
Jac O’Keeffe, Francis Bennett, and Igor Kufayev Transcript: Awakening and Integration
Discussion with Jac O’Keeffe, Francis Bennett, and Igor Kufayev
Rough draft
Non-speech: [Music]
Rick Archer: My understanding of this whole thing, just to kind of get this rolling, is the Bible says the body is the temple of the soul, and all these states of consciousness and realizations and everything that we’re talking about have a physiological basis. Every thought we think, there’s something happening in the brain. Even though the thought may not come from the brain, at least the brain is enabling us to have it the way a radio enables us to listen to music, even though the music isn’t in the radio. I have encountered people– in fact, I’m going to interview one next week– who have had profound, dramatic, sudden awakenings without having a clue as to what they were or what was going on. Holly had that kind of experience. She went by the name Sarojeanie Selge. You may have seen her interview a couple years ago. If that happens, there could be a very intense period, sometimes lasting years, of catch up, where the– not the thing you put on French fries, but catching up– where the body has to adjust and accommodate to support and be able to reflect that awakening. It’s just the way it works. A radical change in consciousness necessitates a radical change in physiological functioning in order to be sustained and supported. So I think that’s the theme of what we’re talking about. And that’s enough of an introduction from me. I’ll just let others kind of carry on.
Jac O’Keeffe: I think increasingly, it tends to be a gentler process nowadays. Traditionally, it was rougher, mostly because there’s such an evolutionary shift now. There’s a globalization, a shift in consciousness globally. It’s like when you move at the speed of the group, it’s a gentler transition. Whereas if somebody’s just popping up, it’s much rougher. So for sure, the stories about even 10 years ago, two years sitting on a park bench, or whatever people went through– Eckhart Tolle, yeah– that it’s not as crude now. It’s just not. It tends to be a glimpse, a glimpse, a glimpse. Also, there’s more awareness about our body. OK, at the other side of it, we have– what are we doing with technology and all these Wi-Fi going through our bodies and all these other things? So that area, we don’t know what’s that doing to the body. But some kind of awareness– no, not some awareness. Some kind of shift in the global vibration is making it easier to embody. For sure, in general, it’s gentler now, for sure. But at the same time, you must have found yourself that sometimes you have a pain in your knee, and you can do everything to fix your knee. But actually, you discover, you know what? It’s issue-based. It’s because I’ve got conflict here. I’ve got resistance to this. So very often, the body will reflect an issue because your brain hasn’t capped onto it. And so the mind will use the body for its own purposes. It will use the body to reflect and to show you and to teach you. The pole will use any tool it can to show you where resistance is. And so in that way, it’s like, how can we ignore the body? It’s talking to you all the time. So in getting to know the body and getting to know how it talks to you, how it communicates to you, if it’s through the chakra system, that anatomy of the spirit, if that’s where you feel something is stuck. Because for the Jac character, physical pain used to be as a result of a chakra. Immediately, it would be like, there’s something wrong with my hip. And it’s like, hold on. If my right hip is this, if my left hip is this, I would know exactly what the issue was by understanding the chakras. And it wasn’t my physiology at all. But of course, it took years of medically and going to doctors and going to this. And there’s nothing wrong. After a while, it was like, there’s going to be nothing wrong with this either. You can have a chest x-ray, but they’re going to find nothing. So in the end, there was a figuring out of what’s physiological and what’s the chakra system pulling from the physical body in order to balance itself out, in order to purify the energy body. So that’s how it used to work for me. So I got really adept at picking up what was going on at a chakra level. And the body then was like, once I got the wiring set up, it’s like, hold on. This is my back. This is nothing wrong with my back. That’s my heart chakra. What’s going on? So that holistic view kicked in, and it was really useful. Really useful. And it’s not that it’s really complex. It’s just that if chakras make sense to you, then start listening to that. But if you were really in the body person and you’re really grounded and you don’t pick up energies, then let the body tell you. Because it might not be that your mind is running the loop. It could be that you don’t even see that your mind is running the loop. Sometimes there’s issues there, but you don’t see them at all. People are telling you, and you’re like, no, I’m not like that. And eventually, of course, something goes, oops. So before you have distance from your issue, before you have distance from a bit of a belief that’s still running, before you get that distance, the mind will use the body for its own purposes. It will do that. So to find out how it works for you, how are you being led, how is spirit pulling you into the awareness of where you think you’re something else, where you think you’re your character, where you’re honoring a belief? You know?
Igor Kufayev: I would like to mention the importance of one truth. And that is, is that with expansion of consciousness, with awakening, with uncoiling of that consciousness which has been contracted onto itself, there are several stages. And the one very important stage, known as a repulse, or return into the body, literally. It could be a return into the body from one off powerful, powerful impact. Or it could be a return into the body from, let’s say, months or even years of being in a very unsettling place. Neither in heaven nor on earth any longer. So that repulse, that return, could be called various. For instance, Francis, in his talk, mentioned today awakening from awakening. And the deepening of the expansion of consciousness and deepening of understanding and deepening of experience that first ruptures this reality into a greater contrast between the subject and object. Because when we first awaken, we awaken to our reality, obviously. We awaken to consciousness. Awakening only happens in consciousness, but on that level where consciousness has been coiled into itself. So the very purpose of spiritual practice, in my understanding of reading various traditions– various, when I say various, it’s like from traditions that were born in Indian subcontinent to traditions that, let’s say, were born in shamanic parts of the world where that particular traditions were practiced throughout many, many different cultures. And that is to rebuild one’s light body. Why? It is because when consciousness awakens to itself, it needs to go back, go back, and find a place where it can reside. Literally, it has to become a tenant of a new premises. Prior to that, the complete objectification caused consciousness to identify with the body-mind conglomerate. Exclusively. And that brought a whole culture, a whole culture, a whole civilization where we actually teach our children, grandchildren, and the whole culture revolves around that objectification. Because we perceive everything like that. Our world is the world of object and subject. And we drown in that. And because of that, our subtle body, our body of light shrunk, literally shrunk. It’s like on a physical plane, if you don’t exercise certain muscles, if you don’t walk, they will become an atrophy. Don’t be surprised that actually the subtle body is not very much different. It has the same, very the same principles. If that body, which just to give a clue in terms of like what do I mean by that, because light body could be taken very kind of like an abstract term. Actually, in yogic terminology, it’s the pranic sheet, it’s the pranic body. The pranic body is extremely important. If any of you have delved into that profound teaching, it’s the pranic body, it’s the one that connects the Manomaya Kosha with Annamaya Kosha, which means the body of mind and the body made of cells. This is what makes a pranamaya kosha extremely important, because it is where all this, so to speak, pathways, pathways. This is how this whole soup, that’s how this whole jelly of human being is being held together. It’s all empowered by the same source, by the same power. However, it has a place where consciousness has to reside. Prior to awakening, it resides in the physical body with complete and total identity, with being this physical organism, story only comes later. The reason why we identify with the story, because the story lives in our body. And this is why I’m always pointing towards these new discoveries. To me, it feels that the discoveries in the field of neuroscience and neurophysiology are doing what quantum physics did in the last century, in the 20th century. The whole spirituality is about to undergo profound renaissance and revolution of understanding. Very, very– even, I remember, Dalai Lama said that if science today will discover that Buddhism is wrong, we’ll have to adjust our teaching to fit the requirements of modern times. And I feel this is a profound statement of somebody who is meeting a very ancient old tradition. It shows that it’s a refusal to calcify, to calcify to something which has been known for centuries, perhaps millennia. So I feel in this particular panel, if this is my part, and this is my voice, I would like to place an emphasis on that recognition and realization. Why spiritual practice is important at all is because we’re literally rebuilding that body which has shrunk, historically shrunk. Consciousness has to reside somewhere. It has to live somewhere. It cannot re-enter the old, so to speak, vehicle. It cannot re-enter the old vessel.
Rick Archer: Pouring new wine into old wineskins.
Igor Kufayev: Thank you. So this is, perhaps, my addition to that light body, variously known in many, many different traditions, like in Kabbalah, explicitly known as Merkabah. In yogic tradition, it is literally known as that very much, the increase of prana. If you really go down, if you boil down the yogic teaching, it all boils down to prana. It all boils down to that very rebuilding of pranic sheath. And that’s what yogis, real yogis, do. That’s what they do. The way they eat, the way they think, the way they do, their practices, they’re building their pranic sheath so that they can reside there as consciousness. When the grace of Shiva will then grant that complete state of unity, Shiva can reside somewhere. It cannot reside in the cells of the human body if it’s not prepared, because human body is not perfect as it is, as we know it today.
Rick Archer: I interviewed David Godman a couple of weeks ago, who wrote all those books about Ramana Maharshi and Papaji and everything. And I asked him why Ramana Maharshi spent so many years, almost a couple of decades, in samadhi, in caves, after his initial awakening as a young man. And David’s explanation was not that he would know for sure, because there was a physiological restructuring that needed to take place. I don’t know if Ramana said that and David was quoting him, or if that was just David’s understanding. But he was saying that even on a cellular level, every cell would have had to be restructured or rebuilt to accommodate the radical awakening that he had undergone. So that’s the principle. Just using it, because everyone holds him as the gold standard of enlightened people. And also, he had to go through it in order to support and maintain his awakening in an abiding way.
Igor Kufayev: And since you mentioned Ramana, just because today we will not have the time to go through all this, and I’m sure tonight might be the night, because we cannot replicate it. We’ll speak tomorrow, probably using different–
Jac O’Keeffe: For sure, we’ll be talking about something else.
Igor Kufayev: So it seems to me, since Rick has mentioned Ramana’s awakening, those of us who understand, again, the way the physiology works– for instance, it takes 24 years for endocrine system fully mature. It is very well known, even within the Indian tradition, when awakenings happen at very early stage, it’s not really desirable. But it does happen to exceptional beings. If it happens to someone in our day and age, it’s not desirable, because the human being has not yet fully developed, as it were. The endocrine system is that which issues crucial hormones. It is responsible for a complete, complete even realization of who you are on the level of your individuality. Individuality cannot be slaughtered unless individuality reached its full blossom. This is one of the things also very important to understand. There’s many teachings, almost like teachers ask an aspirant to jump off the cliff, that he or she will land in Brahman. That’s not always the case. You can actually float in a black void for a few incarnations, if that whole understanding of who you are on the level of your Atman, on the level of who you are on the level of your soul. This is why more integral teachings are required today, because there are. There are. It’s a chain reaction. There is a lot of awakening happening. Awakening in terms of the transmission of grace, and awakenings that, like Jac just said, people pop out of the blue. So this is something that people forget, that Ramana had to pay a heavy price with his body because of his early awakening. It is always swept under the carpet, because Ramana is presented as this very, very iconography of non-duality. It’s like a new icon, an apostle. But we need to face all the ramifications of what enlightenment is. Even on a practical level, because as Maharishi Mahesh Yogi said, this teaching has to be readjusted to each and every generation. It cannot be otherwise. We cannot apply what was relevant 1,000 years ago, even 100, even 50 years ago, to a rapidly evolving world, because that is in the nature of consciousness itself.
Rick Archer: I just wanted to quickly interject, and then these two will talk more, but this may seem prudish, or antiquated, or controversial. But this thing he mentioned about the endocrine system developing up until the age of 24, that’s why in the Indian tradition, celibacy was advocated until the age of 24, five or so. One would maintain celibacy and then get married if they wished to do so at that age, because it allowed the system, the endocrine system, to develop and reach its full strength and potency before entering into a more worldly life.
Francis Bennett: As I understand it, again, can you say the title of our forum?
Igor Kufayev: Human Body Divine Presence.
Francis Bennett: Human Body Divine Presence. And for me, this speaks to something that I find very interesting, and what Igor just said about each generation has to figure out a new way to embody this wisdom, to embody this realization. And I think not only each generation, but each culture embodies it differently. And I think a lot in this sort of non-dual spiritual scene, there’s a real tendency to dismiss our own traditions, our Western traditions, and say the Western traditions are all wet. Christianity, Judaism, all wet. There’s no awakened people in that. They’re just theologically and dogmatically bound, and so on and so forth. And there’s some truth to that. I mean, there’s certainly a dark underbelly to Western spirituality. But I’ve got news for you. There’s a dark underbelly to any spirituality. Hindu spirituality, Buddhist spirituality, contrary to popular Western culture, especially the New Age kind of non-dual scene, is not perfect. There are weak points in it. There are strong points in it. In Western spirituality, there are weak points. There are strong points. And there are individuals in any tradition that somehow penetrate into the depths of this reality that we’re all trying to point to, that conferences like this, that spiritual teachers are all trying to kind of point us toward, hopefully also living that, embodying that, and that points in its own way. And I really feel that in the West especially, in the East, the cosmology, the ontology, those are kind of big flung words, but the cosmology, meaning the understanding of the phenomenal universe, the cosmos, the understanding of the very nature of being itself, of what it means to be a human being in this world, are different in the West than they are in the East. And as they both have their strong and weak points, I think they both have something very interesting and very valuable to bring to the table. And they both have things that would probably be better left on the ground and not brought to the table. And I really think that this idea– and I’ll just say it, and it might be a kind of non-dual heresy, but I’ve already been accused of being a heretic in the Western Christian tradition, so I might as well go for it and be declared a heretic in every tradition. And then I’ll really feel like I’ve accomplished something. So here we go. I think this kind of thing that you hear a lot in this scene, that the body is utterly unreal, that it has absolutely no value, that the world is completely unreal, has absolutely no value, is not viable for Western people.
Igor Kufayev: Or Eastern.
Francis Bennett: And I’m not even sure it’s viable for Eastern. And if you look at Eastern culture, a lot of those ideas is what created things like a caste system, what created people being in poverty and staying in poverty because they felt it was their karma, their destiny. And also, the world’s just illusion anyway, so who gives a damn? Kind of like, OK, it’s all illusion anyway, so I just kind of accept this is my illusion. Your illusion is to be rich, so wonderful. I think that we have to really look at who we are as human beings and what resonates with us, and the archetypes also that resonate with us. We weren’t raised– none of us, or maybe some of us, maybe somebody here, it’s dark, I can’t really see too well. But most of us, I presume, are Western people, people from Europe or the US. We have our own culture, we have our own archetypes, and we have our own people who have realized this reality. And maybe it wouldn’t be a bad idea for us to look at a few of them and see them as models. They were raised in at least a somewhat similar culture, maybe a different time, but a lot of the same sort of philosophical, cosmological, ontological understandings that we were. So rather than look to a complete other culture, we can learn from that, we can grow from that, we can have very valuable interactions with that. And I’m not saying drop it, but I’m saying let’s integrate both things. And I think our understanding of things like the body– and I think it’s important to say also, you cannot separate the body and mind. The body and the mind are really, really integrated. The body affects the mind, and the mind affects the body. And even modern science, modern medical science, will tell you that there’s a definite body-mind connection, isn’t there? And I think that when we look at this notion, and hopefully the reality, of enlightenment or awakening or breakthrough spiritual clarity or whatever, we would have to say that there must be some effect on a human body that embodies that. And whether we like it or not, as human beings, there’s bodies here. They may be temporary, they may be on an absolute level, even illusory, but right now, there’s a bunch of bodies sitting around here, breathing and looking and hearing and seeing and tasting and touching. And to just say it’s all just a bunch of bull, and it’s all illusion, I don’t know about you, but that’s not very satisfying to me. I feel like, well, if it’s just all illusion, then why is it appearing, if there’s not something to it? And I think that the subject that we’re kind of touching on is what is the effect on the body of the embodiment of this wisdom, of this knowledge? And as Igor and Jac were pointing out, there definitely are. You were talking about people getting a sudden jolt, and it kind of affecting them in a dramatic way. And Igor was talking about also running across people like that. And I think that there’s a whole set of conditioning that happens that’s interconnected between body and mind. And I think in times past, both in Eastern culture and in Western culture, there was a tendency for people to put themselves under a spiritual discipline, a spiritual teacher, and do a lot of preliminary practices that involved ethical, meditational, and then kind of wisdom strands. In other words, there was like an ethical training where you tried to kind of live a moral life, live a life of non-harming in one way or another. There was a meditational training, and there was often a communal training of living with others in a spiritual community. And a lot of purification and groundwork was laid there. A lot of purification of the body-mind kind of organism, you could say, happened in that. And it actually created, you could say, a vehicle, a container to contain this clarity, this wisdom, this consciousness, the full kind of expression of this consciousness. And I think that’s a kind of important point. And now we’ve got people who just sort of happen upon this with laying no groundwork. So it’s kind of like trying to build a house with no foundation. To go back and build a foundation after the house structure is up is a little challenging. So I think maybe we could learn something. My sense is like coming from the monastic tradition I did, there was a definite emphasis on doing your basic homework. It’s like when you learn a language. What do you do when you learn Spanish? You take Spanish 1, and hola, hola, me llamo Francis. Whatever. I don’t remember much Spanish. I should have done it in French. But anyway, so you got that. Spanish 1, you learn some grammar. You get some things under your belt. Then you go to Spanish 2. And then you get a little more fluent. You do more dialogues. Then you go to Spanish 3. So I think we might look at that paradigm of creating a foundation, and especially those of us who teach. I know in my own teaching and working with people, I often say it’s good to have a kind of moral foundation. Ethical, I know that’s a bad word in these circles. But you know what? It matters how we treat others, how we treat ourselves. It purifies this body-mind. And if we don’t do it before an awakening, we might have an awakening, and I see this a lot. People get an absolute view, and then they get stuck there. And they dismiss the phenomenal world. They dismiss the body. And I’m not saying that all that stuff is true on an absolute level, but I’m saying that if there’s an integration of wisdom and awakening, then we come to understand that all that stuff that’s phenomenal and relative and illusory on one level and temporary is also, in a certain sense, included in that. Because that absolute level is so huge and vast, it excludes nothing. It contains everything. I’m going on too long. But I think I’ve made a few points, and I’m just going to leave it there, and then we’ll continue the discussion.
Rick Archer: When you woke up, you were very supported in your situation. So did you feel anything physically? Did you have any–
Francis Bennett: Yes.
Rick Archer: Do you want to share? Was it intense? How did you support yourself?
Francis Bennett: I was in a monastery, so I was supported. And I spent six months basically sitting in my room, blissed out, and really had a lot of adjustment in the body. But like you say, I was in a supportive environment. Also, I had done a lot of practice before that that involved a lot of purification of body-mind. So that then the body-mind is a kind of more– what’s the word?
Rick Archer: What did it feel like? Were you spaced out?
Francis Bennett: I wouldn’t say I was spaced out, but I was very– see, like I said today in the talk, there’s a kind of tendency among human beings that are in a state of ignorance, which all of us more or less are at some point early on, that we’re completely focused on the relative. We’re completely focused on the phenomenal world, on this body-mind, and this story of who we are, this character, as Jac said. We’re really convinced that that’s absolutely real. And that’s all there is. And for most people walking around the planet, in case you hadn’t noticed, that’s where they’re at. This is all there is. All that matters is getting a good job, having a good spouse, raising children, having your career, living a life, doing all these physical kind of phenomenal things. And there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s kind of the way it goes for most people for a while. Then sometimes, some people, if they’re really lucky and have the grace, realize this level of pure consciousness, of absolute awareness. And they say, oh, I made a mistake. I wasn’t– I’m not this body-mind. And this whole phenomenal world isn’t really ultimately real. What’s real is this absolute consciousness, this awareness. And then for some, there can be a tendency to say, that’s real, this is unreal. And now I’m really non-dual, because I believe that’s real, and this is unreal. And what’s that sound like? Real, unreal. One, two. Dual, right? It’s dual on a more spiritual level, but it’s still duality, isn’t it? It’s dividing up. Real, unreal. Absolute, relative. And I think what happens is that pendulum swings from thinking relative is it, that’s the name of the game, to thinking absolute is it, that’s the name of the game, to realizing that the absolute is appearing and disappearing in all these billions of forms. And so the relative and the absolute are not two. They’re two sides of one coin of reality. One’s temporary, illusory in a certain way. One’s permanent, eternal. But you can’t separate them, just like you can’t separate two sides of a coin. And now I’m going to shut up, because I’ve just gone way too long, and there’s other people here. So–
Non-speech: [INTERPOSING VOICES]
Jac O’Keeffe: What’s a good idea is to develop a habit of maintaining a clear mind and maintaining a clear body, in whatever way that makes sense to you, whatever maintains well-being in the body, and a clear– an ability to be honest with yourself, to see what’s going on. Because post-awakening, that motivation that you have when you’re on a spiritual path, that motivation is gone. It’s gone. So if things are built in as a habit, do you know what? The habits remain.
Francis Bennett: That’s exactly what I’m getting at, too.
Jac O’Keeffe: The habits stay, whether the habit is going to bed early or feeling sick if you have more than two beers. The habits stay. The sensitivities grow, because the body is finer. But the past is still there. Yeah, yeah. So if you can develop a pattern of something on the spiritual path, that’s great. Now for the Jac character, there was years of meditation, and it stopped totally, totally. There was no meditation at all. It doesn’t happen at all. Chanting happened for a bit, and then that died as well. And I haven’t done it in months, months, the last retreat, probably. So even some habits will die off. But starting new habits, I don’t know how to do that. Because post-awakening, it’s just responsive. Because you don’t have the idea that you can improve something, or you don’t have any of those ideas running. So just responding to what is, to what is present, to what is presented, that becomes your MO. So if you don’t have a habit of being really self-honest about not hiding from your stuff, or kidding yourself about, yeah, I know I shouldn’t smoke, but something tiny, like smoking. I know I shouldn’t do that, because it’s not good for me. It’s like, just get over that. Get over that. Support your beautiful body. Support a clean, healthy mind. If you can get that into your system, pre-awakening, man, I’ll tell you, it makes the integration faster, smoother. It definitely will help as life goes on. Definitely helps.
Rick Archer: That’s really a good point.
Jac O’Keeffe: It just makes it much quicker.
Rick Archer: Well, the way I’ve heard it, there’s a couple of different models of how this energetic stuff operates. One is up through the chakras, up to the crown chakra. And then there’s another model, which is sort of down from the, you might say, initial illumination, down into the body, to the heart center, and then to the heart center. And I wondered if– and there may be some other models that I don’t even know about.
Igor Kufayev: Well, these are not models.
Rick Archer: Yeah, you’re the chakra expert.
Francis Bennett: Yes, he is.
Igor Kufayev: Well, funny enough, I kind of give it a spin. Because I did say on several occasions already that I do not actually support, from direct, first-hand experience, the diagrams that you buy in most New Age books. It actually doesn’t work like that. I feel very often when conversation goes around this whole subject, it is much more complex and less linear. Awakening is never linear. All these books will tell you, it awakens down there and just goes up under a nice, nice kind of like a Devaprimal music. Until it reaches Sahasrara, and then this like a kind of flower starts to fall on the– like the heavenly flowers, you know, heavenly kind of– OK. Like in Indian marriages, they throw the petals of roses.
Rick Archer: What does Gopi Krishna–
Igor Kufayev: Yeah, it doesn’t work like that. And it doesn’t work like that working with people. What amazes me is that there are patterns, distinctive patterns, right, which allowed certain traditions. In my knowledge, that most explicit tradition, a tantric tradition, which actually Tantra is all about the body. Because what Tantra did, as opposed to classical Advaita Vedanta, Advaita negated, spat out the universe. Tantra instead, taking that which is supposed to be denied with all its limitations, with all its imperfections, and declared that everything you can find in the outer universe, you can find in this body. So let’s enter Brahman, or let’s enter the absolute through this vehicle. So this is a radical approach, radically different approach already. Now, before I reply to that, what you just voiced in terms of the ascent versus descent, which is very interesting, I want to kind of like go back to what Francis was just saying, and Jac poignantly pointed out about the importance of maintaining a practice which prepares this instrumentality for the actual act of awakening. And awakening is the portal, is the beginning. So really preparing something to start the real work. And this is why I wanted to take it where Francis left, and Jac, in terms of another more biological perspective. That is, paradoxically, it is when vital force awakens, because that consciousness is inseparable from vital force. Consciousness, consciousness dwells in this body as the vital force. Various traditions call it under various names. When that awakens to itself, what it does, it actually creates a profound steer in the house. It literally, literally– it’s like imagine the pond, which is clear water and lotuses, and they’re very sweet. Suddenly, a bolt of electricity hit that pond. All the mud is kind of like brought to the surface. The real awakening, the more profound awakening, the more stuff comes to the surface. And this is what all people report. Everyone who has ever undergone the awakening know that the more there was that we haven’t had the chance to deal with, the more it will be brought to our face, to literally to deal with. And another thing, another really, really paradoxical thing about awakening is that in pre-awakening, a lot of things are covered nicely. It’s always like bubbling. I’ve sat in meditation for many years as well, and it’s like all nice and sweet, all nice and sweet. You come out into activity until you expand the time to recharge the batteries. All this is kind of like you glide through a lot of what you do, but when awakening happens, the stuff comes out out of your mouth that you never knew existed. The emotions, the feelings that come out of you, you never knew existed. So this is the importance of actually addressing this. Some teachers call it a shadow, because when light is being introduced, shadows are long. When sun is rising, before the sun reaches its zenith, the shadows are long and dark shadows. This is kind of like another side of awakening which is rarely addressed. Because this is when that what has been sitting there, not showing its ugly face, often gains the momentum, because by very nature of that process. And I will give a little kind of like a footnote. Since the vital force circulates in the body inside the spinal column, and this is where it circulates as cerebrospinal fluid, deep within that spinal column, all the three relative states of consciousness are literally, literally rotating frequencies around the transcendent. The waking, the dreaming, and the deep sleep states of consciousness are all hidden inside that spinal column. Each state of consciousness is associated with a particular, let’s say, body. The waking state of consciousness is associated with physical body. Why? Because this is when the acuity of the senses and the mind are at its peak, at its maximum. The dreaming state of consciousness is associated with the astral body, or the light body that I’ve mentioned earlier. And the deep sleep state of consciousness is associated with the karmic body. This is why we don’t know what is there, because it’s a blank, it’s like a pitch black. Deep sleep, we don’t experience nothing, most of us, until we transcend that state of consciousness. So what happens is that when, in awakening from biological perspectives– I want you to understand, from the biological perspective, and we are biological species– it doesn’t matter how awakening will take place, it will always have to move in the body as cerebrospinal fluid. This, all these bodies are getting reactivated and start to rotate at a much higher frequency. In fact, some scriptures say that consciousness moves inside that spinal column, which is thinner than the spider’s web. Yes. That consciousness moves in the speed of light inside. And often, often, yeah. This is like something very fascinating. This is literally consciousness reverses itself. It’s like the whole process of reverse starts from there. But what interests us here, in this particular discussion that we’re having, is that we often experience more, more, than we were prepared to experience. And dramatic awakenings are full of examples when karma is being speed up. Thoughts, what we ought to experience, will be brought to the surface. So all this, all this, is like an indication that this is why those traditions that really safeguarded this knowledge, and that knowledge was passed uninterruptedly, they knew how important it is to prepare the vehicle, to prepare the body. It is known, for example, that in certain traditions, if the perceptor was detecting that the, let’s say, those who were gathered around are not ready, he will not necessarily do anything to awaken that being, because it’s not the time. Some other work needs to be done. And that other work meant to actually help to develop that personality fully, with the help of what Francis has mentioned, as all this internal and external code of conduct, the selfless service, the essence of karma yoga, yamas and nyamas. This is the code of, let’s say–
Francis Bennett: Like precepts.
Igor Kufayev: –relation, exactly. The foundational, the foundational cornerstones on which one can literally build, because when it starts to shake, so it can withstand. And this is what I want you to also– because it was very important, what Francis has said earlier, in terms of these qualities, when awakening takes place, as Jagdan said, it’s much harder to work on when it’s actually in the progress. Because it’s like everything is speed up. Everything happens in a much faster pace.
Rick Archer: Igor, Kashmir Shaivism, can you discuss that a little bit? Because it relates here.
Igor Kufayev: Sure, of course, yes. Kashmir Shaivism is basically– Rabindranath Tagore, in the beginning of the 20th century, said that Kashmir Shaivism is the encapsulation of everything best what happened in Indian subcontinent for the last several thousand years. And Kashmir Shaivism, it’s the so-called religion of householder. In fact, all Kashmir Shaiva teachers were all family members, it was required to fully, to fully integrate the state of one’s enlightenment was checked, literally was checked, against the rocks of householder’s life. Remember like Maharishi said, that when the question was asked, all these yogis, he said, some of them, when they step down, they’ve realized that their realization was crushed when they were intermingled in life, when they started to kind of– when they tested their state of freedom against the requirements of life. Many of them have came to the realization that actually it was not stabilized. Because they were in a relationship, it’s very sweet to sit alone next to the nice little waterfall, and somebody will bring you food, somebody nice cooked dal, chapati, and rice, because you are Brahman. In India, it’s sacred.
Rick Archer: He also said that sometimes– I don’t know how he would have known this, but that at the time of death, many yogis who thought they were liberated discovered that they–
Igor Kufayev: That’s another, yes, exactly. This is another, because there is– like you can be in that beatific state, but that’s not necessarily a fully integrated state of enlightenment. And Kashmir Shaiva tradition is precisely the tradition which is very important in– it’s not my view. I’m only lauding what much, much greater beings have said before me. It came– it was preserved. It’s like a last best kept secret of India. Literally, it’s the last best kept secret. Because Kashmir Shaivism operates with very different notions. The notion of maya is not viewed as an illusion. There is no such thing in Kashmir Shaivism as an illusion as opposed to, let’s say, that very famous postulate, which is, by the way, for some reason, ascribed to Ramana Maharishi. It was actually uttered by Adi Shankara in the 8th century. The world is unreal. Only Brahman is real. Brahman is the world. But he never elaborated on the relationship between Brahman and the world. The greatest sage who actually gave the notion of Advaita Vedanta– if you go before Adi Shankara, you would not find any such term. He is the one who brought Advaita Vedanta, as we know it today. The classical Indian realization all falls within that category. And I dare to say, most of the teachers of Advaita Vedanta simply regurgitating the same postulates and the same. If you read Viveka Chudamani or Brahma Sutras of Adi Shankara, you will never need to go to any satsangs anymore. Everything is said there with crystal clarity. The whole world, Viveka Chudamani, discerning sword of discrimination. That’s what that means. However, the Kashmir Shaivism completely came with another perspective, that instead of immutable Brahman, the pure awareness, Shiva, manifests itself as Shakti. And Shakti is as real as Shiva, because Shakti is Shiva. It’s just that play of consciousness, where Shiva willingly undergoes that transformation to be in every fiber of existence, in every iota, in every particle, or whatever you call it, quark, or what have you. There’s nothing but Shiva. This is what Kashmir Shaiva teaches, Sutras and Kashmir Shaiva real philosophy teaches, the doctrines. And there are many doctrines. And the one that I particularly resonate is known as the doctrine of Spanda, the doctrine of vibration. The continuous expansion and contraction of consciousness, which can be directly perceived at the heart level, of which many, many mystics and saints of various traditions have spoken, within the Christian tradition, within the Sufi tradition, within the Kabbalah tradition, and within many other traditions. So the Kashmir Shaivism is like that. The platform is the household, the platform, is that you have to be in the grit of life. In the grit of life, it’s a requirement. Like Francis said, being stuck in the absolute, it’s not even on the agenda.
Francis Bennett: You know the famous saying that’s attributed to Ram Dass? He said, if you think you’re so enlightened, go and stay with your parents for a week.
Igor Kufayev: For
Francis Bennett: the weekend.
Igor Kufayev: For the weekend.
Rick Archer: For the weekend. That’s funny.
Unidentified participant 1: Can I get back to the strengthening the light body of your mind?
Igor Kufayev: I just can quickly say that this is known as ascent and descent. This could happen simultaneously, as it happened in my case, and as it happened with some people that I’m in direct contact with, when actually the descent of that energy, known as descent of grace, ignites the awakening at the lower end of the spectrum, which facilitates the consequent ascent. But the actual awakening could happen in any energy center. It could happen at the lower center, like the classically known as muladhara. It could happen in the gut, which actually most often happens in the gut. But then, it is experienced lower down. It could happen in the heart. If one’s heart is pure and open, that’s most likely that’s where the awakening will take place. Awakening could happen on the heart level. And that is one of the most, let’s say, painful awakenings, because one is rendered open, completely wide open. But there is a lot of work that needs to be done. Because the awakening has to incorporate the entire body on a subtle level. The entire body. But these awakenings, when they happen,
Rick Archer: a particular center, is it first off experienced as bliss? Say, a chakra opens up.
Igor Kufayev: Some awakenings– Heart chakra and chakra. Well, awakening at the heart level does not necessarily mean that the heart chakra is going to be fully activated. Because what happens most likely, it awakens. But since the work needs to be done there, that’s where the impulse really goes right away. So very often, those who have experienced the heart awakening, they immediately encounter a lot of physical problems down there. On the gut level, on the lower level, which could relate to the fire center, to the water center, to the earth center. Awakening cannot proceed up, because up until all this territory is being covered, it cannot proceed. It’s like in the same way with the descent. By the way, I’ve heard somewhere that the real ideal awakening, from the point of view of Christian perspective, was considered to be the descent, because it’s less painful. It’s less, let’s say, associated with the physiological drama. That is what Sri Aurobindo spoke a lot about. He was initiating and speaking a lot about that integral process of self-realization, where the grace, literally the grace, the Shiva’s grace, or the grace of pure awareness, is invited, descends down, because it’s less painful. It’s like, literally, if it descends down, it opens the body in a very beatific, in a very gentle way. The lower yogic awakening is often much faster, much more violent, and not necessarily the safest. So this is in terms of, it could coincide, it could be one or the other, it could be both at the same time. One can trigger the other.
Unidentified participant 2: And there’s also the side effect of kriyas, where people are involuntary witnesses, is that part of that process?
Igor Kufayev: Every awakening, every awakening is accompanied by kriyas. Kriyas could be physical, emotional, mental, anything that happens involuntary. You can sit and shake. You can have unexpected emotions that floods you. People who awaken, they cry for no reason, they laugh for no reason, and it’s normal. That’s what kriyas are.
Unidentified participant 2: Francis says his awakening wasn’t accompanied by kriyas.
Igor Kufayev: Well, the kriyas may not be accompanied by the physical kriyas, but there will be emotional kriyas, psychological kriyas, mental kriyas. It just doesn’t– you don’t have to call it.
Francis Bennett: What do you mean when you say kriya? I’m not really up on these terms. I thought it was an involuntary movement or something, that’s what I always thought.
Igor Kufayev: Yes, but it’s not necessarily bound to physical movements. The experience of Christian mystics of sudden flood of love.
Francis Bennett: Oh, sure.
Igor Kufayev: OK. You know, sudden like emotion overtaken.
Rick Archer: I still have that.
Igor Kufayev: Yeah, so you still have kriyas. Mudras, you know, like all these sudden like facial, like sometimes you can sit and smile for no reason. And you’re not funny. It’s just a mudra.
Rick Archer: When I first started having them, it was like I would actually– I was sitting in my friend’s living room, I remember, and nobody was there. And my face felt– it went into like these demonic things and all kinds of strange things. I knew kind of what was going on, so it didn’t freak me out. And I was driving an ice cream truck at the time. Not at that–
Francis Bennett: You scared all the children.
Rick Archer: Not at that moment, but during the day, I was driving an ice cream truck. And my head was kind of going like this all the time. And as long as I was active, it wouldn’t do it. But if I stopped to a stop sign or something, my head would start going.
Francis Bennett: This is very interesting, because when I was 13 years old, I remember– this just came back to my memory. I’d completely forgotten it. But I had this– with the doctor, my mom took me to the doctor. And he said, it’s a nervous tick. And I was going like this all the time with my shoulders. And I couldn’t figure out what that was. But actually, that also did coincide with a time in my life when there was a real kind of a heart sort of awakening of devotion, of a lot of devotion. And now I’m kind of like interested and wondering, was it related to that in some way? Of course, I didn’t even think of any kind of connection there at the time. But that’s interesting.
Unidentified participant 2: Even when the body jerk in space, that’s a kriya.
Igor Kufayev: An involuntary motion. Kriya means movement. Really, the meaning of the word kriya, movement. And it could happen on the most subtle level.
Francis Bennett: So it’s like this spiritual sort of energy displaces things, like you could say.
Igor Kufayev: It’s like in order to pick up this glass, very quick electrical response, right? I’m thirsty. I’m going to quench myself. And this whole process in motion. So that is not involuntary. It’s voluntarily. The signal has been sent to the brain.
Francis Bennett: It kind of kicks in a whole chain reaction.
Igor Kufayev: Exactly, chain reaction. What kriya is, is that it’s completely automatic. It has no purpose other than–
Francis Bennett: The response, kind of.
Igor Kufayev: It allows prana to move in the body in the way it does and in the way it wants to purify that body. All kriyas are purificatory. All of them.
Unidentified participant 2: Sorry to interrupt. Does that include sounds that are projected out?
Rick Archer: It could, sure. It almost sounds like you have Tourette’s or something.
Igor Kufayev: Like, roaring like a lion.
Rick Archer: Yeah.
Igor Kufayev: In all this, like, vocal stuff. Barking could be–
Non-speech: [INTERPOSING VOICES]
Unidentified participant 2: –that comes out of me that sounds like tongues or some kind of clicking–
Igor Kufayev: People speak in tongues, yes.
Francis Bennett: Oh, is that a kriya? Speaking in tongues?
Igor Kufayev: Yes.
Francis Bennett: I did that? Yes.
Rick Archer: There you go.
Francis Bennett: There I go. I have a kriya.
Igor Kufayev: Sorry I did interrupt you earlier, but I–
Rick Archer: Japanese or something.
Unidentified participant 2: That’s OK. It would be really helpful if we could go back to the basics when you said strengthening the light body, because we just kind of breezed over the whole principle of the topic. And basically, the reason why I’m asking is because I found that you can go through the chakra system. You can go and do yoga, pranayama, kundalini techniques, alimudras, and whatnot. But there’s a blurry line between what’s sufficient to strengthen pranamaya kosha and what’s actually forcefully raising kundalini. And what I found is that through psychological transformation alone, kundalini is rising when it’s meant to rise. And to push is not so harmonious compared to just the purification process alone. Also, I understand that pranayama and yoga is meant to prepare the body for meditation. But once you’ve actually done so for a number of years and you feel comfortable with meditating, is not spanda itself, is not that sacred tremor or the prana that’s coming through meditation, the grace alone, anyway, continuing to purify the structure. And so the reason why I’m asking is because I would love to know a more clear line between what’s purifying the light body and then what’s unnecessary. Because we live in a society of time now. Time is precious. I don’t want to waste time doing pranayama when I could be meditating.
Igor Kufayev: Yes. It’s a very good question. I personally belong and believe in spontaneous path when it comes to the spiritual practice and reaping the fruits and the benefits. In a sense, so that not to contradict what has been said earlier, I personally believe that meditation, when it’s done properly, it should happen spontaneously. But before it does, an amount of discipline is required. Frequency is required. And a time spent in meditation is required. Because what happens is that I’ve been in many yogic ashrams in my early years, especially in my early 30s. And I was already a proficient yoga instructor. I could have taught yoga in the ’90s when yoga was sweeping across the United Kingdom. In America, there was already 12 million yogi, so to speak, practicing. But even though at that age, I felt this is not real yoga. This is not the real essence of yoga. And a lot of these pranayama practices, and I actually witnessed, there were some undesirable effects, to put it mildly, because pranayama is one of the most direct ways of manipulating consciousness on this level of physiology. Why? Because pranamaya kosha literally that which connects and acts as an intermediary between all other koshas, but specifically between the manomaya, that of the body of the mind, and that of the anomaya, the body made of cells.
Rick Archer: Koshas mean sheaths, by the way, if you don’t know.
Igor Kufayev: Like in a Russian doll.
Rick Archer: Yeah, one within the other. There are said to be a number of them.
Igor Kufayev: So that when pranayama is done voluntarily, forcibly, it literally will move the prana where it’s not ready to go. The body itself is not ready to go. The mind is not ready to go there. But prana forces it.
Rick Archer: Which isn’t to say that a little gentle pranayama for a few minutes wouldn’t be fine. But if you’re going to sit down and do some intense thing for a couple of hours, you can really get in trouble. And that’s never advocated, except under the guidance of somebody who really knows what they’re doing.
Igor Kufayev: But most of the, like, let’s say this Kundalini yoga, that’s what they do. They do real kapalabhati, which is a shining skull. Kapalabhati is a shining skull. It’s a very dangerous pranayama. You work with diaphragm. And ulama viloma is harmless. It’s just like literally balancing breath, right? But all these forms of kapalabhati, and there are many of them. They’re different. There’s bhastrika. All this really ideally should happen by itself. And it does when awakening takes place.
Rick Archer: How many have experienced that, that spontaneously some kind of pranayama thing starts happening, some fast breathing?
Unidentified participant 2: Not a smooth breath, but a jerking breath. Where did that come from?
Rick Archer: Or you can even find yourself sitting there going–
Unidentified participant 2: No, no. All of a sudden– Automatically.
Igor Kufayev: That is involuntary pranayama.
Unidentified participant 2: So that’s what’s happening. OK, I just go with it.
Igor Kufayev: And the best–
Unidentified participant 2: For about a year or so.
Igor Kufayev: And relaxing into it is very important. Sometimes–
Unidentified participant 2: It’s very– Sometimes I don’t even notice it.
Igor Kufayev: I just want to one footnote, very important footnote, because these questions kept coming back to me over years. There’s one pranayama that freaks people out, basically, when the breath is being arrested. When you’re suddenly in that state, you no longer breathe. But not when the breath subsides. It’s a big difference. When breath subsides gently and comes to the point of suspension, it’s a very different ballgame. That is the most desirable, in a sense, because that is a very subtle breathing still goes on. And you know that because your tummy gently moves up and down ever so gently. But you don’t feel the areas. You don’t even hear. If you sit in a very quiet room, you wouldn’t be able to hear your own breathing. This is a supreme pranayama. The most desirable. This is a supreme. It’s the king of all pranayamas. Literally, in that state, left and right hemispheres of the brain, sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems, come and unity is given. Direct unity. Samadhi is easy. But there is another one which is experienced literally on the inhalation or exhalation, when suddenly you’re gasping and you feel as if you cannot breathe. And it’s involuntary. It’s not you doing that. And I know people who freaked out and even been taken forcibly out. Like one husband took his wife. When she was there, she was gasping. And he start beating her. They were both meditating on the cheeks to wake her up. But that is a kumbhaka. This is known as– kumbhaka is a pot. Kumbhaka is that very, very specific yogic practice which actually should not be done again, unless it’s been supervised by an adept. But when it happens spontaneously, I often advise people and often say, this is a very important point in your spiritual practice. Because if you have overcome the fear, after a certain time, you can remain completely in that state. And you will experience your first proper nirvikalpa samadhi even if for, let’s say, one or two minutes only. Because most meditators experience samadhi with the kalpa, samadhi with some kind of awareness. But the nirvikalpa samadhi of which John Hagelin spoke today eloquently in his presentation, the nirvikalpa samadhi is that samadhi which is uninterrupted state. This is a ground of consciousness. This is where we experience ourselves of who we are. And I just wanted to make it as a footnote. So if that happens to any of you on inhalation or inhalation, and suddenly, as a meditator, you suddenly feel you’re gasping for air, but it doesn’t breathe, it’s not to be afraid. The more you relax to it, the more you realize, actually, you don’t need to breathe. And this is what happens is that there’s a very profound process. The breathing is required for giving oxygen to the brain, for the healthy functioning of the brain. But what happens in these spontaneous kumbhakas is that the electrical impulse in the brain happens due to the complete fusion. So it doesn’t need to be fed with oxygen. And yogis realize that. They discover that through the direct practice. And so they desire. For yogis, it’s like Christmas or whatever. Kumbhaka happened on its own. It means the fruit of yoga is already knocking on the door. So that’s the footnote in terms of this, because you asked about pranayama. And I advocate the spontaneous pranayamas more than induced ones. So I would increase time in meditation, because it’s bound to come. And people, in meditation, sometimes, like Rick mentioned earlier, and the gentleman over there, you start to breathe. Just allow that. Allow. I breathed for two years. There was no meditation. I just breathed for two years. Nothing. I would sit down with people at the dinner party, and closing my eyes to say grace. And I start breathing. And everyone thinks, what’s wrong with this guy? Because that builds the pranic sheath, by the way. Prepares the body, the light body.
Unidentified participant 3: So you say you would just meditate and allow pranayama to come spontaneously. What other sort of preliminary practices would you recommend to strengthen the light body? Obviously, diet, general exercise. But do you recommend chakra-based yoga?
Igor Kufayev: I would say that not to say that easy. Like, obviously, diet. Because when I say, obviously, diet, we often like– diet is crucial. It’s crucial in today we live. 70% of our prana today derives from our food, because it’s the day and age we live in. Very little prana comes from breathing. And a minute amount of prana comes directly through the fountain of the head. So most of our prana comes from food. That’s why we’re bound to eat so much. Our age now, the reason why we eat so much is precisely because of that. You see?
Unidentified participant 3: We’re not getting enough prana.
Igor Kufayev: Exactly. We have to replenish that prana constantly.
Rick Archer: Francis was suggesting that maybe the whole idea of light body or subtle body might not be understood. Probably Igor can explain it better. But let me just take a quick crack and then give it to you. And that is that there’s so many strata of creation. There’s the gross, and then subtler and subtler and subtler levels of creation, just as, again, Hegel was explaining in terms of his physics thing. But we have a body, which is not flesh and blood, which is made of subtle matter, subtle body. I believe that’s what you mean when you say light body.
Igor Kufayev: I’m talking about the specific second layer called prana maya kosha, composed specifically of the prana, of the light, out of the five main bodies.
Rick Archer: OK, well, you understand better than I do.
Igor Kufayev: Yes, the lady has very clear understanding. And I’m sure if someone is lost, you have to ask the questions to them. So these terms are put in the context of your tradition or your understanding, because this is very important to understand. It’s not that light body is some kind of imaginative thing that one person have it and another no. It’s just like we have skeleton, where all the muscles are being assembled. And then we have, just like this physical body has seven tissues. In Ayurveda, they’re distinctively– each one is given a name. Each tissue is given a name– the plasma, the blood, the fat, the muscle, the bone, the marrow, and that which is inside the bone marrow, the immunological substance, which is manifest in male as his mite, in a female as a reproductive fluid. Just as this physical body is made of different tissues, in the same way, the light body is made out of light and sound, as simple as that. It’s a light sound structure. That light sound structure has energetic vortexes, which are actually situated in exact proximity to most important glands in the body. And this is where the connection between the light body and the physical body is being made. And the importance of that in awakening– and what is awakening, what Rick said earlier, in terms of the even on a cellular level, there have to be changes. And it’s precisely what happens is that in awakening, the physiology, the endocrine system, undergoes a tremendous transformation. Because all this physiology undergoes through a tremendous transformation, precisely because light body starts to vibrate with much higher frequency. And because it vibrates with much higher frequency, it allows much more light to absorb, much more light of pure consciousness, pure awareness. That in itself facilitates the rekindling of important glands in the body. Those glands that perhaps prior to that were dormant, or went dormant, calcified. Thyroid gland, for instance. It’s the gland which facilitates the growth. And it takes over at the age of puberty. And because of that development, it is often, in 99% of all the cases, at the expense of the calcification of pineal and pituitary gland. So another dimension of tantric practices, in that case, every spiritual practice, is rekindling of these crucial glands. So that they can issue the qualitatively new hormones back into the body. When I did my first interview with Conscious TV, Renata MacNeil took only one line from whatever she found, it’s something I said on some occasion. And she really, really resonated with that. And she brought it to our interview. And that quote she brought, I don’t know where she found it, but it was basically, “Enlightened one is not so and so, it’s the one whose nervous system is no longer swept by the chemical storms inside the body.” Do you understand the significance of that? Because really, our psychological, emotional reactions are issued and really supported by that gut and brain spontaneous reaction. And up until that undergoes a qualitative change, nothing has changed in us. It doesn’t matter how powerful was awakening.
Unidentified participant 4: Can I speak from another perspective?
Igor Kufayev: Sure.
Unidentified participant 4: To me, it seems like this one human drama, which is not wanting the experience we have. That’s it. Not wanting the experience we’re having. Resistance to the field of information we find ourselves in. But not even the field of information, our perception of the field. There’s awareness, and then there’s this field of information, and then there’s the habits of attention. And with the habit of attention, the habit of attention produces both the sense that we have of ourselves and the sense of the universe. So the habit of attention that we have, if you
Rick Archer: look where it comes from, it’s inherited, you could say, from conditioning from your culture, from what happened to the body in your mom’s womb in the early years, way before there was discrimination. And so there’s a habit of attention that is getting feedback for itself. Because when it’s dualistic, it treats people as objects. So that often gets the feedback of being treated as an object itself. We experience a lot of different difficulties just living. And then we try and deal with the difficulties at the level of the difficulty. But actually, the difficulty is coming from a habit of attention, which is usually unconscious. There’s no bad intention. It’s just a habit that focuses in a way that invites a certain feedback and creates a loop. You could say, oh, pain ping pong, you know, because it goes backwards and forwards.
Francis Bennett: Pain ping pong?
Rick Archer: Pain ping pong, yeah. Because ultimately, if you look, all we have to give ourselves and the world and each other is our attention. That’s the currency, yeah? And the way of mom, or the quality of attention that happens in any group determines actually we’re relational. We live in the field of each other’s attention, how people see us, that affects all of us. When I went to see Papaji in India, he would always joke about meditation because he’s saying, you know, if you’re going to meditate for even 18 hours, you’ve already tied your mind outside of meditation. So he would say, what use is that? Once someone came to Ramana Maharishi, he said, look, there’s a guy who’s meditating 18 hours a day. And Ramana’s reply was, what good does it do him if he thinks he’s meditating? What they were pointing at was that there is this innate quality of awareness that makes distinction. But in all of us, the moment our attention gets gripped by some agitation in our system, our attention focuses in a way where it kind of loops on itself. It gets stuck. So how do we free that up? Yeah, it’s like just to recognize that actually all that’s going on, when you notice that your thoughts are spinning or that there’s emotions, those are all movements, automatic unconscious movements. That to get away from a certain sensation. So it’s a knee jerk. It’s an automatic. Nobody does it. But in that movement, the sense of me is born. It shows up as a sense of me. And then the sense of me thinks it can do something about things. But actually it can’t, because it’s just a feeling. It’s not an entity. There’s this capacity to notice these subtle movements. Yeah, that’s inherent. It’s just part of awareness. As this interest develops to be here, just this noticing in ourselves, in you could say, wherever the system starts to be anything less than enjoying the moment, that’s where there’s you could say, there’s information that’s not integrated.
Igor Kufayev: Does that resonate with you?
Francis Bennett: You know, I would say also what you said about this dynamic of pushing away or resistance. And it works equally, almost the exact same way, with the dynamic of wanting to grasp on and hold on. It’s actually the same movement. It’s not wanting what we have.
Igor Kufayev: Exactly.
Francis Bennett: It’s wanting somehow for it all to be different in some way according to our standards. But it works the same exact way, I think.
Rick Archer: Well, because one of the things is that there’s a certain habit of attention that’s dualistic, that produces a feeling sense of separation. And yet there’s a deep yearning to feel connected. But when we’ve tried to get connected from a feeling of separation, it’s clumsy. It’s always going to be a reach that has–
Francis Bennett: Quite get the care of it.
Rick Archer: Yeah, it’s trying to get what’s already there, and also at the same time is afraid that it’s not going to be received properly. It’s trying to reach and it’s trying to defend at the same time. So the signals are very mixed.
Igor Kufayev: No, it’s a good perspective. I just want to, let’s say, for instance, the remark of Papa G, and even if that was a remark of Ramana Maharshi, I don’t necessarily agree. Because I can turn and say that actually the quality of attention rests primarily on the state of consciousness. It cannot be otherwise. Because it is the consciousness that pulls the cart, not the cart that pulls the horses. So that the quality of our attention rests on the quality of our awareness in the first place. Attention, attention. In fact, from the perspective that I often prefer to speak, attention, what is attention? It’s a quality of prana. It’s the same vital force. When I’m looking at you now, my vital force goes to you. When I was looking in front of me at Tanya, then my vital force was going there. Likewise, whatever in the gamut of experiences, wherever our attention goes, prana goes there. But prana is that vehicle, is that connection. It is the active force of consciousness itself. But it rests in the quality of that attention.
Rick Archer: Absolutely.
Igor Kufayev: Based– Yes.
Francis Bennett: Absolutely, yeah.
Igor Kufayev: So this is why I’m not necessarily agree with– because I know where Papaji was coming from. Because people tend to get stuck in whatever they do in their practices. So sometimes you need to shake the status quo. Because I’m sure the next guy, Papaji or Ramana, would say, actually, if you’re walking around and trying to work it in your head, maybe you should just sit down and just quieten your mind. And meditation is the best way of doing that. If you examine what Ramana’s invitation was, no matter what happens,
Rick Archer: you ask who’s aware of it, and the answer must be I am, and then the question, who am I? So all that it is, is it’s working with attention and returning attention to its source.
Igor Kufayev: It’s the atma vichara, yes. But there’s, for instance, because you joined us, I’m not sure if you’ve seen the nature of this panel. It’s the human body, divine presence. So it’s like a specific perspective, let’s say, where the negation of the human body, which is very, very obvious in the non-dualist circles today, is at the price of throwing water, a baby with water. And I would say that, because we did actually mention Ramana Maharishi earlier, Rick, and then I made that remark, that even Ramana’s awakening itself, his life force was first awakened, not the other way around. And when people often ask, what is primarily? And you cannot avoid, avoid to run this process through this very physiology, because it has to come back. And the fruit of realization would have to be lived through this body until this body will free the elements back to
Unidentified participant 4: its– In what I was talking about, how if we look really simply, I think all of us can see that what we call the world, what we call everything, time, space, energy, is all simply experience or sensations, to be more precise, or even deeper than that, information. And what we call the body, how do we know we have a body? We experience it. So it’s all an experience. The whole movie, everything, including the body, is an experience. Now, you could say, once you recognize that this whole thing is an experience, ultimately just sensations, then what opens up is the capacity to rest and to notice the sensations and the movements, how the system relates to the sensations. Because the moment there’s a knee jerk to get away from sensations, I mean, that’s what we call a personality. The personality is an organization of resistance to the sensations of now. It’s like there’s all these different movements to just get away from just here. In terms of what’s not common is to explore enjoying the experience of now. Most of all, we’re enduring the experience of now. We’re putting up with it. It’s like there’s a, oh, life is a drag, and then you’re dead, you know? That’s the kind of–
Rick Archer: Life sucks, then you die.
Unidentified participant 4: Life sucks, and then you die. So there’s a subtle resistance going on almost all the time. And if that’s not noticed, it just keeps going. It just keeps running.
Francis Bennett: Sure.
Unidentified participant 4: Yeah, so in the moment, we can just look here. Wherever there’s any kind of like enduring rather than enjoying, because this is the only moment we have. And you could call it this is the beloved, which isn’t–
Igor Kufayev: But even the realized one on the level of Ramana Maharshi would jerk off from the danger. And scriptures say that even in the enlightened, the impulse to preserve one’s organism isn’t involved. So this is very important, because it’s an answer to you in terms of– you see, because what we’re tackling here is that, let’s say, erroneous understanding that somehow physiology is not important.
Unidentified participant 4: This has a mandate to live as long as it can, and it will. It’ll do that automatically. There has to be the distinction when there’s real danger and when it’s just like a sense of existential danger.
Igor Kufayev: Right.
Unidentified participant 4: Yeah, so that distinction needs to be there. So you can’t stand in front of a car coming at you and say it’s an illusion. That’s a joke.
Igor Kufayev: Sure, but we’re not even talking about that.
Unidentified participant 4: But the thing you said about sensations, I think, is
Rick Archer: significant to our whole topic of consciousness and physiology, because almost always, if not always, as the physiology refines through spiritual practice, there are physiological sensations, or sensations associated with that refinement that one notices. Every time some vasana gets released, you might notice something in the heart or head or someplace. And so we get kind of sensitized to or acutely aware of that stuff. And then, if we’re not oblivious to it, we can facilitate its unwinding. Is that what you’re saying?
Unidentified participant 4: For sure. And what’s interesting to notice is that I would say the difference between hard noticing and gentle noticing. It’s like hard noticing always has this agenda of getting rid of or changing or fixing or forcing. And gentle noticing is an inquiry. Just, oh, wow. There’s this movement. Honoring it, you could say, OK, wow. And what’s its function? What’s going on with it? So there’s just an exploration of what. Is it actually necessary in this moment? Because a lot of these movements are conditioned. Somehow the system is responding on old information. Like when we meet here, and I recognize everyone here has an experience happening in me. And I’m not trying to– you were speaking about this direction of prana. It’s possible that we can all be aware of each other right now. Without that, we focus just one place. We can all be–
Rick Archer: We are. We are aware.
Unidentified participant 5: We’re on top of it. Actually, can I just say something? Because the thing is, I think we are all so aware of the non-dual perspective. And that’s why I think we’re all here. I think, actually, I’m really grateful to this topic. Because it’s so rare, I think, that the body is actually given some sort of importance in this non-dual perspective.
Francis Bennett: Besides just being unreal.
Unidentified participant 5: Yes. And I’m so grateful to this, actually, to actually give attention to the body and focus on how we can support and prepare the body.
Igor Kufayev: I would just want to say something else. Because I mentioned earlier the seven tissues of the body. Even physiological body is still way misunderstood in our present culture. Way misunderstood. Ayurveda barely made its steps into the Western collective consciousness a few years ago. It was only recently reestablished in India as the national system of medicine. Because it was suppressed and eradicated from India by the colonial rule. Ayurveda itself is a completely, totally holistic system. There is a path to self-realization just by bringing all the humors of the body to a complete balance. Then you don’t need to do anything. But it is not easy in our day and age. But Ayurveda speaks of that. If one understands what these seven tissues, they all have precise name and what happens in terms of the food we ate. When I started Ayurveda, it really, really made a strong impression on me. Is that in terms of what really food is. Your food is not something like you just eat and then it sustains, you are feeling good, it’s lovely. OK, one can be happy with that. But it’s interesting that the food that we eat goes through a progressive stage of digestion as it nourishes each progressively subtler tissue. Until it becomes a biological consciousness within the human body. Do you see? Any of you who have any ground in Ayurveda will understand exactly what I mean. It’s like you eat saliva, first contact of the food with your mouth, plasma. Then it becomes part of your blood. It nourishes. It has to be digested on that level. Digestion does not finish on the level of the gut. It’s the biggest misunderstanding. The food I ate today will take 28 lunar days before it will become my sperm. Or before it will become the quality of my sperm. And what is sperm? It’s a biological substance which gives birth to new life. It’s a very interesting fact. So if we ignore all this, we are kind of completely living in this very superficial understanding even what is this physical body. And I feel that in the spiritual community today, it’s the time when we understand what this human body is. Because this human body is divine on every level. And it is experiential. Those of us who have experienced that know that there is absolutely no free space, even on a physiological level. It’s all filled with divine energies. And these divine energies are directly perceivable. They’re not perceivable through the sense of smell, sight, touch, taste, or what have you. But they are perceivable on that strata which give birth to the elements and the sensory perceptions themselves. So this is very important. So when I read about that, what I ate today will become my immunological substance that sustains me in 28 days through progressive digestive process and through nourishing all these tissues of the body that were aforementioned earlier. Right?
Rick Archer: -How many have heard the term soma? Soma is said to be the finest product of digestion which can be produced by the body if the body is completely normalized or stress-free. And it is said to be responsible for the refinement of perception after self-realization such that one’s perception refines to become celestial so that one perceives the celestial field as an ordinary nature of one’s perception. So soma is said to be the physiological cause or reason for that. Just thought I’d throw it in.
Igor Kufayev: -Absolutely beautiful.
Unidentified participant 5: -What kind of substance is soma?
Rick Archer: -It’s said to be a kind of– I don’t know.
Unidentified participant 5: -Is it a natural–
Rick Archer: -It’s almost non-physical kind of physical.
Igor Kufayev: -It’s a conjunction of physical and non-physical. -It’s subtle, but it actually manifests in the physical body as the hormone issued by pineal gland. The pineal gland, this is the real meaning of the Rig Vedic churna, churning of the ocean. And this is the real meaning of the pressing soma, pavamana, all this nine mandala. If you’re familiar, what is ninth mandala of the Rig Veda? It’s all about that. It’s just in metaphorical, allegorical language. Pressing soma to satisfy the gods. What pressing? That rekindling of the pineal gland, which deities? The deities that sustain this physiology throughout its total structure. Because this physiology is divine, full stop. This is the Adam-Kadman. This is the Purusha. It’s not just some kind of like a dream-like, you know? It was taught at some point. But we reach time in our history. This is why the gentleman earlier who mentioned Kashmir Shaivism, I’m very pleased because it’s one of the doctrines, one of the philosophies, where I found full answer to my own experiences. Because it did not negate nothing. It includes absolutely everything. To me, it’s the integral system. It actually helped me to understand the teaching of my own master, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. Because before that, science of creative intelligence presented by him, which is now being presented by John Hegelin, seemed to me too intellectual, if you will, too scientific. But through my own experiences and the, let’s say, verification of that in Kashmir Shaivism, I understood perfectly what Maharishi used to say, remember? Life is 200%. 100% of absolute and 100% of relative.
Francis Bennett: -Oh, that’s wonderful.
Igor Kufayev: -You cannot live life on less than that. I even received a letter that apparently I’m featuring now Eckhart Tolle’s blog. Because Eckhart Tolle talks about some kind of like 80% being an absolute and 20% being in the relative world, like an ideal situation. Confusion. It’s a nonsense. The true non-duality is when in the midst of every physical activity, you experience yourself as yourself. Nothing, nothing is profane or sacred anymore. It completely overlap, merged, and fused. It’s like a very good shake my wife makes in the morning. Everything that put in, really good blend of the half. Well, used to have. We’re traveling. Everything is in storage. But that’s the example.
Francis Bennett: -I would say probably in the last year of my life and my journey, that the growing edge of my realization, if you want to call it that, is that reality, that life, that God, that consciousness, whatever you want to call it, is absolutely a seamless whole. And that even the distinction between relative and absolute and–
Rick Archer: what were the words you were using just now?
Francis Bennett: The relative absolute thing is simply a linguistic thing. There’s really no dichotomy like that in reality. It’s just a way that we can then talk about certain aspects of reality as if there were aspects. But reality is so completely whole. It’s like I’ve often thought of this analogy of the concave-convex of a lens. A lens is both concave and convex at the same time. There’s not a convex lens and a concave lens. It just depends on which way you turn the lens. Turn it one way, it’s convex. Turn it another way, it’s concave. What we call life is really, really one. And it’s hard for me. I really haven’t got a way of talking about it yet, even.
Rick Archer: -Well, there’s a stage of development at which there appears to be a dichotomy.
Francis Bennett: -Yes.
Rick Archer: -And that’s why some people say there is a dichotomy. But it’s just that the progress hasn’t continued to the point where it’s recognized that there is no dichotomy, you know, there’s a stage.
Igor Kufayev: -It’s a very valid, very vital process. The true detachment is necessary. And it’s only possible when subject and object stand in opposition to each other. When we literally experience–
Francis Bennett: -But it’s not the end, that’s all. It’s not it. -It’s intermediary states, in term, what you call it.
Igor Kufayev: And in term, a necessary stage in evolution of consciousness.
Unidentified participant 6: -The dichotomy of relative and absolute is used to address identification. But where it misleads is when we start thinking that the absolute is the opposite of the relative.
Francis Bennett: -Right.
Unidentified participant 6: -For it to be the opposite, it would have to be related. It would be relative. Relative means to be related.
Igor Kufayev: Right?
Unidentified participant 6: So if the absolute were the opposite of the relative, it would be something else. Well, we’ve all heard that. But the continuing use of those terms seems to reintroduce that hypnosis that they are separate. -So as you were saying, the absolute experientially is that absolute seamlessness to where there’s a distinction that’s used in language and in teaching.
Igor Kufayev: -Right.
Unidentified participant 6: -But in terms of experience, forget it.
Igor Kufayev: -Yeah, because we use the word awareness and experience. But if you try and find a boundary between awareness and experience, it isn’t.
Francis Bennett: -I’m at a point where I’m really kind of getting a little disgusted with the word non-duality. For me, at the point in my life that I’m at now, the term non-duality just brings up more sort of problems than anything else. Because it’s just like, well, if there’s non-duality, then there’s duality. And then you’ve got a duality again.
Unidentified participant 6: -For who?
Francis Bennett: -Yeah, right.
Unidentified participant 6: -For the one who’s still confused by that. Then if we start talking about needing to get beyond non-duality, then you introduce another–
Francis Bennett: -No, I’m not even saying that.
Unidentified participant 6: -And you haven’t, but other teachers have. Now we’re going to talk about going beyond non-duality. And then someone’s trying to go there.
Francis Bennett: -I’m just saying that the terms themselves are more and more meaningless to me.
Rick Archer: -Maybe it serves as a provocation. Maybe it just serves as a stimulus to conversation.
Francis Bennett: -It is that. I mean, it’s linguistic. It can be used in teaching. Yeah.
Non-speech: [INTERPOSING VOICES]
Rick Archer: -So instead of it being defined clearly, maybe you have to say something. And you can say that and maybe inherit in that it’s going to be a discussion, it’s going to be a dissension.
Unidentified participant 7: And maybe it’s just a– because there’s really no word that everybody would agree
Rick Archer: upon that’s going to explain the process.
Francis Bennett: -That’s exactly what I mean. It’s fine as long as we use it in a linguistic way and for teaching purposes and stuff. We get into trouble when we start taking it as being real. -Serious. -Yeah, exactly.
Unidentified participant 7: -All language is like that.
Francis Bennett: -All language is like that, exactly.
Unidentified participant 6: -I think one of the most helpful attitudes is to adopt a charitable attitude to language.
Francis Bennett: -Yes.
Unidentified participant 6: -And that’s what we still have to do.
Francis Bennett: -It’s got its limitations, but it’s what we’ve got to work with on one level. And that’s fine.
Non-speech: [Music]






