
Roger Linden Transcript: Part 1: Nondual Awakening, Meditation, and the End of Separation
Roger Linden interview — Part 1
Summary
The discussion traces a long spiritual practice and an eventual shift toward a more open, unitive experience of life. It explores how subtle effort in meditation and everyday action can reinforce a sense of being a separate doer.
Questions This Interview Explores
- How can subtle strain interfere with meditation?
- What can help someone notice and release effort in meditation?
- How is the sense of being a separate doer connected to bodily tension and breathing?
Key takeaways
- Meditation can become strained when the mind treats it as a way to reach a particular goal.
- Noticing effort and allowing it to release can open experience without forcing a result.
- Tightening the body and restricting the breath can support the feeling that a separate self is making things happen.
- Awareness of unnecessary tension can be useful in meditation and ordinary activity.
Transcript
Roger: And yet, the most amazing thing about it was realizing that life had always been wondrous and seemed to be just mundane.
🧘 Early spiritual glimpses and the path to meditation
Rick: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer. Buddha at the Gas Pump is an ongoing series of conversations with spiritually awakening people. I’ve done over 750 of them now. If this is new to you and you’d like to check out the previous ones, obviously you can browse around on YouTube. But if you go to the website, batgap.com, you’ll see that we have them organized in several different ways, which are kind of interesting. One of those is a page called Video Content Search, where you can type in a word or phrase and immediately see a list of all the interviews where that word or phrase was mentioned. If you click on any item in that list, it takes you right to the spot in the video where we’re talking about it. You won’t get that on YouTube.
This whole enterprise has been going on for nearly 17 years, and it’s supported entirely through voluntary donations. There are no fees or paywalls or barriers to entry. So, if you feel like supporting it and appreciate it, there are PayPal buttons on every page of the website, and there is a page with alternatives to PayPal.
My guest today is an old friend whom I’ve never met. We were on some of the same courses and in some of the same places, although we never actually met each other. We have similar backgrounds, although both of our backgrounds have diverged in different ways, and we’ll be going into all that as we go along.
To give you a spoiler here, after about 40 years of spiritual practice and endeavor, and with dedicated interest, Roger had an awakening to what we might call a unitive state or a state of liberation. It was quite unlike what he had anticipated from all the things he had read and been taught, but it abided and abides to this day. So, we’re going to talk about that a great deal. But first, welcome, Roger. Good to have you here.
Roger: Thank you, Rick. It’s good to be here.
A Childhood Experience of an Unchanging Self
Rick: So, let’s take the chronological approach to start with, and then we’ll see where the conversation goes. From your notes, I understand that you had some kind of spiritual experience around the age of six. What was that?
Roger: I did. And perhaps delightfully, it was while playing hide-and-seek.
Rick: Cute.
I hid rather too well, and my friends couldn’t find me. I was squatting behind a wall. I remember very clearly that I was wearing short trousers, and I was keeping very still and looking at my thigh. At a certain moment, there was a kind of opening. The thought came, but it was more of an appreciation, that it was a little boy’s arm, a little boy’s leg. It would be a man’s leg; it would be an old man’s leg. But I would stay the same. I wouldn’t change.
Roger: I hid rather too well, and my friends couldn’t find me. I was squatting behind a wall. I remember very clearly that I was wearing short trousers, and I was keeping very still and looking at my thigh. At a certain moment, there was a kind of opening. The thought came, but it was more of an appreciation, that it was a little boy’s arm, a little boy’s leg. It would be a man’s leg; it would be an old man’s leg. But I would stay the same. I wouldn’t change.
Rick: Interesting.
Roger: I have no memory of how long it lasted. I don’t think it was very long, probably a few seconds. And then I got a bit bored and gave myself up.
Rick: I thought you were going to tell me you had achieved the invisibility siddhi or something.
Roger: I think they were a bit fed up as well, not being able to find me. It was such a powerful experience, although for years I didn’t mention it to anybody because I had no way of speaking about it, no vocabulary or appreciation of any significance.
Reading Krishnamurti as a Teenager
When I was about 13 or 14, I used to spend a lot of time sitting up trees reading books. I’d normally take one of my books and then one of the books my parents had. One time I took a book by Krishnamurti. I think it was the Penguin Krishnamurti Reader. I can remember sitting up a tree on Hampstead Heath, which is a—
Rick: Sitting up means you climb the tree and you’re sitting on a branch?
Roger: I climbed the tree, yeah.
Rick: Must have been uncomfortable sitting on a branch.
Roger: Actually, it was very comfortable. I had a special place.
Rick: Okay.
Roger: It was a sort of secret place where I could spy on people, as little boys like to do. I remember very clearly reading bits of the book, trying to understand. I didn’t really understand what he was getting at, of course, except that I got the impression that a different way of seeing, a different experience of life or living, was possible. That awoke something in me, because my life at that time, my family life, was very troubled. It seemed to me that an alternative or some sort of radical change of experience was desired, and it was also a very hopeful notion. Then I sort of forgot about it for years.
Rick: Do you believe in reincarnation?
Roger: I have no knowledge. It seems to me unlikely. I haven’t experienced it, but so many people in so many traditions believe in it. I just have to say I don’t know.
Rick: Yeah, that’s fair and honest. There’s no need to believe in it, but if it’s a valid thing—and I kind of feel like it is—I think there’s a tendency for people who have had a spiritual urge or life or practice in previous lives to have glimpses early on in this life. I even know people who were in a state of unity in their childhood and then began to lose it as they got into their teen years, and then regained it later on. It talks about that kind of thing in the Bhagavad Gita, for instance, where you’re said to pick up where you left off, you know?
Roger: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Rick: Yeah. Anyway, just a thought. Okay, so then, did your father have PTSD from World War II or something? Is that why it was a troubled life?
Roger: I think, yeah, both my parents were struggling, I think, for different reasons. My father was in the Spanish Civil War as an ambulance driver, and then in the Second World War for the whole five years. I think he came back a very changed man.
Rick: Yeah, mine too. He was a mess. And so, that was when you were 13 or 14, and then your teenage years. Were they troubled, or did you get into—
Roger: I think I was very depressed, actually, and didn’t even realize I was depressed.
Rick: Uh-huh.
Roger: My parents separated, and I was sent to a state boarding school. So, it wasn’t a public school in the English sense, but it was a boarding school for children from broken homes or whose parents were working abroad or whatever. I was generally very unhappy there.
Rick: Yeah. Did you go through a drug phase as a teen? Marijuana, LSD, all that stuff?
Roger: I don’t think I would call it a phase. It was a more committed lifestyle.
Rick: Oh, you were a professional for a while there.
Roger: I think professionals have certain nuances. Not so much that, but I was a sort of hippie generation.
Rick: Yeah, me too.
Roger: And you must have been too.
Rick: Sure.
Roger: So, I did my best.
Rick: Okay. And when you did that, I know in my case that was my first big “aha”—that, “Oh wow, the world is much different than I realized and than people ordinarily perceive.” I was reading Timothy Leary and Richard Alpert’s Tibetan Book of the Dead and things like that. And it just lit a fire in me to gain enlightenment.
Roger: I think that, apart from smoking dope, which wasn’t very spiritual, I seemed to enjoy it. The first time I took LSD, it was given to me by someone who got it in the States from—I’ve forgotten his name—the guy who made it for Timothy Leary. Owsley. Yeah, that’s right.
Rick: Yeah.
Roger: It was a very, very beautiful experience. Sublime, peaceful. And it certainly did give me a sense of an alternative appreciation of the nature of reality. But, of course, it doesn’t last. I had previously had a very brief experience of Zen meditation when I was abroad, and had good experiences with that, but then was distracted by life and dope, probably.
Rick: Yeah, okay, and then you got on to TM.
Discovering Transcendental Meditation
Roger: Yeah. I was living back in Glasgow, where I originally come from, up in Scotland. I discovered that my flatmates—one of them was practicing TM, and he never mentioned it. I was very impressed when I found out, first of all, that he hadn’t mentioned it, because it seemed like a big deal. He lent me his copy of Maharishi’s first book, The Science of Being. I read it before I learned to meditate, and it was a huge revelation to me.
I had been looking for direction. I was 25 at that time, and I hadn’t really found direction. I didn’t know what I wanted to do. As soon as I heard about it and started reading the book, I knew I wanted to teach TM before I had actually learned the technique, which I think is probably a little unusual.
Rick: I instructed a guy who had that same reaction. I was standing in a kitchen of some home where I was teaching a course, and he said, “How do I become a teacher?” I said, “Well, I haven’t even taught you yet.” And then I taught him. He actually went on to become one of Maharishi’s personal secretaries later on.
Roger: Really?
Rick: Oh, well, there you go.
Roger: And, you know, that desire to become a teacher was hugely reinforced by my experience when I actually learned. Interestingly, I had to organize a teacher to come up to Glasgow to teach at school.
Rick: So, you organized your own course?
Roger: I organized my own course.
Rick: Okay. And then what was your experience when you actually learned?
Roger: Well, the teaching was actually in a hotel off a road that I lived on, called Great Western Road in Glasgow. It’s a very busy road. I walked there, and it was a sort of gloomy spring day, with lorries going past and exhaust fumes. About an hour and a half later, I walked back, and it was like a radically different street. Even though there was still the traffic and the fumes, everything looked completely different, and I felt totally different.
Rick: Yeah, I had the same experience. It was in Manhattan, walking down Fifth Avenue afterwards in a pouring rainstorm, getting soaked to the skin and not caring because I just felt so wonderful.
Roger: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And, of course, those first experiences, I think certainly for most people, and certainly for me, faded over time. My life afterwards—about two weeks later, going to the follow-up after about ten days—I had a meal with my father before the meeting. He was going abroad on a business trip, and he died while he was abroad. My life was hugely disrupted by that, clearly. He had very kindly left me his bankrupt little magazine, which I begged him not to do. I wasn’t a journalist and had no interest in that, so it was a bit of a dilemma for me, but we managed to sort of offload it. That disrupted that first year of meditation. During that time, I’d come down to London and got very involved in the local TM Center.
Rick: Yeah, and then you became a teacher in Belgium in 1974, I happen to know, because I was there also. I guess you got pretty involved in the TM movement for 20 years or so, right?
Roger: Yeah, I was busy as a teacher at first, and then for a while I worked in the administration. Then I went on various courses, as you know, sort of advanced courses for teachers, including a six-month intensive course.
Rick: Did you do that?
Roger: I did several of them, yeah.
Rick: You did several? Oh, so hardcore. And it’s interesting, I was going to talk to you about this because one point we’re going to talk about is straining in meditation or in life in general. But I remember at the beginning of one of my six-month courses, Maharishi said to us, “This is a contest to see who can purify the fastest.” And being a natural-born fanatic, I took that to heart. I was fasting and doing all this crazy stuff and really got myself out of balance. But anyway, that’s a whole other topic.
🧘 Recognizing strain in meditation and daily life
Yeah, but I think it’s so easy to misinterpret, or perhaps to interpret correctly in one sense, but then to apply that interpretation with strain. Trying to achieve something which can’t be achieved by forcing, by straining, by imposing on myself.
Roger: Yeah, but I think it’s so easy to misinterpret, or perhaps to interpret correctly in one sense, but then to apply that interpretation with strain. Trying to achieve something which can’t be achieved by forcing, by straining, by imposing on myself.
Rick: Yeah, let’s go into the strain topic a bit. We’ll get back to the biographical timeline. I have some thoughts about strain, but I’d like to hear yours. You realized at some point that there was a subtle strain in your meditation practice. It should be noted that a fundamental instruction of Transcendental Meditation is that you’re not supposed to strain or make any effort whatsoever. So how did strain creep into your practice, even though you were a teacher and you knew the instructions about not straining?
Roger: Yeah, yeah. But I think probably from very early on, maybe during that first year, there was an element—a subtle element—of strain. I was very fortunate. I got a lot of benefits from meditation. Especially the first year, I was less regular because my life had really been turned upside down. But once I got back into regularity, meditating twice a day, it was hugely beneficial. I had been a cigarette smoker for years, and it just stopped. Without any struggle, I just didn’t want to smoke anymore.
Rick: Yeah, my wife had the same experience. She said that after a few days of meditation, she realized she had forgotten to smoke.
Roger: It was a bit like that, yeah. I just one day looked at the cigarette I was smoking. I was like, “I don’t want this.” That was it.
Rick: And did you have any withdrawal symptoms or anything?
Roger: Not at all. It was amazing, apart from the odd dream when I was having a cigarette and then thinking, “No, I’m not supposed to smoke.” But there came a point—I wouldn’t say early on—when I realized there was a lot to my experience of teaching. When I first started teaching, maybe that’s the best place to start: doing a lot of the follow-up for people after they’d learned to meditate. It quickly became clear that a lot of people start trying to meditate quite quickly, even though we say thoughts are part of meditation and explain that you can’t have too many thoughts; it’s how you respond to the thinking. Very often people say, “Yeah, but you don’t mean this many thoughts. I have more thoughts than anybody could possibly have.”
So, I was experienced in guiding people, as you would have been, and explaining and teaching lots of people. But there came a point—and I can’t say when it was, after probably a few years of meditation—when I realized there was something happening that didn’t seem to be getting in the way of the benefits, but something was up. And I’d done those long courses. I hugely enjoyed the six-month course, most of it. I felt huge changes.
But after 20 years, I had been living for 10 of those years in a community up in the north of England called Shelmerdine, a TM community, and then came back to London. One day I sat down to meditate in the morning. It just didn’t happen. It’s not that I had forgotten how to meditate, but somehow something became so obvious that I couldn’t actually do the practice. What had become obvious was a certain sense of strain, of trying.
So, I did my best, in a sense, to stop trying, which sounds paradoxical, and then rested afterwards, a bit confused. The same thing happened that evening, and the next morning, and the next evening. Over the following weeks—and actually for six months—something dramatic and wonderful happened. Every day I’d sit to meditate, and I became more and more sensitive to strain and to what happened when I wasn’t straining. When I stopped straining, things would really open up.
So, I did my best, in a sense, to stop trying, which sounds paradoxical, and then rested afterwards, a bit confused. The same thing happened that evening, and the next morning, and the next evening. Over the following weeks—and actually for six months—something dramatic and wonderful happened. Every day I’d sit to meditate, and I became more and more sensitive to strain and to what happened when I wasn’t straining. When I stopped straining, things would really open up.
It’s an interesting thing, because the instruction in TM is: if it’s difficult, you stop straining, maybe feel what’s happening in your body or whatever, rest a little bit, and then come back to the technique. And that didn’t really work. But I knew that something very good was happening. I also realized that I had been subtly trying to get somewhere in the meditation.
One of the analogies that’s often used in meditation is like picking up a bubble that’s rising from the bottom of a pond, and you’re picking up the bubble at a quieter and quieter level. The idea of going deeper is that you’re going sort of deep inside. I had somehow interpreted that in some subtle way as going somewhere when I sat to meditate. I think it’s interesting that a friend years ago told me that when Maharishi first started teaching, he often used the analogy of a sitar string vibrating, with the vibration becoming less and less and then becoming still. That’s a radically different image: the activity is quietening down, rather than going somewhere quieter.
Rick: Yeah. Well, there’s that verse in the Yoga Sutras, I think I mentioned it in your friend Monica’s interview a month ago: the second verse in the first chapter says that yoga, or union, is the cessation of the fluctuations of the mind. Then the next verse is, “And then the seer rests in their true nature,” something like that.
So, this bubble analogy is just like thoughts are analogous to the bubbles. Ordinarily, we don’t experience them until they pop on the surface of the pond, but meditation is compared to tracing a bubble back to the bottom of the pond. In other words, allowing the mind to settle down to subtler and subtler levels of activity until it reaches a state of least excitation, and then you just rest in your true nature. Yeah, yeah.
Roger: Yeah. And my misunderstanding—although I didn’t even realize I had subtly misunderstood—because I would explain that to the people I was teaching, but subtly there was a sense of trying to get somewhere. As I said, that went on for six months. It was interesting; I was discombobulated by it because, at the same time, I knew that something was opening up and that it was beneficial.
Jean Klein and a Shift in Perception
Then I happened to be in an alternative bookshop that used to exist in Camden Town in London called Compendium. They were looking for a book that I’d ordered. While I was waiting, I picked up a book by a man called Jean Klein, who was a yoga teacher and spoke about non-duality. It wasn’t very appealing. The title was I Am. I thought it would be something I normally wouldn’t be interested in. I flicked it open and read a paragraph that described exactly what my experience had been over the previous six months. So, of course, I bought the book.
I happened to speak, when I got home, to a friend who lived nearby, and she said, “Oh, I know someone who knows him.” She called me back and said, “Oh, he’s coming to the UK next week and he’s going to be running a retreat.” So I went on that retreat. In the first meeting with Klein, I asked him a question. I can’t remember what the question was or his answer, and something just kind of opened up. For about a day and a half, my perception of life, in a sense, was a little bit similar to the first day of TM and the first few days of TM, but enhanced, if you like. Then it faded.
I spoke to him about it, and he was very encouraging. I saw him a few times over the next few years. I didn’t have any more awakening experiences with him, unfortunately, but I really liked him. He was European.
Rick: French?
Roger: French. He was an extraordinary man, with an extraordinary background. The thing I found most challenging about him—I liked him—was that he had a very happy childhood. And I thought, well, what about keep learning about this? Although he said that he was teaching non-duality and there wasn’t anything to do, he did actually subtly suggest a way of being, you know, of listening without listening, without straining or… which I could never really understand at the time. He taught yoga beautifully, and I did enjoy his—
Rick: Hatha—
Roger: Yoga.
Rick: Yoga.
Roger: There was Hatha yoga, but he called it Kashmiri yoga. He’d learned it somewhere in Kashmir. In the UK, there’s a friend called Billy Doyle who was taught to teach that style. It’s a lovely, gentle style of yoga.
Rick: I have a thought about this strain thing before we get too far from it. I was thinking about this as I was listening to a couple of your previous interviews. It seems to me that a certain amount of strain is inevitable if you take yourself to be the doer. Because, you know, if you think, “I am the doer,” if that’s your experience, then nothing gets done unless you do it, unless you individually make an effort.
But if you realize your true nature, which is beyond doing, which is being and not doing, and you realize that something larger than you is the author of action, that Brahman is the charioteer, as it says someplace, then, like someone riding in a car versus driving the car, you can relax and things just get done without any strain. And this pertains not only to spiritual practice, but even to, for instance, athletes who are in the zone and feel like everything is just happening automatically without them making an effort. In fact, you referred to a sprinter you met whose coach told her to relax even while sprinting. Anyway, those are my thoughts on that.
Roger: Yeah, and I take those points and I agree with them, except that for me, recognizing that there was an element of strain didn’t mean that I stopped straining. It meant that I was able to—well, when I say “not stop,” I could deliberately allow it to stop. But then I’d find myself picking up a pencil and realizing I’d restricted my breathing, I’d tightened up.
The more I kind of became sensitive to it, the more it became obvious that certainly in our culture, just about everybody that I met and knew and watched in the street was tightening up in order to do things. It was extraordinary. I trained later on as a Feldenkrais teacher, a Feldenkrais Method teacher, and more recently as an Alexander Technique teacher, because I find that whole physical side of things helpful. I had a bad injury when I was in my early 20s, and they were both very helpful in dealing with some of the consequences.
My great revelation came while listening to the radio one day as I was making some lunch. They—I don’t know what the program was—played a recording of a seal speaking.
Rick: A seal? You mean like the sea creature?
Roger: A seal, a sea creature.
Rick: Okay.
Roger: And it was a very weird, extraordinary thing, because it clearly wasn’t a human, but it wasn’t like a parrot speaking. It was kind of creepy. And what they said was…
Rick: It wasn’t speaking anything you could understand, right? It was just making seal noises.
Roger: Well, they were sort of words. No, no, they were words.
Rick: Oh, okay.
Roger: I don’t think the seal could understand them.
Rick: “Give me some fish.”
Roger: Yes, well, I think that’s probably what… The seal had been found as an abandoned pup and brought up by an American couple as a pet, and they taught it to speak.
Rick: I’ll be darned.
Breath Restriction and the Sense of Doership
Roger: And the point they made was that they could teach it to make sounds similar to human sounds because it could restrict its breathing. It could control its breathing. And it’s only semiaquatic mammals that can do that, which is why we can swim underwater. Now, there was a theory—I don’t know how well supported it is in science—that the strain was happening because I was restricting my breathing, tightening the diaphragm so the air in the lungs was under a bit of pressure, and it created the illusion that I was making something happen.
Rick: You were doing that during meditation or in general?
In general. And that was the physical expression of the illusion of doership that you mentioned. So, the sense of a separate self was supported by this assumption that I made things happen. But actually, it was a trick, a trick of the mind.
Roger: In general. And that was the physical expression of the illusion of doership that you mentioned. So, the sense of a separate self was supported by this assumption that I made things happen. But actually, it was a trick, a trick of the mind.
Rick: I wonder if yoga and other traditions that have all kinds of breathing practices have designed those to undo that habit.
Roger: I suspect that there’s a lot of that, yeah, that it does have that effect. And certainly yoga and meditation—I was certainly getting benefits, as I said, right from the beginning. But that habit was inhibiting some of the benefit, to some extent. And if I may just add, ordinary discursive thinking, daydreaming or whatever, requires a little contraction. Otherwise, it stops happening.
Rick: I was going to ask you later on, but I’ll ask you now. I get songs stuck in my head, you know, or I find myself daydreaming, like I always have. And I’m wondering if that stopped for you after this unitive shift.
Roger: No, it didn’t. The unitive shift came a few years later. But…
Rick: So, you still get songs stuck in your head, maybe?
Roger: Yeah, they’re called earworms.
Rick: I’ve never heard that expression. That’s a good one.
Roger: Yeah, it’s a great expression. Sometimes, yeah, absolutely. It drives my wife mad. I’ll find myself humming away.
Rick: It drives me mad. I think, “Okay, enough of this. Get on to something else.”
Roger: Yeah, so, no, my expectation was that all that would just stop, because we had these ideas about the nature of liberation, the nature of enlightenment.
Rick: In fact, Maharishi taught that in a state of enlightenment, quote-unquote, you wouldn’t really—you’d only have a small percentage of the thoughts that you ordinarily would have. You would only have thoughts that were purposeful or necessary or useful, and the rest of the chatter would just completely disappear. Your mind would be in silence when it didn’t have to apply itself to anything. But you’re saying that didn’t happen.
Roger: Well, not yet. Better hurry up. And that’s, of course, reincarnation is something… is something. Excuse me a second, I’ve just seen an ant walking along.
Rick: Okay, don’t hurt it.
Roger: No, I’m not going to. I’m just going to make sure it has an exit route.
Rick: When I was a kid, I used to sit on the kitchen floor and make little trails of sugar and play with the ants. My mother didn’t like that.
Roger: It must be something to do with you, Rick, because in the 30 years I’ve lived here, I’ve never had an ant on this table.
Rick: It’s a sign.
Roger: It’s an amazing sign. So, just to go on with the story, I’d spent time with Jean Klein, and he died. People who would speak about nonduality came to London, and I’d attend their meetings. I attended particularly the meetings by someone called Tony Parsons, whom I’d heard of.
Rick: I’ve interviewed Tony.
Roger: Yeah. And what I liked about Tony, although it was challenging, was that he wouldn’t give me anything to do. He kept insisting that it wasn’t about doing something. And I sort of intuited that maybe that was true, but I didn’t really believe it. You know, I was always sneakily wanting to be told what to do.
During this time, I was still meditating and certainly sitting, still exploring—not straining, or straining less, probably, is more accurate. I suppose after about a year, I was on a retreat with him, and I had a second, if you like, major awakening that seemed to be triggered—or was triggered—by something he said. And that lasted for about three and a half, four days. So, it was a lot longer.
Rick: And what was the nature of that? What did you feel like during those three and a half days?
Roger: Well, it was similar to the experience after meeting Jean Klein. Everything was radiant. I felt incredibly blissful. A great deal of joy and peace.
Rick: Did you have the experience of maintaining pure awareness during sleep? Do you now, or have you ever?
Roger: That had been going on for about a year. And funnily enough, I didn’t really appreciate it, because I’d had the experience, particularly after my first weekend retreat—a TM retreat—that for a few days afterwards, it seemed like I was just lying in bed, not sleeping, but being able to see my body. Yeah. I remember the first time it happened, somebody grabbed hold of my feet and turned me over, and I woke up. “That’s a strange thing for someone to do.” And I realized all that had happened was that I turned over.
Rick: Oh, you turned yourself over, I see.
Roger: But it seemed like it wasn’t voluntary; it just happened. And I realized that somehow I had been watching myself as I was asleep.
Explain the principle of that, because Maharishi made a big deal of it. He said that’s like the acid test, or litmus test, of cosmic consciousness or self-realization. Not too many other teachers emphasize it like that. So, just explain a bit what your experience was and why.
Rick: Explain the principle of that, because Maharishi made a big deal of it. He said that’s like the acid test, or litmus test, of cosmic consciousness or self-realization. Not too many other teachers emphasize it like that. So, just explain a bit what your experience was and why.
Roger: Well, that one went away.
Rick: Okay.
Roger: Yeah. But that day, I was actually working at the time on Hampstead Heath. The morning after—so that would be the Monday morning after I’d got back from the meditation weekend and had this experience that night—it was extraordinary. It just looked so beautiful. And there were other aspects to it. It sounds so kind of extraordinary. I was looking down across the park, and there was a pond at the bottom of the slope. It was as if everything was just… What I thought of at the time was that it was like it was all Buddha. It looked like there was Buddha radiating sublime peace. It was an absolutely sublime experience, which didn’t last, but made me think, “Oh, I think I’ll do a few more of these weekends.” It never happened again.
Rick: Does it ever even happen now? Do you have times like that?
Roger: It’s a bit different, but let me come to that.
Rick: Okay, we’ll get to that. But I just want to again interject: that was also a big thing Maharishi made a big deal of. He talked about witnessing sleep as being a characteristic of cosmic consciousness, and then having celestial or refined perception as being characteristic of the next stage, which he called God consciousness. And he said that the self-realization phase is the foundation of the refinement of perception, that you couldn’t really have it refined that much without that foundation.
Roger: So, those first experiences went; they didn’t last. But what had been happening, without me really paying much attention to it, since I’d spent those months and then years simply, hopefully meditating in a much less effortful way, and spending time listening to people like Jean Klein—but particularly Jean Klein at that point—not really practicing apart from the yoga or anything he suggested, but hearing what he had to say about reality, I began to notice that there was a very quiet awakeness even during sleep.
But it wasn’t dramatic like that first experience. It was much, much more, in a curious way, ordinary. And I was aware of it, but I didn’t think about it. It was a very funny thing. I just sort of took it for granted.
Rick: It seems to me that abiding experiences tend not to be dramatic. I mean, you wouldn’t want your life to be dramatic all the time.
Roger: No, I wouldn’t want people to be waking up in the middle of the night thinking, “Somebody’s turned me over.” Right, yeah. But you’d have to ask my wife about that, of course.
Rick: “Hey, did you turn me over?”
Roger: With an elbow, yeah. But then I went through a period—and this is closer, in some senses, to what Maharishi said. This went on: that quite inner awakeness during sleep went on, and the sense of an internal self, an “I” inside, changed. And it was more that there was a sense of a witness. But it was me; it still felt personal, as if I was witnessing.
Rick: Some individual quality to it, witnessing. And by witnessing, you mean what?
Roger: Aware of whatever.
Rick: Like detached from?
Roger: It wasn’t really being detached, but it sounds as if it’s detached because it was as if I wasn’t any longer inside looking out through my eyes, as it were, but somehow it was more a kind of open awareness of the experience. The word “witness” does suggest a detachment, and it didn’t really feel like that.
Rick: And did you find that that open awareness was kind of unshakable, even during an intense experience like running through an airport or injuring yourself or something? It was always just there?
Roger: It was just there, yeah. And like we were saying before, it wasn’t a big deal. Then I went through a period of only a few weeks, which were the most blissful few weeks that I’ve ever experienced. It was just as if love was oozing out of everything. I mean, it sounds kind of a bit like some sort of pudding, but it was extraordinary. And it made my work challenging in some sense during that time. I was working as a psychotherapist and I’d be listening to people talking about their difficulties, and I’d be having this extraordinary experience of love.
Rick: Would it translate into compassion for your patient?
Roger: Well, it would, but in a funny way, it wasn’t that it was impersonal; it was sort of nonpersonal. So, it was as if it was happening to me rather than I was experiencing it.
Rick: And it was blissful.
Roger: It was very blissful. So, there had been about a year of this inner awakeness during sleep, then the sense of witness, then these weeks of love and bliss, and then that faded.
Rick: I wonder if these things really fade or if we just acclimate to them. I often think that if I were to go back to where I was 50 years ago, even though I felt good at the time, I’d feel agonized because it would be such a contrast to now. And vice versa: if I could go from then to now, even though now feels normal, I’d suddenly just be incapacitated by the bliss.
Roger: Yeah, I think it’s a very good point. I think the intensity did quiet down, but it didn’t completely disappear.
Rick: Right.
✨ Consciousness and the resting point of awareness
Roger: There was a sense, a very quiet sense, of a glow about all perception, which was like a very toned-down version of the experience I’d had in the park all those years before. But I was curious about it because I could see that there was no self inside; that had been realized. But there seemed to be this sense of a witness, if you like, some sense of the nature of life being… I had a sort of intuition or sense that it was whatever we call it, consciousness or awareness, that seemed to be there but wasn’t really clear. But what was really clear was that there was still a sense of doership. And I was perturbed by that because if there wasn’t a self inside, how could there be a sense of doership? It didn’t make any sense to me.
On a residential retreat with Tony Parsons, I asked him about it. And he said what I had to appreciate was that nothing is happening. And that just—it was like a, I don’t know, a thunderbolt. Now, don’t ask me if I understood what it meant, because I don’t think I did at the time. I understand, but something stopped. And it was that that seemed to be the trigger for the second awakening, which lasted for four days.
That was on a Saturday. I thought, “Oh, this is it. This is liberation. This is it. It has to be.” Everything was just sublime. And then I woke up on Wednesday morning, and it had faded. It had gone.
Rick: Was that depressing, or was it like, “Oh well, I still feel good, but that was nice”?
Roger: No. I remember thinking, well, the first time was with Jean Klein and it was a day and a half, and this is four days. So, you know, if you think of an exponential progress—
Rick: Yes, it’s growing.
Roger: Yeah, it’s four days. So, I don’t think I was disappointed. I got up and meditated and went for a walk on the Heath, as I did every morning. On my way back, it was a spring morning. I was looking at a pond; it was misty, there were swans, it was very lovely. And I remember just turning my head. There was a slope up the hill, and as I turned my head, suddenly: “Oh, this is what’s never come and gone.” And it really was like, “Oh, pop.” It was so obvious, and the thought came, “Oh, this is being.”
And then—and I can’t tell you exactly what the sequence was—it’s all perception. It’s all just appearance. What I realized was that up until that point, there’d been an assumption, I think a very deep, profound assumption, that the sense of something—that all experience being personal—somehow was the illusion, that somehow it would be eliminated in some way. I often tell people I thought there would be some sort of cosmic apple core, you know, that would come and zonk out all the personal, and there would just be—I don’t know what, but something like those descriptions that Maharishi spoke about.
But what was realized was that it was not any of the things that had happened up to then, because they had all been changes of perception. This was not a change of perception. That’s what was radically different. It was realizing that the assumptions about the experience of life were mistaken. I had assumed I was sort of inside, looking out at a separate world, rather than the experience being a simulation. And the sense of space that we think of as nothing, as emptiness between objects, is actually this luminous, silent, still being. And the sense of the personal didn’t disappear; it’s just that everything was personal. So instead of this self with a lowercase s, it’s all Self with a capital S.
Rick: And yet there’s a personal quality to it, because usually the capital-S Self is considered to be impersonal versus the small-s self.
Roger: Yes. Somebody in a meeting made a suggestion which I thought was very good. I said I don’t like to think of it as impersonal, and he said, “It’s non-personal.” I like that. But what I took to be personal, of course, was related to the personality. The personality carried on, along with the characteristics and the conditioning and all the other stuff. But the sense that everything is personal to Roger—my perception, my experience of the environment or whatever—that changed fundamentally.
Rick: Okay. Yeah. I have a couple of thoughts I want to bounce off you. One is, you may remember Margie having said—and he got this from traditional Vedanta—that the shift into unity is really just a clarification of understanding, as opposed to some kind of experience. It’s like the intellect finally gains clarity on some subtle level.
Roger: Yeah, prajnaparadha.
Rick: Yeah, exactly. Prajnaparadha, meaning the mistake of the intellect, is corrected. This thing about—I’ve talked to many people who say they’ve lost all sense of a personal self, and that puzzles me. I don’t think I’ve lost all sense of a personal self. And if I get to that stage, I’ll get to that stage, but I don’t intellectualize myself into something that I’m not experiencing.
Let’s say you and I are walking down the street, and you get stung by a bee. Now, you’re having—you, I should say, just for the convenience of language—you’re having an experience of pain, which I’m not having. So, there is some kind of localization or personal perception. Some guy in China is not feeling the bee sting, and I’m right next to you, and I’m not feeling it. So that, to me, from my perspective, seems like some sense of a personal self, even though it might be—you’ve heard the term—lesha avidya, a faint remainder of ignorance. It might be a small percentage of your entire experience, but there’s still some kind of functioning ahamkara, as they say in Sanskrit, or “I”-maker. You know what I’m trying to say?
Roger: Yeah, very much so. I would have assumed that. I’m not quite sure what I believed, but certainly what was amazing was how ordinary it was. At some point I remembered, on the six-month retreat that you did several of, Maharishi said to us that what he called unity consciousness should be thought of as a normal state. It wasn’t special. He said you couldn’t tell if unity had happened from the way somebody behaved. I had that, but I didn’t really take it on board, because what were the examples of what I took to be enlightenment? Maharishi and the other gurus and great luminaries like Ramana Maharshi.
Rick: Yeah, Yogananda, Jesus, all these people.
Roger: And they’re extraordinary personalities. Goodness knows what was going on for them. You know, I have no idea. And I’ve met some extraordinary people. But what happened was really very, very ordinary. And it didn’t mean that the characteristics associated with Roger, with me, fell away. Some things changed, but nothing very dramatic. Sometimes people say that one of the side effects for them is that all fear stopped, or whatever. That didn’t happen for me.
Rick: Yeah, I always say, “Dangle Ramana Maharshi from the Golden Gate Bridge by his ankles and see if there’s any fear that comes up.”
Roger: Yeah, exactly. But, you know, that was 26 years ago, and it hasn’t changed in any way since. That fundamental clarity has remained because it was always there previously, just simply misinterpreted. So it wasn’t some dramatic transformation that I had assumed would happen, you know, that somehow, through liberation, you’d be some kind of saint or—like you said earlier—there’d be no thoughts, there’d be no anguish, there’d be no… All of that continued. So it was very ordinary. And yet the most amazing thing about it was realizing that life had always been wondrous and had been assumed to be just mundane.
And yet the most amazing thing about it was realizing that life had always been wondrous and had been assumed to be just mundane.
Rick: Yeah. A bumper sticker that says something like, “If you’re not in awe, you’re not paying attention,” or some such thing.
Roger: Yeah, yeah. But maybe from neuroscience, we assume that we look out at the world, that the senses are projected out into the environment. Now, we know—we learn in school—that’s not the case, that the senses are receptive. They receive information, which is processed in the brain, and then this experience becomes conscious. So, what does the baby have to learn? The toddler has to learn to make sense of what is essentially virtual reality and to learn to function as if it were a physical reality. And really, this is what all experience is.
Rick: Yeah, but in terms of my bee sting example, does the contrast in our experience, yours and mine, as we’re walking down the street and you get stung, imply that there is some kind of a kernel of a personal self that enables you to have that experience rather than me? Or what? I mean, would you agree with these people who say, “I’ve lost all traces or semblance of any sense of personal self”? And I think, you know, “Hey, Joe,” and Joe will turn his head and say, “Why did you turn your head if there’s no sense of a personal self?”
Roger: There’s no longer any sense of a self inside, some kind of I-self.
Rick: Okay. But—
Roger: It’s all Self, Rick. Yeah. It doesn’t disappear. It’s just realizing everything is so. It’s the opposite of what I imagined. And your example is a very interesting one, because if I was stung, there’d be a reaction. It might be verbal as well as physical. But the experience of walking down the street would be totally personal. My experience of walking, of seeing the environment, of having thoughts, feelings, emotions, engaging in a conversation with you—and your experience—would be totally personal. And everybody that we walk past, the same thing.
So, what I’m talking about, whatever other people may be speaking about, is just the appreciation that everything is the personal, and that is Self with a capital S. And it’s still silent, quietly peaceful and sublime, and exactly the same as it was before, except that when the sense of us being inside, looking out, was there, it seemed to be completely different. And there was a little contraction that created or supported the sense of a separate self. In a sense, the difference is minimal and yet profound and radical, because that conditioning that I’m looking at solid objects rather than a representation of them—
You know, in your conversation with Monica Khosla a month ago, she mentioned a conversation that she and I had in which she said something along the lines of, “Oh, well, maybe there really is a physical world.” I absolutely believe that there’s a physical world. I don’t go along with the people who say, “Oh, there’s nothing there.” No.
Rick: Yeah, try stepping in front of a bus and see if that holds up.
Roger: Exactly. There’s no experience—saying that because I can’t experience Australia, it doesn’t exist—seems to be just silly.
Rick: Yeah. Einstein and Rabindranath Tagore had an argument about this, whether there’s a moon if nobody is looking at it, you know? Or does the moon somehow materialize when you look at it? And I thought, okay, what if everybody in the world goes blind? Do we still have tides? Yeah, actually, we do.
Roger: Of course. And you know Douglas Harding, who wrote that lovely little book on having no head?
Rick: Right.
Roger: I don’t know if you’ve read it, but 50 years later he wrote an essay expressing his embarrassment at realizing that actually we do have heads.
Rick: Well, do you think he literally thought we didn’t have heads?
Roger: No. But he said he spent 50 years teaching that we didn’t have a head because we can’t perceive—
Rick: Yeah, I always took that as some kind of just perceptual trick or exercise.
Roger: Well, it was, yes, and he said that what he came to realize is the fact that he couldn’t see it didn’t mean it didn’t exist.
Rick: Yeah, Monica said something like, “How do I know I have a brain?” or something like that. I hope I didn’t misunderstand her. But, you know, I mean, I have a liver. I’ve never seen my liver. If I didn’t have a liver, I wouldn’t be talking to you.
Roger: Well, it’s a very reasonable and just sensible assumption.
Rick: Yeah, that sounds weird to deny it.
Roger: I don’t particularly want to see it. I hope, you know, I don’t in many ways. But this whole thing is so simple. The consequences of misinterpreting it are so potentially painful or difficult. Not that the idea that life is suffering—that there is suffering in life—is wrong. But the sense of dissatisfaction or incompleteness, I always thought previously that this would be some major, major transformation and experience. No, that’s almost nothing. Almost nothing. You know, in the Vedic tradition, they talk of Mahavakyas, those sayings, those great expressions like, “Thou art that,” “All this is that.”
Rick: And that’s kind of what triggered you. The nature of a Mahavakya is that when you’re ripe—I mean, you can hear it a thousand times and it won’t do anything, but when you’re ripe, just at the right moment, if you hear one of those phrases, it can trigger the shift.
Roger: And I think the thing that I hadn’t understood was the belief, “Well, I have to practice and purify and refine my awareness or my consciousness until I’m somehow able to realize this.” But what I realized in what was, what, 30-odd years of meditation, was that that which was seen that morning in the park had not changed in any way in all those years of experience of meditation or prior to that. It hadn’t made any difference to their assumption about the nature of perception or the nature of experience. Now people will say, “Oh, well, you were prepared for the insight by the years of meditation.” Of course, I can’t argue with that, because who knows? It’s just that I’ve spoken to many people where this has happened and they’ve never meditated.
Rick: Never meditated, but they—not in this life—were prepared nonetheless. Did you ever see the movie Sliding Doors with Gwyneth Paltrow?
Roger: No.
Rick: Okay, so it’s a movie where Gwyneth Paltrow, in her role, gets on a subway. What do you call them in England?
Roger: The Tube.
Rick: The Tube.
Roger: Or the Underground.
Rick: She successfully gets on. And then they replay the scene, and the doors close before she’s able to get on. From then on, the movie bifurcates in terms of how her life unfolds, whether she got on or didn’t get on the Tube. I thought about that movie when I was listening to some interviews with you, because let’s play this game. Let’s say you had been taking amphetamines for 40 years, although you probably wouldn’t have remained alive, or you had done what you did, which is all this spiritual practice and stuff. Do you think that the likelihood of having the unitive shift that you had would be equal in both of those timelines?
Roger: Of course, it’s impossible to know.
Rick: Yeah, but realistically.
Roger: Realistically, I think what it did was make me more receptive to it. If you like, there were all those years of meditating, then realizing that I’d been straining, and then hearing people say, “No, this isn’t about getting somewhere or refining something or expanding your consciousness, or all the things that I sort of took for granted. This is already it.”
Rick: Yeah.
Roger: There isn’t something to get. And that’s what happened on Hampstead Heath. People will argue about this until the cows come home, and probably a lot longer than that. But what I realized was it was very much that mistake of the intellect, that fundamental misunderstanding or misperception: thinking that I was looking out at physical reality from inside and then realizing, oh, it’s a simulation.
Rick: Yeah.
Roger: So whether practice helps us to be ready to hear that, or see that, or be open to that, I honestly don’t know. But the thing is, I still think meditation is a wonderful practice. So I’m happy with people who think it was because of meditation, and people who think it wasn’t because of meditation. Both are fine.
Rick: There was a Zen teacher who said, “Enlightenment may be an accident, but spiritual practice makes you accident-prone.” In traditional Vedanta, and probably other traditions, Shankara, for instance, doesn’t say that practice causes liberation. He says that certain practices, including karma yoga and bhakti yoga, purify the mind, remove gross obstructions, and make a person eligible for jnana yoga, which is the yoga of knowledge, the direct path. And even then, jnana yoga doesn’t manufacture liberation so much as remove the ignorance that was always obscuring what was already the case, just as the wind doesn’t create the sun but removes the clouds obscuring it. So I really do believe that. I’m in that camp of believing that all that spiritual practice stuff that you did ripened you and got you to the point where you could have that subtle shift of intellectual clarity that you had.
Roger: Yeah, and that may well be true. I really don’t know. What I know is—and I think you’ve heard it very well—that it didn’t change that fundamental assumption about the nature of reality in any way. But it may have enabled me to be available to see what I saw with that.
Rick: Well, it changed a lot of assumptions over the 30, 40 years. You kept changing, changing, changing. You weren’t ready to change the fundamental assumption or to have that change, but at a certain point you were, and it did.
Roger: Yeah. And what I saw was that which had never changed and couldn’t possibly change. That is the thing. I remember thinking, “Oh, if people think this isn’t it, then fine, maybe it’s not what they call liberation or whatever.” But it couldn’t be any other way, because there would be no experience of life without this.
Rick: Yeah. And was your experience that, “Oh, it’s always been like this; I just didn’t realize it”? I guess you kind of just said that.
Roger: If I could show you this, it’s a rather old cutting—you know the picture of the…
Rick: Yeah, the people, faces versus the vase.
Roger: Yeah, the two profiles in the vase. And I like this because, for me, first we maybe see the vase, or we see the two profiles, and then somebody says, “No, no, you could see it, you know, you could see the alternative way.” And it seemed to me that seeking was a little bit like seeing. You could see the two profiles in the vase simultaneously.
Rick: Seeking was like that.
Roger: Yes, that I was looking for something that seemed very challenging, and I somehow couldn’t do it. But I had to work at it and refine my perception or whatever, and then I would realize or see the two profiles in the vase at the same time. What was realized was that it was always a bit of paper. And it was obvious that it was a bit of paper. And of course, just a bit of paper is not important. Empty space wasn’t important. There’s nothing. But it turned out to be everything. Because how could it be empty space? If this is a simulation, if you like, it’s an illusion created by perspective, the way things appear in consciousness. It’s like space: when you dream at night, you dream of scenarios where there’s space, but of course, we know there isn’t actual physical space. So this sense of just nothing is being, is consciousness, whatever we want to call it.
And that couldn’t be any different.
But I want to emphasize that realizing this—of course it was a relief. I said to people it felt like a relief for about three months. But it was the ordinariness that struck me. It wasn’t that Roger became enlightened or anything like that. It was very, “Oh, it’s just this sense of a separate self fell away.” But the personality carried on. The thoughts carried on, the emotions, the conditioning, whatever. Some things eased, and of course, 26 years, being much older, things will change. But I think for all those years I’d thought of it as being very special, rather than the tragedy, if you like, of life being that we’re just so close to well-being. And that sense of strain, the looking out, the contraction, makes it seem as if it’s something we have to achieve or work towards rather than discover is innate. That, I think, is the biggest insight.
Rick: I think, though, as a therapist, you must realize that the average person has layer after layer after layer after layer of deep conditioning. It’s not like everyone is walking around on the verge of this kind of realization. There’s generally a lot of stuff that has to be unwound, don’t you think? So, this has been part one of a little over two-hour interview with Roger Linden. I will link in the description field below to part two, and I hope you will join us for that one. Thanks.
Roger: Thanks.






