
Neil Douglas-Klotz Transcript: Aramaic Jesus, Translation, and Mystical Meaning
Summary
The discussion explores how Aramaic and other ancient Semitic languages connect sound, meaning, and relationship with the world. It also considers Jesus’s teachings in their historical context and how spiritual traditions can become separated from their founders’ message.
Questions This Interview Explores
- How does chanting help create a connection with the sacred?
- What role did sound and language play in ancient Semitic cultures?
- How should Jesus’s teachings about family division be understood in their historical context?
Key takeaways
- Ancient Semitic languages treated words as sounds that acknowledged relationships, not merely labels for things.
- Chanting can open a two-way relationship with the sacred through sound, feeling, and devotion.
- Jesus’s challenging words about family can be understood as urging people to break from harmful conditioning.
- Religious traditions can turn a founder’s teachings into institutions that no longer reflect their original intent.
Transcript
Rick: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer. Buddha at the Gas Pump is an ongoing series of conversations with spiritually awakening people. We’ve done over 670 of them now. If this is new to you and you’d like to check out some of the previous ones, please go to batgap.com—BatGap—and look under the Past Interviews menu, where you’ll see them organized in several different ways.
This program is made possible through the support of appreciative listeners and viewers. So if you appreciate it and would like to help support it, there’s a PayPal button on the website, and there’s a page explaining alternatives to PayPal.
I guess today’s guest is Neil Douglas-Klotz. He is an internationally known scholar in the fields connecting religious studies and comparative Semitic hermeneutics. And, you know, what does that mean?
Neil: Hermeneutics is based on the name of Hermes, the Greek god. The tradition of Hermes is that language can heal you or language can kill you. He was the trickster. Hermeneutics is the big language—the scholar’s word—for the whole theory of interpretation around languages.
Rick: Okay, so in other words, you studied comparisons between various interpretations of the Semitic languages.
Neil: That’s right. They shared a common worldview and a common way of looking at life, which I can speak about later.
Rick: Okay, good. And Aramaic is one of those languages, I presume?
Neil: Sure.
Rick: Yeah. Okay, so you are an internationally known scholar in the fields connecting all that, and psychology as well as a poet and musician. You are the author of Prayers of the Cosmos, Desert Wisdom, The Hidden Gospel, and The Genesis Meditations, as well as co-author of The Tent of Abraham with Sister Joan Chittister and Rabbi Arthur Waskow. You’re also the author of a new book, Revelations of the Aramaic Jesus, which we’ll be talking about today.
You were the past chair of the Mysticism Group of the American Academy of Religion and are active in various international colloquia and conferences dedicated to peace and spirituality. One of your mentors is Sheikh Fadhlalla Haeri, whom I interviewed on BatGap about a year and a half ago. A delightful man.
I want to read a quote from your website before we get rolling, because I liked it a lot:
It is a real blessing if one can find companions on the path with whom one can share honestly, and who are dedicated to the awakening of self to soul through the constant, albeit often painful, massaging of the heart by life’s circumstances. When well massaged, any pain of rigidity, the “ow” of life, is superseded by the awe of the soul’s eyes looking through one’s own.
There we go. I’d like to ask you if we could spend a few minutes on your background. Some people are pretty self-effacing; they don’t like to talk about themselves a lot. But I always like to give people a glimpse of who the person is that they’re going to be hearing for the next hour or two, because many of them want to know on what authority, or based on what study, knowledge, or experience, the person is saying the things they’re saying. So give us a bit of your background.
Neil: Okay. Anyway, thanks for inviting me, Rick.
Rick: Sure. It’s been an enjoyable week, you know, reading your book and thinking about the things you’ve been discussing. I’m going to have a lot of fun today. I hope everybody enjoys this.
Neil: Everything you want to know and didn’t want to know about Jesus.
Rick: But were afraid to ask…
Neil: Yeah, that’s exactly right. And most people are afraid.
Rick: For good reason.
Neil: For good reason. Yeah.
Rick: You get burned at the stake.
Neil: Well, yeah. You know, I was born in a sort of alternative family in a suburb of Chicago, Illinois, and my father was one of the early chiropractors in Illinois. My two brothers and I were raised with what I call the holy trinity of Edgar Cayce, the American psychic; Rachel Carson, the great American ecologist; and chiropractic. I could spell “chiropractic” before anyone else in my school even knew what it was, I’ll tell you that.
So we had this inner-family culture. As most children do, I thought everyone lived that way until I started going to school and discovered that wasn’t the case. We had, as I now call it, our inner-family story, which didn’t involve any theology, really. My parents were raised Christian, but they mainly read us Bible stories at night. They weren’t fussed about that.
But we needed an outer cover story, as I now call it, in our community. My father did, I suppose, because he had to work there, and it was quite conservative. So my brothers and I were sent to a quite conservative Christian elementary school. This was Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, if any of your listeners know what that was—or is—about. They softened up a bit after that, but we had to learn large parts of the King James Bible by heart, all of Luther’s catechism by heart, and all of Luther’s theology by heart, and…
Rick: It was Lutherans that Garrison Keillor was always going on about, right, in his Prairie Home Companion?
Neil: Yeah, Garrison Keillor is good on Lutherans, actually. But these were—yeah. So anyway, that did serve me, because I still remember large parts of the Bible, obviously. But when I finally sort of exited all of that and made it to university, I went as far away from Christianity as I could.
Investigative Reporting in the Anti-War Movement
I basically became involved as an investigative reporter in the anti-war movement, and, because I had a background in it, in investigations of the Food and Drug Administration and the adulteration of drugs and all of this stuff. So what I originally started working as was a consumer investigative reporter in New York City.
I wanted to—I mean, I wanted to give you the background; this is how I came to what I’m doing. I had an editor in New York City at one of the bigger consumer publications. He liked my work, but he said, “Neil, this is all too positive. You have to make people more afraid. If they’re afraid, they’ll buy more of the magazine.”
This is all pre-internet, you understand, Rick. This is all pre-Reagan, actually, too, as far as that goes. In those days, the U.S. still had, excuse me for saying so, somewhat of a free press. And it took the form of alternative newspapers and magazines, and university and college newspapers all across the country.
I ended up working for an alternative news service that syndicated stories to this huge network that was active in the late ’70s and early ’80s. I was one of the investigative reporters. However, I was working 60 or 70 hours a week, as you do in your 20s.
I read a Gallup poll—it asked people, as these opinion polls used to do, for instance, “Given that there’s no solution to the problem of nuclear waste, is nuclear energy a viable solution for our energy?” Seventy percent of the sample said no. Then, about 50 questions later, they asked people, “If you had to give up something because we no longer had nuclear energy, would you be willing to do it?” The same percentage said no.
I should have known, but I was somewhat idealistic and naive, and I had an early burnout in my mid-to-late 20s. Then I had to decide for myself: “Neil, how do you make decisions in life? Do you always make them on the basis of facts, or do you make them on the basis of something else? Major life decisions—and if it’s something else, what is that something else? How do you make decisions?”
A Spiritual Search That Led to Sufism
That led to this sort of inner search that I went on, which would now be called, I suppose, a sort of spiritual search, really. I went to various groups, but I wasn’t really satisfied with anything that was happening there. Then I did end up with the Sufis. The Sufis were broad enough, at least at that point—they weren’t so institutionalized—that you could go your own way, really. You could try to integrate whatever wisdom you could find from wherever you could find it. And that was important to me.
Now, because I had—I’ll finish this story because it takes you to where we can jump off from—editing skills and had worked professionally, which few people in the hippie generation had, actually, in some cases, I was put to work archiving and editing the diaries of the person who started the Dances of Universal Peace, Samuel L. Lewis.
In his diaries and letters, he says, “I want to do two things before I die. I want to start the Dances of Universal Peace, so people can eat, pray, and dance together. And that’s my peace plan. And then I also want to learn to pray the Lord’s Prayer in Aramaic.” He had done the first, but he had not done the second.
That was a moment that struck me. I can still recall the moment, you know, right now. It’s just like it stopped me in my tracks. I knew that if this was something, it would have something to do with sound, with feeling, with the connection of music and sound through the words, which is what the Sufis do. Most Middle Eastern traditions have chanting, so they all do this.
So I began to hunt around. I began to investigate: Who knew Aramaic? Who could help me do that? I didn’t think it was that difficult, because I had been raised hearing different languages in my household anyway—a little bit of German, a little bit of Polish, a little bit of Russian, mostly English, of course. But I had a sort of ear for language, and I thought, “Okay, well, how hard could it be?” So this is where I began to chase down Aramaic, really.
Aramaic, sound, and the ancient worldview
Rick: Is Aramaic like Sanskrit? With Sanskrit, it’s considered that the sound value of words is as important as their meaning. In fact, it’s considered that there’s a correlation between the vibratory quality of the name for something and that thing. In other words, whatever the word for “apple” may be in Sanskrit, somehow that word has a vibratory quality which corresponds in some way to the vibratory quality of an apple. Do they have something like that in Aramaic?
Neil: Absolutely. You know, actually, Rick, I would say that most ancient languages have this, and if they’ve survived into today, that way of looking at life has sort of been sieved out of them, winnowed out of them. The ancient Semitic languages—and here I’m talking about ancient Hebrew, Egyptian, old Canaanite, Babylonian, Aramaic, and even classical Arabic up until the time of Muhammad, the Arabic that Muhammad was speaking before they made up grammar around it—all have this idea.
We could say they arose from a nomadic experience: the experience of peoples in this area of the world, Southwest Asia, as I think we now call it, or the Middle East, as we used to call it, traveling, traveling, traveling, always moving. All of these languages arose from this, where the sounds of the letters are sounds, and the letters and sounds are not just naming things outside oneself, but making a relationship with them. They are acknowledging a link that already exists between myself, say, and the apple, or myself and the tree.
So it wasn’t like, “I’m here and the tree’s there, and, you know, isn’t that a nice tree? Oh, the poor tree,” or, “It’s going to be a piece of lumber someday,” or whatever. It’s like, I feel that the tree is part of myself. And the tree is a being that is not just the physical, what we call the material object, but it is—you could say, you could call it—the spirit, the faerie, the genius. I mean, all these words are used in different world traditions. It is the living deva of the tree in some of the Sanskrit traditions.
Ancient Views of Inner and Outer Reality
This was not just people making up mythology in those days. This is the way they perceived outer reality. Their outer reality was like a dream life that was on the outside, as one author once put it. And I think that’s a good way to look at it. The inner sense of the subconscious that we have today—my dream life is my dream life, my emotional life is my emotional life—that evolved over thousands of years. Before, we didn’t have this sort of inner-outer separation as much as we do now. The individual self was not so developed.
Rick: And it would seem, based on what you just said, that a language in which there’s a correlation between name and form, or between the sound of words and the objects they represent, would enliven the relationship with those objects. I think you were just kind of saying that, but, you know, through chanting, or even just speaking the word, you’re kind of creating a fundamental mutuality between yourself and the object.
Neil: Yes. And, you know, either the object or the person who said the words. Let’s say it’s a shaman, or a mystic, or a prophet, or someone like that—a holy person, you know. If you are chanting—chanting is usually what was used around world cultures—or speaking those words, you could, through the language and through a feeling of, for lack of better words, what we would call devotion or love, make a connection with or through that person. And this is, I think, one of the keys of chanting, really.
Rick: Yeah. And in the Gita, there’s some verse about, through yajna, which is a form of, you know, ritualistic chanting, one enlivens the gods, or the devas, and they in turn benefit you. There’s this mutual sort of…
Neil: That’s right. A reinforcement thing going on. Yeah, there’s a mutuality. So it’s not just, “Oh, praise Jesus.” You know, Jesus is up there, and how wonderful. It’s meant to open a channel, if you will. So it’s a two-way street, if you will. There’s a communication both ways.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: One person once said, “If you believe in angels, you’re saved, but if you actually see them, you’re probably cursed.”
Rick: Why would you be cursed?
Neil: Because it’s not acceptable theologically.
Rick: Oh, I see. You might get in trouble.
Neil: Yeah, get in trouble.
Rick: No, I have friends who see them, a few friends anyway.
Neil: People do…
Rick: …and they keep it quiet, you know. In fact, one friend, when I found out that he saw these things, I was in an elevator in the San Francisco airport. He had told me that he sees them. And I said, “You know, are there any in this elevator?” He didn’t really say much. But when we got off, he said, “They just said to me, ‘Don’t point us out to people. If they’re meant to see us, they’ll see us.’” This week, by the way, he said there were three.
Neil: Well, yeah, absolutely. Yeah. I mean, now so-called modern science poo-poos all this stuff, Rick, but, I mean, how much do we really understand about most of the way the universe works?
Rick: Not much. I mean, we know a lot.
Neil: How much do we actually understand about the way the so-called algorithms that control the stock market and the economy work? I mean, these are robots, basically. And, you know, they’re determining people’s futures in some way. So, I mean, we put our trust in the economy or this or the markets. But what does it actually mean? I mean, honestly, you know…
Rick: Wasn’t there some Bible verse about not stocking up on all the things of the world because, you know, they’re going to turn to dust or whatever, and you can’t take them with you? Well, I mean, I’m slaughtering the verse…
Neil: But traditions do say this. Honestly, it’s—but, you know, we’re living… Well, I don’t want to…
Rick: You can rant a little bit if you want to ramble. I rant a bit. You know, we’re a couple of old hippies; we can blow off some steam.
Human consciousness evolved in such a way that we have a much more individual human self. That’s where I was going before. We’re much more separated from each other and from nature. And also, we’re much more deluded by the idea that only outer reality, so-called material reality, exists. Those are the two big delusions of modern life. They did not exist 2, 5, 100,000 years ago. They had other delusions, most likely, other challenges.
Neil: Human consciousness evolved in such a way that we have a much more individual human self. That’s where I was going before. We’re much more separated from each other and from nature. And also, we’re much more deluded by the idea that only outer reality, so-called material reality, exists. Those are the two big delusions of modern life. They did not exist 2, 5, 100,000 years ago. They had other delusions, most likely, other challenges.
So we’ve evolved in that way, you could say. It’s a devolution in some ways. We’ve evolved in the sense of individual human rights. This is an evolution of human consciousness. But along with that goes more individuality, more separateness. And so now our question is: What are we going to do with this separateness?
One of the things Jesus—who came at a sort of cusp, when this consciousness is really starting to change—Yeshua, in his Aramaic name, Yeshua came to show us, okay, how to make this shift in a healthy way, so that we don’t end up, well, basically, sort of where we are. Not that everyone is there, but mostly what the news reports is the results of, you know, a more selfie, selfish, isolated, materially hypnotized culture.
Rick: Yeah, I’ve interviewed a lot of people who are trying to overturn the materialist paradigm, you know, which is that everything is fundamentally material, and the brain creates consciousness, and so on. And I’m sure you’re aware, they are up against a lot of blowback from academic institutions and so on, whether they’re a student in them or a faculty member. It threatens their career path and their tenure, and so on, if they start talking that way. So there’s a lot of resistance to seeing life from a more spiritual perspective.
Neil: It’s a wrench for people because there’s so much invested in all of this, whether in academia, technology, or the scientific community. Even in the spiritual community, you have a lot of an equivalent sort of thing going on, actually, where people mistake the symbols of spirituality for, you know, actually anything real. You know, instead of the emperor with no clothes, you have the clothes with no emperor, basically, in many cases.
Rick: What you were just saying kind of reminded me of the issue of polarization that’s rending society these days. And isn’t there some verse in the Bible where Jesus says something about, “I came to pit son against father,” or some such thing? And it sounds like he was advocating polarization, or separating the sheep from the goats, or something. You know what I’m talking about—that verse?
Neil: Yeah, I know. He’s really talking, in modern terms, about the need to get over one’s conditioning from one’s family and from one’s culture. And in the time of Yeshua, Jesus, the family culture for most people was pretty bleak. These were all underclass people, as we would now call them, who had been oppressed, taxed into penury and slavery, basically, by empires for generations. And so in these types of families, a lot of dysfunction appears—what we would now call people living under trauma. And so they would have all these what we would now call in psychology liminal disorders, dissociative states, abuse. All of this was going on.
A lot of what Yeshua’s healings were about was showing people: “Okay, there is another realm, there is another dimension or other dimensions in the unseen, but here are ways to access them in a healthy way. You’ve had this conditioning, so to speak, abuse, whatever.” I mean, you have to understand that at the time of Yeshua, there was virtually no middle class. It was all, you know—even maybe an even smaller upper class than what there is today, as unimaginable as that may be.
And so the local ruler, he could just come and say, “Well, now you owe this, and if you can’t pay it, I’ll take your son or I’ll take your daughter.” It’s like that. And what is the effect of that on a family, or on a son or on a daughter? So he’s pointing out that you have to, at this point, separate from that. Maybe you can go back and heal it later, but you’d have to separate from that.
Rick: Okay, so let’s shift into our discussion of the book. We’re already sort of doing it, but let’s shift a little bit more. Firstly, let’s establish that Jesus actually existed. Have you ever read the books by Tim Freke and Peter Gandy about whether or not Jesus even existed? They kind of reference all these traditions that tell similar stories to those we’re told about the life of Jesus.
Neil: Yeah, yeah.
Rick: What do you make of that?
Neil: I have to read all this stuff, actually, because people are always asking me about it. I don’t put much—here’s a couple of things. If Jesus did not exist, he wouldn’t appear all over the Qur’an, unless you believe the conspiracy theory that the Qur’an is just a Christian aberration, which is another conspiracy theory. I mean, you can sell books with these things, but there’s no reliability to it.
I mean, these sayings, this type of wisdom, whether it’s Jesus or the Bhagavad Gita or Gautama Buddha—people don’t make this stuff up by committee. I mean, it just doesn’t happen. This happens when individual people open themselves in a deep way to whatever that is, the “great Mystery,” and something begins to come through them. Later, it gets made into a religion. Later, it gets made into a religion. That’s the whole story, you know, of all these so-called “great religions.”
Rick: Yeah, no, I agree. And then, when it gets made into a religion, that soon begins to fail to resemble what the guy who established it was actually saying, unfortunately. And we’ll get into that, you know. And eventually it becomes, in many cases, the polar opposite of what he was advocating. I mean, I’ve seen memes on the internet of Jesus holding an AR-15, you know, with love…
Neil: Absolutely. I mean, look what’s happening with Buddhists in Myanmar, or, you know, with Hindu nationalism in India. You can go on and on with this. And of course, we don’t even have to mention Islam. So…
Rick: Yeah, I was a student of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. On this topic, he used to say, “Knowledge crumbles on the hard rocks of ignorance.”
Neil: Yeah.
Rick: Okay, so we’ve established the existence of Jesus; we won’t debate that.
Neil: Yeah, well…
Rick: Somebody made a splash back there. I mean, wow…
Neil: Somebody made a splash. Yeah, exactly.
Rick: So when was anything first written down? I mean, he obviously wasn’t followed around by a stenographer. And there are accounts of private meetings he had, like with the woman at the well and various other instances where nobody else was there.
Neil: No one else was there. I know.
Rick: So who? How did this stuff come to us, and when was anything first written? Did it go through decades of oral transmission before it went into print?
Neil: I’m going to put my scholarly hat on here, Rick, even though I’m not changing my hat. Is this the stuff that dreams are made of? No, this is the stuff that PhDs are made of in the religious studies and biblical studies fields: the so-called “transmission history” of the Gospels. How does it go from Jesus’s mouth to whatever was written down on the page? Did it, for instance, go through various people making little scribbled notes in different places? And then did people compile these different notes? Or was there some source document? Or did it simply result from people’s memory? Because we know from anthropological studies that, in non-literate cultures, memory is much, much better than it is in literate cultures.
The different so-called Gospels perhaps simply arise from different groups’ remembrances: “Well, we remember him saying this.” And then the Thomas group says, “Well, no, we remember him saying this.” And the Mary Magdalene group says, “Well, we remember this.” And it goes on like that. My point with most of this is that if you look at all of them together through an Aramaic lens—that is, through a native-language lens, a native Semitic lens—it’s still the same Jesus. Really, it’s still the same Yeshua, just different people remembering different things, because we’re human and we need different things.
I mean, look, if you go to any spiritual teacher and ask 10 people, “What did you remember from that?” they’ll give you 10 things. And this is even given that we have much poorer memories than people did 2,000 years ago.
Rick: Yeah, that’s an interesting point, that we have much poorer memories. I don’t think that point has ever come up on BatGap before, but that’s recognized in other cultures, too. For instance, for thousands of years, the Vedas were just handed down orally, and they weren’t distorted. They had these very elaborate methods of memorization. They had to do them forwards and backwards and this way and that, and people devoted their lives to that. Then finally, when we entered what the Hindus called Kali Yuga, Veda Vyasa came along and said, “Everybody’s really going to get foggy now, so we better write it down.” So he got the whole thing written down.
Neil: It was the same with these texts, whether they were the Hebrew scriptures, the Gospels, or things like this. The earliest versions are in pieces. But if we boil it down to what we have today, the earliest Greek version is only about 100 years older than the earliest Aramaic version. And if you consult the Aramaic Christian scholars on this, they say that’s because we never kept old manuscripts. We didn’t want them to get too old and too frayed, so we ritually recopied them, checked them, and then burned the old one. We didn’t keep them; we were not a relic culture. They’re basically nomads. They don’t keep old things; they keep fresh things. They don’t carry around old stuff just because it becomes a relic or a John the Baptist thumbnail, or God knows what.
Rick: Yeah, that wasn’t the way it was done. So the Aramaic Christian scholars say that if or when he spoke, he spoke in Aramaic, and their version is going to be a lot closer than any Greek version. That’s the point of view I go from. So, in terms of it being written down, did Aramaic precede Greek or Greek precede Aramaic? Or was it kind of simultaneous, with different people writing it down in their respective languages?
Neil: I would say it was simultaneous, really. Okay, because most of Jesus’s listeners were Aramaic speakers. Remember, they were poor, the underclass. Only a few of them would have understood Greek or Latin, if they were collaborators with the Romans. That would be a very, very small minority of people.
Rick: Were there many Greeks hanging around in Jesus’s vicinity, or was it mostly Romans speaking Greek?
Neil: Romans. The Romans would also have spoken Greek, because it was a trade language, a language of commerce all the time. But Aramaic is a very, very old language in the Middle East. Most likely, if you remember your Bible at all—and I don’t know how much you remember—when the ancient Hebrew people were carried into captivity by the Assyrians and by the Babylonians, those who came back were speaking Aramaic rather than ancient Hebrew, the Hebrew they had spoken before.
The people who still speak a form of so-called ancient Hebrew, not modern Hebrew, are the Samaritans, who live in Israel and other parts of the Middle East. They were the ones who were left behind when these other people were carried off by the empires in the fourth, fifth, or sixth centuries BCE. So they say they maintain that older pronunciation.
Rick: I heard you say in your book that there were literally hundreds of different Gospels, all kinds of different source documents, and that under the Emperor Constantine, it was winnowed down to the four Gospels that are widely recognized today. And then, obviously, there have been some other finds in recent decades, like the Gospel of Thomas and the Dead Sea Scrolls and all that stuff.
Neil: Sure. The Gospel of Mary Magdalene, the Gospel of Judas, all these good things. But they all had to be hidden. They had to be hidden; otherwise, they would have been destroyed at that time.
Constantine and the Making of a Christian Orthodoxy
Now, Emperor Constantine is left with a quandary, a conundrum that is still the same for modern politicians: How do you simplify things for a bureaucracy? If the Roman Empire is going to become Christian, what does “Christian” mean? So we have to boil all this down. Up until that time, as one scholar describes it, what you had were all these little individual groups all over the Middle East who were Jesus people in some ways.
Let’s say they start out in the Egyptian desert. A mystic goes into the desert, has experiences, has visions—it could be she, too, because there were “Desert Mothers” as well as “Desert Fathers.” They gather people around them. These ascetics, these mystics, if you want to call them that, have a community gather around them. The people in that community aren’t really up for going into the desert and starving themselves and seeing visions. They just want a community. So then the question is: How do we determine what holds this community together?
The community begins to write little mission statements, as we would call them today for a corporation. The mission statements would be like, “Okay, we’re going to gather and say a prayer, and then here’s the statement of who we are.” These early mission statements become the early creeds of Christianity. Then Constantine boils them all down, simplifies it all to four Gospels and one creed: “This is it. Everything else out. That’s it.”
Rick: So it’s a little absurd the way some modern fundamentalist Christians say, “Well, the Bible is the inerrant word, the literal word of God, and not a word can be modified or reinterpreted or anything. It’s just set in stone. This is what God said or wants to have said.” It just seems kind of rigid.
Neil: Well, it is rigid. And again, people, you know, look around. I mean, you’ve got your midterms coming up in a few days, and this religious right is a very powerful force. It has been for a long time in the U.S., even when I lived there. It was very powerful. So people are afraid. People want to maintain control over life; they want it to be the way it used to be. But you know, it ain’t gonna happen. Life is change. Face it, friends. Get out of the outer selfie-grasping bit, and find where it’s really coming from. Find where your self really comes from. That’s what Yeshua was pointing his people to.
Rick: We do it in this country with the U.S. Constitution. I mean, you know, we’re fussing over what these guys thought in 1781, or whatever it was, when they had no idea what we were going to be dealing with today. In fact, I read the other day that Jefferson figured the Constitution might last about 19 years and then would have to be completely revamped. Anyway…
Neil: Would have been a nice idea, maybe?
Rick: Okay, well, that’s a little off track.
Neil: You know, that’s us.
Finding Jesus’ Meaning in the Aramaic Texts
Rick: So, let me try to define what I understand your book to be. It’s an attempt to find fresh interpretations of the words that Jesus may have spoken by looking at the original Aramaic that he probably used, or the words he probably used in Aramaic, and then considering what the different meanings of those words would have been in the context of his society. How did you do this? Did you find enough original Aramaic text to work from? Or did you have to take the English Bible and figure out what this would have been in Aramaic before it went through whatever it went through to become English, and then, going back to the Aramaic, figure out what this verse might mean as opposed to what it’s usually thought to mean?
Neil: No, the first rather than the second. It makes no sense to go back from English.
Rick: Okay, so there are original Aramaic renditions of the Gospels?
Neil: Yes. I use the Bible called the Peshitta, which is what the Assyrian Christian churches use—or actually, all Aramaic-speaking Christians today use this Peshitta text of the Gospels. Although that particular Aramaic, if you will, is a little bit newer—that is, not quite as old as the one Jesus spoke—all of the major words are the same. All the words he must have used, if he said anything, remain the same.
This is my main point with scholars, because I often have to lean on them about this: if or when he said anything, he said it in Aramaic. Basically, the major words—like the words for spirit, breath, blessing, good and bad, and all this stuff—are the same. They remain the same from ancient Hebrew even into classical Arabic. A lot of it remains the same, really. It’s a shared cosmology; it’s a shared worldview. So anyway, this book… Yeah, thanks. We’re backing into the book!
Rick: And before you say that, how did we end up with the King James Bible, or whatever the various modern versions of the Bible are? Did somebody go back to the original Aramaic and go from there, jumping to English, or did it go through Greek and Latin before it got to English?
Neil: It went through Greek in most cases, and in some cases through Latin, but it went through Greek. It has to do with the Reformation and the invention of the printing press. Again, the Aramaic Christians point out, “We always had these scriptures, these scrolls, if you will, in our homes for maybe 1,500 years, whereas for you Europeans, it was illegal and punishable by death even to own a Bible if you were not a priest.” This is pre-Reformation. So you could be executed for having a Bible in your home. Most people don’t realize this. So they think, “Well, fundamentalism.” The King James Version was a translation by the King James scholars at the time. It’s actually, in many cases, very poetic, although very wrong in most cases. But in other cases, it’s just theology that has interpreted the heck out of it and twisted the meaning incredibly.
Rick: Yeah. And I just want to point out one thing, which I think you’ll agree with: This is not just a matter of translating things accurately from one language to the other. You hear people say, “What would Jesus do?” And when I hear them say that, I always think, well, you kind of have to be Jesus in order to do that. You have to be in Jesus’s state of consciousness to act as Jesus would act. And if you’re at some low level of consciousness, you simply cannot do what Jesus would do.
The same point applies to translating scriptures from one language to another. If you’re incapable of grasping the profundity of some statement because you’re just not at a level of consciousness that could grok its meaning, how mutilated is the translation going to be?
Neil: Quite a bit, actually. So, as you say, it’s not just a matter of the language itself: “Okay, words meant something different then. The word for spirit actually means breath. So cross out ‘spirit’ wherever you see it in the New Testament, write in ‘breath,’ and see if that changes the meaning for you.” It’s not just about that, although that’s a good thing. It’s about the consciousness, the cosmology, the way of looking at life that Jesus had.
Again, this is, as you say, you have to have this sort of spiritual gestalt, if you will, where you get into the feeling of Jesus. If you read the Gospel of John, which I have in the new book, this is actually what he’s advocating: “Feel it like I’m feeling it. Look at it through my eyes. Feel it as though you’re embedded in me. And then it’ll all make sense to you. You’ve had me here in the flesh for these years, and now I’m scarpering off, I’m leaving. So you’re on your own, but you know, you can feel me if you make a connection from your self to your soul.”
I think that’s one of the main points of the book, really. I was trying to bring together 40 years of work in one book. I started out with this little book, Prayers to the Cosmos, in 1990, and then I did various things over the next 30-plus years. This book is really meant to bring it all together and place it in one view for people, along with—as well as I could do it—some guided meditations, some contemplations, whatever you want to call them, which I think are really some of the keys to the book. Because, as I say, you have to feel it. You have to experience it, rather than just, you know, hold it up here in the head.
Rick: Yeah. And I think there’s something to be said for trying to imagine the inner state of a great soul like Jesus, trying to feel into it. But that still doesn’t mean one totally gets it. Jesus assured people that they could totally get it, as evidenced by works that they could potentially perform as he did, and even greater works, as he said.
But we don’t see too much—well, we see some evidence of that kind of thing. Various saints levitating and things like that. Anyway, I think one should always approach this stuff with humility and not make snap interpretations of things, but realize that one’s interpretation is probably going to continue to evolve as oneself evolves.
It certainly has for me, yeah. There’s no question of that. Anything that’s wise—you know, wisdom words, if you want to call them that—they will continue to deepen like seeds. They’ll continue to grow new plants in oneself. Otherwise, I don’t want to be stuck with what I said 20 years ago or 30 years ago about something. Why would you do that?
Neil: It certainly has for me, yeah. There’s no question of that. Anything that’s wise—you know, wisdom words, if you want to call them that—they will continue to deepen like seeds. They’ll continue to grow new plants in oneself. Otherwise, I don’t want to be stuck with what I said 20 years ago or 30 years ago about something. Why would you do that?
Jesus doesn’t actually point people to him. He says, “Look through me,” “Go through me,” is what he’s talking about when he says, “Connect your small self to the source of that self,” which Jung would call the capital-S Self. In Aramaic, it’s really called the ruha, the soul—ruha. Connect, make that inner connection, and then you’ll know what to do. You don’t need me to tell you. You don’t need some scripture or some holy person to tell you. You’ll know what to do.
Reading Jesus’s sayings through Aramaic
Rick: So your book mostly consists of taking various verses from the Bible and looking at the original Aramaic, and reinterpreting the verse based on what it might have meant if you understand the Aramaic. Since you just mentioned that Jesus didn’t say to people, “Look to me,” why don’t we start with that verse that’s so often quoted: “I am the way, the truth, and the life. No man cometh unto the Father, but by me,” which fundamentalists use as an exclusionary kind of thing.
Neil: Yeah, that one, plus John 3:16, are the ones that go on the billboards.
Rick: Which one is John 3:16?
Neil: “For God so loved the world….”
Rick: “…only begotten Son.”
Neil: Yeah. Anyway, I’ve got all that stuff in there. But all these sayings from the Gospel of John that are translated “I am” do not actually say “I am.” And for this, I’ll have to take a pause before I say it for all of you listening. The ancient Hebrew languages do not have a verb that is translated as “am,” “are,” or “is”—a “being” verb. They do not have this. Why? Because, as you recall, I said they’re nomadic; they come out of a nomadic experience. So you can’t say, “Here I am, and this is never going to change.” Everything is changing.
So what he’s saying in the Gospels—in the Gospel of John—is literally, in Aramaic, “ina”—I, plus another “ina.” Ina-ina. Two “ina’s” together. That means “I and I,” like the Rastafarians talk about the “I and I”: the connection of the individual “I” to the source of my self, my “I.” Not my eye, but my individuality. Smallest self to the biggest Self. Smallest self to biggest—that’s what he’s talking about.
So if you connect this way, this is the way, he says. This is literally the path, is what he says. Then he says, “ina-na urha”—urha is a path. Then shrara is the sense of right direction, which way to go when you come to a crossroads. He uses this word very often. For instance, “You shall know the truth, and the truth will make you free.” He says in Aramaic, “If you know, if you find the heart’s direction, the right direction, then you’re free. You know, that is the truth.”
So he says here in John, “Inana urha shrara”—“I am the way, the truth,” the sense of right direction, or the heart’s GPS. And hayye, which is universal in the ancient Semitic languages, means life energy. He doesn’t mean life somewhere else, or life on a cloud somewhere. This is life energy that is throughout the universes, seen and unseen. So he says, if you make this connection, you will have your path, you’ll know which way to go, and you’ll have plenty of energy to travel the path.
Now, on the other bit, the exclusive bit, he says—well, this is, as he understands it, and I’ll give you a gloss on this; it’s more exact in the book—Yeshua says, “As I understand it, this is the way everyone has gone. This is the way everyone gets to where I’ve gone: They follow this interconnection of small self to big Self, or, you could say, of self to soul.” So this is his experience. This is the way it goes, you know. You can go directly, or you can have somebody help you. I’m helping you. But, you know, you have to start with dealing with your individual self.
Rick: Right. So, in other words, if you want to get water, you have to hook the pipe up to the reservoir.
Neil: Well, basically. And some people go, as we say—you can use other people to help you, to go through them. Middle Eastern traditions are strong on this. Or you can go direct; you don’t have to have help, you could say. Some people just—and you’ve had many of them on your program—they just wake up one morning, and boom, life has changed. That happens too.
Rick: Yeah. So then, to summarize that verse, basically, it says, you know, if you want to be free—or you can’t even say, to reach your full potential—you have to connect jiva with Atman. You have to connect the individual consciousness with universal consciousness, and then you’ll be good to go.
Neil: Then you’re good to go. And the rest of it is all him giving you different stories, metaphors, you know, to help—how would we say it?—corral his students into that experience, if you excuse the sheep metaphor. He does use that at some point. So, you know, he uses story language, metaphor, parables, things like this.
Rick: It’s remarkable. I mean, you know, if we believe that Jesus did all the things he was reputed to do—all the miracles—it’s remarkable how abundant they were. I mean, he must have been making such a stir, healing all these people and multiplying loaves and fishes and walking on the water. If anybody were carrying on like that in today’s world, they’d be all over YouTube and on the evening news and stuff like that. I mean, it must have been quite a shock.
Neil: Well, again, remember that we’re 2,000 years earlier or so in human consciousness. So the understanding of the—I’ll switch to psychology language here—the understanding of a “liminal realm,” a realm between the realms, between this everyday and the unseen, is that more people are open to that.
Rick: I see.
Neil: That’s why you have people who are able to see demons or devils or things like this. And these can be shared experiences, even. So, I mean, one of the things that struck me about his healings is that it says in the usual translation: Jesus shows up in a village, you know, and he “preaches,” and everybody flocks to him. Well, the word for “preach” in Aramaic just means he announced himself. So he comes to the village and says, “Okay, here I am. Have you heard about me?” It’s not like he’s giving them a Sunday sermon.
Because people were living under this traumatic reality, and they were living in these dissociated states, all these people pour out to be healed. Some of these dissociated states would lead to what we would now call physical ailments. And because he can make this connection—a healthy connection to the unseen—he’s able to heal them. It’s as simple as that. Because how is it that all these ailing people were running around in Palestine at the time? I mean, was every other person sick? Well, it’s because, again, they were all living under a traumatic reality and had been for generations.
Rick: Yeah, I mean, we see that today…
Neil: We do.
Rick: In Afghanistan and places where the people of Somalia have been so traumatized by decades of brutality. That’s an interesting point you made about how the consciousness of the people was much less what we were talking about earlier—the materialist paradigm that dominates today. It was much more subtle than that, in a way, or in tune with the deeper levels at which things like angels and all that were considered normal, just part of people’s understanding.
Neil: Sure. I mean, it was—I would call it—it was much more embedded, Rick.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: Everything was more embedded in each other, in nature, and all of this. Now, that has a downside if you’re in a so-called dysfunctional family, as we would say in today’s terms, or if you’re living in a terrible reality. But this is why people were having these unhealthy states, if you will.
Rick: Yeah, interesting. So, let’s take some other verses. You’ve interpreted the Lord’s Prayer, the Beatitudes, and all kinds of verses. You’ve hit some of the greatest hits, like, “If a house divided against itself cannot stand,” and all that. We couldn’t possibly cover them all. Those of you listening live, if there are particular verses you’d like Neil to comment on, send them in through a question, and maybe he can comment on one. What would you like to do next?
Good and Evil as Ripeness and Unripeness
Neil: I think the one I want to do is about the words for good and evil, which are very key in the Gospels. For instance, Jesus is quoted as saying, “A good tree bears good fruit, and an evil tree bears evil fruit.” So how does this tree become morally evil?
Rick: Was he speaking metaphorically? He’s not talking about—
Neil: Well, no. This is the King James Version translation: “A good tree bears good fruit, or an evil tree bears evil fruit.” What he’s saying, actually, is that the Aramaic word for good—the word that’s usually translated as good from the Greek—actually means ripe, R-I-P-E. That is, at its right time, in its right place. Again, think of a nomadic reality. Think of timing, being in the moment, all of this. So a ripe tree bears ripe fruit, and an unripe tree bears unripe fruit.
You might say, “Well, Jesus, that’s a no-brainer.” But he’s saying to his students, “Look around you. Look at nature. Live the way nature is. Live as a ripe tree; don’t live as an unripe tree, not in the moment.” Be in the moment: in the right time, at the right place, with the right action.
Then this becomes the form of the word, the main word for “blessing” in the New Testament. For instance, all of these so-called Beatitudes: “Blessed are the…” We use no “are,” as you’ve heard me say before. The word for blessing means ripe, ripeness. For instance, in the first Beatitude, usually translated, “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven,” he says, “Ripe are those”—”ripening are those”—who “lemeskenae b’ruh,” who are able to find their home in the breath.
“Poor in spirit” is the King James translation. But “lemeskenae” means that the person is holding on to the breath, to their breathing, as though it were their first and last possession—which actually it is. I mean, it’s the first thing that comes into our bodies when we come into life, and it’s the last thing that leaves.
He says when you hit rock bottom in this way, then things begin to open up for you. Then you have—then comes to you “dilhounie,” which means “is coming to you”—”dilhounoie malkuta.” Malkuta—not kingdom, actually; queendom in Aramaic, because it’s feminine gender. Then comes a sense of empowerment, of vision, vision with empowerment, that is throughout the whole cosmos. You have a much bigger home then. You have a sense of vision with the energy to accomplish a vision in life. But you have to sort of go to what the 12-Steppers call rock bottom, and start from there, really.
Rick: So do you mean rock bottom the way a 12-Stepper would, where you’ve really bottomed out and you’re desperate? Or do you mean rock bottom in terms of some deeper, fundamental level of reality that you connect with? That can be thought of as a foundation or a rock bottom, too.
Neil: Yeah, it can be either one. I mean, the people to whom Jesus spoke the Beatitudes in Matthew seem to have been really at rock bottom. They were homeless; they had nowhere to go. They had been driven off their land, maybe driven out of their family. So literally, they didn’t know where to go or what to do. And so he begins to give this—you could say—
Rick: He’s encouraging them. So—
Neil: He is starting a process with them that proceeds through the Beatitudes, starting with finding your home in the breath, acknowledging the places that are mourning or grieving or confused in you. And then it goes on and on through the different Beatitudes, the so-called Beatitudes. Yeah.
Rick: Maybe what he’s saying there is, “Yeah, I know things are really rough for you people, but I have something to teach you here, which will actually bring you fulfillment and inner happiness, regardless of your outer circumstances, and might, in fact, improve your outer circumstances.”
Neil: Yeah. And, you know, it’s not just the words. Again, imagine that there is an atmosphere around this person, as one has around authentic spiritual teachers today, where one can sort of feel that.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: You can feel their way of being, perceiving, and living with that.
Rick: What would you like to do next?
Neil: Let’s see. Where shall we go?
Rick: I can throw a few out here, but I want you to choose, if possible.
Neil: Well, you know, gosh, I started with the prayer of Jesus, the so-called Lord’s Prayer, although I argue there’s no word in Aramaic that is actually well translated as “lord.” That’s a medieval, feudalistic concept that gets layered over onto the Gospels. So I just call it the prayer of Jesus, the one that he gives in words. We can look a little bit at that. I’ll dip into a bit of it.
But I’d like to remind people that Jesus didn’t always pray in words. When it says he went into the hills and stayed overnight praying, it doesn’t mean he’s mumbling words to himself all night. In another place in the Gospels, he’s talking about, “Pray just with my atmosphere.” That means in silence. Pray with my “shem,” the word for atmosphere or light, or the light that you feel through my atmosphere. Just pray that way. Pray in the silence; pray with that feeling.
But I’d like to remind people that Jesus didn’t always pray in words. When it says he went into the hills and stayed overnight praying, it doesn’t mean he’s mumbling words to himself all night. In another place in the Gospels, he’s talking about, “Pray just with my atmosphere.” That means in silence. Pray with my “shem,” the word for atmosphere or light, or the light that you feel through my atmosphere. Just pray that way. Pray in the silence; pray with that feeling.
Rick: What you mentioned—the atmosphere around a spiritual teacher—you’ve probably experienced it, and I know I have. You can entrain with the teacher’s consciousness—
Neil: Exactly!
Rick: —by sitting in that atmosphere and shift into something very profound just by mere proximity.
Neil: Absolutely. It’s a human thing. You don’t need any special apparatus. If you feel your breath and feel your heart, you’re there. You don’t need anything special, actually.
The only reason I’m doing all this with Jesus is because many people will have been burdened with Jesus in their childhood, as I was to some degree, although not as badly as some people. When they go into other traditions—Vipassana or anything, Advaita, this or that—they may reach a certain point where their childhood comes up for them. And part of that childhood is sort of fear and loathing around Jesus, basically. I call it “Jesus phobia,” and that prevents them from actually going a little further.
For a lot of people who have come to my work, that’s how they found their way to it. They went elsewhere, and then they figured, “Well, I guess I better heal this, too.” So—
Rick: Yeah, I was just watching a television series called Anne with an E, which is based on Anne of Green Gables. There’s a part of the story where the missionaries, these Christian people, are taking young Indigenous kids away from their parents and locking them in these residential schools. We’ve heard a lot about this recently, because the Pope went and apologized for that.
One of their phrases was, “Kill the Indian to save the child.” They were literally killing many of them, but they were also brutalizing their whole traditional understanding in order to supposedly save them. I mean, it makes my blood boil sometimes when I think of the number of genocides that have been committed in the name of religion. I’m afraid that Christianity might, if you look at the whole history of all religions, be in the lead in that unfortunate regard.
One of their phrases was, “Kill the Indian to save the child.” They were literally killing many of them, but they were also brutalizing their whole traditional understanding in order to supposedly save them. I mean, it makes my blood boil sometimes when I think of the number of genocides that have been committed in the name of religion. I’m afraid that Christianity might, if you look at the whole history of all religions, be in the lead in that unfortunate regard.
Neil: It is. I mean, if I can— we can segue into that briefly. I would agree that a misinterpretation, not only of the Gospels but also of the whole Bible, empowers colonialism, racism, and ecocide.
One of the key verses I point to, which I retranslated when I did my book on Genesis, is one of the most egregious mistranslations—deliberate mistranslations—in the history of translation. It’s the verse in Genesis that’s usually translated, “Be fruitful, multiply, dominate and subdue the earth, and rule over…” and then it’s all the other beings created in Genesis before the human.
Well, the Hebrew doesn’t say that. The Hebrew says, “Yes, you will be fruitful, and you will multiply. Learn how to manage your own ‘earth,’ that is, your own earthiness, your own material existence. Learn how to manage that.” And then it doesn’t say rule “over” the fish and the animals and the trees. It says, “rule together with,” “rule along with,” or “rule from within” these other beings.
This is a total mistranslation of a Hebrew preposition. This preposition has never meant “over” throughout its whole history, either in ancient Hebrew or modern Hebrew. So this just gets right into it, because rulers said, “Well, it has to say that because we have to dominate. We are now in charge, and we’re going to go—”
Rick: To where there’s gold among the Incas, and we want it, so let’s go there.
Neil: “You Native peoples are not using this land, so you’re not there. You don’t exist.” It’s like that.
Rick: Boy, we’re getting back into rant mode.
Neil: I know. Sorry.
Rick: It’s okay. I do it too.
Neil: I tend to get into that.
Rick: I mean, there are so many injustices. It’s so ironic, tragically ironic, that so many injustices have been perpetrated in the name of what should be the greatest blessing a person could possibly have in life: the blessing of knowing God and experiencing God. It’s just so twisted.
Neil: Yeah, it’s difficult. I say human consciousness developed in such a way that now we’re stuck with everything this has resulted in. It’s all in front of us. So how are we going—
Rick: In other words, like the condition of the world, the condition of the environment, all that—
Neil: Everything, everything. How are we going to use this human self, which is now separated? How can we turn? How can we return, as the Hebrew mystics talk about? And again, this is where Jesus is constantly giving this—you could say—his mode, his map, although the map is not the traveling: to turn from your small self to the big self, your self to your soul. From the breath, which is only living in this body, this material form, for a certain number of years, toward the breath which is everywhere and all the time, and before my birth and after my death. Before my original face and after my last face, if I can paraphrase the Buddhists on that one. So we have to—we’re either going to make the shift or we’re not.
Rick: Right. Okay, well, that reminds us of a verse. Because I think of deep spirituality as being the ultimate solution to the world’s problems. The verse says, “Seek ye first the kingdom of heaven, and all else should be added unto thee.” Yeah, let’s work on that one.
Neil: Well, my translation, although it’s not in this new book, says, “If you’re going to aggravate yourself and run around and pursue anything, do that first about finding…” And this word “kingdom,” again, it’s malkuta in Aramaic—it’s actually queendom, feminine-gendered—and it means a combination of a vision with an empowerment. A lot of your interviewees have had this in the awakening moments they’ve had, because it’s not just that they had a vision of something somewhere else. This was downloaded into them in a sense that was empowering to them, whether they’re a psychic, an online mystic, or whoever they are. So they have this sense of the malkuta.
And this malkuta is throughout shemaya, he says, the kingdom of heaven. Heaven is not up there, but the realm of light and vibration that is everywhere around us, underneath us, above us, and within us. As I called it in another book, it’s sort of the wave reality that the new physics people talk about, rather than the particle reality. So he says, don’t fuss yourself too much about all the particle reality. Find first this connection, this connection to that which is always on and which you can always rely upon. And then you will have a real nonduality, because everything will be included. You’ll have the individual self included, but it will be included in that which is empowering it, every breath.
Rick: Yeah, empowering is a good word. And I see that inner world as being the potentiality from which the whole universe arises. And if a person is cut off from it—and I bet you there’s some Bible verse about this—then they are like a plant that has been cut off from contact with the ground or the nourishment from the earth. Whereas if they’re deeply connected to it, then it just pours into their individual life and, through their individual life, to all whom they contact.
Neil: Yeah, that’s exactly right, Rick. The verse I think you’re alluding to is the one where he says… This is another one of the ones that people make a lot out of in Christian fundamentalism: the so-called sin against the Holy Ghost. Well, Jesus talks about sin. In Aramaic, sin means to cut yourself off from something.
Rick: Does it also mean to miss the mark? I’ve heard it translated…
Neil: It can mean that. It depends on which word for sin. The Greek is actually the same, but the Aramaic is more sort of like cutting yourself off. I know I’ve heard this thing about missing the mark…
Rick: Like I said with the plant: cutting yourself off from the source of your nourishment.
Neil: They’re absolutely right. It’s the same word in Aramaic: “within” and “among” are the same word. And this again points to what I was mentioning earlier on in our talk: okay, my withinness, what I now call my subconscious, my psychology, is also connected to what is around me. It’s not like my inner life is just my inner life and it doesn’t affect anything. No, my community life affects my inner life; my inner life affects my community life. So this “within” and “among” were sort of intertwined in ancient times. I mean, the Gospel of Thomas talks about—similar verse—what’s called malkuta d’Alaha, the kingdom-queendom. What I have called “the I can the cosmos,” as though it’s arising within you and then spreading around you. So that includes both of the meanings.
Rick: Now, I think about 15 minutes ago, you were about to start talking about the Lord’s Prayer, and then I sidetracked you onto something. So, do you want to come back…?
Neil: I sidetracked myself! No mea culpa is necessary. Well, the prayer again, you know, the place of prayer for many people is fraught; it is difficult. Devotional practice, while it can be heart-opening, can also lead to its abuses. And one sees that in many aspects of fundamentalist religion, not only Christianity but other types of religion, because you’re placing God out there somewhere. You know, it’s like up on some throne, or this or that or the other thing. And again, I hope I’ve said enough in the time we’ve talked together to indicate that Jesus was not coming from this sort of place. He’s coming from a place where prayer is like a chant, if you will, that helps attune you to different realities within your soul, so that you can make that connection we’ve been talking about between self and soul.
And so he begins with this beautiful word in the so-called Lord’s Prayer: “Abwoon… Ah-bwun. Dbashmaya… dbashmaya.” “Oh Thou, breathing, creating source, parenting source throughout the cosmos.” And again, why idealize at all? Well, because to idealize, I have to invoke, you could say, my imaginal sense, as Henry Corbin calls it. I have to envision the best of what I can imagine and place that as something for me to grow into. So this is the function of prayers in general. Okay, you’re going to pray to Krishna, that’s fine, but be Krishna. You want to be a Buddhist? Be a Buddha! So praising is about finding a doorway, opening a doorway in one’s heart, so that the heart can turn easily between self and soul.
The Lord’s Prayer as a Practice of the Heart
This is the key place of the heart in ancient Semitic prayers or in ancient Semitic culture in general. Again, ancient Semitic languages don’t really have words for mind or brain or any of this other stuff. They only have a word for heart. So he says, “Abwoon d’bashmaya,” “Oh Thou, breathing life of all, creating one throughout the whole cosmos. Create a space, empty me a bit, to create that presence here.” “Nitkadash shmakh.” What they usually translate as “Hallowed be thy name.” Well, hollow oneself so that that sound, that vibration of the cosmos, can resonate within you there of Reality.
And then it goes on from there, basically. Again, he talks about malkuta; then this leads you to this “I can,” this vision with the empowerment. And then you’re ready—and this is the payoff—you’re ready to bring heaven and earth together. Then you’re ready to, with your own heart’s desire—“Let your heart’s desire come through me.” This is the one translated as “Let your will be done on earth as it is in heaven.” Well, it’s not willpower, and it’s not someone else’s will. It says, “Let your heart’s desire”—“nehwe sebyanach, nehwe sebyanach”—“let your heart’s desire be done through me.” And so that will bring heaven and earth together in my life.
Rick: In other words, God’s heart’s desire, you’re saying…
Neil: Yeah, let the heart of Reality—you don’t have to use the G-word—let the heart of whatever the great mystery is come through my heart, and then bring my life together. So that I connect my individual experience in life with my communal experience, my communal experience in life in my world. In other words, what am I going to do now? You know, that’s wonderful that I have this moment of illumination. But what now? And do I have to go out and convert everybody else to my moment of illumination? Well, no, but you have to find out what is yours to do, and then do that very well. And this is what Jesus points to.
The rest of it is all about, okay, now what do we do in our communal life? Well, we can share bread and not hoard more bread than we need to hoard. “Bread” means not wheat, or even gluten-free bread, but any food. So the word for bread, lachma, can just mean any food. It could be emotional food, mental food, like that. Sometimes I fear I’ve hoarded too much Aramaic biblical food, but I try to give it away as fast as I can. So I hope people spread it!
And then it’s about releasing, untying, forgiving. The main thing about the line about forgiveness, which is usually translated “forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us,” is that trespassing is about going over somebody’s boundaries. The Luke version has, again, a sense of untangling knots—a slightly different word in Luke’s remembrance of the prayer. Or maybe Jesus said it different ways at different times. People do that, go figure! So untangle these knots. If you can “unstep” an overstepped boundary, do it. And then everything will be released at the same time. So it’s not as though if you do this, then you get the reward later. No, it all happens simultaneously. It’s not an if-then thing.
And then the words that give people a lot of problems—mistranslations here—are usually translated, “Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil.” And why the heck would God lead us into temptation? Well, mistranslation. The Aramaic clearly says, “Let us not enter”—nesyuna—which really means forgetfulness. And forgetfulness is a big theme in the Middle Eastern spiritual traditions. This is why the Sufis have a practice called dhikr, which is remembrance. So nesyuna is the opposite of this. We also find it in classical Arabic, and it means forgetfulness of where we’ve come from, of our original face, of where we’re going, of the bigger picture of life. Don’t forget, don’t forget!
But then he also says, “ela patsan men bisha,” “Set us free from bisha”—unripeness. Again, back to that word I mentioned half an hour ago. Set us free from not acting at the right time, at the right place, in the right moment, with what is mine to do.
And then it ends with a beautiful sort of praise statement or a dedication. Semitic languages also had this sort of dedication that one has in Buddhism, too, where you would say, “I dedicate this now for the benefit of all beings.” Well, in Aramaic, you offer it up in different ways. And then Jesus offers one way at the end of the Aramaic prayer. He says, “For all of this returns to you”: the malkuta—that is, the “I can,” the vision, and the energy. And what is usually translated as “glory” is really “song” or “music.” You could say, “And this music of my life is returning to you.” And we move on. Amen.
Rick: Nice. Speaking of fundamentalists, as you mentioned, and…
Neil: Speaking of! What do you make of converting people, speaking in tongues, handling snakes, being saved? I guess handling snakes is kind of a rare one, but certainly speaking in tongues is more common. And then converting others to save them, because they’re all going to hell forever if we don’t save them. And we are saved because we believe such and such. They derive these beliefs, or use various Bible verses as excuses for these beliefs. How would you reinterpret some of the common verses that are basic to those behaviors?
Well, if we stay with conversion for a bit, there’s a basic misunderstanding of what the soul is for Yeshua, or the real Self. It’s all over the Gospels. It’s called “ruha.” It’s similar and related to the word for breath. It’s that always-on part of us, if you will. And there are terrible mistranslations, or confused mistranslations, throughout the King James and other versions of the Gospels, where the words “self,” “soul,” and “life” are mistranslated as one another. This confuses things.
Because for Yeshua, we don’t need to save our soul. No one needs to save our soul. We need to simply let our soul save us—that is, redeem us, show us what to do. We don’t need to save our soul. Let your soul save you! That’s his basic message.
So what does that do to conversion? Well, if you look in the Gospel, in the book of Acts—and I ventured a little bit into Acts in the new book, just not too far!—all of the early people who come to the Jesus movement, we could call it that, or one of the Jesus movements, don’t have theology. There’s no theology being preached to them. People like Peter are just saying, “Receive that—receive ‘ruha d’qoosha,’ receive the breath, receive the sacred breath. We received it from Yeshua, this transmission, if you will, this atmosphere. Here, we’ll give it to you if you want it.” And, you know, end of story. Communities form around this.
Only later, as I mentioned, do you have theology, mission statements, and on and on like this. So it’s all about transmission and people being attracted naturally, not about going out and converting the poor heathen.
Rick: So, in other words, the apostles weren’t pushy. They were sort of like, “Come if you want. Here I am.” And if you don’t want to, then fine. There’s that kind of attitude, apparently.
Neil: Well, I mean, you could say Jesus was not spectacularly successful, looking at the long history of things. But, on the other hand, his immediate disciples seem to have had something. They seem to have had whatever you want to call it—some real, for want of a better word, spiritual magnetism. No doubt some went off the rails, but they had something that people would be attracted to, basically.
Rick: Why do you say Jesus wasn’t sort of spectacularly successful?
Neil: I mean, well, just looking at the long history of Christianity.
Rick: Oh, yeah. I wouldn’t blame him for that.
Neil: Yeah. I wouldn’t blame Jesus for what has been done. And you could look at that in any religion. It’s true. But we don’t know; the story is not completely written. So we won’t—I won’t pre-judge anything. And that’s, you know, something I run into quite a bit.
The thing about snake handling and all that: people like to prove their faith.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: It’s an interesting phenomenon. There are some Sufi groups, mostly unknown to Westerners, who do things similar, in terms of piercing themselves with skewers in the same sort of fashion, to prove their faith in the unseen shaykh, basically. So I’m not a member of one of those groups. I’m still unpierced, but I’m not a member of any. This sort of ascetic practice has been known throughout history, to show, you know, “I’m going to rely only on that,” whatever that is. “And we’re going to trust that and go for that.” So I’m not so down on all that.
I mean, no one’s going to force you to go into snake handling, are they? Not likely. I think that’s in Peter somewhere or something like that. And I think Peter—excuse me if I’m misremembering, for those who are better on their Bible than I am—I think it’s Peter who is bitten by a snake, and he’s fine. No problem: a poisonous snake, by the way. So, you know, this all gets extrapolated from little bits in the Epistles, that is, the letters that come later from Paul and—
Rick: Okay, let’s get off of snakes.
Neil: We’ll get off of snakes! Snakes are good, but I won’t go into snakes. Okay, never mind.
Rick: I see them on my walks in the woods. They’re really cute. They lie in the sun on the trail, and I’m careful—
Neil: Snakes are sacred in a lot of Middle Eastern cultures.
Rick: Yeah, some relationship to Kundalini there, maybe. So this is a popular one: “I and my Father are one.”
Neil: Yes. Well, what he says here—this is again in the Gospel of John, chapter 10, I believe. It happens as a sort of punctuation mark in a particular story. But I’ll tell you the short version. He’s called in front of the scribes, that is, the temple officials, several times, particularly in the Gospel of John. And they ask him, “By what right are you doing these things?” And at one point he says, “Before Abraham was, I am.”
Again, remember, there’s no “am.” So he’s pointing to—I’ll get to your passage in a moment.
Rick: And Abraham preceded Jesus by a thousand years, or two, or whatever.
Neil: Correct, yeah. And because the Middle Eastern way of looking at time is different from the Western way, it’s as though the past is in front of us. The ancient Middle Eastern way of looking at time is that the future is behind us, and we’re all traveling—again, remember, nomadism. So we’re following our ancestors; we’re following the best of our ancestors. And we want to make sure that we leave something for our children who are coming along behind us, and our children’s children. So there was a sense of continuity and constant travel.
So when Jesus says “before Abraham,” he means, you could say, the idea, or you could say the archetype, to use a Jungian term—the archetype of the human, of the complete human being, the completing human being—was there before Abraham. It was there in the heart of the great Mystery, when all this happened, and when self separated from soul to some degree, and Adam and Eve and all that great stuff.
So when Jesus says “before Abraham,” he means, you could say, the idea, or you could say the archetype, to use a Jungian term—the archetype of the human, of the complete human being, the completing human being—was there before Abraham. It was there in the heart of the great Mystery, when all this happened, and when self separated from soul to some degree, and Adam and Eve and all that great stuff.
And then we get challenged. So the idea of a person who could easily turn his or her heart from self to soul and back again was already seeded in the cosmos before Abraham. And then the scribes say to him, “You’re hardly 30 years old. How are you saying you’re before Abraham? What’s that about?”
And then we get challenged. So the idea of a person who could easily turn his or her heart from self to soul and back again was already seeded in the cosmos before Abraham. And then the scribes say to him, “You’re hardly 30 years old. How are you saying you’re before Abraham? What’s that about?”
So he says, “Well, you know.” Then he says, “Ina wa aby had hnan.” Had to pull it out of the memory banks! “I and that breathing life of all, the creating source of the cosmos, live together. We are one, living together.”
Now, that is a paradox, in the sense that how can you have one and be together? This is about nonduality, actually. So you have a oneness, a unity, that is also a togetherness. Possible? Well, for Yeshua, it was possible.
So he’s not saying he is God, or he’s not saying he is the great Mystery. Well, how could that be? Because he’s in a body, and his soul is part of that great Mystery, is living within that great Mystery, within Alaha—which is the word he uses for Reality, or, so to speak, God. He’s embedded within that Reality; that is, living together. And the word “hnan” in Aramaic comes later into Arabic, actually, and is a word for love. So there is a love relationship in this living togetherness with the creating source of the cosmos, with this birthing, fathering, mothering of the cosmos.
And that doesn’t get him in—that doesn’t cut any dice with them either. So he “gets out of Dodge” and leaves Jerusalem again.
Rick: It seems to me, I mean, aren’t there verses in the Bible which describe God as omnipresent, omniscient, omnipotent—those words?
Neil: All of that is a Greek construct from the Creeds, Rick. And we have it in other religions too. I mean, yeah, you know, but—
Rick: I mean, is that something that your basic Christian would agree with? That God is omniscient and omnipotent and omnipresent and all that?
Neil: Yeah. But that begs the question, then: What is this?
Rick: This is God.
Neil: Exactly. You know, that should beg that question. But usually it’s construed in such a way that this omnipresent, omniscient being is up in the cloud somewhere, in some transcendental reality, what I would call a Platonic heaven.
Rick: Yeah, but then it’s not omnipresent if it’s up there and we’re down here and—
Neil: Exactly.
Rick: —you know, separate.
Neil: Exactly.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: Exactly. So, I mean—
Rick: There’s God, off in some corner someplace.
Neil: Yeah. So—
Rick: Yeah. Anyway, so let’s see, what shall we do here? I’ve got all these six pages’ worth of… I took all the verses, the actual verses from your book, and put them on six pages in 13-point type. I’m just sort of picking whatever would catch my eye.
Well, there’s the Only Begotten Son thing. So, yeah: “For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish but have everlasting life.”
Actually, I’ve had instances where Christian evangelists or something have called me on the phone out of the blue, and I start talking astronomy with them in terms of how many planets there must be in the universe and, by the odds, how many of those must be inhabited. And then I say, “Well, is Jesus on tour? Does he spend 33 years on each of them? And if the universe is only 6,000 years old, how does he get around? Is it like Santa Claus somehow? Does he visit all the households in the world on Christmas Eve?”
Neil: Yeah, I have that when Jehovah’s Witnesses sometimes come around here. I used to say, “Do you want to know how the word is actually pronounced?” And they run the other way.
Rick: I’d love to see you in a conversation with a Jehovah’s Witness.
Neil: They try to give me literature, and I give them literature back.
Rick: Little do they know whose door they knocked on!
Neil: No, they don’t know. But anyway, where are we with—
Rick: God’s only begotten son.
Neil: Oh, the “only begotten Son,” yeah. Well, ask the next time what “only begotten” actually means. Yeah, what it says: “only born”—beget, to be got? Anyway, the Aramaic has nothing… The Aramaic says, “fully integrated.” “Alaha loved the worlds of diversity”—that is, so-called material reality—“so much that Alaha sends a fully integrated human being, so that whoever has”—not “believes in” him, but whoever believes and has trust “like” he does. This is, again, another preposition thing. So Jesus never says to people, “Believe in me.” He says, “Have the same trust, trust with me, trust within me, or believe with me.” It’s really not about beliefs or concepts. It’s about having trust that there is this only Reality, Alaha, as he calls it, and that this is the ground of being, again to use another Buddhist term. This is the ground; this is where we come from and where we’re going.
“So whoever has the same trust I do will not”—you could say—“disappear with their individual form. But they will continue, like the breath will continue, like your breath will continue from world to world.” And whether that implies reincarnation or not—I don’t know if we want to go there or not. But, you know, you can read it whatever way you want.
Rick: And I would say, depending on how we define the word trust, that maybe trust is the first step. You know, like, if you have as much faith as a grain of mustard seed, that whole idea, then you can move mountains. And it’s more like you get your foot in the door with a certain amount of trust, but then there’s a lot more than just trusting or believing. There’s actually undergoing the transformation necessary to be able to function or experience as Jesus did.
Neil: Yes, absolutely. And, you know, that’s what he keeps pointing people to. While he’s there, they trust him, they trust his atmosphere, they trust his being. And then towards the end of the Gospel of John, he’s trying to tell them, “Okay, how are you going to do this after I’m gone?” You know, what’s going to be there for you? So develop that.
Rick: Yeah, right. Good point. All right. I’m going to fire some questions at you, which means we’re going to jump around a bit from one topic back to the next. A lot of people sent in questions, and I want to ask them.
Neil: Okay.
Rick: And I think Irene’s saying there are a lot of them. So let’s not go too long on every one, but just say whatever you feel needs to be said. This one was sent in the other day by Sarah Page from Ascot, England: “Did Yeshua die on the cross? I have had what sounds like ‘ashea’ come to me in meditations, but I’m still unsure of its true meaning. So can you shed light on this?” So, two questions, basically.
Neil: Again, as I was just mentioning, you know, I’ve read a lot of books about this, too, that he didn’t die on the cross. He was revived with aloe and went to India. And all of this is possible. I’m not saying it’s not possible. It is possible. On the other hand, already at the same time, the different Gospels report that after his so-called crucifixion, different people had experiences of him, partially in the body or not in the body, or in what we would take as a spirit body, or all of this. All of this was there for them. And that should not be a surprise, because he actually promises this, again at the end of the Gospel of John, when he says, you know, “I’m going, and then there will be a place where you can connect with me.” This is the so-called “my house with many mansions.” “I go to prepare a place for you.” And the place is not a physical condominium somewhere in heaven.
It’s a state of consciousness, is the word that’s used there. In Hebrew, it’s called a “makom”; in Aramaic, it’s called an “atra”—that is, a state of consciousness. Like the prophets go into in the Hebrew Bible, like Ezekiel or Isaiah do, when they have these visions. “There’ll be a place where you can go and contact me. It’s just there.” And then he goes on to say how they contact him, you know, what methods they’re going to use to do that. So that’s clear, of course. Did he die on the cross? Some part of him, no doubt, died. But not the rest. Not the real bit.
Rick: I mean, the fact that he supposedly came out of the tomb three days after he was crucified in reasonably good shape makes it seem like his physical body must have died; it must be some spiritual body, because he wouldn’t have been up for coming out—unless he had some miraculous self-healing abilities.
Neil: There are different theories about this. You can read the books, Rick. You know, he’s up in India; his tomb is in Kashmir, in Srinagar, and it’s possible. I’m not saying it ain’t possible.
Rick: That’s a good attitude. Who knows? Okay, some more questions. The next one is from Hasim Sadka: “Do people from different faiths see angels or divine beings of other faiths?” Hmm. And if you don’t know, you can just say, “I don’t know.”
Neil: I don’t know, but certainly it would be possible.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: Depends on if you’re tuned to multiple faiths.
Rick: I guess a similar question is: If you’re a Christian and you die, do you see Jesus? If you’re a Hindu, do you see Krishna? If you’re a Buddhist, do you see Buddha, you know, when you go to heaven? In other words, is the initial, at least, antechamber of heaven fashioned to make you feel comfortable when you get there?
Neil: Well, again, back to this passage in John I mentioned: He says, “In that place, there are many mansions, many places you can go.” You could go a lot of places, and don’t forget about the non-aligned people. They’re not necessarily Christian, Buddhist, this or that. And so, you know, what about them? Anything could happen. And it’s a big mystery out there.
Rick: Yeah. There’s a nice verse in the Gita where Krishna says that anybody, anywhere, if they have any sort of faith or expression of, you know, religious whatever, I accept that. I honor that. I appreciate that. It doesn’t have to be in any particular form or even to him or anything else. All right, a question from Travis Rybarski in Richland, Washington: “On your website, there’s a quote from Jung, which states that Christians must create their own yoga rather than borrow from China or India. Could you explain why you liked this quote? To me, it seems like a very good thing when Christians borrow from their elder sibling traditions.”
Neil: Well, I mean, it’s in the context of what it is. Jung says, which I basically agree with, that if you’re raised in a particular way, at some point you’re going to have to confront that and deal with it and heal with it in order to go further. Of course, it’s good to borrow. I mean, it’s good to learn many things.
Rick: You mean, certainly… As the Qur’an says, you know, “Seek wisdom even unto China.” So I don’t see any problem with that. But Jung did feel that—well, Jung actually felt, if you read Peter Kingsley’s work, that his form of therapy would become this Christian yoga, but then it gets perverted into, you could say, a more materialistic psychological technique for many people, not all. And the visionary spiritual capacity that Jung had envisioned for it was sort of pushed aside. And that’s from Peter Kingsley. I would encourage people who disagree with me to read his book Catafalque , which is about Jung and Jung’s legacy and all of that. He’d be another good one for your program, if you can get him. But we actually reached out to him years ago, and he was sort of potentially interested, and we haven’t followed up on it. So maybe, yeah, maybe one of these days.
This is from Daniel Ramirez from San Antonio, Texas: “Several prominent Western spiritual teachers talk about the deep undercurrent of unworthiness that plagues us in the Western world, connecting this to our founding mythology of the Garden of Eden and our supposed core of original sin. Is it possible to be raised in the West and escape that fundamental feeling of unworthiness? Further, is there a path for us to create a new, life-affirming mythology?”
Neil: Absolutely.
Rick: Nice question.
Neil: It is possible. I can speak from experience. I was raised with all this original sin stuff, at least in school. I mean, it was like that. Again, this is a misinterpretation of the Adam and Eve and the serpent story. And again, I have that in my book Original Meditation , how that one should actually be read. But basically, it’s about, you know, if you look at that, it’s again like a Sufi story or a Zen story. You’ve got the original human beings, and they are given a choice. You know, “Here, you can eat all of this, but don’t eat that.” And what is this tree that they can’t eat from? Well, the so-called “tree of the knowledge of good and evil,” which is basically about having preference. In other words, I like this, and I don’t like that. So when does that happen in human consciousness? When does the human self become able to choose between what it likes and what it doesn’t like?
When does that part of the human self evolve, such that we’re no longer so embedded in this natural reality that I’ve spoken about earlier, that we’ve individuated? And now I have a choice? And who was it that said—I think it was the Buddha—“The great way is not difficult for those who have no preferences,” something like that. And so this is all about the human self evolving. It’s not good or bad. It’s not “original sin.” It’s just what happened. And it’s what happens to children as we grow up. I mean, we grow up and we’re sort of embedded in this beautiful childhood—or, for many of us, it’s fairly beautiful. Some, obviously, not so much. But at some point, the self of the child, myself as a child, begins to awaken, and there you go. So it’s the same thing that humanity goes through.
Rick: I’ve been having some conversations with friends recently about judgment versus discernment, and it kind of relates to the question we were just discussing. Jesus said, “Judge not, lest you be judged,” right? And maybe you can give us a spin on that verse. What do you make of that phrase, “Judge not, lest you be judged,” in the whole consideration of having preferences, which are healthy in life if they’re not out of proportion?
Neil: Yeah, it is about having preferences, because the Aramaic word Jesus uses for “judge” here—I mean, in this passage you mentioned and also in John—is really based on the word “din,” D-N, which means to find what is one’s—you could say, what one owes to life. Okay, now I’m in this form. I’ve come into this human form from wherever, and what is mine to do in life? What do I owe? You know, what is this? What is the preciousness of this human existence, and what do I owe back to life for having this life? And this is the word he uses for “judge,” but it’s really more, as you say, more like “discriminate.” Discriminate what is yours to do, what is not yours to do. You know, you have something that you owe to life. Okay, pay it. But don’t try to pay everyone’s debt, and don’t try to convert somebody else to pay your so-called debt to life.
And by life, I mean this preciousness of this existence that we have in these names and forms for as long as the breath is in this flesh, as Jesus would call it. So it’s all about that.
Rick: That’s nice. I wouldn’t have thought you’d interpret it that way or go into that from that comment. But there’s definitely a feeling of giving back. You know, there are some verses in the Indian tradition: “Thy gifts, my Lord, I surrender to thee.” It’s like, these gifts aren’t mine. They’re there for me to pass on or to serve as an instrument of the Divine.
Neil: And the main thing is determining what is mine to do. I mean, Jesus could have stayed at home in Galilee and never gotten in trouble. Basically, he was pretty safe there. But he goes to Jerusalem, he throws over the moneylenders’ tables, and all this stuff, upsetting people. And he didn’t have to, but he felt, “Okay, that’s mine to do.” So he did it. And there you go. Sometimes you have to upset people, and…
Yeah, that’s an interesting whole topic, too. I mean, one’s dharma—what is mine to do? And to what extent are one’s behaviors or actions motivated by a sort of individual consciousness? And to what extent are they just an impulse of the Divine being channeled through one’s individuality?
Rick: Yeah, that’s an interesting whole topic, too. I mean, one’s dharma—what is mine to do? And to what extent are one’s behaviors or actions motivated by a sort of individual consciousness? And to what extent are they just an impulse of the Divine being channeled through one’s individuality?
Neil: This is the whole journey, the challenge of our lives.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: I mean, as I see it. Now, the “din” in the Qur’an—we’ll just segue a little bit into the Qur’an. The Qur’an uses the same word, “din,” which is very similar to dharma, really, if you look at the way dharma is used mystically. So the “din” is this: What is mine? What is really my path to do? And unfortunately, in most translations of the Qur’an, this is translated as “religion.” So people think, well, this is all about Islam, or some institutionalized form of Islam. But it’s not. It’s about finding your own “din,” your own way of proceeding, your own way in life. What is mine to do, and what is my path? It doesn’t mean you can’t join with others. It helps to join with others at some point, but at a certain point, probably not going to be…
Rick: I’m reminded here of Christ in the Garden of Gethsemane, you know, “If possible, let this cup pass from me.” And then, after all, “Let thy will be done.” Yeah.
Neil: Yeah, like that.
Rick: That must have been so heavy. I mean, can you imagine yourself knowing that you’re going to be beaten half to death and then crucified, on the eve of that, and what you would have been feeling or going through? Some people have gone so far as to distinguish between pain and suffering. They’ve said that Jesus was at such a deep level that while his body was experiencing pain, he was just residing in heavenly bliss deep within and wasn’t actually suffering. Do you have any opinion about that?
Neil: I think it’s very possible. I’m not there.
Rick: Me neither.
Neil: Yeah, it’s certainly possible. Yeah.
Rick: Because there’s such a fuss made in Christianity about Jesus suffering, and there was that horrible Mel Gibson movie, which I spared myself the experience of seeing.
Neil: And, you know, “Jesus suffered for you.” So you’re going to suffer, and…
Rick: Right.
Neil: On and on…
Rick: Some people interpret that as he took on a lot of karma. And if you connect yourself with him, then you become the beneficiary of some of that absolving of karma.
Neil: Yeah, I think, you know, that’s—I have… I’m not so sure about that. I think Jesus was more about, as I was mentioning, finding your own way, basically. He can help you at a certain point. But you go through him, like a door—“go through me like a door”—and then keep going.
Rick: Yeah. Is “God helps those who help themselves” actually a passage in the Bible? Is that just a common saying?
Neil: I think that’s a fairly common thing.
Rick: But not a biblical passage?
Neil: I could be wrong. I don’t believe it’s in the Bible, but I’m sure I’ll be corrected by someone on the chat.
Rick: Okay, good. Okay, here’s a question from June Waterman in Midland, Michigan. What would be a good resource or book geared toward laypeople about the most true or realistic representation of the ministry of Jesus?
Neil: Well, there’s mine! I have to be self-serving and say, I think—
Rick: Which of your books? The one we’re talking about here?
Neil: Yeah, Revelations of the Aramaic Jesus.
Rick: Okay.
Neil: I think that is a good place to start, actually. And see if it makes sense to you. That’s all I can say.
Rick: Yeah, I thought it was good. I liked it. It was funny because I use this voice translation software to turn written text into speech so I can listen to it. And you should have heard what it did with the Aramaic. But fortunately, the passages are short, so it’s just brief little pieces of gibberish. Okay, here’s a question from Rizwati Freeman in Los Angeles. “I’m wondering about the scripture in which Jesus tells a woman to go and sin no more, after castigating the men who were chastising her. In other words, ‘Let him who is without sin cast the first stone.’”
Neil: Yep, that’s in the book, too. So this is John 8. And as the Gospel says, they’re trying to get Jesus in trouble. So they bring him this woman who is supposedly, as it’s usually translated, caught in adultery. And what is usually overlooked is that Jesus starts writing something on the earth. This is in the Gospels. He starts writing something on the earth. It’s not clear what he is writing. And then he says, “Let the one who is without their own tangles”—which is about sin; “sin” is, in this case, the word for tangles—“let the one who doesn’t have their own tangled relationships, or doesn’t have tangled relationships in their path, cast the first stone.”
And so he’s writing and writing and writing. Then the Gospel says that the people begin to sort of filter away, the ones who are the accusers, and the oldest go out first. Now, why does it say this? Well, this is speculation on my part, but I would speculate that the oldest have more tangled relationships and things in their past than the younger ones! And so they put down their stones first, and they all leave. Then Yeshua says to the woman, “Well, okay, no one has anything against you. No one owes anything against you. I don’t owe anything against you.” Again, he uses this word usually translated as “judge.” “So try not to get tangled in the future.”
Rick: In the sand, yeah… What do you make of—this is a bit of a curveball question—but what do you make of the Christian political base in the U.S., who will support people who are obviously dishonest, adulterers, and so on, because they want to get Supreme Court justices appointed or just get their political party in power? They really don’t care how corrupt the politician is, as long as they get their way in Washington. I wonder what Jesus would have said about that.
Neil: Jesus would not be pleased! I mean, I was ranting to my wife about this last night as we were watching the U.S. election news. “You don’t know how bad it is,” I told her. You think Russia is bad because of the way the Russian Orthodox Church is in bed with Putin. You’ve had this going on for generations in the U.S., from my experience, and it’s just built to a head now, where they can completely overlook all the things you say because they believe somehow that God is going to rule the country. Their limited image of God, so to speak, is going to rule the country in some way. It’s delusion.
Rick: Yeah. That kind of reminds me of “a house divided against itself cannot stand,” because, I mean—
Neil: Yes. Let’s get into that verse just a little bit. Well, again, there’s a similar thing in Thomas, too, where he says… Remember this thing that we talked about, this “only begotten,” this fully integrated human being where self and soul are turning easily from one to another, the heart is turning. So this is the fully integrated human being. This is where we want to be. And so it’s all one, but the heart is turning easily.
But the “house divided”—you know, you’ve got part of you over here and part of you over there and part of you doing this. And this can happen on the inner, you could say, the so-called inner, as we now call it, or it can happen on the outer. One can be very divided in one’s outer occupation, too much so, but one can also be very divided inside if one does not become more integrated, whole, on the inside. And again, just as a parenthetical, the word that’s used for “perfect” in Aramaic in the Gospels is this word meaning to become “whole” or “complete,” not to be perfect according to some exterior standard.
Rick: So when Jesus said, “Be ye therefore perfect,” he was saying, “Be whole and complete.”
Neil: Complete and completing, because you’re never really complete. It’s just that you’re completed in the moment. Then, as life unfolds, more completing will be required.
Rick: Yeah. And of course, “a house divided against itself cannot stand” is within the context of Jesus being accused of Satan giving him the powers that he had. And he said Satan doesn’t do good stuff. If Satan is doing good stuff, he can’t stand because—
Neil: Exactly.
Rick: It’s counterproductive. But the flip side of that is these politicians who are lying and cheating and stealing and corrupt in various ways. How can they be representatives of anything worthwhile? It’s like, no, that won’t stand.
Neil: No, but, you know, this is again something we see happening with some aspects of the Christian tradition, not all by any means; some aspects of Buddhism—I mentioned Myanmar—some aspects of Hinduism, and, of course, Jewish religion. You can go on about this. Just as with the human self, there’s a tendency now for spirituality to be all sort of “out-here-ness.” You know, it’s all about the symbols. It’s all about the trappings. It’s all about how much control I feel I have over my external life, my so-called material life. Well, of course, you want this, because the soul already has control of everything, but you’re looking in the wrong place. The soul already has freedom and everything you’re looking for—the “ruha.” But, you know, you’re looking to try to control this outer reality, and it ain’t for that. It’s for learning how to turn back and how to return.
Rick: Of course, this reminds me of the verse, “You shall know them by their fruits.”
Neil: Yep, yeah. Ripe or unripe, he says. You know them by their ripe fruit or their unripe fruit. But there’s a lack of awareness of what unripe fruit is, it seems, in the instances you’re speaking of.
Rick: Seems like it should be common sense. But then sense isn’t very common. So here’s a question from Jason Harms in Manhattan, Kansas. “Thank you for sharing your insights, Neil. It’s fascinating. It’s fascinating. In your research, have you found that the original meanings of any of these translated texts support or do not support a nondual understanding of existence?”
Neil: Yeah, I did mention this earlier in the talk. I’m not sure if it ran by people. But what you have is more of a view of—not a splitness, not a twoness, but a continuum, a polarity of all these qualities. Self and soul, everything.
This continuum means that, okay, here I am, individual, in this time and space, and here I am, everywhere and all time. And then there’s a place where they both come together. So it’s like the North and South Poles. The magnetic field of the two poles meets somewhere, and then in this middle, you have attraction from both.
It’s similar also to what the Chinese tradition has as the yin and the yang: there’s a little bit of this and a little bit of that. We’ll add a dot in this and a dot in that. So it’s more like this in the ancient Semitic languages, and so that makes the Unity, you see.
You could say that the yin and yang is dual, but it’s not actually, because it’s nondual. It’s just a way of viewing life so that you’re not in denial and just in an abstract, so to speak, mental nondualism that refuses to recognize what the needs of this moment are. And Jesus was all about the moment.
Rick: That’s an important point, because a lot of modern nondualists, or neo-Advaitins, as they’re called, have this sort of mental concept of it, which they mistake for realization, and do not give proper importance to the relative world. They dismiss it as illusion and continually emphasize that there’s really no person. And so I thought that it becomes very harmful for people.
I did an interview with a woman named Jessica Eve a couple of months ago. That was our main focus: the downside of conceptual nonduality versus the genuine article.
Neil: And again, one is led to a certain sort of passivity with that.
Rick: Yeah, nihilism.
Neil: Yeah, and what’s the use of doing anything?
Rick: Right, exactly.
Neil: On and on.
Rick: All right, here’s a question from Aaron Fish in London. Jesus said, “Pluck out your eye or cut off your hand if they offend you, as this is better than what you will experience in hell after you die.” I’m not quite sure that’s the way he said it. But the times Jesus talks about hell make it hard for me to reconcile what he was saying with the universal and compassionate God. Do you have any thoughts on this?
Neil: Well, on the hell bit, yes. Again, this is a reading of a later Christian notion of hell back into the ancient Semitic afterlife, which has nothing to do with this hell of punishment, actually.
And again, even into the Qur’an, this notion survives that the afterlife is more like this: initially, there’s a time of purification. Anything that the individual self is holding on to is gradually, for want of a better word, purified—sweated out of you, can I say? And then the soul, the eternal part of one’s being, travels further, travels on and on and on.
And again, even into the Qur’an, this notion survives that the afterlife is more like this: initially, there’s a time of purification. Anything that the individual self is holding on to is gradually, for want of a better word, purified—sweated out of you, can I say? And then the soul, the eternal part of one’s being, travels further, travels on and on and on.
So Jesus sometimes uses quite extreme language. Again, it depends on who he’s speaking to when he tries to shock people. He does use shock therapy. He’s like a Zen master; he uses some sort of shock phrases. But he’s trying to point out that whatever you do here, in so-called this life, will have an effect on your experience of the afterlife.
They very definitely have a feeling about the afterlife that there is mercy and compassion, and there is time to purify. Then, for the soul—you can say that individual self—to be gradually dropped, and then the soul to travel onwards, if you will. And that’s just a very loose cosmology of ancient Semitic mysticism. There is a bit more in the book on that.
Rick: Speaking of the afterlife—and we mentioned, you mentioned reincarnation earlier—some feel that reincarnation was part of early Christianity, but was edited out. Yogananda says it was edited out at the Council of Nicaea. As you’ve been poking around in all these ancient things, have you come across it?
Neil: It’s very possible. There are little bits of allusion to it throughout the Gospels. Because if you recall, there’s one instance where Yeshua asks his students, “Well, who do people say I am?” And then the students, the disciples, say, “Well, some people say you’re Moses reborn, and some people say you’re this person reborn and—”
Rick: Elijah or somebody.
Neil: Elijah, or like this. So, if that notion was in the culture, a particular being, a particular prophet, or some quality or aspect of that prophet could be reborn in a new body, so to speak.
Rick: What does Sufism make of reincarnation? Is it part of that?
Neil: Sufism? Well, again, there’s no one Sufi point of view on that. And some—well, you know, it’s again similar. I mean, one of the great Sufi teachers of the 20th century, Hazrat Inayat Khan, once said, “The afterlife is like a recording, and it plays the music we created in life.”
And so we’re going to, at least at some point—and this is early in the process, as he imagines it—hear this music that we created in our life. Is it great music? Is it harmonious music? Not so much? You know, it’s going to be there, and then we keep traveling further on.
And Inayat Khan—I don’t think this is necessarily a generally Sufi point of view—but Hazrat Inayat Khan talks about how, in his cosmology, his cosmogony, there are souls leaving and souls coming. And they exchange things, sort of like a Middle Eastern marketplace on the way. So Mozart’s heading out and somebody else is heading in, and he says, “Hey, here, you can play the piano like me.” So, and he goes on like that. I hope I’m not making this too… But I think that’s a rough paraphrase of what he talks about.
Closing reflections and a chant
Rick: Who knows? All right, well, we’ve been going on for a pretty long time, and it’s been a lot of fun. Are there any concluding thoughts that you want to leave us with, or anything? Or even a song, if you want to sing something?
Neil: A song? Well, let me see if I still have a voice, Rick. I’ll turn on “original sound,” and I’ll play you out with a little bit of the original, one of these chants that came to me.
Rick: Okay. What do you mean, it came? You kind of cognized it or something?
Neil: Well, all of the chants that go with this work—and people can find them on my website—they all happen on spiritual retreat. So this is an aspect we haven’t talked about: music as inspiration. You know, this is the way chants—authentic chants that have a deep effect—come, when they’re being given, so to speak, in inspiration.
And so this came to me on a retreat 40 years ago, actually. And it’s the first line of Jesus’s prayer in Aramaic. I heard a voice, and the voice said, “You know, this isn’t just for you; share this with other people.” So I went home and I said to my wife, “Well, you know, am I crazy? What’s going on here?” So she said, “Well, just try it, you know, see what happens. You know, that’s all. Just try and see what happens.”
So since then, a lot of this has spread. A lot of groups do this sort of chanting now, along with Taizé music or other chanting or interfaith chanting, things like that. But anyway, this is the first line of Jesus’s prayer, and the words are “Abwoon d’bashmaya.” And I’m going to have to, for your engineer here—
Rick: Almost sounds like “Om Nama Shivaya.”
Neil: “Abwoon” is a bit like Om, yeah, and “shmaya” is a bit like Shivaya. But it’s got these “oo” and “ah” sounds. So this is the sound of the first line, which is usually translated “Our Father which art in heaven,” which, as I already mentioned, is not that at all. There’s no “in” only, but this reality is moving to and from the reality that is in space and light and all around us. So let’s just do a wee bit of that. [Chants “Abwoon d’bashmaya”] “Breathing the words.”
Rick: Very nice. Thank you. Nice guitar work. You weren’t even looking; you had your eyes closed the whole time.
Neil: Yeah, takes practice.
Rick: Yeah. Great. Well, thank you so much. Really, I’ve enjoyed this whole conversation and getting to know you and reading your book. I’ve already created a webpage on BatGap for your interview, which I’ll post when I get your interview ready to post. It contains links to several of your books and also to your author page on Amazon, which lists all of your books, so people can get them, and also to your website. So—
Neil: Fabulous.
Rick: Yeah.
Neil: Thank you. Thank you, Rick.
Rick: Oh, you’re welcome.
Neil: Best wishes to you and your work, and your continued helping people find their way through all these wonderful interviews.
Rick: Yeah, it’s a joy. And I’m the prime beneficiary, you know. I mean, it just helps.
Neil: Yeah, sure. It changes you too.
Rick: It really does. It’s kind of a powerful technique. I’m usually high as a kite all day after an interview.
Neil: That’s how it should be.
Rick: Yeah. All right. Thanks. And thanks to those who are listening or watching. My next guest is going to be a very dear friend of mine named Robin Chaurasiya, who lives in—well, at the moment, she’s in London, but she spent a lot of time in the Himalayas. Long story with Robin, but her primary work in recent years has been helping children who are born in the red-light district of Mumbai get out of there, get a good education, and live a good life.
She’s knocking herself out helping people all over the world in the midst of, or in the face of, daunting obstacles and challenges, such as getting beat up by corrupt policemen and all kinds of horrible things that she’s had to face. But I just love her so much for what she’s doing. And anyway, that will be my next interview. So stay tuned.
She’s knocking herself out helping people all over the world in the midst of, or in the face of, daunting obstacles and challenges, such as getting beat up by corrupt policemen and all kinds of horrible things that she’s had to face. But I just love her so much for what she’s doing. And anyway, that will be my next interview. So stay tuned.






