is. It’s called Nothing Sacred: When Sex Invades the Pastoral Relationship . Some of the distinctions she makes are between wanderers and predators. She’s talking about boundaries, right? There’s a boundary between a pastor, a minister, a spiritual teacher. I think those are different roles, of course, but they’re similar. And the student, right?

The boundary is generally acknowledged: a teacher or a pastor doesn’t have sex with his or her parishioners or students.

Rick: Yeah, and unfortunately, we’re often talking about pedophilia here, because we’re talking about children who have been victimized.

Stephan: By clergy.

Rick: Yeah, I mean, that’s been a huge, huge scandal in recent years. Remember that movie Spotlight? Did you see that?

Stephan: Yes, yes, I did. Let’s put that aside because I totally agree that it happens, but let’s put it aside because that’s a whole other issue. Pedophilia is really a mental illness of a certain sort, and usually people who are pedophiles were abused, sexually abused, as children. But, you know, that’s a whole other category. Let’s just say we’re talking about two adults, whether same sex or different sex.

So there are these acknowledged boundaries. We all acknowledge those boundaries. We could all say, just commonsensically, “You just don’t do that.” So, on the one hand, Marie Fortune would say there are those who lose their sense of the boundaries. They lose their boundaries. Like a minister or a teacher who, in the relationship with the student, starts falling in love, starts being attracted, and feels that the other person is responding to their overtures. They’re not being aggressive. They’re just expressing some interest or affection, and the person seems to be responding. Of course, they may be completely misreading what’s happening, and men, of course, tend overwhelmingly to misread signals as being sexual when a woman doesn’t mean them to be. There’s a lot of evidence for that. So the man takes them in that way. Usually it’s a man.

Then the woman maybe acquiesces, and they go back and forth until, next thing you know, they’re in a sexual relationship, maybe even a romantic relationship.

Okay? It wasn’t intentional. There was no intent on the part of either one. They just kind of fell into that, and sometimes it works out. Sometimes they end up getting married and live happily ever after. That does happen. So those are the wanderers. On the other extreme end of the spectrum would be the predators. Those who intend to have sex with their students, who are looking for appropriate students—or vulnerable students—to have sex with, are targeting them or possibly even grooming them.

Rick: Sometimes they even have helpers who groom them, you know, kind of line them up.

Stephan: Like Richard Epstein, right?

Rick: Jeffrey Epstein.

Stephan: Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, or whatever her name was. So that sort of thing. Sure. As you can see, these are different roles to play. They’re different approaches. The predators are obviously dangerous individuals. I would say Sogyal Rinpoche was obviously a predator. Marzumi Hiroshi was a predator as well, certainly when he was drunk. And several people—certainly one in particular in his lineage—were supreme predators, par excellence. I don’t need to mention his name, but it’s common knowledge. This is not something he hasn’t been confronted about numerous times. He has continued over the years to do the same thing over and over again. These are people who tend to be narcissistic, sociopathic, psychopathic, and not really empathic. They’re not aware of the suffering they’ve caused. Somehow, some of these people have been drawn to being spiritual teachers.

They’re the exception, for sure. I think more of them tend to be wanderers, but again, they’re caught in the Zen sickness of, “I’m someone special. The rules don’t apply to me. Ethics are not appropriate for someone of my understanding. I have the right to transgress.” That kind of attitude.

Rick: Yeah. Robin Williams once said, “God gave man both a penis and a brain, but unfortunately not enough blood supply to run both at the same time.”

Stephan: Right. Or put them in two very different places.

Rick: And I think what happens, in light of that joke, is that sex and sexual attraction can be very hypnotic. They kind of cloud one’s judgment, you know? And if you feel like you’re— You don’t realize you’re clouded. That’s the first thing that maya does: it deludes you to the fact that you’re deluded. But then, like we were saying earlier about the incremental joining of a cult, you incrementally get more and more occluded or deluded. One thing leads to the next, and in many cases it becomes extreme. It also is often associated with other foibles and misbehaviors, like you were saying—anger or drinking or other kinds of mistreatment of people.

Stephan: Exactly. There’s some interesting work done by this guy named David Buss at the University of Texas. Sam Harris recently interviewed him about what’s called evolutionary psychology and how our psychology, particularly male-female psychology, evolved to perpetuate the species. One of the things he talks about is what he calls the “dark triad” qualities, which can predispose someone—a man, for example—to act in abusive ways, given men’s existing predilection toward sowing their seed as widely as possible. This dark triad is narcissism, sociopathy or psychopathy, and what he calls Machiavellianism, which are more or less different facets of the same thing. He calls it the dark triad. When those qualities are joined with the general male tendency, it becomes abusive.

Men in general aren’t necessarily abusive, but these other qualities can cause them to become abusive, and I think it’s well researched.

Rick: Yeah, it’s funny you mentioned that point of sowing one’s seed widely. There was a spiritual teacher whose interview I took down years ago. But last summer, I heard a YouTube video he did. He was obviously somewhat inebriated, but he was going on about how adultery is perfectly fine, especially for men, because it’s hereditarily appropriate or wired into us, and that anybody who disagrees with this and has some kind of moral objection to it is an “ignorant monkey,” to use his phrase. He was obviously living out this principle in his own life and abusing literally hundreds of women.

Stephan: There you go.

Rick: And yet people still come around and be his students.

Stephan: And remember, when we say abuse, we don’t just mean abusing the body. We mean abusing the soul, abusing the being at every level, especially when you’re doing it in the spiritual dimension.

Rick: Abusing their trust. To me, the ardent search for God or realization is such a rare and precious thing. When it finally dawns in the course of a person’s spiritual evolution, it’s such an important milestone. Initially, it’s like a little tender sprout that has to be treated with the utmost care. Maybe once you’ve been on the path for 40 years, you can weather all kinds of storms and not be crushed. But you get the point I’m getting at. It’s just…

Stephan: I totally agree. I totally agree. Yeah.

Rick: It’s interesting: when we were trying to formulate the code of ethics for the Association for Spiritual Integrity, it took a long time to address this whole sex and relationship issue. Some people felt like a spiritual teacher and a student should never form a relationship. I was kind of arguing, “Well, yeah, but maybe they’re really meant—or would be really good together, and they just happened to meet because the teacher is well known and the student shows up. Maybe there are certain guidelines that could be followed to prevent capricious and abrupt situations, but that could eventually result in them being able to have the relationship that they would both benefit from.” I think Spirit Rock had some good guidelines that eventually helped us.

Stephan: Yeah, they had excellent guidelines. In the psychotherapy profession, certainly in California where I’m licensed, the rule basically is that if there is an attraction, it of course cannot be acted on. If they want to act on it at some point, they would have to wait two years before doing so.

Rick: That’s psychotherapy, right? You’re saying, not Spirit Rock?

Stephan: Yeah.

Rick: It’s good you mentioned that, because obviously, in a profession like that—or probably other areas, like physical medicine and so on—there are organizations that regulate these things and have guidelines like that. You could actually lose your license for violating them.

Stephan: Oh yeah, absolutely, absolutely. The thing, of course, about the relationship between a therapist and a client, just like a teacher and a student, is that there are many dimensions to it. A client shows their vulnerability and reveals aspects of themselves in absolute trust that the other person will not misuse them or use them for their own personal gain, right? When a therapist turns around and takes this vulnerability and abuses it, takes advantage of it for their own personal gain, that’s again a very deep betrayal, which is why you have to wait for several years. The basic guideline is, if you need to do it, wait several years, but we don’t advise doing it at all.

Rick: Yeah, but several years might seem like a long time. It seems to me that if the relationship is really sincere and genuine and deep, one would do that. My wife and I met and married, and we were always thinking, “Okay, I wanted to be a monk.” But I was always saying, “Well, if I decide not to be a monk, I would like to be with you.” We kind of stuck to our guns for 11 years. She actually pretty much waited for me, and she was also on a similar program. We weren’t in a big rush because we had something we felt we needed to do that was kind of a higher calling—at least at the time, I thought it was a higher calling—but something that was important and had spiritual significance to us.

Stephan: Right, right. Yeah, exactly. When two people are really drawn together in that way, it’s amazing. I can’t tell you. I know probably three or four people in my own circle—a big circle of therapists—who have slept with their students and clients, or clients who slept with their therapists. I mean, it’s amazing how often it happens.

Rick: And it didn’t turn out well, you mean?

Stephan: No, it never turns out well. No, it never turns out well. I can say pretty much with utmost confidence that it almost never—maybe I shouldn’t say never, but almost never—turns out well.

Rick: Yeah. Now, I think in the case of Adyashanti and Mukti, was she a student of his first before they formed a relationship?

Stephan: No. No, no. They were just boyfriend and girlfriend. It started, yeah. But she came from a very spiritual household; her parents were SRF. She was raised in SRF. She was actually from an Irish Catholic family, but her parents discovered SRF when she was a certain age.

Rick: Yogananda. Yeah—

Stephan: Yogananda. Yeah, so she was groomed in that and was obviously very attuned to what Adya was teaching and stuff.

Rick: Yeah, I think I remember her saying that some friend said, “Hey, you should meet this Stephen Gray guy, because he’s the only other person I know who meditates like you do.”

Stephan: So there you go. It was kind of like that. Yeah, it was kind of like that.

Rick: Okay, is there anything else we want to say on this topic?

Stephan: No, I think, as you said, it’s been written about quite a bit. There are some good books about it. Sex in the Forbidden Zone, although that’s also not available any longer. That was Peter Rutter’s book. And then Power in the Helping Professions, the Jungian book by Adolf Guggenbuehl-Craig, which is also very good. So these are good books.

Rick: Okay. If any questions have come in about this as we’re speaking, I’ll bring them up in a bit, because Irene’s in the other room and she’ll be forwarding them to me. We’ll move on to a new topic now, but we’ll come back to this if any questions have come up. So, crazy wisdom. You know Timothy Conway? I think you know Timothy.

Stephan: I do, yeah. Beautiful guy.

Rick: He sent me an interesting little clip on crazy wisdom. He said,

Stephan: Interesting perspective. Timothy is very careful, I think, in his scholarship, so he may very well be right. There are, of course, though, in the Tibetan tradition, venerated examples of crazy-wisdom teachers.

Rick: Like Milarepa and that thing.

Stephan: Marpa and Milarepa; Drukpa Kunli, the famous drunken sexual saint of the 1400s, I believe, who was known for hanging out with prostitutes and drinking, and enlightening women with his sexual behavior. He’s revered in the Tibetan tradition and actually existed. And then there’s Ikkyu, a Zen master in Japan, very similar: he hung out with prostitutes, although he had a close girlfriend, a partner, toward the end of his life for about 30 years. But in his early life, both of them were trying to show that sex is not profane, that sex can be included on the spiritual path, and that you don’t have to be a renunciate monk.

But I think, whether Timothy is accurate or not, certainly there have always been teachers who are provocative with their students and use provocative behavior to try to awaken them. And I think that has a place. But the primary mark of true crazy wisdom, as opposed to abusive behavior, is that the sole intention and motive behind it is the benefit of the student. As long as there’s any benefit coming to the teacher, this is not crazy wisdom. So any so-called crazy wisdom where a teacher is acting abusively toward a student—if it’s perceived as abusive by the student—then this is not crazy wisdom behavior.

Another mark of true crazy wisdom behavior—and again, we won’t talk about Trungpa Rinpoche, because I had a pretty close relationship with him, so I’m one of those people who has a more provocative view of him. It’s too complicated, but let’s just say that Trungpa Rinpoche is from a lineage of crazy wisdom teachers that goes back generations of incarnations, which is acknowledged within the tradition. So again, was his behavior justified? Was it true crazy wisdom? Was he an alcoholic? Certainly he was an alcoholic. There’s no question about that.

Rick: He died of it in his 40s.

Stephan: He died of it in his 40s, so he pickled his liver. I watched him drink vodka as if it was water, or sake as if it was water. I poured his sake. So, you know—

Rick: Yeah, I believe it.

Stephan: Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I was there. I saw it. On the other hand, was he a compassionate being? One of the most compassionate people I think I ever came into contact with. But was his behavior true crazy wisdom? I can’t really say.

Another mark of true crazy wisdom is that if a person is caught doing it—let’s say you’re doing something illegal and someone arrests you for it—you don’t protest and say, “This is crazy wisdom.” You go and succumb to the punishment involved. You take the punishment. You don’t profess to be a crazy wisdom teacher. You take the karma involved. And most so-called crazy wisdom teachers will say, “No, who? What? I wasn’t doing anything.”

Rick: Probably not too many judges who would accept that in a court of law.

Stephan: No, I don’t think so. In other words, we accept the rules of contemporary, conventional society, even though we’re acting in unconventional ways.

And even if these unconventional ways are not illegal, they’re not necessarily ethical or right. The danger, I think, of crazy wisdom is that it can become an alibi that anybody can use to do anything. And that’s what you hear most often: “Oh, I’m just a crazy wisdom teacher.” It’s a free pass to just act like a jerk.

Rick: And even if these unconventional ways are not illegal, they’re not necessarily ethical or right. The danger, I think, of crazy wisdom is that it can become an alibi that anybody can use to do anything. And that’s what you hear most often: “Oh, I’m just a crazy wisdom teacher.” It’s a free pass to just act like a jerk.

Stephan: I agree. I agree. I don’t think there are any legitimate crazy wisdom teachers currently operating. I mean, maybe there are, but I’m not sure how we would know whether they were legitimate or not. I think what Timothy says is by and large true. It’s trumped up. The whole notion of crazy wisdom has been magnified out of all proportion to what actually did occur.

Rick: Yeah, it makes for entertaining stories.

Stephan: That’s right, I would say. That’s what I agree with. But you still have those crazy sadhus who come out and start hitting their students, and then suddenly they’re galvanized by it. So it seems to happen sometimes.

Rick: Yeah. Right.

Stephan: I guess Marpa was like that, right?

Rick: I’ve been around that, yeah, sure, with Milarepa. Who was the teacher of Milarepa? He kept tearing down that house and rebuilding it and stuff.

Stephan: That’s right. That’s right.

Rick: I mean, I’ve been with a couple of teachers who could be as conventional as they needed to be, meeting at the UN or with a president or something like that, but who could also act very—I’m trying to find the right word—who would really blow your mind with their ability to think outside the box and shift gears abruptly.

I’ll just tell you a story. I was with Maharishi Mahesh Yogi for a long time, and one time there were several plane-loads of teachers over the Atlantic, people coming to Europe to be on courses. They were still negotiating with the hotels about where people were going to stay, and he was, through intermediaries, negotiating hotel prices. It still wasn’t settled, and someone said, “Maharishi, these people are going to land pretty soon. Where are we going to put them?” He said, “Well, just put them on buses and tell them to start driving south, and we’ll let them know about the hotels.”

Meanwhile, there was a lull in that conversation. It was maybe one in the morning, and he said, “Let’s start a university.” So the rest of the night was spent planning a new university, Maharishi European Research University, designing posters and all this stuff. There was this kind of, “What?” He was often like that. I’ve been with Amma a lot, and she’s often like that too. But it’s not abusive; it’s more like being so unconventionally outside the box that it really makes you flexible, you know?

Stephan: That’s right. Yeah, yeah, that’s beautiful.

Rick: Yeah. Okay, that’s enough for crazy wisdom, unless you want to say more about it?

Stephan: No, no, I think that’s fine. Yeah, by and large, as we said earlier, I think ethics has an appropriate place.

Rick: Yeah.

Stephan: No right or wrong—right is right, wrong is wrong.

Rick: Keep repeating that mantra, yeah.

Stephan: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

📚 Narcissism and spiritual teachers

Rick: Do we want to say anything more about narcissism? You have a chapter titled “The Special Problem of Narcissism and Sociopathy.”

Stephan: Right. Well, as I say, narcissism—as David Buss also mentions—involves those qualities of narcissism, the exaggerated sense of self-importance. So this is the four E’s, it’s sometimes called, right? Exaggerated sense of self-importance. So I, at the Zen Center, with my—

Rick: Here are your E’s, by the way: exaggeration, empathy, entitlement, and exploitation, since you mentioned the four E’s.

Exaggerated sense of self-importance, a lack of empathy, a sense of entitlement. Again, these are qualities you can see being acclaimed by spiritual teachers. And then exploitation, right?

Stephan: Exaggerated sense of self-importance, a lack of empathy, a sense of entitlement. Again, these are qualities you can see being acclaimed by spiritual teachers. And then exploitation, right?

When I was with my Zumi Roshi and some of his disciples, I saw what I would consider to be narcissistic behavior. In fact, when I left—I mean, now narcissism has become a topic of great interest, with these teleconferences on narcissism that I attended, which were very interesting. But even back then, 40 years ago, I was still thinking, “God, there’s something really narcissistic.”

I remember talking to Roshi after I’d left. I came back to visit with him a couple of times after I left the Zen Center, and we hung out together. It was interesting because I got to see him outside his role as teacher. We were just hanging out. I wasn’t a student anymore, and I just watched him. He was really upset that the Dalai Lama was getting so much attention because he thought, “Who’s the Dalai Lama? What we’re doing is so much more important.” And I thought, “Where’s this guy coming from?”

He would talk, and he never asked me how I was doing. I’d spend two hours with him, and he never asked me about my life. He was always talking about the next thing the Zen Center was going to be doing, the next project, the next glorious—

Rick: It was all about him.

Stephan: And I thought, “There’s something. He’s not teaching me anymore. This is not in the guise of teaching, where I’m not important. There’s something off about this.” I started realizing, “This is narcissism.” And then it was happening with his students, who were also narcissists. There’s this strange fit between narcissists and spiritual teachers. I don’t know what it is, but they already think they’re special, and so it’s very easy for them to think they’re special enough to become a spiritual teacher. “Yeah, I’m special. I’m enlightened. That’s how special I am.” There’s some weird fit there, you see, and they’re drawn to being spiritual teachers.

You talked about everyone wanting to become a spiritual teacher. First of all, understand that we’re all narcissistic. As long as there’s an ego, we’re narcissistic. We think we’re the center of the universe. That’s narcissism. Everyone with an ego is narcissistic. It’s just a question of degree: how narcissistic are we?

Rick: There’s that old joke: “Me, me, me, me. Okay, enough about me. What do you think about me?” But actually, I bet everyone listening to this can relate to this in a way. Think about how many times you’re having a conversation with somebody, and you’re listening and asking them questions, and they’re telling you things. Then you try to balance out the conversation a little bit and say some things from your side, and they space out. They lose attention. They say, “Okay, I gotta go.” There are so many people like that, that you have these one-sided conversations with.

Stephan: Right. Exactly.

Rick: I think maybe it’s common.

Stephan: Yeah, whereas if you’re really open and awake, you’re just as interested in what the other person has to say as in what you have to say. I mean, there’s no prioritizing what you have to say. It’s just like a story anyway. I like your story better. It’s more interesting. I’ve heard my story plenty of times.

Rick: Yeah, you have an opportunity to learn something new.

Stephan: Right, right, right. But, you know, again, we are all narcissistic, so it is a matter of degree. But I think there’s an unusually strong fit between some of these qualities. When you get a narcissist who becomes a spiritual teacher, they can do these things to their students and not feel empathy.

In fact, even oneness can be used to disguise a lack of empathy: “We’re all one, so what I do to you doesn’t really matter because you’re just me.” Where does oneness begin and end, and where does solipsism begin?

Rick: I think if a person’s saying something like that, they’re not experiencing the kind of oneness that we would really aspire to.

Stephan: Of course.

Rick: They’re not in the “I and my Father are one” category.

Stephan: No, of course. It’s a misunderstanding. Of course.

Rick: A lot of times, you see people using an intellectual concept of something and mistaking it for the actual experience of oneness or whatever. Then the behavior comes out in the kind of warped way you describe, because it’s not genuine.

Stephan: Right, absolutely.

✨ Awakening, embodiment, and shadow

Rick: Okay, you have a topic here: “Once You Awaken, Do You Bypass or Embody?” What do you mean by that? Let’s dwell on that for a bit.

Stephan: Well, you know, you’ve awakened to the truth of your being. You know that you’re not this separate self that you’ve taken yourself to be, with all the story and the history and the beliefs and the hang-ups and all of that. You know that you are, again, boundless awareness, consciousness itself. That has been recognized. So, do you hang out there and avoid the human realm, bypass the issues that are presented in being a human in the world? Again, the Zen sickness. Do you hang out in the monastery or on your cushion? And we’ve met people like that. We all have met, you know, “Who, me? I don’t get angry. It never affects me.” And relationships are to be avoided because they stir up unresolved issues. Yeah, that’s one way to deal with it. You hang out in that more ethereal realm, in the absolute.

Or do we venture—which takes more courage and a willingness to be humbled again and again and again and again—into the realm of human relationship? You know, have a partner, have close friends, and learn from those experiences. Yeah, that’s embodiment. Living it moment after moment so that it descends into—you know, Adya is fond of talking about the different chakras—the heart chakra, the root chakra. The root chakra is basically about trust, basic trust in the world. The heart chakra is about love and connectedness. Do we allow it to embody in those ways, or do we just hang out in a disembodied awakeness and bypass? Do you think that we have a choice?

Rick: Yeah. On the point of choice, do you think that, the evolutionary power of life being what it is, a person would be allowed to hang out indefinitely in that state? Or do you think that eventually something is going to kick them out of it? Some external event is going to force them to snap out of it and deal with it? Or do you think that a person could spend an entire lifetime hanging out without really embodying?

Stephan: Well, it depends. I mean, I guess some people have enough money, or they live simply, and they can just live a more monastic, solitary lifestyle.

Rick: That may be appropriate for some people, you know?

Stephan: It may be appropriate, yeah. And again, this is not to say that one is better than the other. I would definitely preference embodiment, but maybe in this lifetime that just doesn’t happen. Maybe you’re not ready. You know, if there’s been severe trauma, you’ve had a really, really difficult, unhappy childhood or past lives—and, you know, I’m agnostic on past lives—but if you’ve in fact had a very difficult time in lifetimes, this lifetime maybe you just want to hang out in the absolute and drink deep of the nectar of enlightenment, of this Self. Then, by all means, you know, that may be appropriate for some people. It’s true.

Rick: And you wouldn’t accuse Shankara or Ramana or someone like that of bypassing just because they were monks. But actually, you know, they were very engaged with the world, running around.

Stephan: Ramana read the newspaper every day. He was very close to his mother, you know, all those things, and very involved in the running of the ashram. He was constantly talking to people. He was very involved in that way.

Rick: Sure.

Stephan: He didn’t have a wife, of course. He didn’t have that sort of more involved relationship.

Rick: And Shankara ran all over India setting up centers, debating people, and writing books and all that stuff. So, yeah.

Stephan: Yeah, there’s certainly a place for that.

Keeping your own discernment and power

Rick: Yeah. Let’s talk about how students give their power away. There’s a bunch of points on that, but why don’t you just start riffing on it? Or unless you want me to read some of those points.

Stephan: No, no, no. I’ll riff on it. I’ll riff on it. But, you know, it’s very tempting. I mean, let’s face it, you know, we’re struggling. We’re suffering. We meet someone who claims to have the answer to our problems, you know, to offer us the solution to our suffering, right? And it’s so tempting to want to believe them and give our power away and say, “You, show me the way, please. I’m an endarkened soul,” like we talked about before. “I don’t know what to do. You tell me what to do,” you know. And it’s very seductive, and it can be very reassuring to have someone you consider to be an enlightened sage guiding your life at every turn, right?

But as we know, there are pitfalls to that, and that’s what we’re talking about, you know. Ultimately, of course, you have to take power back. You have to take responsibility for your own life. But, you know, there’s that sense of a good father. Many people are looking for a good father, you know. People’s relationships with their fathers are unfortunately often problematic. They need a teacher who’s a good father or a good mother, and, you know, there’s the potential there for healing: having a healing relationship with a good father or a good mother when their relationship with their actual father or mother was not. That’s another draw.

And the other, you know, coming back to the narcissistic element, is that we feel special when we’re the student of someone who believes they’re special, right? We bask in the glow of their specialness, you know.

Rick: My teacher is the bestest, and, you know, he must be because I’m with him. T—

Stephan: There you go, and vice versa. I must be the best student because I’m with a teacher like this, you know. And then it also, you know, lets them be responsible for my life. I don’t need to. I can remain a child. I don’t need to make decisions. Let my teacher do it for me. That’s very appealing to some people.

Rick: Yeah. You know what you just said about a student saying, “I don’t know what to do. Please tell me what to do.” It reminds me of the Gita, actually, in which Arjuna said just that. He said, “I’m stuck. I don’t know what to do. Please tell me.” And then Arjuna and Krishna have this big, long conversation, and at the end of the book Krishna says, “Okay, well, I’ve given you all this knowledge. Now decide what to do.”

Stephan: Yeah, yeah, exactly. And that’s what I think a teacher’s role is, ultimately. And, you know, I certainly do this: Don’t believe anything I say. Find out for yourself. Don’t take my word for it. You’re the expert in your life. You’re the expert on your path. You know, if what I say is helpful for you, great. If not, forget it.

Rick: Yeah. You’re actually paraphrasing the Buddha there. Remember that quote?

Stephan: That’s right.

Rick: Yeah, he says pretty much that.

Stephan: Work out your own salvation with diligence. Be a light unto yourself. Work out your own salvation with diligence—your own awakening, your own freedom—with diligence.

Rick: And he also said, “Don’t believe something just because somebody said it, even if I said it.” He said, you know, think it out for yourself, you know.

Stephan: Absolutely. And that’s why so many of us are drawn to Buddhism and similar paths, because it is experiential and it’s about being your own authority.

Yep.

Rick: Yeah.

Stephan: At least traditionally. At least theoretically.

Rick: Yeah. It’s a subtle thing, in a way, because there is a certain element of surrender that’s involved in a student-teacher relationship, in any context, spiritual or even academic.

Stephan: Right.

Rick: I mean, in an academic setting—or, well, in either context—in a healthy situation, the student is encouraged to question: “Wait, I don’t get this. Please tell me, explain.” “No, that doesn’t sound right to me.” “Could it really be that?” You can go on and on like that, and a good teacher won’t be offended by that. They’ll take it as an opportunity for bringing out more knowledge.

Stephan: Exactly. That kind of lively dialogue is what I think really should happen between teachers and students. Not the teacher transmitting from on high this wisdom that then becomes the light that the student follows, but more that it’s a back and forth, and the student, as you put it before, does the experiments. You know, does those scientific experiments to discover whether this actually is true in their own experience?

And, of course, they may not discover that immediately, and so then they trust the teacher’s guidance to keep going, even though they’re not getting there yet. They haven’t had the experience yet, but eventually it needs to be something that they’ve realized for themselves, and the teacher is guiding them along the path. You know, I love that famous quote that Jack Kornfield attributes to his teacher, Ajahn Chah. You know, Ajahn Chah says, “You know, I’m not really teaching you anything.” He said, “I watch students go down the path, and I say, ‘Well, you know, just go a little left, you know, just go a little right. You know, that’s my job.’”

Rick: And it’s not like you have to sort of work with a teacher for years and years and years and years before experiencing anything. It’s like the confirmation is there at every step of the way. You know, it’s like the teacher says, “Practice this,” and you have an experience. “Okay, that worked. Now what?” “Okay, well, then do this.” And, “Oh, yeah, more experience.” So that’s my experience, anyway: there was verification from day one, and then continual steps of knowledge and experience growing.

Stephan: Yeah, that’s great. I mean, some people don’t get that verification from day one. Some people, you know, I was always the most—I always say I was the toughest nut to crack, you know, so I wasn’t that student. I wasn’t you. I was the other one. I was the one out of—you know, Suzuki Roshi talks about the horses and the whips, you know. There’s the horse that moves when it sees the shadow of the whip, and then there’s the one that moves when it feels the whip into its flesh, and then there’s the fourth horse that doesn’t move until it feels the whip hit the bone. And even then, you know, and that was like me. You know, it’s like I was really the difficult student, so, you know, I needed the advice I’m giving today, you know: even if you don’t get it right away, trust the teacher and just keep going, you know.

Rick: Yeah, that also sort of depends on the path or technique one is doing. Some of them take a while to really show results, and others are more immediate. There’s a little sub-point here which might be useful: the limitations of being a dilettante.

Stephan: Right, yeah. I mean, my experience was that when I became a Zen student, I just practiced Zen. I studied Zen; I didn’t do anything else. That was my life. So I’m just saying it was true for me. I’m not saying it’s right for anyone else.

Then I left Zen, and I played around with a few other things. Then I met Jean Klein. When I met Jean Klein, I’d never heard of Advaita Vedanta, Ramana Maharshi, or Nisargadatta Maharaj. I had no idea what it was. All I knew was, “This guy’s got what I want, and I’m gonna practice with him until I get it too.” I didn’t read anything else, and I wasn’t interested. I just read and listened to Jean Klein for 10 years.

When that was done, I met Adyashanti and spent a couple of years with him, kind of finishing things up. And that was it. Then I started reading about other things, and what I’ve read since then has enriched me. But I found, at least for me, that staying really on path, staying focused, and keeping it simple is helpful.

What I find with students again and again and again is that the most pervasive difficulty is that they’ve read so many books. When I started practicing, there were no books. Even finding a book on Zen was really difficult. Now there are millions of books, YouTube videos, and satsangs, and so they imbibe all these words, all this jargon. They’re full of it, and then it’s completely confusing. So I say, “Throw it all away. Stop reading and start from scratch.”

That’s the problem with being a dilettante: you get all these different views. They may all be different views of the same moon, the same truth, but they’re different views coming from different perspectives. It’s really helpful to have one thing over and over and over again. On the other hand, if that one isn’t working for you, at some point, try something else. I don’t want to be rigid about this, but there’s something about sticking with one thing until you finally get the essence of it.

Rick: Yeah, I’m gonna lose all my Batgap viewers if they take you too seriously here. Somebody new every week, you know.

Stephan: The ultimate smorgasbord of spiritual teachers. I love that you say “awakening,” though. I think that’s great. Instead of “awakened,” I think that’s great.

Rick: We used to say “awakened,” but we changed it.

Stephan: I know, I know. I think it’s great.

Rick: And, you know, in my own case, I had a very regular practice that I stuck to like glue. But I felt comfortable reading Carlos Castaneda or Yogananda or various other things that came my way. They were fascinating, but it’s not like I was seeking a teaching and thinking, “I’ll try a little of this, I’ll try a little of that.” There was a kind of a foundation.

Stephan: I read Carlos Castaneda while I was practicing Zen, that is true, and I read Chögyam Trungpa while I was practicing Zen. I found Trungpa particularly helpful. In fact, Trungpa was one of the first teachers I ever met when I started practicing Zen.

This guy comes in—I’m at the Zen Center in New York City on East 67th Street, and I’ve just started practicing Zen. I’m used to all these people in their robes, and the roshi barely speaks English. This guy comes in wearing a suit and tie. He speaks perfect English with an English accent. He limps in, in a suit and tie, sits down, and gives the clearest Dharma talk I’ve ever heard. It was like nothing I’d ever heard in Zen. And I thought, “Who is this guy?” This is in 1970; he hadn’t even begun in the United States yet.

So I started reading his books, and he was amazing. We can talk about Trungpa and crazy wisdom, but some of his books are incredible, pioneering texts of American Buddhism.

Rick: People say that about Adi Da too. I haven’t read his books, but people say his listening and so on were great. It’s funny, I went to that Zen Center on East 67th Street in the fall of 1968, and I was thinking of joining.

Stephan: Wow, that’s when I went.

Rick: You might have been there.

Stephan: Where did you go to school?

Rick: Well, I lived in Connecticut, and I was going to—yeah, I grew up there. I was going to college at the University of Bridgeport, or maybe at that time it was Norwalk Community College first. But anyway, I was thinking of joining a Zen Center, and I wrote to this place up in Rochester. They said, “Well, first you have to visit a local roshi and do that for six months and get his recommendations.”

So I went to check this guy out, but then I ended up getting into TM more deeply, sticking with that, and becoming a teacher. I remember that experience. Yeah, we did. You might have been there that night.

All right, anyway, the true guru is inside you. You touched upon that point, but is there anything more we want to say about that? And have any questions come in, Irene?

Stephan: No, no questions.

Rick: Okay. You know, I hear people say that, and sometimes they say that as a way of saying, “I don’t need a teacher.” But I think there’s a way that you can interpret that even in the context of working with a teacher.

Stephan: That’s right. Like we were talking about earlier, ultimately, you’re your own teacher. Simply put, practically speaking, everything that you’re being taught is being filtered through you. If it doesn’t resonate for you, then it’s not going to work for you. Eventually, you’re going to have to throw it out. So ultimately, only you know what’s right for you.

In that sense, just practically speaking, it’s only going to work for you if you are discerning, as we talked about before. So ultimately, the true guru is inside you. Are there other gurus, other teachers, who can help that guru find his or her own way? Yeah, absolutely. But only in the depths of your own heart can you know what’s true for you. That can be schooled and enriched by various teachers and various teachings, but ultimately, it comes back to here.

And, of course, what do we awaken to? Our very own true self, our very own inherently awake true nature, our natural state. It’s here. It’s not out there.

Rick: Yeah. For some reason, that statement reminds me a little bit of Christ’s parable of the sower, where someone throws seeds on various types of ground or soil. In some cases, it just dies; in other cases, it sprouts up nicely. Sometimes it sprouts up quickly and then dies because the soil isn’t that deep, and so on. It’s like you have to be a fertile field for the teaching of any teacher, for it to really take hold and have benefit.

Stephan: Right, yeah. That’s a beautiful metaphor.

Rick: Yeah. And we can cultivate that ground; we can make it more fertile.

Stephan: Absolutely.

Rick: And therefore, more likely to enable teachings to have their intended value and purpose.

Stephan: Absolutely. Yeah, I often say that, just as we can be accident-prone—I think your metaphor is more elegant—we can make ourselves awakening-prone. By sitting quietly, by inquiring, by reading the teachings of the great teachers, by hanging out with sangha, with fellow travelers on the same path, all these things predispose us to be fertile ground, as you put it.

Rick: That to which you give your attention grows stronger in your life.

Stephan: That’s right. Absolutely.

📚 A more egalitarian teacher-student relationship

Rick: You have a point here, a new vision for the teacher-student relationship. What is your new vision for the teacher?

Stephan: Well, I haven’t written a book yet, Rick, so—

Rick: Now you’ll have to. We’ve given everybody a teaser.

Stephan: Right, right, right. Yeah, I think, again, we’ve been touching on it throughout here: a more egalitarian relationship. I think teachers, again, I’ll come back to what I began with, which is that teachers really have an important role to play, either before or after awakening, or both. But it can’t be a top-down hierarchical relationship in the culture in which we live. It’s not going to last. It’s not going to work.

I like the notion of a spiritual friend. Kalyāṇa-mitra is the term that’s used in the Buddhist tradition, and teachers in the pastoralist tradition are often characterized as kalyāṇa-mitra, as spiritual friends. So I think we’re friends. This is more Aquarian, more egalitarian. We’re all in it together. We’re all awakening. We’re on this awakening journey. Some of us are a little farther ahead, and we look to them for guidance, but we’re all on the same journey.

I think that metaphor—that we’re all on the same awakening journey and we’re helping one another on the path—is helpful. Some are somehow taking the role of teacher, but at the same time are very cognizant of the fact that they are students as well. If you’re a teacher, you’re also very aware of being a student. That is an integral part of being a teacher: also being a student, and not polarizing, as we talked about, into the archetypes of “awakened” and “darkened.” So that would be my vision. And I think it’s happening. So it’s not my vision; I think it’s happening more and more.

Rick: Yeah, and I don’t think this model necessarily levels the playing field. In other words, if you’re an aspiring cellist and you happen to have a friendship with Yo-Yo Ma, you’re not going to just assume that you’re as good a cellist as he is. But there’s the friendship dimension, in which you’re buddies, and you have a lot to learn from him.

Stephan: Did you ever—have you ever seen videos of Yo-Yo Ma? The humblest person around. He’s so interested in the people around him, so interested in learning from them. When he plays music with other people, he’s really responsive and interested in what they have to offer. So Yo-Yo Ma, to me, is a beautiful example of a teacher in the mold that we’re talking about.

Rick: Yeah. I saw a thing a while back where he went to get his COVID vaccination, and he set up his cello and played it for the people who were waiting to get their vaccinations. That’s pretty cool.

Stephan: Yeah. Beautiful, beautiful human being.

Rick: Yeah. I guess one more point I want to raise with you: I was reminded of it because I mentioned COVID vaccination. I’ve had to take down some—I didn’t have to, but we took down some interviews recently because the teachers in question seemed to have been doing nothing but harping about COVID and vaccinations and so on, in a way that I feel is scientifically unfounded and rather dangerous. It’s not their expertise; they’re just picking up on all the misinformation flying around, which I characterize as misinformation.

So what do you think about the role, the importance of teachers sticking to their craft or their expertise, and not necessarily dispensing advice on other things they don’t really know about, even if they feel they know something or have learned something and feel it’s important?

Stephan: I’m not going to judge what other people are doing or not doing, but I’m with you fundamentally. I mean, that’s how I perceive my role. I don’t feel that it’s my role or responsibility, or that I have any authority, to tell other people or even to share my views on politics. This is just how I am. Now, I know plenty of other teachers may do it differently, but I don’t have any expertise, as you said, or authority. And to use my authority as a teacher to try to leverage other beliefs and influence other people in that way, I don’t think that’s my role. I’d rather keep it pure. This is what I’m here to offer. This is my role. This is why I’m here, you know, and I think it’s muddying the ground. But again, that’s just for me. Others can do what they want, but that’s not what I would do. I don’t recommend it.

Rick: Yeah, and I got some flack for doing that, naturally. Someone just today emailed to say, “Now you’ve shown your true colors for taking down so-and-so.” But I don’t know, I just feel like Irene and I both feel we have a big responsibility with this show. An interview is kind of a referral and sometimes launches people’s teaching careers or boosts them. We just don’t feel that if a person is saying or doing something we feel is irresponsible or inappropriate, we have an obligation to continue referring people to them. We feel a responsibility not to, as a matter of fact. Obviously, people have differing opinions and views, but we just have to go by our best insights and judgment.

Stephan: Yeah, you have to do what feels right to you. Again, discernment.

Rick: Yeah, yeah. Because again, it’s a big responsibility being a spiritual teacher. It’s a big responsibility referring people to spiritual teachers. It’s the most precious, like we’ve been saying, most precious relationship one can have in life, in many respects.

Stephan: I agree. I’m glad we’re coming back to that at the end of our interview, that it’s such a precious thing. To discover the Dharma—in the Tibetan tradition, they say it’s rare as… What is it? I forget the metaphors. But it’s so rare to actually encounter these truths and be open to them in one’s lifetime, and then to meet a teacher. That relationship is so precious. So I think it’s important to take really good care of it, to tend to care for that.

The relationship with a teacher is so precious. It’s important to take really good care of it.

Rick: Yeah, there’s a sacredness to it, which—yeah, okay, well, that is a good note to end on. Obviously, all these points could use further elaboration, but I think we’ve covered things pretty thoroughly.

Stephan: I think so. Two hours—that’s a long conversation. I’ve enjoyed it. It’s great. It’s also been a back and forth, and I’ve really agreed with most of what you’re saying and appreciated your part in this whole conversation.

Rick: And if you hadn’t agreed with some of it, I wouldn’t have been upset.

Stephan: Of course. Yeah, of course.

Rick: All right, well, thanks, Stephan. I really appreciate having the opportunity to get together with you like this again. And to those who’ve been listening or watching, I’ll put up a page on Batgap about this interview, with links to Stephan’s website and books. Here, I’m showing his website on the screen right now. What is it, stephanbodian.org or .com?

Stephan: Dot org.

Rick: And you spell it S-T-E-P-H-A-N, B-O-D-I-A-N, dot org. And in any case, like you mentioned earlier, you have some kind of six-month course every year, and you’re probably doing that online.

Stephan: School for Awakening, yeah. It starts again in January.

Rick: They can go to your website and find out information about that six-month course.

Stephan: Right, right. Sounds good. Okay, very good. Thanks so much.

Rick: Thank you, and thanks to those who’ve been listening or watching. We’ll see you for the next one. Go to batgap.com and explore the menus. Talk to you later. Bye.

Stephan: Okay, take care.

Support BatGap

Support BatGap with one-time or monthly donations. BatGap Non-Profit is a tax-exempt 501(c)(3).
 

Subscribe to the Podcast

Choose How You Listen

Recent Interviews:

765. Sarah Walker Ting
764. Roger Linden
763. Carmen Acevedo Butcher
762. Dave Markowitz
761. Monica Khosla

Try the BatGap Bot

Your interactive spiritual companion.

BatGap Bot