BatGap Logo
A seamless montage shows Monica Khosla centrally in an ivory blouse and deep teal cardigan, surrounded by scenes of a fell walk, yoga class, running with papers and neural imagery, therapy training, and sitting with a dot-marked page beside an ocean view.

Monica Khosla Transcript: Spiritual Liberation, Memory Reconsolidation, and the End of the Separate Self

Monica Khosla interview

Rough draft

Monica Khosla: It was a very momentary, very quick thing, but there is this sense almost like my brain rebooted itself. It’s funny because how small it was, sort of experientially in that change, it was just such a nice, just a little sort of relief, you know, it’s just like, “Oh, okay, that’s… Oh, it’s so much simpler than maybe it seemed. Life is so much simpler than it had seemed.”

Rick Archer: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer. In case this is new to you, Buddha at the Gas Pump is a long-running series of interviews with spiritually awakening people. And if it is new to you, you might want to either subscribe to the YouTube channel and check out what we’ve got, or better yet, go to the website. Well, do that, but go to the website and you’ll see all the interviews organized in a variety of ways. It’s a little bit easier to explore and navigate them that way. And in case you like to read things or want to quote something for something you’re writing or anything like that. This program is made possible through the support of appreciative listeners and viewers. So if you appreciate it and would like to help support it, there are PayPal buttons on every page of the website. The only ads you’ll ever see, I think, are the little thing at the beginning of a YouTube video, and there’s a skip button, so you can always skip it. But we don’t run ads on the podcast or anything else. And we get offers all the time to advertise stuff, but I never wanted to do that. My guest today is Monica Khosla. And I’m gonna have Monica introduce herself, rather than having me read the little bio she sent me ’cause it’ll just be more interesting for her to say it than for me to say it. So why don’t you go ahead and start by just telling us a little bit about yourself, Monica. And you wrote a book called “The First and Last Belief,” which we’ll be talking about. And I’ll ask you questions about that, but go ahead, tell us about yourself.

Monica Khosla: So as a little kid, I was what’s called a secret Catholic. So we were a Catholic family, we went to Mass and it was quite unusual where we were, there wasn’t a lot of Catholics around and I was kind of quite used, mostly by my big brother for being sort of humiliated for whatever I was into or expressing anything personal about myself. So, but secretly I was quite religious and I was really into Jesus and Mary and used to pray and sort of, I suppose, naturally quite devotional in a way, but I wouldn’t have told people about it because it wasn’t cool. So I was also very busy trying to be conventional, be normal. And then when I was 17, I had an awakening experience. So I was, I grew up in the English Lake District, very, very beautiful valley that I grew up in. And I was at the side of a fell, a mountain, and had a sudden sense of one minute maybe being this quite angst-ridden teenager and the next minute having a sense of expanding and kind of being everything that was in view so it’s including the whole beautiful scenery where I was.

Rick Archer: You were 17 were you smoking anything or this just happened spontaneously?

Monica Khosla: Did you say was I smoking anything?

Rick Archer: Yeah I mean I I was when I was 17.

Monica Khosla: I was far, far better behaved than you, Rick. I was just a bit kind of stressed out about boys. My family owned a hotel in the valley where I grew up and they had just sold the hotel and they had to move beyond a hundred mile radius of where they had the hotel in order to have another business.

Rick Archer: It’s a weird rule, but anyway.

Monica Khosla: And so effectively my parents were leaving home. I was leaving home. I wouldn’t have a home to go back to. I was going to go to university before too long. But my kind of whole life was in this valley and in this sort of area of the Lake District. So and I had a complicated thing going on with boys or men, young men. I was just really confused about it all. So I think it was a sort of, maybe there was some kind of stressy contraction thing and then something just let go and yeah, there was a kind of a beautiful experience. And yeah, it was nice. And then I came down from the mountain and it gradually faded, but I kind of opened up.

Rick Archer: Were you carrying a couple of stone tablets at that point?

Monica Khosla: Yeah, yeah, absolutely, Rick. Yeah, I brought down all these words of wisdom for everybody. No, I, again, I wasn’t, I didn’t come down and talk about it or share it. I was, you know, I kept all that kind of stuff to myself. I did start finding books about different ways of looking at things. I found one quite odd book in a telephone box, which I can’t exactly remember what it was, but it opened my mind to, you know, not just looking at things maybe from a Christian religious point of view or that kind of thing. And then, Alan Watts, The Wisdom of Insecurity, that was quite cool. And I started hanging out with people who did take drugs and who sort of had a alternative view put on things and talked about different sorts of experiences. So although that wasn’t certainly my big thing I was influenced by here. It felt like it resonated with something more closer to how I was starting to see things. And then I just kept, I guess I kept searching. I kept, I was already interested in psychology. I was going to study psychology. Psychology was kind of unsatisfying. I actually dropped out for a while while I was studying it for about a term and then I went back again and nobody noticed I wasn’t there and I completed my degree but I kind of in some level really dropped out with it. It just wasn’t answering what I was interested in and I studied all sorts of things. I studied acupuncture, I studied astrology, eventually became a psychotherapist. And along the way, and I also studied things like yoga and qigong and lots of meditation stuff. And I guess everything, I’d take it to a certain point and then it would become unsatisfying and it kind of, that wasn’t it. Or I just couldn’t do it anymore. I couldn’t practice it anymore. I kind of gave it up and then something else. So I guess I was searching and also I think think maybe trying to get away from something that felt not okay in myself. Yeah, just this… yeah, I don’t know. I had so many of these opening awakening experiences that suggest that were kind of a relief and some ease and some freedom and then there’d be this sort of constricted, kind of insecure, self- conscious personality that was a bit lost I guess in a lot of ways.

Rick Archer: I think a lot of people can relate to what you’re saying you know a lot of people go through patterns like that or they have the old I got it I lost it syndrome that cycles on and off and exploring a lot of things and I don’t think it’s necessarily a bad thing to hopscotch around from one thing to the next until you find something that really works for you if you just stick with the first thing you find and bang away at it for years it might not be very productive.

Monica Khosla: Yeah yeah and it gradually came to non-duality I think I was hanging out with people who were into sort of more odd sort of crazy wisdom things and I don’t know different ways of looking at things then I think Tony Parsons came to Totnes and I went to his meeting and read his book and that was a little bit different and things like Douglas Harding and and then Roger Linden came to Totnes and and he was great because I could talk to him about the different sort of experiences I had and my confusions around and he was so good at sort of pointing to the confusion and there seemed to be lots of little realizations, recognitions with him but but none of them were liberation or series of things and then one day I was in a yoga class that my husband Paul was teaching and there was just a sudden like it felt like a little energetic pop that kind of happened in my solar plexus it’s like something just released and there was a it doesn’t matter I mean, it’s hard to remember, really, because it was a very momentary very quick thing, but there is this sense almost like my brain rebooted itself.

Rick Archer: Yeah.

Monica Khosla: And…

Rick Archer: It’s funny because about a month ago I interviewed a guy named Keith Parker and he had a similar experience where he had done all kinds of things and had nice experiences and everything, but one day he was doing some yoga and there was like a click in his hip or something and all of a sudden the kundalini shot up his spine and he was seeing auras around everything and so, you know, you hear that kind of thing, wow, you know, yoga is more than just stretching and bending it can really affect some deep changes.

Monica Khosla: But I don’t think it was the yoga. It wasn’t because it, yeah, in this particular case, it wasn’t like a Kundalini experience, it wasn’t a big energetic shift. It was a tiny, tiny little nothing. It was like almost nothing sort of energetically. It was just like a tiny little something just went and I was possibly even lying down at the time. It was all doing some kind of lying on the floor pose and then it just carried on whatever Paul was telling us to do I just kept doing it. But it was like there was just this “oh” and one of the thoughts or there was a thought, there’s nothing underneath thought, that seemed really important that was part of the insight, it was sort of seeing that that thought is essentially just thought. We can’t really know anything. And the sense of personalness just went, it just felt really simple.

Rick Archer: Interesting.

Monica Khosla: Really simple.

Rick Archer: But it was a watershed moment and things were never quite the same since then, were they?

Monica Khosla: Yeah, yeah, that’s right. Yeah.

Rick Archer: And so you use the word liberation a lot. I guess you feel like that’s the best word, maybe one of the best words to describe what this is that happened or dawned in you.

Monica Khosla: It was weird when I started writing the book. It felt quite a little bit uncomfortable to use that word. And bear in mind that I didn’t really talk about this. I mean, it happened I think maybe 17 years ago now. And I wasn’t out there talking about this. or, you know, occasionally I would talk to people about it and found it difficult to find the words and wasn’t very good at expressing it. I would talk to Roger Linden and he became my counselling supervisor and so he was really great to be able to talk to about it. And he uses the word liberation and he was like, when I was writing it and somebody said, “Oh, you should put liberation in inverted commas.” And I said to Roger about that and And he was like, “No, that’s nonsense. You know, it’s liberation. It’s simple, you know, don’t mess with it.” And it sounds like a big word, but it’s describing something so small in a funny way. It’s just the dropping away of something that really wasn’t important.

Rick Archer: Yeah, it’s not fireworks and kundalini rushes and auras and all that stuff. it’s something very simple, natural and…

Monica Khosla: Yeah, I’ve had some of that kind of stuff… Unremarkable. …energy things and stuff I did, but it… Yeah, no, nothing like that. They were all what Roger Linden would call experience. You know, experiences, it was nice experiences.

Rick Archer: Since you keep referring to Roger, I was aware of him, but I hadn’t really tuned into what he was about, but then I listened to several interviews or videos on your YouTube channel, in one of which he pretty much told his whole story. And I found him a very interesting guy, very likable. And it turns out he and I both have a TM background, and were teachers for a long time, although neither of us are anymore. But in any case, I really liked what I heard Roger saying. And a lot of it pertains to what you say and what we may talk about in this interview in in terms of naturalness, effortlessness, you know, not straining, not struggling, that kind of thing.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, yeah, I know he’s so great at talking about that in relation to well-being. So, you know, in a way, forget liberation, just how can there be more ease in an ordinary way in everyday life as well? You know, Roger’s really big on that, which I think is really important.

Rick Archer: Yeah, but since you have used the word liberation quite a bit in the book and we’ve just been discussing it, perhaps you could give us a simple definition of what you mean by the word. So in other words, what it is when you use that word, and also what it is not, because it’s one of those words, like awakening, that there could be so many different interpretations of that we better clarify our terminology, or otherwise we’ve got a Tower of Babel situation going here.

Monica Khosla: I’m really with you on that. For me, I think it refers to the end of the false sense of being a separate self. So the dropping away of that, you could call it an assumption. And particularly in the book, I’m sort of seeing it as an event in time that can be sort of studied, say, from a potential sort of quasi-scientific way. I mean, I’m not a I mean, maybe a real scientist could study it. There doesn’t seem to be much actual studying around what actually changes in terms of neuroscience in that moment. But yeah, that’s kind of what I’m interested in.

Rick Archer: So there was an event in time for you because you were in a yoga class and this shift happened. But I don’t want to put words in your mouth, but you would probably say, well, it wasn’t that I discovered something brand new that just came into existence. I just kind of realized, and again here, words are limited, but I realized what had always been the case and had never seen clearly before.

Monica Khosla: Absolutely. It was just like a little misassumption that dropped away. Yeah. Just like, it’s funny because how small it was, sort of experientially in that change, and yet it was just such a nice, just a little sort of relief, you know. I was like, “Oh, okay, that’s… Oh, it’s so much simpler than maybe it seemed. Life is so much simpler than it had seemed.”

Rick Archer: So you’ve given us a nutshell definition of what it is, the falling away of the false sense of a personal self. Could you itemize some things which it is not, that people might assume it is but are not the case?

Monica Khosla: Okay. I mean, there’s something to do with all this sort of special enlightenment business you know I think you get these very and maybe very accomplished and very beautiful teachers who are very maybe have wonderful energy and wonderful charisma and there may or may not be liberation there I’ve been reading a book by Mathieu Ricard you know the French translator for Dalai Lama hmm

Rick Archer: Right, I’m aware of him but I don’t think I’ve ever read any of his books.

Monica Khosla: He’s great, but this is actually his autobiography and he’s talking about these amazing Tibetan masters who were his teachers and you know that they’re that they’ve spent their whole lives meditating and studying these texts and doing these amazing things and I’m sure they’re extraordinary kind of human beings and you know just that that sense of something special whereas what I’m talking about is just the dropping away of a misassumption that doesn’t turn somebody into a special sort of higher being, I guess. Which I think there can be some muddling up around that sometimes. Is that what you meant?

Rick Archer: Yeah, that’s part of what I meant. I think we can probably, we’ll probably get in more stuff as we go along. But, you know, like here are some ideas that you often hear bandied about with regard to enlightenment or liberation, that you’re going to be perfect in some respect, you’re going to be incapable of making mistakes, you’re going to be compassionate all the time, you’re going to be blissful all the time, you’re going to sort of have…I mean, I’ve often heard people speak of their spiritual teacher as somebody who really knows where it’s at. And so-and-so said, and it’s like they’re implying that, well, since he or she said that, it must be true. I’ve even heard people attribute omniscience to their spiritual teachers.

Monica Khosla: Attribute what, sorry?

Rick Archer: Omniscience. You know, like if you and I had a spiritual teacher, we might say to each other, “Oh, well, so-and-so, our teacher, he or she is listening in on this conversation right now because they’re so enlightened that they know everything, everywhere, all at once,” which is, hey, good name for a movie, huh? And I’m not exaggerating. I’ve actually had arguments with people about this kind of thing. There was one woman who had a spiritual teacher and thought the teacher was omniscient and that she knew even what we were chatting in this chat group, and later on she got breast cancer and she was so shocked and disillusioned that the teacher hadn’t told her that she had breast cancer. She should have known! So all these superpowers are often attributed to so-called awakened or liberated or enlightened people.

Monica Khosla: I haven’t got any superpowers, sadly not.

Rick Archer: Shucks.

Monica Khosla: I know, I mean, who knows what goes on, maybe there are some people who have got some superpowers, I don’t know. Projection is a wonderful, wonderful thing, isn’t it? That, you know, that, that, I was just talking to somebody this morning who was talking about how when he talks to all sorts of different teachers or just listens to someone on the radio or podcast or something who he kind of has, is in awe of in some way, there’s a kind of opening up in him. And it’s like, I don’t think it’s got much to do with the actual teachers, it’s just something in him kind of, kind of relaxes a little bit and opens up and he feels better.

Rick Archer: That’s an interesting point. Yeah, there are instances of people following teachers who turned out to be quite corrupt in some way, but the person got tremendous inspiration and upliftment by virtue of their power of projection.

Monica Khosla: And also that, I mean, you were just doing that, like, you know, we can have this tightness and struggling and trying, and then we’re with somebody who seems to have the answers, and it’s just like, oh, what a relief. Yeah. So something, you know, lets go, opens, softens. Yeah, feels better.

Rick Archer: Which is not to say that nobody has the answers. On the one hand, there’s all this projection tendency and attributing more to teachers than they actually deserve. But on the other hand, there are people who know more than we do in just about any field of life, physics or economics or whatever, and maybe spirituality. I’m sure that the great sages and saints, in my way of thinking, were more evolved souls than the average person and obviously had something to impart.

Monica Khosla: Or the Tibetan masters that Mathieu Ricard is writing about.

Rick Archer: Yeah, Tibetan masters.

Monica Khosla: You know, he’s been their whole, yeah, they sound like incredible, incredible human beings. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So to me that’s different, but yeah, that’s not what I’m talking about.

Rick Archer: Right. So, at this point, let’s talk about your book a little bit. Give us a synopsis. How did you come up with the title and what are the first and last belief?

Monica Khosla: The book is about a neurobiological theory about like a hypothesis or a non-scientist’s perception of a possible explanation of that sudden change in relation to what may be happening in the brain. Only because I work as a therapist and I spend a lot of time particularly studying and training in trauma therapy, which is a lot around nervous systems and neurobiology and I’m just interested in that stuff. And I read a book called Unlocking the Emotional Brain by Bruce Ecker and his colleagues which is all about something called memory reconsolidation theory. And that book provided a hypothesis or explanation of the sudden transformative changes that can occasionally suddenly happen in therapy. And they are quite rare. They’re more like sometimes happen with certain techniques and certain sort of modern techniques are sort of geared around this now to actually generate this particular mechanism or way to update the brain. And it just seemed, when I read it, this book came out in 2012, the liberation thing happened in 2009. When I read it, it just seemed like, oh, that’s a description of what happens in the yoga class. it sounded like the same kind of thing. And I’ve, all that time since then, sometimes when I’d be talking to Roger Linden and I’ve got another friend called Roger Hart who I do talk about some of these things with as well, I’d always be saying memory reconsolidation theory to all sorts of things. I’d be saying it could be that. And I’ve watched a lot of conferences of people in the therapy world, in the trauma world, also a lot of things come across from the sort of contemplative traditions, which therapy is much more mindfulness-based these days, so there’s a lot of things coming in from that, and the neuroscientists. So there’s a lot of things now where people are talking about all these kind of things together and about research and what’s going on. And more and more they’ve been talking about this false sense of separation and what they call non-dual states and things like this. And there was, there has been, or there was a kind of, not exactly frustration, but something along those lines, because people seem to keep missing the point just around this particular thing. And I guess it’s one of those things that if it’s not obvious, you just can’t see it. So they would all be talking about the sense of self and non-dual states with a little bit of lack of insight from this perspective. And so, eventually I wrote an email to a neuroscientist who I heard talking and read his book saying, you know, you all seem to be missing this particular phenomenon of that sudden change in relation to the sense of separation. They were hypothesizing about what it was and stuff, but they weren’t really acknowledging that it can seem to suddenly change in that way. And I never got a reply. I sent him a second one and I still didn’t get a reply. And then one morning I went for a run and I do, I run occasionally, not very far and not very fast, but I do run. And that title, The First and Last Belief, a Theory of Liberation in the Age of Neuroscience, kind of just, I don’t know, my mind came up with it and I came home and and wrote it down and started writing a book. And it was quite surprising, but it was kind of fun too, to start sort of spelling it out and learning how to try to give a language to these things that I hadn’t really spoken about.

Rick Archer: Yeah. I’ve always been a believer in there being a neurophysiological correlate to not only liberation or awakening or higher states of consciousness, but to everything. I mean, right now you and I are speaking and 40 people are listening right now on YouTube. And the act of our speaking and in them, the act of their listening is causing or involving all kinds of things in the brain. Far more complex than we could possibly conceive and more complex than scientists yet understand. But there’s definitely a neurophysiological correlation to every little experience, the smell of a rose. Or if we go to sleep or dream, we know that those are distinct states of consciousness, distinct from waking state. Each has their own neurophysiological and brainwave signatures. In any case, if awakening or liberation is distinctly different than ordinary waking state, in some respects, as all the traditions say it is, then there is probably a distinct neurophysiological signature to it, which a lot of scientists have been trying to study in terms of brainwaves and fMRI scans and all kinds of other things that can be done. And indeed, you know, it’s been found that 40-50 year meditators have a much thicker prefrontal cortex and a whole different style of brainwave coherence and functioning and many many many other measures. And that’s why It’s important not to abuse your body or neurophysiology. It’s the instrument through which you experience anything in life and also through which you experience higher states of consciousness or awakening or whatever term we want to use. And that’s also why various techniques such as meditation or yoga or breath work or all the different things people can do, even psychedelics, produce neurophysiological changes, and those changes can be cumulative, are cumulative. Now you say sudden shift, but you did a lot of things over the years before you had that sudden shift. And if you had just been like drinking heavily every day, up until that date 17 years ago, it’s unlikely that you would have had that shift because your brain and your whole neurophysiology would have been in a different condition. So anyway, that’s a mouthful, but what do you think about all that?

Monica Khosla: What do I think? I was just thinking of Wayne Liquorman. I don’t, was he an alcoholic? I don’t know. – He had been. Cast aspersions.

Rick Archer: The name and form, he had been an alcoholic and then he kicked the habit and got into Ramesh Balsekar and eventually had an awakening of some kind.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, I’m not sure you know, well I mean obviously I’m not sure, I don’t really know at all. But, because to me it’s not a state change, it’s just a…

Rick Archer: A stage change.

Monica Khosla: It’s just like there wasn’t, it’s like we have all sorts of assumptions and beliefs, conditionings in the system and occasionally some of those are kind of contradicted by present experience and they drop away. And on some level what I’m kind of suggesting is it’s that in a funny way that smaller thing okay it’s a it’s quite a core assumption and maybe it is quite important developmentally to feel like a separate self it may well be relevant to brain development. But the sort of identification as something is it’s not anything it is like you know maybe that one of those core beliefs in therapy about unlovable or you know unacceptable whatever in some way it’s it’s a primary belief that might be affecting a lot of somebody’s life but it probably doesn’t have that much in the brain that goes with it so if that changes it’s it’s just one belief that’s gone in a funny way way or part of the model of reality has just shifted?

Rick Archer: Yeah, but I think it’s more substantial and fundamental than just changing a particular belief. Like, you know, maybe you don’t believe in UFOs and then you see a UFO, you read a book about them or something and now you believe in them, that doesn’t necessarily create an abiding difference in every moment of your life thereafter. But I suspect that you would say that this little thing that happened was a watershed moment, and ever since then you’ve had a different orientation, regardless of what thoughts you’re thinking or what other things you believe or don’t believe and so on. It was a, it may not have been dramatic, but it was a significant shift.

Monica Khosla: And I would turn it around slightly with the UFO thing. So it’s more like, you know, you believed in UFOs and maybe had some reasoning for it and, you know, had some experiences when you were young. And at some point you saw through it and you saw, oh, there just couldn’t possibly be UFOs. And that dropped away. And maybe believing in UFOs went with maybe all sorts of angst or I don’t know patterns or habits in the system that were there for dealing with UFOs and then suddenly I don’t need to deal with UFOs. So it’s just like, oh, that’s a relief. It’s more like that. Or maybe if you and I weren’t going to be abducted by aliens, you know, you spend your whole life being worried you’re going to be abducted by aliens and then you realize, oh no, that’s just not going to happen and then it’s like, what a relief.

Rick Archer: Yeah, I could see that. Maybe the belief in Santa Claus dropping away changes you as you grow up. I’m just kind of accustomed to thinking of liberation in the spiritual sense as more, not dramatic, but more significant and life-changing than the acquisition or rejection of any old belief, you know, all the many other things we may or may not believe, like we love this particular politician or we like a certain kind of food and then we don’t or, you know, those things are relatively superficial compared to what we’re discussing here.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, and I call it the first belief.

Rick Archer: First meaning primordial or fundamental, right?

Monica Khosla: Yeah, and maybe in the development of a little baby, if we imagine a little baby, maybe, you know, to begin with, maybe, you know, presumably, no sense of separation. just experience happening and no sense of existing as something or just it’s just experience and at some point those little people seem to start kind of owning experience, kind of starting to view the world as an agent, as a doer, as somebody who could have a choice, who could make things happen, who doesn’t like the way that things are and thinks they should be different and all of that kind of stuff and it seems like maybe there’s something here you know I think in healthy in healthy systems life appears from sort of from a perspective that is sort of inside here you know it’s like we view the world around us from a perspective. The way that the brain creates a representation of reality and that’s a big jump. I think you might understand what I mean but I guess people listening probably might not necessarily. Should I explain that about the brain creating a representation?

Rick Archer: Do you ever read that article by Thomas Nagel called “What is it like to be a bat?”

Monica Khosla: No, but I can imagine.

Rick Archer: Yeah, and it’s a popular phrase now in consciousness studies of whether, and Bernardo Kastrup uses this a lot, and it’s also discussed in AI circles where they’re trying to determine whether AI is conscious, but the phrase is, is there something that it’s like to be this thing, you know, to be a bat, to be an AI, to be a mouse, or whatever. Do they have a subjective experience? And how far can you take it? Does an amoeba have a subjective experience. So, anyway.

Monica Khosla: Yeah. Yes, so we assume in a sort of bat brain or an amoeba brain that somehow constructs some kind of version of a possible real world.

Rick Archer: Right. And all beings do this.

Monica Khosla: That’s what we’re certainly taught, aren’t we, in sort of biology? I don’t know, I never study biology properly. But I think, you know, that’s the general understanding is that sense perceptions are turned by the brain into some kind of version of reality. And now we’re also told that the brain factors in lots and lots of assumptions, predictions about what it expects to be there in order to create the experience that we’re having. So it’s vast majority of it is the brain’s prediction of what it expects to be here. It’s not the thing itself. Does that make sense?

Rick Archer: Yeah, you use the the princess and the pea story in your book about how the the the prince was able to determine that this woman was really a princess because she felt the pea under 20 mattresses and couldn’t sleep properly. But there’s another fable of the princess and the pin where a princess was told she was going to get pricked by a pin and she just went through all this angst and conniption fits and everything for a long time until she finally got pricked by the pin and it was like, oh, that’s no big deal. So she’s kind of laying on all these assumptions based upon an idea.

Monica Khosla: That’s what our brains do, that they’re laying on assumptions. It’s just how they work. based on, it’s energy saving I think, the idea that there may or may not be an actual real world, because we can’t experience it directly.

Rick Archer: Well there was one point in your book which you actually said, “I don’t really know if I have a brain.” You know, you could cut the top of my head off and all, but even that would just be an appearance in consciousness. And there’s a phrase in Vedanta, I want to throw around a few phrases in this conversation, called “mithya” which is the idea that there’s something there. It’s not that there’s nothing there, but that it’s not what you think it is. So, and they commonly use the analogy of a rope mistaken as a snake and the guy gets all scared because he thinks the snake’s going to bite him and all. But there is something there. There’s a rope. It’s not like there’s nothing there, but it’s not what it appears to be.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, but for a moment the brain might have produced a representation of a snake So there might have been just for a moment the scene appeared as if there was a literal snake and then looking closer It’s known it’s not a snake and it’s the brains of update, you know, it’s sort of updated itself and it’s a rope

Rick Archer: yeah,

Monica Khosla: but for a moment the representation of life included a snake

Rick Archer: And so what you’re saying is this is happening all the time, right? We go through life misperceiving everything.

Monica Khosla: Who knows if it’s misperceiving or perceiving because we’ve only got what we experience. We’ve only got this representation or construction and that’s all that can be known in that way.

Rick Archer: In that way. So what does liberation do to that equation?

Monica Khosla: It kind of makes it obvious. It makes it obvious that what is being perceived isn’t a separate solid world in the way that it might have seemed to be. be. So and what’s interesting is this does seem to fit with neuroscience now. It’s one of the things and I guess one of the things that’s important about Roger Linden is he’s always tried to express this and I heard it when he used to talk about non-duality in Totnes and I couldn’t really hear what he was saying. And then after liberation I remember having a conversation with him once and And he said, “There could be a real world, you know.” And I’m like, “What? What do you mean there could be a real world?” Because from how things seem now, it’s just like there’s just this, and what this is, is obviously consciousness. Everything’s sort of appearing in consciousness. It’s all sort of made of consciousness. It’s, you know, I’m calling consciousness the sort of, what everything is and everything appears in. the absolute yeah something I you know I don’t know what any of it is but it was kind of obvious that it it wasn’t the it wasn’t this separate something in here looking out a separate world it was more this is all the same stuff it’s like an appearance in consciousness something anyway Ross just said there could be a real world and I was a bit cross with him and I said where would it be? You know, it’s like, how, and you know, how could we ever know it? And he said, well, it would just be where it appears to be, but it just can’t ever be directly known because we only get the brain’s representation of it. But it was, then it was like, oh okay, so yeah, so actually, you know, it’s quite possible that there is a brain, that this is a representation by a brain. We can think about things in brain terms, we don’t know, we can’t ever directly know because we can’t experience directly the thing itself, we just have the representations. And that’s also what people who wrote about a writer had, you know, that they, but they didn’t have neuroscience. So they were also trying to describe this thing, but they didn’t even have the neuroscience version of things to explain it. They were just describing what appears.

Rick Archer: Yeah. And I still think that they have, they realize some things that neuroscience doesn’t yet have a clue about and it will benefit from learning at some point. And since we’re referring to that old tradition, you know, some people say, “Well, why do we have to bother with all these old Sanskrit terms and everything?” But it’s like, if you really want to understand snow, you know, talk to an Eskimo, talk to an Inuit. They have like 30-something names for snow because they have been dealing with it so long and so much that they have all these different… And a skier would would have the same. There’s corn snow, powder snow, you know, there’s all kinds of different things. But same with consciousness. I mean, these people have been studying it intellectually and experientially for thousands of years, and they have a very nuanced vocabulary that has no direct equivalence in English. And so a couple of handy terms here. One is the absolute level, to use the English word, which they call Paramarthika. And it’s the idea that Brahman or Atman alone is ultimately real. There is no independently existing individual self or universe for that matter. But then there’s the empirical or transactional level, which they call vyavaharika, and that is the world in which we live, which includes bodies, minds, persons, actions, ethics, relationships, learning, and all of that within our lived experience. And Neo-Advaita tends to lean too heavily on the paramarthika, the absolute perspective, and dismiss the transactional level, the vyavaharika, and just hammers away at, you know, “You don’t exist, the world doesn’t exist, the whole thing is an illusion,” all this stuff. That is not a practical teaching for the average person. There are some scriptures which devote themselves to that perspective, like the Mandukya Upanishad and the Ashtavakra Gita, but in general there are a great variety of teachings and teachers covering the whole spectrum of reality so as to meet everybody at a level that is relevant and useful to them and then lead them from there. So in any case, from this perspective, there is a personal self, it is just not ultimately It’s not ultimately substantial, but it has gross and subtle components to it. The gross body and the subtle body, which is called the antahkarana, which consists of the mind, the intellect, memory, impressions, and what is called the ahamkara or the eye maker, the sense that there’s a me in a sense. And again, not ultimately real, but practically necessary in order to function in the world.

Monica Khosla: Is that a question?

Rick Archer: No. It was a pontification, but you’re welcome to comment on it.

Monica Khosla: No, it’s interesting. I don’t quite know what to say. You know, because like I’m with you, I think the way that they describe things is incredible, really. They were able to meditate and contemplate way before the neuroscience, You know and and and kind of have have that you know have some very wise Perspective on it, but you know what pictures beyond you know beyond My understanding in that kind of way And yet sometimes it does seem like yeah They are trying to point to something that put on a point sometimes trying to point towards the same thing that I’m talking about

Rick Archer: Yeah, yeah And I think what you’re doing is really valuable because we need to put all this ancient knowledge in modern terminology and investigate it with modern technologies as well, such as EEG and fMRI and all that stuff. I think, I gave a talk about 10 years ago at the Science and Nonduality Conference about how science and spirituality are not at all conflicting with one another. can actually be comrades or colleagues in the search for a more complete understanding of the universe, of ourselves.

Monica Khosla: It’s just interesting, isn’t it? I mean, I have this sense of the, you know, it’s very obvious the ultimate unknowability of what on earth is going on. We can’t really know anything for sure, but science, and particularly modern neuroscience, is really interesting. And it seems to map and match with experience. So yeah, I think that’s what got me interested in writing my book because it matched and mapped with so much of my clients’ experiences and then they get to this one area and it goes a bit messy. And so that’s kind of what interests me.

Rick Archer: What’s the area that gets messy?

Monica Khosla: The false sense of separation and the end of the false sense of separation or what they they call non-dual states or that kind of thing. It’s sort of…

Rick Archer: Why is that messy?

Monica Khosla: To talk about non-dual states?

Rick Archer: Yeah. It’s just difficult to talk about, is that what you’re saying?

Monica Khosla: I’m not sure what it means, non-dual states, I guess, because generally, and again, I don’t know what people are talking about, but there can be all sorts of states and experiences and like I had when I was younger of those sort of sense of oneness and expansion and everything is me. And there was still that assumption of separation was still in place. It was overlooked all the time and it’s they seemed like my experiences. It seemed like sometimes I’m contracted and small, sometimes I am everything, sometimes and yet the subtle sort of implicit automatic sense of it being my experience, of being some kind of experiencer, was still there. And I think that with a lot of the description of non-dual states, they’re talking about lovely experiences, but it’s not technically non-duality.

Rick Archer: Right. Ken Wilber has a handy terminology here. He distinguishes states from stages. And what you just described of all these wonderful experiences you had when you were younger, and what people describe in, “Oh, I had this great meditation,” or “I had this far-out psychedelic experience,” or whatever, those are all states which are transitory. But stages, in Wilber’s terminology, are more stable. You can have all kinds of states, but then a stage would be something which doesn’t fluctuate. There was a story about Ramana Maharshi when Papaji first came to him. He had been a Krishna devotee and he showed up late or something and Ramana said, “Where have you been?” He said, “Well, I was hung up because I was playing with Lord Krishna.” And Ramana said, “Oh, is he here now?” In other words, Ramana was trying to point to something which doesn’t come and go.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, and he had a lovely experience and so what?

Rick Archer: Yeah, the unreal has no being, the real never ceases to be. So that’s what I was trying to get at when you were talking about, well, this dropping of belief. Because belief I think of usually as just a thought or a kind of a conditioning or something which is not stable. Something can overturn it. But I have a feeling that this shift that you underwent is more fundamental and abiding than just a belief which might just come and go. Some people actually find this, that as a result of some kind of spiritual awakening, they think, “Wait a minute, am I getting senile? I just can’t remember things, or I don’t remember much of my past.” And I usually, I mean maybe that’s a possibility, but I usually feel like it’s actually a sign of, in most cases, of the mind beginning to function in a more efficient way where it’s not cluttered with all kinds of extraneous thoughts all the time. Thoughts come when they’re needed and otherwise the mind might be quite silent when thinking isn’t needed. You’re not just going to be obsessing about something endlessly.

Monica Khosla: I think mine’s probably got more to do with menopause and aging than anything else. So yeah, I wouldn’t attribute it to anything special.

Rick Archer: We’ll rack it up to some spiritual thing.

Monica Khosla: I don’t think so. No worries. I don’t think so. You know, yeah, it’s all just happening and it’s funny when, yeah, things appear and disappear.

Rick Archer: You’ve been alluding to something which was always there but which you had overlooked and then when your liberation shift happened, you became aware of it or began to appreciate it or something like that, right?

Monica Khosla: I would say it slightly differently. I would say that there was a little assumption going on, a kind of embodied belief. That’s what I was going to come back to about the belief thing. So, which was overlooked? There was a little layer on top of things which was being overlooked. It wasn’t that the nature of reality was kind of, I’m calling it the nature of reality also, I don’t want to be like, oh, I know what reality is or something, but I just mean that the absence of this particular assumption seems simple and it wasn’t necessary. So, that this kind of sense of being an experiencer, a doer of life on some level, had some kind of tightness or little bit of embodied stress, I think, associated with it. And when that kind of just released or just kind of let go, it was just obvious how simple life is, I think. It was more, the kind of simplicity was overlooked because there was all this complicatedness on top of it.

Rick Archer: Yeah. I think that’s a good description. layers upon layers of complicatedness in the average person’s psyche and makeup and awakening is often referred to as the simplest state, simplest form of awareness sometimes.

Monica Khosla: Yeah. And there can be all sorts of states within that but there’s a simplicity that’s still there no matter what the state.

Rick Archer: Yeah. Simple can also mean settled. The second verse of the Yoga Sutras is “Yoga is the cessation of the fluctuations of the mind” and usually when like an ocean let’s say is all turbulent and frothy and dizzy and waves and thrashing about and all that stuff it’s a very kind of agitated condition but you know if the ocean settles down there’s no wind and it becomes glassy and smooth and it can reflect the sunlight brilliantly compared to a choppy water, which relates back to the Yoga Sutra’s point. It’s that yoga is the cessation of all these fluctuations. And then the next verse is, “Then the seer rests in the self,” once the fluctuations stop. And of course, that doesn’t mean you can’t go on and engage in activity and have thoughts and actions and all that. But this settled, simple condition becomes ingrained and thus abides throughout the most dynamic activity. So you can be playing basketball or tennis or running or watching a movie or whatever, but at the same time there’s this pure, settled, quiet condition. Does that resonate with your experience?

Monica Khosla: I mean to me that sounds like a wonderful maybe result of meditation potentially, couldn’t it be or practice that this is that there can be a calming and a quietening and there could still be a sense of being a doer rather than just everything’s just happening, which is the simplicity in a way is just the I guess maybe maybe more like it is for a baby or a baby. I imagine that experience to be much more chaotic because their brain hasn’t got all sorts of conditionings that my brain still has. But, um, so it’s more like just lots of different weather passing through or just, yeah, moving my hands about it’s, the hands are just moving about, uh, seeing you, um, some sensations, everything is sort of equal or just happening and none of it’s personal even though I could say well that’s Monica’s hand somehow it’s it’s not a personal as it is our personal qualities strange it’s hard to describe

Rick Archer: yeah yeah I agree with what you said one could cultivate with meditation a quiet state of mind and yet still be gripping a sense of doer, doership or ownership of one’s actions and then eventually that could give way to not having that sense of ownership and yes, having the kind of spontaneity of everything is just unfolding naturally through the activities of the “Gunas of Nature” as the Bhagavad Gita puts it. But paradoxically, even in that state, at least in my experience and understanding, there is still volition and discernment and qualities like that. Well, just let me throw a couple of Gita verses at you and then let you respond. One is that, yes, the gunas of nature do everything, and he who takes himself to be the doer is like a thief who is misappropriating the ownership of action. He’s not really the doer. But then there’s other verses which say, “You have control over action alone, never over its fruits. You know, get up, take action, do this.” And I think both those things can coexist within the same personality, the same experience.

Monica Khosla: I think there’s something about choice and the possibility of choice which can also be part of what appears. And it’s a really helpful thing, you know, people have no sense of choice that there could then be a sort of belief, well I’m doomed or whatever. the sense of openness to what arises might feel like choice or responsiveness. The thing here is just that none of it’s personal. So whatever appears, it’s just what’s appearing and sometimes it’s bad behavior or uncomfortable feelings or something that sounds really cool, but it’s just, It’s just kind of, in one way you could say what Monica’s system is producing or how it’s responding and it’s all very creative. You know everything, all of life is very creative and in that sort of action or generating.

Rick Archer: Well do you have a sense of choice? Let’s say you choose which dress should I put on today or what shall I have for lunch or should I do this BatGap interview or not, or maybe your husband sort of annoys you or something and there’s an impulse to speak sharply, but then you check the impulse because you think, “Well, that won’t really be helpful.” So there’s a little bit of volition there. And I’m often reminded of the nursery rhyme, “Row, row, row your boat gently down the stream.” It’s like the stream is really carrying you along, but there’s a little paddling you can do that just sort of like nudges it this way and that. Do I want to hit this log? No, I think I’ll just put the oar in and go that way. It’s gentle, it’s subtle, but it’s still something.

Monica Khosla: Funny thing is that, say there could be any of those things if you like, like, I hate using all this seems and appears like and arising but that’s it’s quite hard to say it without using those words. So any of those things could happen but it’s still not personal. So that sense of volition or being a chooser if that was to appear would be a sense of volition or choosing but it’s simpler than that. that. It’s just more like this one little, it’s so hard to describe because when it’s obvious, it’s obvious and when it’s not, it sounds like gobbledygook and I’m aware people can just tune out when I try and describe it.

Rick Archer: Well, do you feel like there’s anything in your life which is personal? Do you have children? No. No children?

Monica Khosla: I have nieces and nephews. I have a husband.

Rick Archer: Nieces and nephews? Pets? A husband? See, what I’m trying to get at is I believe that there can be the personal and the impersonal simultaneously, even though they might be and seem like different dimensions or something, but they’re not mutually exclusive. And we could say the personal is not ultimately real, but it’s still a thing. I mean, if you go out in the backyard with a hammer and whack a rock with that hammer, and then put your thumb on the rock and whack your thumb, you’re gonna notice a difference between those two whacks. One of them is gonna get real personal in some way.

Monica Khosla: You could say it’s personal but it’s just that personal term is kind of trying to describe the difference in the sense of, you know, like extreme pain or love or appreciation of somebody. All those things experience our life. It’s just that that sense of personalness isn’t part of it. so impossible to describe, which is why nobody ever manages to say it clearly, I think. Maybe the enlightened people were better at that. But, yes, absolutely life is full of richness and experience and Monica, this personality, responds and does things and has a history and memories of all sorts of things. But there’s also, it’s also completely obvious that this moment now is kind of all that can be known directly. And it’s so straightforward in that way. So that there’s, you know, ideas and thoughts and memory all kind of, can appear presently and there could be a story about something else. But life is really immediate. And not, no part of what’s going on is more or less personal. Even though Monica might be really cross with you if you hit her with a hammer. I’d rather you didn’t.

Rick Archer: I won’t. I was suggesting you try hitting yourself.

Monica Khosla: I understand.

Rick Archer: Besides, I’m not in England. And even if I were, I wouldn’t hit you with a hammer. Thank you. What I’m trying to suggest is that the personal and the impersonal can coexist. And what you seem to be saying is, no, there is no personal whatsoever. And I’m wondering if this is a semantic problem where we’re not defining personal properly. But you know, you have a personal relationship with your husband and your nieces and your lunch and things like that. I am not having those experiences. I am having personal experiences over here. And at the same time, there’s a non-dual, impersonal field, that field that Rumi says beyond right and wrong, there’s a field, I’ll meet you there, which we share in common.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, it’s so hard to get across because it sounds like that. It can sound sort of just really annoying and you can never find the right word, you know, you could say, okay, it’s not personal to try and express something, but then it’ll say, well, but isn’t that personal? Isn’t that personal? And you could say, well, yeah, okay, yeah, my nieces are my personal nieces. But the thing that I’m trying to express is inexpressible. I think that’s the problem that we have. And often it’s not helpful to even try and describe it because people will try and understand what you’re saying, but they can’t.

Rick Archer: Yeah. I think maybe one way of going at it is that for most people, their personal experience as an individual is all they know. It’s not only predominant, it’s exclusive to their experience. And for someone like yourself, there is, well, pardon my assumption, but there is still personal experience, but it’s not predominant. Just as Advaita says, there’s still an “I” sense, but it’s no longer taken to be ultimate or ultimately real. The impersonal, or that which is more fundamental than any individual expression, has become the predominant stance from which life is lived. But that doesn’t utterly eradicate any sense of duality or personalization. If it did, we could walk in front of buses and not know that there was any distinction between them and our bodies. There’s a phrase in Advaita called lesha avidya, which means faint remains of ignorance. And it said that that’s essential if you’re going to be alive. You have to have some sense of duality and individualization and personalization in order to function as a human being as long as you are living as one.

Monica Khosla: Actually helped me to remember the thing that I kept forgetting before.

Rick Archer: Good, there we go.

Monica Khosla: So, see that sense of experiencing life from a kind of central point. So, you know, so Rick is kind of looking out at a particular room or on the screen and maybe has a sense of space around and all that kind of thing. It’s like there’s a central point from which life is experienced. Something like that?

Rick Archer: Are you asking, is that a question?

Monica Khosla: Yeah, I’m just checking that in some way…

Rick Archer: Well, there is and there isn’t.

Monica Khosla: Even if it, yeah. But experientially, that’s the field of awareness, the visual field, say, is sort of based around a sort of central point. Like there’s a sort of out to one side, to the other side and there’s over there.

Rick Archer: Yeah, the visual field is, but the actual experience is, if I could put it in three words, I’m everywhere, I’m nowhere, and I’m right here.

Monica Khosla: So, and in terms of the visual field, there’s a perceiving that seems like it’s from a particular place.

Rick Archer: Sure.

Monica Khosla: Which is really healthy.

Rick Archer: I’m not seeing things from the perspective of down the street, I’m seeing them from this perspective here.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, or from the ceiling or, you know. like, so there’s this fairly stable sense of, you know, the visual field. And maybe also within that might be a sense of where sounds are happening and things like that. And I think that is really important and that is still the case, you know, for me. So that’s how, um, the visual field appears and all that kind of thing. And I suspect that that has something to do with the development of the sense of actually existing as something in here that’s experiencing life. You know, maybe for that little baby, that little toddler, there starts to be some sense of being something inside that experiences a separate world and something that exists. And it seems to have a physical embodied quality somehow that, you know, until people start questioning it, they will just assume on some level that they’re the body or in the head or something like that. You might have all sorts of experiences that suggest otherwise of expansion or non-location in a sort of more profound way. Is that right?

Rick Archer: Sure. And most people, that’s their world. This is me. I’m in this body and that’s all I am. And when this body dies, I’ll cease to exist or maybe I’ll go to heaven or something, but there’s not this sense of expansiveness or unboundedness or being far more than just what is confined within the body.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, and so maybe for that little person whose brain’s developing, there’s some kind of that start of identification which you could say, “I am, I exist,” seems to have something to do with this maybe experiencing from a particular place, and it helps to have a sense of how to negotiate the world and the way the brain makes sense of things. It’s just, it seems to be a developmental thing. And then people start to question it and then they go, well, you know, am I, you know, what am I? And they start questioning all that stuff. And in some way it seems like there’s, you know, in some way there’s some subtle sense that I am something. And it might be that it has a particular location in the body or a sense of it having a location in the body. It might be something that maybe doesn’t have a location anymore. It just has a sense, there’s just a sense of witnessing or perceiving or something that can expand and contract. And it’s somehow it’s all me or I feel like contained or restrained within life. But this is like, the liberation is like when that little identification as something, anything that could expand and contract drops away. Everything is still the same. It’s just that there’s not this sense of me in life. There’s just life, including Monica’s personal experience. It’s all Monica’s personal experience because that’s that’s how life appears to Monica. Yeah. So you could say it’s all personal, but it doesn’t feel personal. It doesn’t have that sense of it’s mine or that there’s any, as if it’s been an experience or an agent with that. It’s just life.

Rick Archer: A friend of mine used to say with regard to the ocean analogy, of course I’m a wave. I’m just not only a wave. That’s what the wave might say once it realizes is that it’s actually just the whole ocean. But, you know, it’s a particular wave is saying this and it has an identity as a wave, but it’s really nothing separate from the entire ocean. And yet we see waves, we can surf on them or get knocked over by them or whatever. So it’s a both-and kind of a thing.

Monica Khosla: And it can seem that it could be identification with the wave, or there could be identification with the ocean, or the rug could be pulled out from the identification. So the sense of being something, whether it’s the wave or the ocean, just dissolves and then there’s just ocean, but there’s no sense of being something, it’s just, it’s just all happening.

Rick Archer: Yeah, I don’t know, analogies begin to break down after a while. But let’s skip to a question at this point ’cause I have one here. Let me pull it up. Here it is. So this is from someone named Joanna Waters in Devon. Is Devon near you?

Monica Khosla: I know Joanna. I know Joanna. She said she might, yeah.

Rick Archer: Okay, so here’s what she asked. When a piece of plain paper with a dot is held up, I should have made a graphic, and the question “What do you see?” is asked, most people will say “a dot.” It can then be pointed out that there is a page on which the dot is drawn, without which the dot couldn’t exist. Would you relate this to the sense of separation and to the nature of reality? That’s actually relevant to what we’re talking about.

Monica Khosla: And yeah, she told me she was going to ask something along these lines. Maybe she was changing the question slightly. And yeah, it is very relevant in as much as, you know, it seems to me almost like a koan, a zen koan, you know, you could sit with this piece of paper with the dot on it, or the image of the piece of paper with a dot on it, and maybe something, you know, it could be then identifying with the dot or identifying with the paper, and at some point maybe it’s just obvious it’s just a dot on a piece of paper, you know, it’s, you know, I think Joanna’s sense is, yeah, you know, the dot could be could be this separation and the identification as something and then as a something small and then you have the paper is consciousness. But yeah I think that’s what often happens with people they feel like this moving between identifying as consciousness and identifying as the dot and it’s the identifying itself which is the misassumption that I’m talking about. I’m also not trying to teach anybody anything, you know, I’ve just got this theory about what might have happened, so it’s not like I’m saying, “Oh, teach you about non-duality or something.” It’s just trying to describe the change in a possible theory for that.

Rick Archer: Yeah. Well, you know, I’m learning things. I learn things all the time from everybody. I don’t mind if someone… You don’t have to call it teaching, but you’re expressing a viewpoint which is interesting and and discussions like this which I have all the time not only during interviews but during my walks in the woods talking to friends it just helps to clarify understanding. There’s three stages of or aspects of spiritual practice in Vedanta. One is called shravana which just means hearing a thing like watching a YouTube video or reading a book or something. Another is manana, which is really thinking about it. Don’t just watch the video, but watch it ten times and discuss it with friends and like really get into what is it saying. And the third is nididhyasana, which is do something which will actually make it a visceral experience, not just an intellectual concept. Some meditation or something, some practice which can make it a living experience. And so what we’re doing here is kind of the the manana aspect that we’re hashing it out, discussing things and thinking about things. And it has an important role to play, I think, on the spiritual path.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, and I really appreciate that. I was saying to Paul before, it’s so nice to be able to talk about this stuff. I haven’t got anything to gain from talking about it. I’d like to sell a few more books, but I’m not selling anything. I’m not a teacher, I’m not trying to convince anybody of anything. But it’s nice to find the language to talk about things. It’s interesting.

Rick Archer: Yeah, and it’s edifying. Think of how much chit-chat goes on in the world over trivial nonsense that has no lasting significance. The philosophers and spiritual leaders have said, “Don’t fritter away your life. Focus on this deeper stuff and you’ll appreciate it in the end.” I heard a story recently where some young fellow saw this 90-year-old monk and he just seemed so wise and peaceful and he said to him, “How can I get to be like you are when I’m in my 90s?” And the old fellow said, “Start now.”

Monica Khosla: It’s wise.

Rick Archer: Yeah. It’s cumulative. It really is. What you give your attention to grows stronger in your life.

Monica Khosla: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, and I never talked about this stuff. You know, not really for a long time. And it’s interesting to express it and talk about it.

Rick Archer: Yeah, absolutely. It’s the most interesting thing there is, in my opinion. So do you have more time? I could ask you a few more questions.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, I can stay as long as you want, Rick.

Rick Archer: OK, great. So what impact did this shift have on your personal life? Did it make it less vivid and interesting or more so or, you know, more immediate and intimate? Did your friendships get deeper? I mean, anything, what kind of ramifications did it have?

Monica Khosla: I think the words immediate and intimate are good ones. You know, I think that’s a good description. I asked Paul and he said, yeah, like less inhibition in some way, you know, like, so just a bit freer maybe.

Rick Archer: noticed that in you?

Monica Khosla: I asked him, you know, would you say there’s a difference? But I mean, this is, again, we’re talking about something for a long time ago and who knows how personalities change anyway.

Rick Archer: Sure.

Monica Khosla: But there’s less fear. I used to be a bit afraid of people and that could possibly something if somebody was really scary and dangerous I might feel scared of them now, but in general, you know, it’s very easy to connect with people, to enjoy people.

Rick Archer: Interesting, you just dropped that little nugget there. You said, “If somebody was really scary and dangerous, I might be afraid of them now.” When you say something like that, it sure does sound like there’s still some sense of a person who could be afraid and could be harmed potentially.

Monica Khosla: and yeah. So this you know it’s weird because it’s impossible to again to describe it you know just what that little little change is but absolutely Monica’s biological system if we you know if we want to talk about really impersonal terms could could respond to a threat you know and one of the things I talked about in my book was learning to speak in public before I went to a particular experience on my training course where a particular pattern in me of getting quite tight in talking about myself dropped away. I don’t think we’d be having this conversation in the way that we are. Because I would get kind of tight and get a lot of sort of fast heart rate and activation and it was kind of freed up after liberation in as much as it, I think I did still speak, but it wasn’t, you know, it was a bit gnarly really when I spoke. Whereas now I’m learning how to speak or how to express things and talk about things that ironically might seem more personal. I just didn’t as a younger person speak about anything personal.

Rick Archer: So this liberation event happened 17 years ago. Do you feel like over the past 17 years there has been a continuous maturation or deepening or something of it?

Monica Khosla: Not in that way. Not in, like the fundamental thing hasn’t changed.

Rick Archer: The fundamental thing, but perhaps the embodiment or the manifestation of it. There’s a quote from Nisargadatta towards the very end of his life where he said, “Forget I am that.” That was his book. He said, “I’ve learned so much more since then. It’s so much deeper.”

Monica Khosla: Yeah, Nisargadatta is confusing. You know, I wrote about him in the questions and answers bit at the end of my book because he’ll say something, yeah, that whole end thing is kind of interesting, like wondering what was he talking about before if he’s talking about that now. Yeah, who knows? A lot of people talk about this and use the language and we just don’t know, you know, if they’re talking about the same thing or not. But in terms of, I think the recognition of impersonalness in that way and sort of timelessness, you know, that this, the, yeah, it’s really hard to say this without just turning people off, I think because trying to describe it just sounds so alien to people I think or they try and fit it with what they Think they know But yeah, the fundamental Sense of how things are in that way hasn’t changed.

Rick Archer: Okay, but I get that I keep I keep coming back to this Multidimensional thing. So the fundamental thing by its very nature couldn’t change or it wouldn’t be fundamental. But the the reflection of it in the Monica manifestation the expression the reflector that is Monica Has the let me put it this way So the mirror started reflecting the Sun clearly for the first time 17 years ago. You said, “Oh, yeah There’s the Sun being reflected.” But maybe there was still dust and mud and stuff on the mirror has the mirror gotten clearer over the 17 years So that the reflection is more full than it was then

Monica Khosla: I don’t know about the reflection being more full, but the personality, you know, all the dust and mud and the personality, I’m sure there’s still plenty of dust and mud in the personality, but some patterns do change. Just like I’m saying about communicating, you know, I’m still, you know, still got a long way to go, but I’m getting better at communicating.

Rick Archer: And perhaps these patterns are changing in ways they wouldn’t have if there hadn’t been this liberation breakthrough?

Monica Khosla: There’s something I noticed that you know on the training course which I talk about my my book when I was doing my sensorimotor psychotherapy training or accreditation training and patterns in my system do seem to drop away a bit more easily it’s like there’s less protection in it so some of the outer layers of almost you know avoiding feeling shame avoiding feeling those really vulnerable, difficult feelings. There seems to be less of that and so when those things can be freely felt it’s more like some misunderstandings and misassumptions. Other ones can kind of be seen through and drop away. So yeah and so if I have, I am trained in EMDR, you know the eye movement thing and when I was on an EMDR course my brain would just process things so quickly. So you know it just take a bit of that and it would be done and they couldn’t quite believe it and they call the teacher over and they say, “No, I think it has processed.” Just because there seems to be less in the way of it.

Rick Archer: Yeah.

Monica Khosla: But there’s still, there was so much to start with, I think there’s still plenty more dust left. But in that way, things maybe get a bit easier.

Rick Archer: Yeah, I’m glad I asked you that question because I think that is definitely the case. And there’s various ways of making that happen. I mean, meditation does that in a way. you immerse yourself in a field of bliss and pure consciousness and whatever, and it kind of acts as a solvent to start loosening up stuff in your system. I heard Roger talking about this in your conversation with these knots of tension or trauma or whatever start to loosen when exposed to that level of deep, restful awareness, otherwise they might remain tightly bound for who knows how long.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, and it’s my experience that most things have a physical correlate, something physical that goes with them. So all these patterns in my system, like I was saying about the difficulty speaking in public or speaking about something personal, there was a tightness associated with it, some kind of holding, contracting. And often there’s some kind of contraction or collapse or something that goes with these patterns that we have that are maybe based on some misassumption about ourselves.

Rick Archer: And I think that in the Indian tradition, and also I think Buddhist, they would say that a lot of these patterns and conditionings are not only in the gross physiology or the psychology but in the subtle body. Some scars or impressions are lodged on a subtle level and even carry on from life to life. And that’s part of what’s being transformed in this process.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, I don’t know about that. It’s one way of describing something. I don’t totally relate to it, but you know, who knows?

Rick Archer: It’s good to throw out there. It’s good to maybe ponder as a hypothesis. Now, you know, the whole non-dual thing in some circles has a bit of a negative reputation because the way some people get into it or the effect it has on them tends to depersonalize them or make them disassociative or emotionally flat or nihilistic where they feel like nothing matters and nothing is real and they might lose motivation for their jobs or engagement with their families and stuff like that. And there are a couple of people, Jessica Nathanson and this lady in Germany who specialize in dealing with people who have gotten into that condition. So what would you say differentiates what you’re talking about from that kind of thing? And do you feel like even what you’re saying, in addition to what some other people like Jim Newman and people are saying can be misunderstood and deleterious if not properly

Monica Khosla: dealt with. Yeah, definitely, definitely. I mean the first thing that what differentiates say derealization and depersonalization and things states like that, they’re states and in general maybe there’s a, you could say there’s a more of a state of well-being and aliveness and awakeness and yeah I don’t know well yeah just things that don’t feel like that. I guess technically in my system there could still be that those things could happen I guess you know if you if I had some sort of I don’t know brain injury or illness who knows you know maybe there could be depersonalization or derealization or I don’t know, whatever the other things were that you said, but you know, who knows? And they would still, there would still be states appearing that, you know, I haven’t experienced those, but they could. You know, I work with trauma a lot, so you know, I’ve been a trauma specialist, so I work with people who experience a lot of those kind of, again, dissociation, you know, people experience a lot of dissociation. And I certainly wouldn’t start talking to any of them about non-duality. There’s no need. It’s not, you know, I think for anybody who’s experiencing those things, you know, let’s start with maybe some grounding, that even locating that sense of where they’re experiencing from, that where, where am I, and in relation to

Rick Archer: There’s actually a verse in the Gita which says the wise should not delude the ignorant by talking about the uninvolved nature of the self. In this case they mean universal self. They should set an example by just engaging in activity and acting like a normal person. But I guess the nature of my question is that there’s a lot of non-duality flying around these days on the internet and I think it’s obviously there’s a legitimate and valid teaching about that, but somehow the way it is sometimes taught, and I’m not accusing you of this, you and I talked even the other day about this, but the way it is sometimes taught and the way it is sometimes received by certain people has an undesirable influence on their personality and on their life. And so I just wonder what you would say to that and what precautions you might take in speaking about this to prevent that from happening to people.

Monica Khosla: people. Yeah it’s it’s a really tricky one because I think there was something I felt a little bit uncomfortable about in writing the book and putting it out there particularly because I work as a therapist and I in a way you know I don’t think my clients necessarily need to to take on board all that kind of stuff and so you know it’s it’s not the most important thing for most people. And I’m not a teacher and I am not looking to try and convince anyone of anything. Having said that, like in my book I’ve got a chapter that says there’s nobody there and you know it’s messy, you know, it’s messy saying those things because people could experience a sense of nihilism or it’s just annoying annoying and I don’t know, not particularly helpful sometimes to say those things, particularly like you say in the modern world where people are saying those kind of things all the time and just bashing people over the head with them. I mentioned that particular phrase, there’s nobody there at that point in my book to try and explain something about the theory in that if we were going to set up an experiment to interrupt the false sense of separation which is what memory reconsolidation theory is all about. So the theory of memory reconsolidation is about how beliefs can sometimes be updated or erased just naturally in our brains. And in order for this to happen, what they reckon is, first of all, the neural network relating to the underlying belief or assumption learning has to be activated. So something gets lit up in the brain and then at the same time there is some kind of contradiction or something shocking or surprising that suggests kind of to the brain, maybe I haven’t got it right, something like that. There’s something that suggests that this initial assumption might be wrong, could be improved in some way, and so the synapses open or unlock the other connections between the neurons, unlock, and during an approximately five-hour period, there is the possibility of some kind of new learning or updating of that particular pattern in the brain. And then after five hours, the synapses locked again and you can’t go back to the way it was before. So this is a kind of theory relating to sudden transformative change where things do just drop away and you just can’t go back. And this happens all the time in little ways, I think, in, you know, just the way the brain works. But for these, you know, really primary, early fundamental beliefs or emotional learnings is what a lot of the literature is about. So think sort of beliefs about ourselves, that they tend to be quite buried in the system and quite hard to kind of open up and contradict, because there’s so much protection around it all.

Rick Archer: I have a friend who had a drinking problem and we noticed that he underwent a big personality change at a certain point where Irene and I were saying, “Wow, I wonder what happened to him? He seems so different.” I had a conversation with him recently and he said, “Well, I did a rather high dose guided psilocybin trip and it just totally shifted me and I just haven’t had that problem anymore.” Would this be an example of what you’re talking about?

Monica Khosla: It could well be if it hasn’t come back. If something has changed in a lasting way, then maybe, yeah. Again, I’m not an expert on this. I’ve just taken the theory and run with it, really but yes I’ve spoken to a couple neuroscientists and they say I’m on the right tracks. Well just those experiences I was talking about in therapy where on that training course we would work with, so the example of that then this the finding it difficult to speak in public or speak about something personal and how everything would get kind of tight. So on the training course I was on, we were doing an exercise where you pick something like that and then you go around the room and speak a little bit to somebody who’s in the sort of therapist role and they came up with a statement like you believe you’re not good enough or there’s no support for you or something like this and and you just see if it resonates. And we did this exercise and I was describing this experience that happened earlier in the day on the course when I’d spoken about something to the group and I got to my friend Nicola and she said you’re afraid you don’t belong and she said it in a really kind way and in that moment you know it was just like oh yeah and I kind of laughed and it just dropped and it just went. Then I was in a meeting at work and I just stood up and talked and until the guy behind me actually said give somebody else a chance to talk. You know it was, I didn’t even care and yeah I don’t know it just something opened up and so to me that would be memory reconsolidation. It was like the, so there was an activation of the uncomfortable feeling just in describing what had happened I could feel it in my body. Then there was something contradictory, which was Nicola saying, “You’re afraid you don’t belong.” And also something contradictory in the kindness with which she said it, that kind of suggested that I do belong. And that seemed to just interrupt the expectation and it just dropped away. So the right intervention at the right time can sometimes just do that.

Rick Archer: So for people listening who might want to try this and benefit from it, is there a book they can learn or a video they can watch or a teacher who teaches or…

Monica Khosla: So the book that I read back in 2012 that got me interested in how this works and applying, thinking about how it works in terms of other things is called Unlocking the Emotional Brain and it’s by Bruce Ecker, Laurel Hulley and Robin Ticic. And they, certainly Bruce Ecker does something called coherence therapy, but he talks about it in relation to other therapies. And it’s much more well-known in the therapy world now as a possible mechanism for how sudden transformative changes can happen. But it’s still quite rare. These things don’t tend to happen as often as you would hope with those early emotional learnings. Partly, I think, because we’re so protected, and a lot of my book is around those layers of protection and, you know, how we try to defend ourselves from experiencing the uncomfortableness underneath. Because if we can just let ourselves experience the uncomfortableness underneath, everything works itself out. Everything just resolves, unless it’s traumatic and then you need a little bit of extra something else. But those kind of…

Rick Archer: If you don’t mind, I’ll link to that book on your BatGap page to make it easier for people to find, link to the Amazon page of it. Great. Yeah. Okay. I’m sorry, what were you going to say?

Monica Khosla: I was just gonna say about the radical non-duality thing in terms of liberation and how people talk, use that language and talk about things that can seem, sometimes can feel quite unkind or nihilistic or a bit brutal. Maybe very occasionally for some people who go to those meetings, and maybe particularly early on when they first go, they might hear something that cuts through the assumptions how they think things are and you might get that. Maybe also they might feel safe enough in the group and then to hear something surprising that contradicts the way they think things are and maybe then liberation happens. You know we hear these stories that can happen, has happened around those groups and if people start talking that language and using it all the time it loses that surprise or shock. So then it’s just a scripture or another belief that doesn’t do anything other than, you know, it’s a nice shared philosophy.

Rick Archer: Well, it can become very annoying, you know.

Monica Khosla: Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Rick Archer: Mm-hmm. Please pass the salt. Who wants the salt? You know, it’s like, give me a break.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, totally. Totally. It’s so annoying. It’s so annoying. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And not kind of, you know, I was talking to a friend in town just before, and I asked him because because of the thing you sent me. I said, “So that phrase, ‘there’s nobody there,’ do you find that helpful at all?” And then he said, “No, it’s just really annoying.” Because this is somebody who spent a lot of time around, you know, non-duality teachers. And he said, “It’s not helpful at all.” “No.” And I thought, yeah, you know, that’s the experience.

Rick Archer: There’s a Tibetan proverb which says something like, “Don’t mistake understanding for realization. don’t mistake realization for liberation. I think a lot of people watch a lot of videos, read a lot of books, and soak their brains with this non-duality talk, but it doesn’t really suit their particular level of development or experience, and that’s when it can become depersonalizing or destabilizing or something. And they can easily mistake that ingrained belief that they’ve fed into their brains as actual realization, where it’s actually just conceptual.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, in lots of traditions, it’s like in Zen or maybe more historically, just those, just saying one thing that cuts through something, you know, who knows, you know, that I’m sure that’s, that’s, maybe, you know, done something to people, lots of people’s brains, maybe in relation to liberation, maybe in relation to other things, you know, just saying something that contradicts. There used to be something called provocative therapy, maybe it still exists, where people would kind of deliberately say quite shocking things, but within, against the background of kindness.

Rick Archer: Yeah, sometimes when you’re ready, just a shocking thing. I interviewed a guy about 15 years ago who was crossing a parking lot and a car screeched to a halt, you know, almost hit him, and the shock of almost being hit by that car woke him up. That was his “aha” moment. Never the same since.

Monica Khosla: And there’s something, isn’t there, like, you know, like, I mean, back to this sort of theory, like, what happens in that moment? It’s almost like just something is recognized, something is seen, some assumption is seen to not be the case, You know, that’s what it seems like in that something just is so contradictory that it can’t It can’t survive it drops away. I don’t know.

Rick Archer: Yeah,

Monica Khosla: that’s what it seems like to me

Rick Archer: But I think perhaps there has to be a ripeness, you know, you can’t just go Walking in front of cars and almost getting hit and hope and use that as a spiritual technique He must have been ready for you know And something else could have done it. A dog could have barked at him and it would have had the same effect

Monica Khosla: Yeah, yeah, who knows and then we can see, you know, we can see this as this sort of spiritual ladder, if you like, and achieving ripeness or something. I don’t think it’s like that. I think maybe there definitely can be something in being curious about it and genuinely open. It seems like that to me that if there really is a kind of wanting to know on some level, then it’s almost like, why wouldn’t it become obvious? But I think a lot of people think they’re seeking and they think that they really, say, want liberation but the reality of it right here right now being open to something unknown you know actually could feel really scary or just instinctively be avoided.

Rick Archer: Yeah they might, I do think that there’s a spectrum of spiritual development and it’s vast and I don’t think anybody ever reaches the end of it that’s my perspective. But obviously, and if that’s valid, then there are points on that spectrum where one is ripe for having a particular breakthrough or shift and there are other points in which, you know, that’s not going to happen. Anyway, that’s just kind of… Yeah.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, who knows? It’s fascinating, isn’t it? We just don’t know what’s going on.

Rick Archer: Yeah. So let me make sure, did I get to your other two points you wanted to cover? Identity in relation to therapy and non-duality, who am I, where am I, what am I? Did we cover that?

Monica Khosla: I sort of referenced it before that. I guess what I meant by that is that that who am I question, particularly in the modern world, you know, people can be very preoccupied with identity in a very kind of, you know, I’m, I don’t know, male, female, I don’t know, you know, all sorts of other identities. And, you know, and almost like if I can find the identity that fits, then I’m going to be okay. That’s, and what I find in therapy is that people will worry about who they are when they’re not feeling good. When they feel safer, calmer, they don’t care. They’re just experiencing life, it’s fine. The what am I, I kind of think that’s an interesting thing to explore if you’re curious about what you are. It’s an interesting sort of exploration to notice what seems to be true if you’re curious about the nature of reality. And the where am I, which I think I was talking about before, I think more and more with trauma therapy now, they’re talking about how important it is to be able to locate the physical body in space in relation to objects and things like that. That actually helps to provide that sense of safety and stabilization. So where am I I think is quite an important question experientially or you could say where is this body located but having a sense of sort of gravity and here-ness is actually important and maybe back a little bit to your question about how people can become destabilized, you know, it’s okay to have a sense of location, it’s okay to feel like it’s your experience. Yeah, I don’t know, there’s something that’s really important about that.

Rick Archer: Yeah, on the where of my question, I listened to the Telepathy Tapes podcast, I don’t know if if you’re aware of that.

Monica Khosla: I’ve heard of them. Somebody told me about them.

Rick Archer: Yeah, and they still come out with episodes, but it’s about these autistic kids, many of whom can’t speak and they have to use a letter board to communicate, but they’re very telepathic. But one characteristic of these kids is that they have a hard time locating their bodies. They have to sort of be touched or something has to happen in order for them to even know that they have a body or where it is. So it’s a phenomenon. And it’s another thought that comes to mind when you mention that is what I said earlier is that there can be this multi-dimensional quality of your experience where, yeah, I’m right here, but there’s also the feeling that I’m not isolated to here, I’m everywhere. Like the wave, it’s, yeah, I’m a wave right here about to crash on this beach, but I’m also the entire ocean.

Monica Khosla: Yeah, so that kind of identifying, it’s back to the sort of dot on the piece of paper, isn’t it? You can identify as the dot, you can identify as the ocean. Yeah, that. I guess, and that’s great. And I think more identifying as the ocean is really helpful. You know, that’s, you know, it’s not liberation, but it’s, it feels a lot better.

Rick Archer: Yeah, and it’s not a concept. It’s something that has to be experiential. Maybe thinking about it and talking about it helps, but again, there is a level of your existence which is oceanic, which is unbounded, which is not limited. And if you can find a way of actually tuning into that, and I think meditation can help and other things can probably help, then it’s a lot nicer to be the entire ocean than to just be a little wave that’s vulnerable to all kinds of death and destruction.

Monica Khosla: And I’m just coming back to that idea of a bit of paper, because what I’ve done before, to just explain something in a simple way, nothing to do with non-duality, but just this kind of awareness of experiences, you can have a piece of paper and write on it feelings, thoughts, sensations, images, sounds, smells, all of experience is arising on this piece of paper in consciousness. And just seeing this is all experience, it can all be, just like meditational practices where you just, you can notice that these are all phenomena arising and disappearing in awareness. It’s very helpful for people.

Rick Archer: Yeah, so I guess maybe a concluding point is do something. Find something that works for you and pursue it. And obviously anybody who’s watching this interview is doing just that or they wouldn’t be interested enough to watch this. So we’re preaching to the choir here. But I think it’s good to do what you can to enliven and reinforce that motivation that brought you to watch this video. There’s something really here, and I think your experience is an example of that. And as Jesus said, “Seek and ye shall find, knock and the door shall be opened.”

Monica Khosla: Beautiful. Can I just say, I just want to say how much I appreciate your curiosity in everybody. I’ve watched a few videos before coming on here and I just, all the way that you were with Paul the other day, you know, you’re just so interested and it’s beautiful. So I just want to say thank you for that.

Rick Archer: I am. I read some book when I was a kid, I forget what it was, it might have been a Rudyard Kipling book or something, but it kept using the phrase insatiable curiosity. I think I’ve always had that about things. I can barely walk past the television in the living room without seeing what Irene is watching and what’s happening in that movie and what did this guy do? And she said, “Why don’t you just watch the movie and stop asking me questions?” But I’m just always curious about things.

Monica Khosla: Well, I appreciate it. So yeah, thank you.

Rick Archer: Yeah. Well, thank you and thanks for your time. I enjoyed your book. I’ll put a link to it on your BatGap page. And do you interact with people? I know you do as a therapist locally there in the UK, but if people reach out to you from New Zealand or something, is there some way in which you would like to interact with people?

Monica Khosla: I mean, I have little interactions, not big time, but little interactions are welcome.

Rick Archer: Okay, so I have a link to your website.

Monica Khosla: I have a website now because I had to self-publish my book after Julian retired, and ended up with a website, which was quite interesting. So yeah, there is some contact details on there.

Rick Archer: Okay, so people can get in touch. Great. All right, well thanks Monica, and thanks to those who have been listening or watching. And as I always say, we’ll see you for the next one.

Monica Khosla: Great, thanks Rick.

Rick Archer: You’re welcome.

Non-speech: [MUSIC PLAYING] Thank you. [MUSIC PLAYING]

Support BatGap

Support BatGap with one-time or monthly donations. BatGap Non-Profit is a tax-exempt 501(c)(3).
 

Subscribe to the Podcast

Choose How You Listen

Recent Interviews:

765. Sarah Walker Ting
764. Roger Linden
763. Carmen Acevedo Butcher
762. Dave Markowitz
761. Monica Khosla

Try the BatGap Bot

Your interactive spiritual companion.

BatGap Bot