BatGap Logo
A seamless luminous montage shows Bart Marshall in a central sweater portrait, with surrounding vignettes of jungle memory, books and stones, a seminary conversation with Douglas Harding, an airplane window scene, and a retreat circle beside Deborah Westmoreland.

Bart Marshall Transcript: Richard Rose, Douglas Harding, and Ultimate Betweenness

Bart Marshall interview

Audio-assisted review draft

 

Speaker headings reflect service output checked against conversation context. Unresolved passages need listening; this is not a recording-verified transcript.

 

Non-speech: [Music]

 

Rick Archer: Welcome to Buddha at the Gas Pump. My name is Rick Archer and my guest today is Bart Marshall. I’ve really enjoyed getting to know Bart over the past week reading his book, which he didn’t write actually. This book is a compilation of the Yoga Sutras, the Dhammapada, the Heart Sutra, the Ashtavakra Gita, the Faith Mind Sutra and the Tao Te Ching, or however you pronounce that, in which Bart took numerous translations and compared them side by side in the light of his own experience and came up with the best translations he could. And I hadn’t read most of these, so that was really interesting, and those which I had read, it was interesting to hear his take on them. Also listened to a bunch of his talks and so on, I think it’s going to be an interesting interview. So, Bart, I’ll let you kind of introduce yourself rather than reading a canned bio, because people just get to know you in the course of the conversation. And as I’ve heard you tell it, by most accounts, it starts in Vietnam.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, there was a near-death experience in Vietnam which kind of took me from being someone who just took life as it was, I had no questions, I had no spiritual leanings whatsoever, and filled me with questions. So that was the beginning of what became a 37-year journey, which ended in 2004.

 

Rick Archer: Wow, you’re going fast. Whoa, 37 years!

 

Bart Marshall: I figured maybe we’ll fill in the gaps later. Sometimes I’m not so sure how much the story helps, but I know I always used to love to hear my teacher Richard Rose tell his story.

 

Rick Archer: And people do, you know, it kind of makes it human.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh, I know.

 

Rick Archer: It’s like if someone just gets up there and starts pontificating about the absolute and what not, it doesn’t quite hit home for people as much as if they thought, “Gee, I was in Vietnam or I was in Iraq and this happened to him and this happened to me and maybe there’s hope for me if things worked out pretty good for him.”

 

Bart Marshall: No, you’re absolutely right. That is one of the main advantages to telling your story is it can be inspirational. I know in my case, it seems like no matter how much we dedicate ourselves to this path, we somehow never really think we’re worthy of what it is we’re going for. And it’s only for these name-brand guys that got religions named after them. And for somebody that’s really special and has all these qualities that I certainly could never hope to attain. And then you hear some stories from other people that it’s happened to. And you know, “Yeah, he was like me,” or whatever, and you think, “Oh my God, if it can happen to him, it really could happen to me. For God’s sakes, the gun’s loaded, you know, I’m really playing with something that could take fruition.”

 

Rick Archer: Which was actually my motivation for starting this show. I mean, some people may have heard me tell the story, but I live in a town where several thousand people meditate out of a total population of 10,000, and a lot of people were having these really significant awakenings, and some of them would tell their friends and their friends would shoot them down. They’d think, “Ah, you’re just Joe Schmo, this couldn’t be happening to you, and besides which you can’t levitate, so I don’t believe it.” And so I was seeing this disconnect. And on the other hand, there were people running around saying, “Oh, it’ll never happen to me.” And I thought, “Well, it happened to Joe Schmo.” So I thought I’d put a show together where these people could start telling their stories and their peers could see that people are waking up.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, and I think it has tremendous value. For me, one of the most valuable things that happened to me was when close personal friends started waking up. And then it really was, “Oh my God, it really could happen to me. I knew this guy before, I know him after, he’s a regular guy.” It really was, I think, one of the things that really propelled me into what I call the “final push,” you know, I said, “Oh, this really could happen.”

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, yeah. So, I guess a key point that we’re making here is, it’s good to know that it’s possible.

 

Bart Marshall: Right.

 

Rick Archer: Because if you’re at least not convinced of that, then maybe you’re not going to put forth the effort required or take the steps necessary or just give up and live a so-called ordinary life. You need to know there’s some hope.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, I think that’s one of the ingredients in this is, I think perhaps the most key ingredient is desire or having that intention or that drive. This is something that you really want. You have a single-minded prayer that this be something that happens in your life. But then if you don’t have the confidence that it can happen, if you don’t have the faith that it can happen, that prayer loses a lot of power.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I mean what’s the point in yearning and striving if there’s no hope? In fact you quoted your teacher Richard Rose as saying, “Extreme spiritual effort is our best shot at enlightenment.”

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, yes. I mean there really isn’t, I mean in the final analysis, anyone that has this happen to them will turn around and tell you, “Nothing that I ever did worked, and nothing that I ever did of my own made this happen in any way. And yet, statistics tell us that it uniformly and almost always happens to people who do try very hard to have it.

 

Rick Archer: And Richard Rose also said, which is one of my favorite quotes, I don’t know if he originated it, but “Enlightenment may be an accident, but spiritual practice makes you accident-prone.”

 

Bart Marshall: Yes, there are ways to become more accident-prone.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, yeah.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, it’s kind of along with that, as he says, there’s no recipe for a lightning bolt.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah. What was I just going to say? Oh, yeah, you know, there’s the old cloud analogy where the clouds are obscuring the sun, right? But the sun is always shining and awakening. And from the perspective of the sun, it doesn’t matter one way or the other, I’m shining, you know? From the perspective of somebody on the other side of the clouds, the wind is important, it helps to blow away the clouds. And although all that in stretching the metaphor may be ultimately a thorn removing a thorn, it may be ultimately unreal and so on and so forth, it’s very real to the person who hasn’t had the realization yet. And so, personally I think that these people who kind of sweep away the whole notion of making any kind of effort or doing any sort of practice at all, are selling their listeners a bit short or misleading them.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, I couldn’t agree more. I think effort is key. I did a little essay one time called “Useless Effort, Well Spent.” What you end up doing isn’t going to work, but if you don’t do something, nothing’s going to happen.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah.

 

Bart Marshall: There’s a Zen saying that I probably will misquote, I’m sure, but it’s something along the lines of, “You will not find this by looking, but if you do not look, it will not find you.”

 

Rick Archer: That’s good, you know, and Christ said, “Knock on the door, she’ll be open, seek and you shall find,” and all that. So you know, it’s kind of paradoxical, and I would almost contest the point that it wouldn’t work or it doesn’t work and so on. It’s kind of, you know, it’s not, I mean obviously the self is uncaused and you know, the self realizes itself by itself and so on and so forth, but so many different traditional sources, if we respect them, advocate doing things to clear away the obstacles, to make the likelihood of the self realizing itself by itself more probable.

 

Bart Marshall: Yes, exactly, and that is the right way to put it, I think. It’s clearing away the obstacles, there’s nothing that can be added on to you, you can’t become more and more spiritual. The path is subtractive, so you get rid of things that are in your way, and the things that you can’t get rid of on your own, make it your prayer, your request, or your intention, or whatever, whatever your concept of a higher power is. I’m not afraid of the word “prayer,” but some people don’t like it, but you make your prayer is whatever is in my way, please take it from me, and then be prepared for perhaps a rocky road. But if you have a single-minded intention to know truth, then it doesn’t matter what the path may turn out to be. You have to be prepared even for death. It may kill you, it may drive you crazy, it may make you homeless, you may lose every relationship and every friend in your life, but if you have a single-minded purpose for truth, that prayer will be answered.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I agree and there’s a couple of points in there. I mean one is I’m not much of a prayer, but I’m not afraid of the word either, and I’m also kind of fascinated with who or what it is we’re praying to when things do tend to start working out miraculously when that prayer or that intention is there. It fascinates me that there’s this apparent intelligence governing the universe and that we can actually change the course of events in our life by appealing to it in some way and that it has our best interests in mind and so on and so forth. That to me is intriguing.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, yeah, I mean the truth is ultimately the small self is praying to the large self. That which you are praying to is what you truly are. But for our purposes, while we live in duality and while we are seekers on the path, there is no harm in dividing that into “I” and “Thou.” And it puts us in the proper relationship with where the power lies. “I” of myself can do nothing, and the prayer that speaks that and the posture that submits to that says, “I cannot do this, I need you, you are all powerful, thy will not mine,” and all that sort of thing. Even though ultimately it’s you praying to you, the formula works.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, and the you you’re praying to happens to contain the entire universe and govern all of its functioning on every level and so on and so forth, so it’s a pretty big “you.”

 

Bart Marshall: It doesn’t just contain the universe, it is the source of all that is.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, the source, course and goal, the complete essence, whatever.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, and it’s spontaneous manifestation and that’s you spontaneously manifesting.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, so I guess it’s kind of fun to stop at certain points and say, “Okay, what is the key point we’re talking about here? I think the key point here might be, the nugget point might be that there’s a sort of a divine intelligence all pervading and you can restate this better than I, that we are intimately and deeply one with that and that our intentions can elicit its support and cooperation.

 

Bart Marshall: Yes, it’s coming into alignment with yourself. It’s coming into alignment with that which you truly are. And this little guy that thinks he’s in control of things, he’s really headstrong and he thinks he knows what’s right and he thinks he’s got all these ideas and opinions and judgments and everything and he’s just not in alignment with that which truly is. And so the process is bringing that, you know, getting, removing the obstacles and coming into alignment with that which you truly are. And I just talk about, you know, staying in constant communication, you know, 24/7 with whatever you conceive of as a higher power. It is you, but you don’t realize that and you can’t say it’s me until that is the fact of your existence, until you know that for sure beyond a shadow of a doubt, otherwise the ego is going to try to claim it. And that’s not going to be helpful obviously. So it’s putting yourself in a subservient position to that which you truly are, and saying, “I of myself can do nothing.” Help? I had a friend who woke up and her final prayer, her final mantra that she repeated for a number of years, actually I don’t think it was years, it was more like months, was you know, “Please I want to go home, please I want to go home,” and that became a one-pointed prayer from herself to herself, capital H, and lo and behold it worked.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, and there’s a cart and a horse issue here because on the one hand, a person Someone might just start trying to browbeat themselves with a prayer like that or with an intention like that, but still have a lot of other things they need to attend to, I should think. But on the other hand, there are people who are kind of getting close to the goal. You know, if you’ve ever done anything with horses, I haven’t, but my wife used to ride horses and all, and she’d remind me of this when we were on hikes and we were somehow walking very fast as we were going back to the campground. She said, “Boy, you know, this is like horses. When they’re getting close to home, they start to really go fast, you know, because they’re eager.” And so it seems that at a certain point that intention or that prayer becomes kind of really ardent and all-consuming. And I’ve talked to people who have said, you know, who have done things like said, “I’m going to sit on this rock until I wake up,” you know, and starve to death if necessary. So try that 20 years before you’re ready to wake up and you might have a problem, but it doesn’t…

 

Bart Marshall: That’s a lot of time under the Bodhi tree.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah,

 

Bart Marshall: there are things that are better suited for when you’re first starting out. I mean, I think one of the things that a person needs to do if they are just beginning to be curious or beginning to be dissatisfied with what they think is true and maybe begin suspect isn’t, suspect isn’t, is you start absorbing the teachings, you know, you read the books and you listen to the teachers and get a framework and that sort of thing, and along with that do a lot of self-inquiry. Turn that ray of projection that’s manifesting the world back in on itself and look back at the looker. What is it that’s looking out on all of this, you know, and turn that around and look right straight back in and ask the big questions. And then the little questions about the character, you know, leave no stone unturned, you know, you don’t want to be a mystery to yourself, the little guy doesn’t want to be a mystery to himself, shouldn’t be anyway, because you can’t drag around a self-deluded character and expect truth to happen. So there’s a lot of inquiry work that needs to go on as well. And then I think the third leg of the stool, you might say, is silence, you know, which meditation is very conducive to courting silence, but there’s other ways too to approach that state of no thought where the mind which is so active in self-inquiry, the mind fighting it out with the mind let’s say, is in complete abeyance and there’s no thought and there’s silence. And it is in that silence that grace has the opportunity to take charge let’s say.

 

Rick Archer: You know what, we’re sort of getting into Richard Rose’s top 10 tips for serious seekers here, and it might be fun to run through these and we’ll loop around and get back to your personal story because we don’t necessarily need to do that in the beginning, but I think it would be fun to go back and then, you know, what happened in Vietnam and what you went through and everything. But since we’re getting into this, let me read these out and you comment on each one a little bit. So here we go, David Letter…Richard Rose’s top 10 tips for serious seekers. Ten, make a decision and carry it out – commitment.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, Rose was extraordinarily vocal about the importance of commitment. We touched on that a little bit by calling it desire and intention and that sort of thing, but when you make a commitment to something, and he used to have that Goethe quote about, which I will not be able to quote, but when you make a commitment all sorts of unseen forces appear to help you.

 

Rick Archer: Oh, I remember that Goethe quote, yeah, that’s great.

 

Bart Marshall: And he had that framed up in his house. But it’s that sense of, “Hey, if you go to the new world and burn your ships, you’re committed.” And so if you put yourself in that kind of a position where you don’t give yourself weasel room, say, “Truth or bust?” And then whenever you come to a juncture where there’s a decision to be made between your commitment and something else. You always choose in favor of your commitment.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, Maharishi used to call that the highest first. You always have choices, choose the highest.

 

Bart Marshall: The highest first, exactly. I love that phrase, I hadn’t heard that.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, and you told the story of how Richard was out in a snowstorm on a horse and the horse threw him and he clung to the horse and was dragged for 20 minutes or something because he had made a commitment to that horse, I guess, didn’t want the horse to get lost in a snowstorm, so he just hung in there until the horse calmed down.

 

Bart Marshall: – Right, commitment was a commitment to Rose, and it didn’t matter whether it was for, you know, what we might call a higher purpose or a relatively prosaic or mundane purpose. If Rose gave his word and made a commitment, that was it. There was nothing else, I mean, he would die rather than break his commitment. In this case, there was a very serious snowstorm, and he said he had committed to the horse, you know, we’re gonna go out in this, and we’re gonna try to round up the cattle, And I’m not gonna leave you out there. We’re both coming back or neither one of us is coming back. And that’s just a horse.

 

Rick Archer: – Yeah.

 

Bart Marshall: – Not just a horse, but I mean, it’s not a person. It’s not your child, it’s not your wife or anything. But he got his foot was stuck in the stirrup and he was dragged and his head cranking over rocks and stuff. –

 

Rick Archer: Oh man.

 

Bart Marshall: – But he hung on when he could have got off. He could have got loose, but he hung on and reined it back in and was eventually able to get both of them back to the barn.

 

Rick Archer: – Wow. What about relative commitments? I mean a commitment to marriage for instance, you know, 50% of all marriages end in divorce. Do you feel, would you apply this to relative commitments, like finishing your graduate degree or something, that you’re just going to hang in there for dear life no matter what? Or does this really apply to the highest commitment, that to enlightenment, and that that might actually involve the abandonment of certain relative commitments if they are impeding it?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, that’s a really good question and it was well phrased because yes, relative commitments in the context of your highest commitment, your highest first, I think it was what you phrased it, or your best first or first first or whatever. Highest first, thank you. You know when it comes to your highest first versus anything else, then your highest first takes precedence and other things that you might call commitments, you know commitment to marriage, a commitment to certain friendships or something, you know if you wanted to use that word then they would fall by the wayside. Nothing can be allowed to get in the way of it.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I know when I first started meditating I pretty much just dropped all my druggy friends and spent the next several months just walking the dog and down to the beach every day, you know, just being by myself because there was nobody constructive to hang around with and then new friends started coming along. But that was my commitment, I said, “I’m not going to make it if I keep hanging around with these guys.”

 

Bart Marshall: Right, exactly. Yeah, there’s commitments and then there’s lesser commitments, one might say. And there’s always going to be choices, you know, and you choose in favor of your highest first.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I mean I saw photos of you when you were younger with little children and all. Are you still with their mother or did that shift at some point? Did that shift before or after your awakening?

 

Bart Marshall: After, after.

 

Rick Archer: So somehow after your awakening it just wasn’t the proper fit anymore and there was some mutual agreement or something?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, in my particular case, my spiritual inclinations were always a problem in my marriage. After I woke up, they became exacerbated because my time was being taken up in various different things and whatnot. But it was a mutual, that, “Hey, this really isn’t making either one of us happy anymore.”

 

Rick Archer: Right. Okay. Number nine, get your house in order. What’s that?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, that has to do with on every different level just kind of not having a lot of clutter in your life, both mental clutter and physical clutter. And being able to, you know, clear your, Rose might say, clear your life so that you can think straight, so that you have the time and the capacities to think clearly about things and you’re not, you know, dealing with mountains of unpaid bills or something, you get things cleared up so that you can focus on what’s important.

 

Rick Archer: As best you can. I mean, you might have three kids and they might have soccer practice and all kinds of things and you do have unpaid bills and you got to do them and you’re not just going to walk away from the kids, right?

 

Bart Marshall: No, no, no. Not like that. That’s getting organized about all the things. It’s not dropping. This wasn’t recommending dropping things. It was just paying attention to what is in your life and in your mind, you know, clearing your mind for the things that are important to think about. When he first started teaching, it was in the late 60s, and he would say things like, “The kids that used to come around here, they didn’t know how to wipe their own noses, and they wanted to jump into enlightenment.” So there are some things about just learning how to take care of yourself and take care of your life that are…they’re obstacles. If you don’t do it, there are going to be obstacles, and we talked about clearing obstacles. So that was another way of talking about clearing obstacles, one might say.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, yeah, we seekers were a pretty motley crew back in the late 60s.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh, I know. Touche.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I mean, you were on some early TM courses, I know, and some of the characters that would show up there were quite colorful.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh, I know, yeah.

 

Rick Archer: Okay, number eight, back away from untruth.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, that gets to the idea that the path is subtractive, so that we don’t know what the truth is, we can’t head for it, we can’t posit what the truth is going to look like, or you know, I think that’s one of the mistakes that a lot of people make that are hooked into traditional religions or traditional paths, but there’s a belief system associated with it. And you’re essentially telling grace, you’re telling the Divine, you’re telling truth that I will accept you as long as you fit into this paradigm that I expect you to fit into.” And Grace goes, “Yeah, right, I’m not, you know, forget that.” So the process is not heading towards something that you believe in or heading towards some positing that you’ve done about what truth might look like. It’s backing away from those things that are untrue and eventually say, “It’s the neti neti, this, not this, not this, not this, until there’s this core of things that you can’t decide on your own that are untrue and those you have to ask, “Take these from me.” But that’s the path, it’s a subtractive path.

 

Rick Archer: Maybe that kind of relates to number seven, which is doubt everything, in the sense that if you’re adamantly certain about certain assumptions and beliefs and ways of understanding then there’s a rigidity which you kind of can’t let the truth in, but if you doubt everything or at least take everything with a grain of salt, you know, you don’t have to totally … doubt doesn’t mean utterly reject because that’s not doubt either, that’s certainty. It just means sort of have this kind of a little bit of ambivalence in the way you balance your thinking, would you say?

 

Bart Marshall: Yes, absolutely, and it’s not the rejection part, you neither accept nor reject because rejecting is saying I know better, I already know even though I don’t know the truth I already know better, so you can’t do that either. So the doubt part is just leaving yourself wide open to whatever truth may be and not jumping into belief.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, there were a lot of verses like that in the Ashtavakra Gita, your translation that I was just reading where it’s like you’re not sort of on either side of the fence in terms of either accepting or rejecting, you’re just whatever is you know you’re open to it.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, exactly. And that’s the paradigm into which truth will make its way.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, we kind of covered number six and let’s see if you want to say another word on it which is keep your head on it, extreme spiritual effort is our best shot at enlightenment. Maybe we could say stick-to-itiveness would be a good phrase.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, I think that’s just one of the things you don’t have to have a special spot to sit down, you know, it’s not a practice per se that you have to do, but just in your daily life, when you get a chance, you know, think about it and just do things which will keep your head on it, keep it foremost in your mind, whether that’s, you know, prayer, regular meditation, whatever. If you don’t do anything on this for a week or two weeks at a time and they say, “Oh yeah, I forgot to look into the spiritual thing that I think I’m interested in,” you just lose momentum and there’s all sorts of things that are not going to happen that would happen if you kept your head on it and just kept putting one foot in front of the other.

 

Rick Archer: That to which you give your attention grows stronger in your life.

 

Bart Marshall: Exactly, exactly.

 

Rick Archer: Number five is look under every rock.

 

Bart Marshall: That just has to do, I think, well not I think, it has to do with don’t be afraid of looking in all the corners, you know, don’t say, don’t prejudge, and it’s about the, it’s sort of the flip side of doubt everything. Look at everything as potentially it’s something that might hold the truth. You need to look over every, under every rock, you never know what’s, under which one truth may be hiding. And so I know that you joked about, probably before we were on the air, about the books that I have in the library, the thousands of books in my life, but I would be probably embarrassed at this point. Well, I don’t get embarrassed, but it would be silly. Some of the things that I looked into seem pretty silly to me now, but being a fool for God is okay. You look under every rock and look in every corner and listen to every teacher until they prove themselves not worthy of listening to, and you just never know, there’s a cumulative effect that’s going to take place and it’s part of the neti-neti process. Nope, not this rock, nope, not this teacher, nope, not this book.

 

Rick Archer: For some reason I have some words added on to this point which I think I might have copied and pasted from something else that you wrote, which is, “Eliminate teachings that emphasize enhancement, improvement, compassion for non-existent people. And I took exception to that. Do you want to comment on that before I voice my exception?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, no, I’ll let you voice your… Well, okay, what the heck, who cares? But yeah, I can be a little bit inflammatory sometimes in the way I say things. I kind of toss a grenade over the fence and see what happens sometimes. I used to give meetings every week which I’ve backed away from in recent past year and there’s so many people that just want to think that compassion is the path in some way and that by being a nicer person or having your good qualities and eliminating your bad qualities, there’s nothing wrong with that. It’s wonderful. It will make you a nicer person. I’d rather hang out with compassionate people and good people, but that’s not a path to truth. And so I try to disabuse people of that notion that compassion is not a path and it can actually you know be a trap, it can make you trapped into being a really good person and you’ll never get out of that. So and the non-existent people part is that’s just something that’s that’s discovered when self is revealed, when truth reveals itself, is that the world and you and everything in it has no substance whatsoever.

 

Rick Archer:

Okay, well here’s my exception, and that is that these days … I mean I’ve talked to people who are very much in this sort of vein of “the world is an illusion and I don’t care what happens to it,” you know, there was an interchange at the Science Non-Duality Conference a couple years ago in which a Buddhist teacher, David Loy, who was really into finding practical applications, compassionate, world-helping applications of Buddhism, was debating another fellow who was up on the stage and saying, “Shouldn’t we be more concerned about environmental stuff?” And the guy was saying, “The world is like a grain of sand to me and I don’t care what happens to it.” And that’s kind of easy to say, you know, from a kind of a detached perspective, but most of the great spiritual teachers and saints and sages have apparently been very concerned about the world and very full of compassion for suffering people and have dedicated their lives to not only awakening them spiritually, but even to housing and feeding and clothing and healing them, obviously Jesus being a famous case in point. So yeah, granted the world is an illusion ultimately, but the all or nothing approach in which we just sort of dismiss because we understand or experience ultimately that the world is an illusion, therefore we don’t engage in it in a compassionate way or make efforts to improve it in various ways, doesn’t quite resonate with me. And I know what you’re saying about people getting into all kinds of self-improvement things and taking seminars and going to motivational speakers and all that, and I think that’s all on a very superficial level. So what I’m kind of referring to is something deeper where the full package is there of realization or seeking for it, and at the same time not being an SOB in your personal life and doing all you can to sort of help others, given whatever gifts and talents and inclinations you have in whatever way you can help them.

 

Bart Marshall: And I understand that completely and there’s nothing wrong with, as a matter of fact, it’s admirable to be doing compassionate things. You know I was a hospice volunteer for six years and that sort of thing and there’s nothing wrong with that and it’s good and it’s a good way to spend your time, but you know I have a limited amount of time that I’m willing to spend teaching. I essentially teach because I’m asked and I generally talk to people that are so far into this that they can’t get out. I’m not an evangelist. I’m not trying to convince people that they should be going for enlightenment or anything like that. The people that generally that I talk to are people that they’re stuck. They’ve already gotten so far in it that they can’t turn back. That hot red ball is halfway down and it can’t be swallowed and can’t be regurgitated and pick your metaphor, the only way forward is forward.

 

Rick Archer: Like the plane that’s gone halfway across the ocean and doesn’t have enough fuel to go back.

 

Bart Marshall: You don’t have enough fuel to go back. So, okay, you’re there, I’ll talk to you now. Now, you also have a limited number of years on this earth. And if truth is the most important thing to you, then I’m going to talk to you about things that will help you have truth reveal itself to itself in your presence, let’s say. one way of saying it. And not waste a lot of time on other things. There’s nothing wrong with those other things, but compassion, compassionate action, and some of these other things that are, you know, vegetarianism and I don’t know what all, you know, I mean the things that go under the guise of spirituality, there’s nothing wrong with those things. They’re wonderful things, but I tend to focus on the things that I think are the more direct path and say, “Okay, look, once you wake up, do whatever you want. But if you want to get, if you want to wake up as fast as possible, you have to make the highest and best use of your time. And you’ve only got a limited amount of time. You don’t know if you’re going to die tomorrow. So let’s talk about something that can make that happen right now. And becoming a better person is not going to make that happen right now. There are things that can, it can happen at any time to anyone, any place. There’s no preparation necessary. There’s no worthiness required. It doesn’t need to be earned in any way. There’s no way anyone could ever be worthy of a gift like this. And so what do you say to someone that will possibly create an environment in which something spontaneously might happen? And so that’s all that I’m up to, you know, and sometimes I’m provocative in the way I say things and if someone’s leaning in a certain direction very strongly I’m likely to try to kick the support structure for that out from under them.

 

Rick Archer: Okay, well a little devil’s advocate point here would be that I’ve known some very selfish, narcissistic spiritual seekers, you know, it’s all about me, and I think that that has been an impediment to their growth. They become so self-absorbed, I’ve seen them go on for decades being selfish and narcissistic. I’ve gone through phases like that myself, hopefully I don’t have too many remnants of those, but been there, done that. Another thing is that seva is a traditional spiritual practice which is supposed to be conducive to your ultimate realization, and some teachers say that you can sit on your butt for years meditating and not get too much out of it, but also in some people at least that dedicating yourself to the betterment of others can attenuate the ego to a great extent. In fact, Shankara said that not everyone is cut out for jnana yoga for the final realization, And he said, “Karma yoga or service in a more relative sense can actually purify you to the point where you are more capable of jnana yoga.” So there is some traditional argument for that.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh, I know. I make a joke sometimes, you know, about how sometimes people call me a Zen master. Being a Zen master is easy, all you have to do is say the opposite of what someone thinks they are doing, just tell them to do the opposite. And if somebody is a completely avid reader and they always got their face in a spiritual book, I tell them to stop reading. Don’t let other people’s words get in. If someone hasn’t cracked a book, I tell them to start reading. And if someone is a narcissist, as you were describing, a narcissistic self-absorbed person, I would recommend and I have recommended to a number of people to do some kind of service work like hospice or something. or something.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, go work at an animal shelter or whatever.

 

Bart Marshall: Anything, anything to get to cease that self-absorption. It’s not a good, it’s not self-inquiry, it’s not self-observation, it’s just this incestuous self-absorption and when you see someone in that situation then you prescribe the opposite.

 

Rick Archer: Right. Okay, good, that covers that point. Alright, number four, re-traverse the ray of projection. I understand what that means but you go ahead and explain it.

 

Bart Marshall: Well we touched on that a little bit earlier and that is essentially looking back at the looker. You know the creation, the world, the illusion, we’re using that word in this interview and that’s okay, is a projection. It manifests, it’s projected from the source of all that is, which is you and the one awareness. And that ray of projection is focused outwards to an external let’s say manifestation, which there is no internal or external, but it’s what appears to be an external manifestation. Now re-traversing the ray of projection is to turn 180, turn that looking, turn that projection 180 degrees right back into the looker and look back at what’s projecting, look back into the light. The projection metaphor you would be a movie theater where the light is coming from behind you and it’s casting this movie on a screen and you’re totally absorbed in the screen, you’re totally absorbed in the projection, but in the Plato’s cave analogy is wonderful here too. Turn around, look back into the light, you know not at what is being projected, not that’s this these I don’t want to call false images, but they’re images without substance that are being projected. Look back into the light from which they come, which is you, which is that which you truly are.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I think that’s what meditation does or should do. In fact, the Gita talks about how the senses are designed to direct the attention outwards and we turn them around like a tortoise withdrawing its limbs, you know.

 

Bart Marshall: Exactly, exactly.

 

Rick Archer: Good, okay. And so, you know, I think that you and I have both done a lot of meditation and probably have experienced that very thing in meditation where the attention is inner and outer, it’s just metaphorical, it’s not really inner and outer, but there’s a sort of a withdrawing of the senses from their objects and reabsorption back into the self or into consciousness. So how would you advocate or prescribe that a person do that?

 

Bart Marshall: I’m not sure how to answer the whole question you’re talking about.

 

Rick Archer: Well, the re-traversing the ray of projection, is that something one would do in a meditative state or is something one would try to do while driving a car or functioning in the world or do you take certain, you know, you dedicate certain portions of your day or you you try to do it every time you come to a stoplight or you know what do you do?

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, all of those, any of those things except while driving. Yeah. I would say, you know, if you’re in motion at a speed which could prove harmful in collision situation then you should focus on that and nothing else. But most any other time you can, and it doesn’t have to be meditation, you can just be in the midst of daily life. And you know as I’m sitting here now thinking about describing it, I’m actually doing what I’m about to say. I don’t know if the words will come out right, but you know what’s in front of me, what’s in front of my eyes is all the external images, but where my mind is, is on what you might call the flat panel of the focus of where this, you know, let’s say the film of the the eyes, this flat 2D thing right here on which everything is painted and then the mind can just step one step back from that. And so it’s a mental exercise you can do while your eyes are open, you can do with your eyes closed.

 

Rick Archer: So it’s sort of a self-referral thing rather than just blindly getting caught up in the external thing, there’s a sort of a curving back somewhat.

 

Bart Marshall: It’s a stepping back visually as well as mentally. You can just pull your vision in. If you’ve ever done any target shooting or something, they have this wire that will bring the target back to you. The target is way out there, you hit a button and it brings the target back to you so you can see whether you hit it or not. So you can essentially just vision, you can bring the world back to you in close and just bring it back closer this way and then flip it. These are those thought experiments, it’s all just kind of playing with it. It’s just once you realize that it’s possible to look, literally look at what’s look inside, I’ll use the word, at what’s looking out, you can start playing with your own ideas about how to do that. But that’s who you truly are is back here. What we have…I don’t know if I should get into this now or not, but there’s just one awareness, there’s not a multiplicity of awarenesses and we all know where that one awareness is, it’s always been there. We’ve just misidentified it as belonging to this little guy with a name, but it’s God-awareness and it has, for the sake of this purpose, this conversation, we’ll say that it has a shape and the shape is the single eye. It’s this everything that we can see with the parameters, you know, Jesus said if thine eye becomes single thy whole body is light and that is our constant experience. The single eye is full of light and that light is full of color and texture and manifestation, but as we pull back in and not getting so focused, not getting so lost in the details of the external world, pull back in to be conscious of this clear single eye that is projecting everything, let’s say, and rest there, rest our attention there. Something might happen, then something might happen, stop looking out out and just let the attention rest here.

 

Rick Archer: Larry will edit that bit out. Good, I think we covered that pretty well. I’m sure we’ll touch on points related to that more as we go along. This next one, “Life Gives You All the Koans You Need,” I was listening to one of your recordings and those satsangs you did and there’s someone with you named Debra I believe And she was saying something about, you know, she doubts her thoughts but she doesn’t doubt all the circumstances that unfold in her life. Like if she gets a flat tire, it’s not like, “Oh crap, a flat tire, I’ll be late to work.” It’s like, “Okay, what is this showing me?” So life is giving her a koan there. I don’t know if that’s what she was trying to convey when she made that point, but go ahead and elaborate on that one. Life gives you all the koans you need.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, I’m really glad you mentioned Debra. Deborah Westmoreland is an amazing teacher who I happen to be married to, and we teach together now, we teach retreats and it’s a real joy and good things seem to happen. And she talks about, she’s talked about that for a long time, about she doesn’t trust her thoughts about anything, it’s just whatever is appearing before her, “Okay, I’ll trust that,” you know, in the interim. I know that that’s projection and illusion, but it’s at least something that can be trusted. I cannot trust these ephemeral thoughts that pass through and are constantly changing, but for most people, thoughts have priority. If we think it, it must be true, we must act on it, even if it changes in the next half hour, then we say, “Oh, okay, now I know the truth. Now I know what I should act on,” and we’re jumping around like chickens with our heads cut off, you know, trying to follow and obey our thoughts and thinking that we have the right opinions and the right judgments and everything. And Debra, you know, quite rightly says, “No, you know, look at what’s right in front of you. Trust that.” And the thing about life gives you all the koans you need, of course, comes from the formal Japanese Zen koans where you would have the, you know, things like the sound of one it was the sound of one hand clapping or you know why did Bodhidharma go to the East and things like that. The nonsense questions essentially that by pounding your head against them long enough the mind stops, you know which is the purpose of you know the Japanese formal koans is to stop the mind not to find an answer. They don’t have an answer. Its sole purpose is to stop the mind. And so you know Rose says you don’t need these kind of formal koans. Your life will give you all of those kind of problems that will stop your mind that you can handle. And I often talk about your life, your particular life is your path. You don’t need to go looking for any esoteric paths that have been followed by historical sages or anything like that. Your life is your path. And one way of talking about it would be to say that it is specifically designed to get your specific character to truth. And that by paying attention to what manifests in your life and following that is your quickest way to truth.

 

Rick Archer: That kind of harkens back to what we were talking about earlier about there being some sort of divine orchestration in life that you can provoke with prayer or with intention. And the notion that every little leaf that falls is permeated with intelligence, there’s intelligence governing the universe and things don’t happen arbitrarily or capriciously or meaninglessly. Which I’m sure you would agree, it’s not to say you’re supposed to analyze every little thing that happens, “Oh, what’s the significance of this? This guy walked past me wearing a red shirt, what does that mean?” I think we would agree that that would be a superficial way of treating this point.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, yeah, that’s when you become slavish. You don’t want to become slavish to anything, you know, just take everything and chew on it and, pardon me, digest the part that works for you and the rest out. But there is this idea that, and it’s not just an idea, but one of the first things we need to ask ourselves I think is “Does the universe have my best interest at heart? Is the universe on my side? Is it out to get me or is it out to help me?” And that’s a nod towards some kind of a higher power, that there is some sort of help there. I think most of us would agree, certainly people that get on the spiritual path, others may not, but the universe does have our best interest at heart, even if sometimes it takes us over rocky roads and drags us over broken glass, that there is some sort of reason for that and if you stay focused on that in your life and watch for that, it doesn’t even matter if you ultimately understand it. It’s faith. It’s capital F faith that all is well and all is well and all manner of things are well no matter how the little guy thinks about it. You know Bart still has all his preferences and desires that he had before he woke up, but now he just doesn’t care if he ever gets his way or not. I’d much rather, he’s even you know smart enough now to be able to say I’d much rather have what I’m supposed to have than what I think I want. And so no, your preferences and desires are not always going to be fulfilled and you could say well the universe is against me because I didn’t get what I want. Well how do you know what’s good for for you. You know what you want but you don’t know what is proper in the long term of your life and especially if you have a one-pointed desire for something and in this case we’re talking about enlightenment or truth or however we want to talk about it. If that’s our long-term desire then we can’t pick bones about what happens along the way. You know it is going to take us through some rocky paths and there are going to be some obstacles that are going to be removed and we are going to have some life-changing events, you know, all in service of that highest first. And faith, I think, is one of … it comes very easy. Once you wake up, faith is natural, it’s your natural state of being. Beforehand you have to work at it a little bit.

 

Rick Archer: And what we’re saying could sound a little glib to somebody whose child has been raped and kidnapped or killed by a car, or you know, terrible stuff happens to people and we don’t want to sound heartless.

 

Bart Marshall: No, and to be quite honest, you know, as I was a seeker during my seeking days and the The idea that you had to be prepared for anything to happen in your life. If you make this commitment and you have this prayer for truth, it has to be at all costs. And I adopted that and I’ve taught that and I’ve prayed that with very fervent sincerity. And yet I had this caveat and I was hoping I would get away with it. I said, “But,” you know, talking to the Divine, “if you hurt my children, I’m out of here. Nothing good will happen. You know, if you want me to die an alcoholic in the gutter, then hurt my children, but I will not serve you if you hurt my children.” And so there are things that, you know, we just don’t ever want to have happen in our lives and if they do, quite honestly, it can be devastating to one’s faith.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, and I mean you were saying earlier about you make this commitment and even if it means you go crazy or end up homeless or all that, but generally speaking, at least in my experience, things tend to go better in life once you make this commitment. It’s not like all hell is going to break loose. Things may fall away, sure, but we shouldn’t scare people into thinking that it’s just going to be … who was that guy in the Bible, was it Job, who was seriously tested by God?

 

Bart Marshall: No, statistics show that it’s not like that at all. I think, of course, there’s no formula and we have no idea what works, nothing works, But what seems to be efficacious is to be prepared for the worst, but it is almost never asked. As you say, it’s almost always better. And if you lose a friendship or lose a relationship, you say, “Well, you know what? It was time for that to go,” or something. It’s not as bad as you are saying that you’re prepared for. You don’t have to pay the price, you just have to be prepared to pay the price. Now that’s a delicate line to walk because once you say that, then someone who listens will say, “Well, I’m not really prepared, but I’ll say I’m prepared,” and you can’t do that. You can’t scam it. It has to be a total surrender to the commitment.

 

Rick Archer: And wouldn’t you say that not everybody is in a position of making a total surrender? surrender and commit and have faith to the extent of your capacity, and that capacity in most people is probably going to deepen as they go along. It’s not an all-or-nothing from day one.

 

Bart Marshall: No, not at all, not at all. And you know I think in my case for instance I mentioned that I counted as 37 years from when I first was sort of shocked into having questions until something happened and I would only say that maybe the last two years, two or three, four years if I stretch it, would I be able to say that I wholeheartedly had a one-pointed prayer. You just, you know, other things are happening in your life and it’s okay to pay attention to them, but everything is moving you towards that point where eventually nothing else will matter if you stick with this long enough and at that point that’s when that happens.

 

Rick Archer: And you just basically said it, but just to reiterate, so 35 years were necessary to bring you to the point where it could be wholehearted, but those 35 years weren’t wasted. There was a progressive, greater and greater preparedness taking place during those 35 years.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, a whole lot of obstacles and a whole lot of resistance had to be overcome. And one of the things that I sometimes say, and I think it’s true, is that the whole spiritual path is removing our resistance to a gift that is constantly being offered. So it’s not that we’re becoming more worthy, it’s we’re becoming able to accept what is always there. And you know that Jesus says, “Knock and it shall be opened to you” and that’s very true and it’s a paradox and when you say one thing you can say the other, but it’s also true that it’s the Divine, it’s God that’s knocking. And we have our hands and feet against the door and saying, “No, I’m not ready. I got some questions. I got things I need to do in life. You know, I’m a little bit afraid. You know, what’s it going to be like if I let you in?” And that’s why it doesn’t happen. It’s not because we haven’t done enough work. It’s because our resistance is too great to the gift that wants to be given.

 

Rick Archer: Interesting. Okay, number two. Make your whole life a prayer. We kind of covered this, but any further things on that?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, I don’t think you can talk about it too much, so I’ll see what happens if I try to say something else, but it just has to do with that one-pointedness of intention. And since we’re reading from that talk I gave on Rose’s 10 one-liners or whatever I call it, 10 one-liners that speak volumes. One of the things that he said was, “If your whole life is a prayer, it will be answered instantly.” And so, if there’s nothing else in the way, if you’re not saying, “I want this and this,” or if everything in your life is saying, “I only want this,” then grace, the Divine or whatever has a clear path to just come in right then, and there’s no caveats.

 

Rick Archer: And the final point is very interesting, I think we can go on about this for a little while, which is betweenness. And before you elaborate, I just want to relate it to the previous point, which is, on the one hand, prayer can be very specific and it can be self-centered — I want a new car, I want this or that or the other thing — very specific, which may or may not be what you really need. What was it, Mick Jagger, you know, he said, “You can’t always get what you want, but you get what you need.” This betweenness thing is interesting and it’s a process I’ll have you describe and Richard Rose actually used it in poker games to get the cards he wanted dealt to him, and it actually also relates to the Yoga Sutras and the whole process of samyama, which we can talk about a little bit. But go ahead and riff on betweenness a little.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, it’s a really hard thing to riff on and it’s a hard thing to understand, and I wouldn’t say that I ever really understood it for a long time even though I was trying to understand it and trying to apply it. But essentially I don’t know if I can encapsulate it or not but it essentially is some small bit of leverage we have over the little guy let’s say the small self some small bit of leverage that the little self has over making events turn in his or her favor. And this has to do with holding your head in a certain way, right on an edge of neither caring or not caring. And in Ashtavakra Gita it talks about neither accepting nor rejecting, and there’s lots of in all the ancient wisdom there’s references here and there and you said in Yoga Sutras which is quite true as well. And I think if I had to just say a couple of sentences about it, it would be it’s the process of wanting something with one-pointed intention with great power and not caring if you ever get it at the same time.

 

Rick Archer: Which I think covers dharana and dhyana in samyama, those two aspects of it, and then the third one is samadhi. So actually being established in the self, wanting something and surrendering it, all kind of in this simultaneous balancing act.

 

Bart Marshall: Exactly, exactly. Yeah, and you know, Rose apparently was able to do it for relatively mundane things like a hand of poker, you know, I’ve not been able to do that, I haven’t really given it much practice to be honest with you. But I think what happened to me, and I only can say this in retrospect, but … and Rose called it “ultimate betweenness” when it was applied to the spiritual path, you know, wanting truth more than anything and then not caring with it and surrendering whether you ever got it or not. And I think I stumbled into ultimate betweenness right before I woke up, and I can identify that state and only by being in that state could I understand it. And since then I’ve tried to talk about it a little bit in ways that may be understandable without being in the state.

 

Rick Archer: That takes care of our ten points, but since we’re talking about the Yoga Sutras, I read your translation of it, your compilation of other translations, and for people who aren’t familiar with the Yoga Sutras, there are four chapters in it, and the third chapter is all about siddhis, and it talks about practicing samyama, which is this thing we just mentioned of Dharana, Dhyana and Samadhi, fixity of attention, surrender of attention and pure consciousness. And a lot of people write off the whole fourth, I guess it’s the third chapter, they say, because of this one verse, 3.38, it says, “They are powers in worldly experience but obstacles to Samadhi.” And one thing I’m confused about in this is, well, why would Patanjali devote an entire chapter of a four chapter book to something that you’re really not supposed to pay any attention to. And the second is, Samadhi is one of the three pillars of Samyama, so how are powers obstacles to Samadhi if Samadhi is an essential constituent of the very process by which the siddhis are performed? You have any idea on that?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, I don’t pretend to be someone who can explain other people’s works or writings, even the ancients that I’ve you know obviously have translated and worked with quite extensively. I’ve tried to stay faithful to exactly what is recorded there and not interject my own ideas about that, but you bring up a very valid point. I think the takeaway for me in those passages is that even though he’s dedicated a whole chapter to the siddhis and everything, then one might question whether that was necessary or even desirable, I think the essential point is that these, let’s call them worldly powers or things that you can do along the way are lesser amazements and you can get stuck there. And a lot of, you know, at least historically a lot of the yogis in India, you know, get stuck on various different siddhis and that’s what their life is, you know, they hit that cul-de-sac and they sleep on a bed of nails the rest of their life or whatever. And that’s not the point. And so Patanjali I think was giving a nod towards it, “Yes, you could do this. Yes, you could do that.” I can almost see him kind of being casual and giving a shoulder shrug, “Yes, you can have all the powers you want. You can do this. You can become invisible, but if you want truth, don’t get stuck there.”

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, Maharishi’s take on it, and for me the jury is out on this. I’m not saying because he said it, it must be true, but his take on it was that these things can actually … he would probably also have acknowledged that you could get stuck, but he was saying that they were being offered as actual practices to sort of integrate consciousness into various channels of the physiology or into kind of enlivened latent capabilities that again, one can easily get stuck, and people do, but that if we want to really achieve some kind of complete holistic development, these abilities should be part and parcel of our toolkit, the way Christ did all sorts of stuff. If you take the story literally, He was able to walk on water. How do you do that? Calm the ocean, multiply the loaves and fishes. It’s kind of fascinating to consider because sometimes awakening is, in my opinion, dumbed down in terms of what it might ultimately include. People do begin to encounter some of this stuff, either sometimes before or after they awaken. Perhaps 50 years from now, as a culture, we’ll have a more complete understanding of what awakening is and all the various things that it may evoke in us as we develop and that might need to be understood in a kind of responsible way and not just swept aside as some kind of distraction or impediment.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, I think there’s…I guess what I would start by saying is that all of those things, you know, however we characterize them, are a thing apart from awakening, have nothing to do with truth or enlightenment. They’re things that are done within the manifest world, you know, by the residue of the character that remains after one wakes up, and it doesn’t really matter what you do after that. You can have these spiritual powers or whatever, it doesn’t really matter, but it doesn’t… I think it’s doing a disservice to lump them in with the idea of awakening or enlightenment, whatever we want to call it, because that is very simple. That is a very simple realization. It’s just turning the facet of a jewel so that suddenly out of nowhere and for no reason we, you know, we’ve been looking for our glasses all these years and we find that we’re wearing them.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah.

 

Bart Marshall: And it’s this very subtle… It’s not subtle, it’s a sledgehammer, but it’s so ordinary. It’s, “Oh my God, yes!” You know, it’s this huge forehead slap kind of a thing that, “Oh my God, I’m God. Oh my God, I’m the source of everything. There’s only one awareness and I am it. I am that.” That’s the whole thing. It has nothing to do with anything that the body might do afterwards. That’s the whole thing about awakening. And once that happens I think it’s much easier if you wanted to pursue other things spiritually or otherwise. It becomes easier. The character is not in the way and it’s a faster track to any of these other things that you may want to do with your remaining time on earth. But I personally don’t see anything necessarily preferable about dedicating yourself to these kinds of siddhis that Patanjali was writing about, versus becoming a good gardener or you know … Improving your golf game or something. Improving your golf game or something. Yeah, yeah.

 

Rick Archer: Well I guess one thing that seems to be going on in the spiritual community these days is is that a lot of people are talking about embodiment, and a lot of people who maybe woke up some years ago are saying, “Okay, that was great, but now how do I live this as a human being?” And there seem to be certain shortcomings in relative life that need to be addressed. Adyashanti and A. H. Almaas had this nice talk out at the Science and Nonduality Conference, and they were kind of both in agreement that in a way awakening can be considered the beginning, You know, that’s when the game really gets started. Of course, from the perspective of not having awakening, it seems like an end point, but from their perspective, having awakened some years ago, they’re looking at it now as having really been the launch pad for further refinement and unfoldment and so on. And that seems to be becoming more and more relevant to people these days, and there are a number of talks and panel discussions at the conference about that.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, it’s absolutely true. You know, I say, on the one hand, awakening is game over, but at the same time a new game begins and I think that it’s not until that discovery of that which you truly are happens that spiritual work can really begin. And you now are of use. You’re now not in the way of whatever the Divine wants to do. You know, what hands but these does the Divine have to work with and you may and you are now available because you have no resistance to what’s asked and nothing may be asked but one thing that I can pretty much guarantee anyone that will be asked is that the remaining rough edges of the character are going to be tested and burned and that life Life does not get easier after awakening, it gets funnier and you have no real attachment to how things go. I mean yes, I’d much rather be rich than poor, but if I’m supposed to be poor then so be it. And it’s not really until after awakening that you can say those kinds of things from the the heart and know that whatever happens happens and that’s the way it’s supposed to be and that you know you’re now can be of service even though there’s nothing really that needs to be served you know who’s serving who, who’s teaching who, you know we’re all just dummies sitting in the dark saying are we dummies and there’s nothing really to be done and yet something seems to be asked. You know, there’s a divine momentum that needs to be fulfilled in some way and until you stop working, until you get out of your own way, you can’t really be of service to that. You just keep stumbling over things and get caught up in your underwear and you know you’re all about your little self and once that’s gone, now something can really start to happen, but in conjunction with that it’s not a free ride, it’s not an easy ride necessarily, you know, things will be in conflict with maybe what your preferences are.

 

Rick Archer: That was a nice little wrap there. I like, what was that phrase you used, a divine momentum, I like that phrase. I kind of sense and resonate with people who describe that as really being the ultimate governing force that drives the universe, and there’s this sort of evolutionary momentum, like the universe is one big evolution machine. And as you just said, if you have awakened then you become a much more potent servant of that force, much potentially potent, but if you’ve still got a lot of rough edges, they’ve got to be smoothed off. And I know some people discuss the idea of smoothing most of them off before awakening and others say, “Well, because it could be a pretty rough ride if you haven’t done so,” or you could actually be a rather irresponsible jerk and yet have a lot of influence on people and get caught up in your ego again if there hasn’t been a certain degree of refinement and purification before awakening.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, there’s a certain amount of that I think is probably good to become somewhat of a better person along the way, there’s no harm in it, but I think there’s also a danger in making that your path, trying to…

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, as we discussed earlier, yeah.

 

Bart Marshall: you know, trying to polish the turd, you know, instead of just see past it. So you don’t want to…there are some things…I characterize it as if there are things that are truly…things about your character that are truly in the way of your path, then certainly those need to be addressed. But these sort of extraneous, nice-to-have qualities, you know, we’d all like to be super Bart or super Rick or whatever, you know, and the pursuit of that isn’t really in the service of an awakening.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, well I guess one final thought on this point might be that once you’re out of the way, I think you used that phrase, it’s not really in your hands anymore in terms of things getting smoothed out or not. I mean, have you found in your own experience and in observing others that once awakening has occurred then you know nature or the divine or whatever is going to put you through the ringer to whatever extent it wants to in whatever ways it wants to in order to make you a more fit servant of that evolutionary impulse.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, it’s going to happen. So I mean I can only speak for myself.

 

Rick Archer: So what ways were you put through the ringer?

 

Bart Marshall: Well I would say that there were stages, you know, and I shouldn’t say that it’s just going to happen right off the bat or anything, but because for maybe the first month I would say, you know, literally nothing else was going on but the joy of being, you know, I literally was just lost in the joy of self. And then gradually that honeymoon period gave way to life coming back in and saying, “Well, Well, things need to be attended to and you know the momentum of you know Bart’s character and Bart’s life started coming back in but really for the first year or so there was no challenges to it and I even had the thought you know a very conscious thought of I wonder how this holds up when life’s not going as well as it’s going for me right now and lo and behold you know things started falling apart and my parents both died within six months of each other and my teacher died, Richard Rose died, and just there’s other things in relationships and friendships and different kinds of things in your life that were stable before became unstable. And so, okay, so it’s time to let go. It’s just things need to be streamlined. sort of one might say you know throwing the sandbags out of the hot air balloon or something and so the life that you had going into it may not be the life that’s suited to what the Divine has in mind for you afterwards. So you need to be prepared for some things to get thrown overboard.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I’m kind of thinking the way this is going that you know maybe we won’t go into great detail on your personal story because there’s a lot of interesting stuff to talk talk about, and you told that story on your interview with Conscious TV with Ian McNay and everything, and a number of other occasions, so people could also watch that. But just in a real quick nutshell, you were in Vietnam, you got kind of knocked out by a mortar round and you went into this blackness and it made you realize that there was, you know, another dimension to life, it was sort of a near-death experience and that kind of kick-started your seeking and your seeking went on for many, many years, and you know, Richard Rose, and then you eventually … I’m telling the story real fast here for you.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, thank you.

 

Rick Archer: Then you flew over to England and spent some time with Douglas Harding, just a long weekend or something, and on the plane on the way home, you had an awakening, you had your awakening. So maybe let’s pick it up from there, but we throw this word about so much, “awakening,” everybody’s talking about their awakening, and I’m not entirely sure that everyone means the same thing or understands the same thing when they hear the word. So exactly what happened on that plane and maybe we can fast forward to now and what your moment to moment experience is as a “awakened person,” and of course the person doesn’t get awakened, I don’t know if you can explain all that.

 

Bart Marshall: Right. Well, there’s a lot of territory there. First of all, I think I’m tempted to say something about just the word “awakening” and “awake” or whatever. I wish there was a better word. I mean, “enlightenment” is not good either. Enlightenment kind of sounds like you’ve been knighted or something. Awakening is, I think it’s been used for, I think, some time in the past, you know, 10 years ago or 15 years ago or whatever, it had some power. But I think it’s just become so overused that it means so many different things to so many different people I think and quite honestly there’s a lot of people going out there saying they woke up and I’m not so sure. I don’t know what they’re really talking about. You know I listen to some people try to talk about it and I’m saying well you know. I mean from my perspective if somebody says they’re done, they’re done. I got no questions for them because I have no criteria that I try to measure by for anybody. I say, “Oh okay, well congratulations. You get to not be a seeker anymore, there’s a lot of benefit in that.

 

Rick Archer: Oh, I must say I’ve met people who say they’re done, whom I feel maybe haven’t quite even started.

 

Bart Marshall: I couldn’t agree more, but I’m not going to quibble with them. Yeah. Oh, okay, well, you’re done. They’re done, find out. Yeah, you don’t need to talk to me then, you know, that’s one less person I need to talk to. So I don’t criticize or anything, but I think there is a lot of that out there now. So anyway, all that to say that I’m not so sure what that word means anymore when to even use it. But what happened on the plane to me, there’s a buildup to it and I won’t go through the story there at the workshop or the other parts of it you’ve touched on about the path, but on the plane itself…

 

Rick Archer: There was one thing that happened to you though, just beforehand when you were with Douglas Harding as you were I guess in your last encounter with him or something, he very intensely said to you, “Simplify.” And when you tell that story I kind of get the feeling there was some kind of a Shaktipat or something in his doing that, some sort of … he knocked something loose, you know, it wasn’t the word even so much as it was the intensity of his interaction with you and his intention, it kind of jarred something at a deep level.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, I agree, I mean it’s only in retrospect that I can kind of go back and look at it and make a statement about it like that. But Harding was such a warm and personable person. He made me feel like, he even said, I feel like when I first met him, he said, “I feel like I’ve known you my whole life,” and I think he did that with everybody. He just was so warm. He just made you feel like you were his brother or his long lost son or something. And so we were in the the midst of that kind of a goodbye and then he just sort of stiffened up and in this incredibly powerful voice for especially for a 95 year old man you know said “SIMPLIFY!” and you know I took a couple of steps back and that was literally I don’t think I said anything else you know I went back to my room we were in a an old seminary there in Salisbury England and I went back to my room and about a half hour later erupted in a huge uber surrender cry that I think was very precipitous to what happened the next day.

 

Rick Archer: Which was uncharacteristic of you, right?

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah.

 

Rick Archer: You weren’t like the weepy type.

 

Bart Marshall: Not really, not really. I mean I’m a fairly sensitive guy but you know that was uncharacteristic. And after it was over and for the rest of the day and evening, I even took some notes about it that I was done. I was no longer a seeker. I was actually felt apologetic to God or whoever, you know, I felt like a real wretch that, you know, I’d been given this wonderful life and all I’d asked for was more, and I apologized for asking for a truth and enlightenment and said, “I’m done, you know, don’t worry about me, you’re not going to hear from me on this subject anymore, and and whatever this is, is great. I just am so grateful for what I already have, and I don’t care to have more. And I really think if nothing had happened the next day, I would be living very happily with that as the final, you know, okay, it didn’t happen, but I’m no longer looking. And but then the next day that which was surrendered was given. And on the plane, my encapsulation of what you know what it was, was being immersed in the truth of that I am the source of all that is, quite literally. There is nothing else going on in the universe except this awareness and this source that manifests all that is, and I am that. And my little elevator speech I guess you could say was that you know for however many years I had always mistakenly identified this awareness as belonging to Bart and that everybody else that I saw in this externally manifested world had a similar awareness and that it was and would die with the body. And, but no, that was a small, but very powerful misconception that that awareness, which I’ve always known, is the only awareness and it’s God awareness, doesn’t belong to Bart or anybody else. It’s the only awareness. And whatever is manifesting within that awareness, within that single eye of awareness is all that is going on in the entire universe. nothing else is happening.

 

Rick Archer: And obviously you’re using words and concepts to explain that to us, and you had already been familiar with such words and concepts having read a thousand books, but what you’re doing here is trying to describe the actual experience.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, you’re not just philosophizing with us.

 

Bart Marshall: No, no, everything was self-evident. I mean everything was absolutely self-evident. There was all questions disappeared. Well, didn’t disappear, the possibility of having a question even disappear.

 

Rick Archer: Sorry.

 

Bart Marshall: That’s all right. But there’s… everything was just, one might say, laid out before me as, you know, as absolutely self-evident. And… and there was more weeping actually on the airplane. Fortunately, there wasn’t… there wasn’t anybody anywhere near me, not just not sitting near me, but it was a fairly empty airplane even though it was a big jumbo jet.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, these days you can’t get away with that.

 

Bart Marshall: I know.

 

Rick Archer: Sorry for people who wake up on airplanes now, they’re going to just have to…

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, you’re going to have to deal with it. The stewardess kind of came by between episodes, you know, she never really came by when I was in the throes of anything, but it just seemed to wave in and out for me. It didn’t happen all at once, it happened, it came and went over a period of I don’t know how long.

 

Rick Archer: Why do you think the weeping happened?

 

Bart Marshall: Well it was just, I think one of the things that I wrote I just felt that I had been, it was love in the most extreme use of the word. I felt that I had just been crushed to dust by love and blessings and there was nothing left, but that was literally, I mean talk about cliches, you know, God is love. I mean that realizing that you are God, that you are the source of all that is, the experience of that is excruciating, all-encompassing, a love beyond anything that language can ever touch and the body’s response was weeping.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah. Was it just on the plane or how did you go through a period, and maybe still go through where there’s just a tenderness, an emotional tenderness which can give rise to tears. Like for instance, I have a friend who said that after he woke up he really couldn’t go to public movie theaters because he would cry so readily, even in scenes where the other people weren’t inclined to cry, but they would just touch him in a way that made him cry a lot.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, I know, I really resonate with that. The world becomes incredibly poignant, just the general poignancy of existence is so apparent and heart-wrenching really. I don’t think I originated this but I think someone else said it, but after you wake up be prepared to live with a broken heart. And not broken heart in the sense of a failed relationship or something, but in the sense that it’s broken wide open and totally vulnerable to everything. You have no defenses against anything anymore, you’re absolutely undefended and everything gets in. You know all of these emotions and all the poignancy of the world and talking about compassion earlier you know that’s it comes with the territory, you can’t help but be empathetic and compassionate because everything gets in and everything is you. And so daily life is, I wouldn’t quite say it’s a battle against tears, but tears or the feeling that produces tears is much closer to the surface all the time.

 

Rick Archer: And yet you’re not weak, you’re not overshadowed. It’s not like you’re in some kind of emotional mess. there’s a kind of an oceanic foundation to it, is there not? Well, you know, I mean the analogy Maharishi used to use is that a small pond can’t really rise up in big waves, it will only stir up the mud at the bottom, but the ocean can rise up in tidal waves because it has the depth and the capacity to do that.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, yeah, it doesn’t… there’s no superficial emotional manifestations associated with it. You’re totally functional and maybe even more so, you know, you could be feeling, you know, great compassion and empathy for someone and then operate in a very normal or even heightened way if there’s a situation required it. It doesn’t have anything to do with being incapacitated by it. you’d be highly effective at the same time. So it’s not like that.

 

Rick Archer: So that was what, 2006 or something you said?

 

Bart Marshall: 2004.

 

Rick Archer: So 10 years ago.

 

Bart Marshall: Yes.

 

Rick Archer: So we talked earlier about maybe awakening is just the beginning and you know things really kick in after that. So what’s been going on for the last 10 years?

 

Bart Marshall: Well I was going to a part of what I was doing as a seeker, I was going to weekly meetings which were just some friends, some close friends we used to get together for dinner because you can’t talk about this stuff you know in your normal job and that sort of thing. And so when you find some fellows you go out of your way to create a situation where you can talk about this stuff and share some things. So we had a few friends and then we got tired of going to dinners and having dinner every time. So we started meeting at somebody’s house. So there was this little group that we had and someone else in the group, a friend of mine, woke up during the time that we were having these meetings. And that was one of my first, I mentioned earlier about when my friends started waking up, it put my feet to the fire. And so when Bob woke up, that was part of what was happening. And then sometime later, I think it was maybe four or five years later that I woke up, and Bob had since left the group and moved to another town. And so when I woke up, there was this very small group that was already meeting once a week. And so essentially all I did was not stop going. But now I had this different perspective that I could bring to the table. So as I talked about that, you know, gradually the group grew and we got more people and became known as my group or whatever. And next thing I knew people were talking about me as a teacher and I just felt like it was something that sort of evolved and I… it wasn’t anything that I really wanted to get into necessarily. I remember being so impressed and so filled with admiration for how Rose conducted himself because he was so committed to this. He was the quintessential teacher, was his whole life. And I assumed that when one woke up, that’s what happened, it came with the package, that you just had this compulsion to pass it on. And that didn’t really happen for me. And so, you know, people sometimes call me the reluctant guru or something, because it you know, it wasn’t something that I was naturally attracted to. But I feel like it’s one of these things when you’re asked, how can you say no? And so you just do what you can do when you’re asked to do it and that sort of thing. So for a lot of years, until a year or two ago, I was doing these weekly meetings as well as some talks. You know, you’ve quoted from … we talked about some talks. I do a TAT and other places that I’d be invited.

 

Rick Archer: What is TAT? I kept hearing a reference to that.

 

Bart Marshall: Culadasa It stands for Truth and Transmission, which is the group that Rose left. So they’re still in …

 

Rick Archer: They have little conferences or something?

 

Bart Marshall: Yup, have four conferences a year, still a very viable group and it’s a foundation. Rose left an organization that was hopefully going to continue his work after he was gone. And to a great degree, TAT has and has been able to do that, although it’s really difficult when as you know, in any group, when the teacher goes, it’s hard to hold things together. Sure. TAT’s doing a great job of that.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, where do they have those conferences?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, they used to have them at Rose’s Farm near Wheeling, West Virginia, but that farm has since been inherited by his daughter and they no longer have them there. So they alternate between two places, one is Penn Scenic View in Pennsylvania and the other is Claremont, which is a mansion in Northern Virginia.

 

Rick Archer: Okay, just curious. So you just gave us an answer to that question about what’s been happening in the last ten years in terms of your activities.

 

Bart Marshall: In terms of teaching, yeah.

 

Rick Archer: But in terms of your subjective experience and development, such as it may be, what’s been going on in that realm?

 

Bart Marshall: Well I think one way of encapsulating it would be to say that Bart the character has been in a state of dissolution.

 

Rick Archer: More and more and more and more?

 

Bart Marshall: More, yes.

 

Rick Archer: Okay.

 

Bart Marshall: And events in his life and events in my life have been conspiring to thin that character more and more and more. It’s a process of realizing that you don’t have to… there is no doer. You know that, you feel that, and yet there’s this momentum that keeps you thinking you need to do things and you need to make decisions and you need to have opinions and you need to have preferences and the process is to disabuse you of that notion. No, you don’t need to do any of that. Get out of the way even more and those aspects of character that still sort of insist upon itself in some way are the circumstances of life will say no, you know, you don’t need to be that way anymore. Take a break, relax.

 

Rick Archer: So there’s no doer and there’s no essentially no Bart but if the Bart character stubs his toe on the bedstead in the middle of the night…

 

Bart Marshall: He curses like hell.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, somehow the pain is localized, it’s not off on the moon some place or something.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh no, as I often say, nothing really changes for the character in a lot of ways. The same preferences and desires are there, things that make you angry still make you angry, you may get angry a lot less and take more to perturb you or whatever, but none of the wiring gets cut. You wouldn’t want it to be. You don’t become this, you know, I want to characterize, you don’t become this, you know, generic sage that is unmoved by anything or something, whatever we might imagine going in, you know, “Life is going to be easy and I’ll never be disturbed by anything again,” or something like that. It’s nothing like that. You know all of those things are still in place and all the wiring is still there and you even I would say experience emotional and other things probably more so.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, like you said with the open heart.

 

Bart Marshall: With the open heart, right, and so all of that’s you know I mean if the occasion calls for anger you know you get angry as hell and you know if you get cut you bleed and all of those sorts of things. So really on that level nothing changes except that the… I think the whole process is towards dissolution. I don’t think final dissolution happens while the body’s alive because without some semblance of character remaining you can’t interact with the world. And so that has to be… something of that has to be in place as long as the body lives. But I think the process after awakening, we’ll go back to that word, the process after awakening is the dissolution and the thinning of that character to where it becomes thinner and thinner and more vaporous.

 

Rick Archer: You may have heard the term “lesha avidya” which means “faint remains of ignorance” which is said, like you just said, is essential for any sort of living to take place. there has to be some recognition of limitations and boundaries and objects and whatnot or else you’d just be some kind of amorphous blob that couldn’t function.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, what was that phrase again?

 

Rick Archer: Lesha avidya. You know how vidya means ignorance? Yeah. Or vidya means knowledge, avidya means ignorance. So lesha avidya would mean faint remains of ignorance.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, okay, that’s a good phrase.

 

Rick Archer: So what is the … well, speaking in terms of some utilitarian value, what is the advantage of the thinning of the character? Why does nature conspire to continually thin the character more and more? Why is that the evolutionary direction that life seems to be going in?

 

Bart Marshall: I don’t know. I have no answers to why questions.

 

Rick Archer: But in terms of the utility in your life, the way your life is lived, you know, how is it, let’s say, lived more heartfully or skillfully or something, in some way, now versus 10 years ago just after your awakening? If you were to snap back to 10 years ago right now, what kind of contrast would you notice in terms of the way you function and interact with others and so on?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, you know it’s interesting because I’m trying to snap back and one of the things that happens upon awakening is that immediately everything, all past and future and present, everything becomes exactly the same. As soon as you wake up, let’s say, if you want to call it that, as soon as you wake up everything is the way it’s always been. “Oh, it’s always been this way.” So when you talk about snapping back, I’m only dealing with memories of stories of Bart at another age or in another time. I can’t connect with the feelings of that time. What I can say about how it is now, I don’t think there’s, just speaking for myself off the cuff right now, I don’t think there’s any utility to it. It’s just the way it is. I suppose you know if there was something that was more beneficial about being awake than not being awake it would be imperturbability or you’re not constantly thinking that you need to be doing something. And it’s actually there’s a loss that takes place that you know as Debra my wife says the notion of a passionate life is lost, ambition and the desire to be a great something or another or to write with great fervor and things like that, that’s a sacrifice, those things leave and so it’s a trade-off, I’d have to say it’s a trade-off and I say I’m not an evangelist for it, if just knowing the truth and just becoming truth isn’t enough for you, then probably this isn’t the path you need to get into. You know it’s not really good for anything. That which you truly are could care less about, you know, waking up. As you said earlier, the light is always shining and the only benefit is to the small self which may acquire some sort of smoothness of life. And well absence of fear is one, you’re no longer afraid of anything. Not in the…I mean you still have the flight or fight animal fear, there can be you know the startle instinct and all those sorts of things, but the recreational fear of imagining a precarious future of some kind and responding in the present as if it was the truth, all of that is gone and you live in great faith, capital F faith, there is never any doubt that all is well and you experience life as the source of all that is. It becomes laughable sometimes you know and there’s this closeness with this intimacy, there’s a great intimacy with what is. is. You’re not removed from it anymore, you’re not standing apart from it. That’s of course the catchphrase is separation and that’s what’s gone is that sense of separation is no longer there. And so there’s this great intimacy with all that is rather than being just focused so much on the concerns of the character and worried about you know what’s going to happen to the character and is he going to get his way and is he going to get hurt and you know who does he need to get even with and all of those sorts of things. All of that is gone and one of the biggest things that’s gone is you don’t have to be a seeker anymore, and that’s a great unburdening.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, well I mean a lot of people over a lot of years have made a big fuss about this whole enlightenment thing. This whole culture is dedicated to it and traditions and you yourself have dedicated your life to it to greater and greater degrees. So, you don’t want to trivialize it and say, “Eh, no big deal, maybe it’s of some value to the individual.” It seems to me, from my perspective, it’s still kind of the most significant thing one could be interested in life or aspire to or hope to “achieve.” And like you were saying, it’s a very personal thing, but I And like you were saying earlier, you know, you found yourself, well firstly you found yourself being a catalyst for others’ awakening, so if awakening is a worthwhile thing to have happen then the fact that you’re able to trigger it in others is good. But also, you know, as you were saying earlier, if there is this sort of divine momentum or whatever you called it, that kind of drives the universe, then it’s no small matter when someone actually fully comes on board as a servant of that that divine momentum. It’s like, you know, “Hey boys, we’ve got a live one here, let’s give them more juice.”

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, no, I absolutely agree and as you say, you know, I’ve dedicated most of my life to it and I don’t mean to trivialize it in any way. You know, for those that have the tendency, I highly recommend it and go through it and see it through to the end. There’s also some truth that old Zen saying is, you know, better not to start, but if you start better to finish, because there’s no penalty for not waking up. You don’t go go to hell or anything and you know that which truly is does not judge anything in the manifest universe. There is no right or wrong, there is no good or bad, you’re not a bad person if you don’t want to be enlightened or you know they’re really you know some of the… I look around in the world and see what has… see the personages that have manifested that what I I think of them as avatars, people who were just born to be exactly what they were. You know like Muhammad Ali is an avatar of boxing, you know, and I would no more try to make…

 

Rick Archer: Clapton is an avatar of guitar.

 

Bart Marshall: Exactly, and you just don’t go around saying, “Oh, you’re doing the wrong thing, you should really want truth at all costs,” or something.

 

Rick Archer: In fact people used to show up at Clapton concerts with signs saying, “Clapton is God.”

 

Bart Marshall: Right, and they’re right, as is the person who is holding the sign.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, so we all have our dharmas.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, right, and as God, as the source of all that is, I see truth and beauty in everything, in all of the suffering, in every manifestation that there is, in the greatest achievements and the greatest failures, you know, everything is woven of the same cloth and that cloth is emptiness.

 

Rick Archer: Would it be metaphysical speculation to surmise that there will come a time in the course of evolution at which Muhammad Ali will be on the doorstep of awakening as you’ve been in this lifetime and be keenly interested in it, or wouldn’t you go there in terms of speculating the way the universe works.

 

Bart Marshall: I don’t think that, you know, I think the idea of reincarnation is very attractive to the character, to an individual who thinks he’s a separate self and wants to continue in some way as a separate self beyond death and get a still be the same separate self with a different body and hopefully a better one that achieves more greatness in some way. But I don’t think that, and here I can’t speak with authority on this, but that which you truly are could care less about things like that. It’s something that appeals to the human mind, “Oh, I’m miserable now but I’ll be better later in the next life,” or “I’m miserable now but when I die I’ll go to heaven,” and I’m not saying believe or disbelieve any of that, I’m just saying mistrust those things that are attractive to the mind.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, but it also may be the way the universe works. I ran into a friend the other day down at the hospital and his wife was not doing too well and we got to talking about death and what happens after you die and so on. He said, “I don’t believe in reincarnation,” and I didn’t want to get into a debate with him because he was also gloating over the recent Republican victory and I had my feelings about that. But afterwards I thought, “Well, you know, I might have said to him if I wanted to get into a discussion, ‘It doesn’t really matter what we believe, does it? I mean there’s a certain mechanics to the way nature functions which does just fine whether or not we understand or agree with it. I mean gravity did its thing long before Sir Isaac Newton came along.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh yeah, yeah. I mean that which you truly are could care less what your character believes, and has no sway whatsoever except over the experience of the character. Beliefs will define your life and will limit you and will be obstacles to truth. And so as we were talking about earlier, neither accept nor reject belief or disbelief, hold to that line of indifference about all things and doubt everything. Believe nothing and doubt everything and that way you leave yourself open, most vulnerable to grace.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, when you say believe nothing and doubt everything, do you believe and I mean do you disbelieve and doubt in equal measure with regard to all things or do you find that you know certain things are higher on your credibility scale than others?

 

Bart Marshall: No, I think that everything, there is nothing about the manifest world that’s true. So as soon as you start talking about the different levels of story and the different possibilities of belief and the different concept structures that we weigh against each other and try to decide which has more or less possibility of being true, they’re all equally true and they’re all equally untrue. And I think it’s a fool’s errand to spend a whole lot of time trying to sift through it when you really want to what you want to do is just cut the Gordian knot, go straight for it, go straight for the go full speed for the place where all questions disappear. Don’t spend a lot of time trying to answer all these thousands of questions. It’s one of the things that I you know the Eastern religions and traditions you know I love them to death and I did that book and they have great power and they’ve produced a lot of people that have discovered that which they truly are but also some aspects of them can be very complex and convoluted and I think just invite people to get lost in them rather than cut through it all and you know in Christianity is the same way. My most recent book that’s coming out soon is called Christ Sutras and it compiles everything Jesus ever said from all sources and puts them into sermons topic sermons 42 sermons and when you put everything when you get Christianity out of the way one thing I like to say about why I did that was to rescue Christ’s words from Christianity. But when you get the dogma out of the way and the complexity out of the way and just go straight for it, you know Christ has beautiful teachings about non-duality and enlightenment, but the church does not. You have to really, really dig for it to get through a whole lot of crap before you get to where the nuggets are. So in that book I’ve tried to put Christ’s teachings on the table in a very readable and digestible way. I think that’s the same with all traditions, you know, they just get so caught up in trying to explain things and make concepts out of things and that’s just not the way to go.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, what you just said reminds me of something that Buddha was reputed to have said, which is that, you know, if you’re shot with an arrow, you don’t sit there thinking, “I wonder what kind of wood this is, and are these duck feathers or chicken feathers?” You know, it’s like you just want to get the arrow out.

 

Bart Marshall: Exactly. Yeah.

 

Rick Archer: When Richard Rose, well, I don’t know, I want to avoid getting us back into speculation land, but as Richard Rose got Alzheimer’s and deteriorated in his ability to function, did you get the sense that his essential realization was progressively clouded and lost, or do you Do you think that realization once achieved is untouchable by whatever happens to the body?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, realization isn’t achieved and it doesn’t happen to…

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, no, poor choice of words.

 

Bart Marshall: I know, I know, I know. No, no, I’m not, I wasn’t picking you up on your words because I do that all the time. Yeah,

 

Rick Archer: it’s hard to not talk in English.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, we’re stuck with language and literally talking in words and writing. Everything obfuscates; they don’t elucidate, you know, they get in the way. No, it doesn’t have anything to do with any of that. It was a real conundrum for me when it first happened because obviously I wasn’t awake at the time and I thought, “How can an enlightened man who often said, ‘I live to think, others live to eat, I live to think, or others live to live, I live to think,’ so an enlightened man who said he lived to think loses his mind. What does this mean?”

 

Rick Archer: What’s happening in his subjective experience as his mind is being lost, is you know this awakening thing that we make such a big fuss of, is that being lost or is there some is that somehow untouched in his deepest level of experience even though his ability to communicate or express it might be degrading?

 

Bart Marshall: It’s untouched in his deepest level of experience, not his deepest level of experience, but that which underlies all experience is untouched by anything that happens in the mind or the body. That solid ground of being is unmoved, different to everything that transpires on the surface of it.

 

Rick Archer: And it always has been. So would you say perhaps that even though the sun is shining just fine, whether or not there are clouds and it’s from … I don’t know if I want to go over the metaphor here or not, but would you say that once … let’s put it this way, is a physical vehicle needed for awakening to occur, such as happened with you, and once it has occurred, and again occurred is a bad word, but once awakening has taken place, is it sort of rock solid regardless of what happens to the physical vehicle thereafter? Well, we’re talking about liberation essentially. Is liberation something which once, pardon the word, is achieved, is never lost regardless of what happens in the relative sphere?

 

Bart Marshall: The short answer is yes.

 

Rick Archer: Are you sure about that?

 

Bart Marshall: Yes. Okay. I would go back to the beginning of what you said before I forget it, and we said, “Is a physical vehicle needed for awakening?” I would say a physical vehicle is necessary for ignorance and sleep. So it’s because of this physical vehicle, which was … I mean there’s probably great reasons for it. I mean, like I said, I don’t answer why questions are speculated about concepts and metaphysics and things like that, but you know, what the character is really, really good at is experience. The Divine, the solid ground of being, that which you truly are, has no qualities, no capacities, no senses, no nothing. It just is. And so it needs, let us put it in these kinds of words, it needs physical vehicles in order to experience, in order to create, to manifest, and to experience and enjoy. Deborah my wife talks about you know that life is a satellite, we’re satellites sending back data and experience to the divine. That’s what we do.

 

Rick Archer: Sensors of the infinite, as my friend likes to say.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah exactly, and so that’s what we do and that’s what we’re good at, but in order to to really take it seriously and send back really juicy, dramatic tidbits of data and experience, we have to be ignorant of the true game, we have to be ignorant of what we’re doing, so that we’re really so caught up in it that it’s just everything what seems to be appearing to us and we’re interacting in such a way that gives the Divine really juicy stories or whatever you want.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, it’s kind of like a movie wouldn’t be very much fun if you were predominantly aware of the whole time, “It’s just a movie, I don’t care.” Right, exactly. It’s like you really want to get into it.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, exactly. And I like that there was a movie called The Game with Michael Douglas that I really enjoy and I think has a lot of spiritual implications, especially the fact that the part where as long as he thought it was a game, he was indifferent and unmoved by what was happening, but at some point that turned and his brother said, “No, it’s no longer a game, you know, these guys are really out to get us, out to get you and everything,” and everything turned. Then it got really serious. It turned out it was still a game, but he didn’t know that at that point. And so anyway, long way around to talk about something which I may have already forgot what the question was.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, about liberation and whether it matters what happens to the body once it’s achieved.

 

Bart Marshall: Right, so the body is necessary to be asleep and to experience and all that sort of thing.

 

Rick Archer: But the body is also necessary for this Divine Consciousness to be a living reality.

 

Bart Marshall: Yes.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, I mean, you know, and there’s all kinds of interesting … you talk about bringing data back, I mean there’s all kinds of interesting possibilities for experience once awakening is established that just aren’t there beforehand.

 

Bart Marshall: And so we can talk about that and we can say yeah, so you wake up and now you’re of more as we were talking about earlier, you’re of more use to the Divine and we might say higher ways or more powerful structures opened up to you or something, but it’s still interacting within an illusory manifestation. Still not the truth itself. And so again I don’t want to trivialize it in any way but in acting as an enlightened teacher in an illusory world is really no more elevated than in acting as a basketball player in an illusory world. These are just things that happen within manifestation and the Divine love it all.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, you’re just serving a different function.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah. Interesting. It’s fun to play with this stuff. For me anyway.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah.

 

Rick Archer: I mean it’s fun to ponder these kinds of questions.

 

Bart Marshall: Oh, absolutely. Yeah. And that’s one of the things that I noticed about, I was talking about that initial honeymoon period when I didn’t read, I was just enjoying being and and all that sort of thing and just kind of spaced through life. But then as the momentum of Bart’s life came back, that’s what started happening on this level of spiritual work was the mind wanted to get engaged and try to think things through about it and to explain things and to be as well if I was going to put I know words aren’t going to do it but if I was going to really find the best words I could what would they be and what about this and what about that, and so the mind starts getting engaged in it and that’s what we’re talking about now, the stuff that the mind can do when it gets engaged in it, but we’re still removed from the thing itself. But it’s great stuff and I love doing it and when I teach and when Debra and I give our retreats and seminars and stuff, I really find it really enjoyable, just in the moment talking to people who are really engaged and who really want to talk about this stuff. We do a lot of guided self-inquiry in a group setting and really get into people’s personal paths and that sort of thing. And I find that it’s just you know everything is engaged, my mind is engaged, my body is engaged, whatever you might call it, the spiritual component is fully engaged. And there’s a silence, that ground of being that’s always there comes to the fore and becomes part of the manifestation because of that particular environment, something about it, the dynamics of that interaction, you know, it calls the energy into the fore. And so, you know, I love doing it, you know, and it’s going on.

 

Rick Archer: I know what you mean. So, it gets you firing on all cylinders.

 

Bart Marshall: Exactly.

 

Rick Archer: And that’s very gratifying. Yeah. Well, boy, I’ve got all kinds of notes here and I marked all kinds of passages in your book with a yellow marker and we could probably easily spend the next two hours, you know, me throwing out passages and you talking about them and probably also saying, “I don’t know, I don’t do commentary, I just But we’ve covered a lot of good stuff I think and given people an opportunity to get to know you and get to know what you’re all about. So you were just alluding to retreats that you and Debra teach, is that mostly in the Raleigh area or you travel around or what?

 

Bart Marshall: Well, that’s an evolving thing. We just got back from doing one in Ireland and we kind of go back and forth on how active we want to be and how much of our life we want this to be. And we’re sort of settling in on a schedule where we would do anywhere from four to six a year, some of them in Raleigh, some somewhere else.

 

Rick Archer: So if somebody invites you to Alaska or Costa Rica or someplace and they say we have a pretty good sized group together, you come down.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, exactly. That gets to the idea of saying “yes” when asked. You just get a feeling that, “Oh, this is the Divine asking and so I’m going to say Yes. You know, this is the one that we need to do.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah. Well, you may experience the bat gap bump. People say there’s quite a bump sometimes.

 

Bart Marshall: Well, you guys are doing great work and I’m really impressed with your operation and it’s wonderful talking to you.

 

Rick Archer: Well, it’s like you were just saying, you know, when I do this I feel like I’m firing on all cylinders and it’s just a lot of fun and very fulfilling and it seems very meaningful and valuable and useful and we get great feedback from people and the impact that it has on some people’s lives is quite remarkable sometimes.

 

Bart Marshall: Yeah, I can imagine, yeah, I know that you know when I was seeking I was just turning over every rock and there wasn’t this kind of material available then and I just can’t imagine how rich it must be to have all this available now the internet and with you and Conscious TV and all the resources there are now, it’s amazing.

 

Rick Archer: Yeah, it’s just really fun to be part of it. So I guess I’ll make a few wrap-up points then. I’ve been speaking with Bart Marshall, as you probably know by now, and Bart has a website which I’ll be linking to from batgap.com, and if you go there you’ll be able to see what he’s got to offer. There’s a lot of audio recordings there, you mentioned the satsangs you used to do, and you can download those off of his site. I’ve been listening to some, there’s a lot of good stuff in them, and it’s all free. You probably have some kind of email newsletter people can sign up for to be notified of things?

 

Bart Marshall: Well all of this, I’ve never been very good about the promotional part. The website is way back level and out of date and actually a friend is creating a better website for us now. We’ll probably move things over there and get a lot more organized about this. We say, well, if we’re gonna do it, we might as well be organized and have a fairly decent web presence. So we’re sort of in transition along those lines. But yeah, for the last year or so that we were teaching, we were doing the weekly meetings, were recorded and those are available on the site.

 

Rick Archer: Good. All right, so what’s that website?

 

Bart Marshall: Selfinquiry.org.

 

Rick Archer: Okay, no hyphens or anything, just Selfinquiry.org. And again, I’ll be linking to that from batgap.com, from your page, and I’ll be linking to this book on Amazon, so people know what to do. So if this is the first time you’ve listened to one of these, there are over 260 of them now at batgap.com, B-A-T-G-A-P, which is an acronym for Buddha at the Gas Pump. So go there and there’s a past interviews menu, you drop that down, there’s a bunch of different ways they’re organized, and there’s a future interviews menu. There’s a donate button, which there’s no charge for any of this obviously, but I wouldn’t be able to invest the time I do in it if people weren’t donating, so if you feel inclined to do that, please do. There is a place to sign up to be notified by email each time a new interview is posted, you’ll see that menu. And this is also available as an audio podcast, so there’s a link with each interview to the iTunes page where you can subscribe to that. There’s a discussion group that crops up around each interview, and there’s a link to each interview’s discussion area with each one, so you’ll know what to do. You just go to the website and explore and you’ll find all this. So thanks for listening or watching. Next week I believe it’s Tom Campbell who wrote My Big Toe, and I’ve been getting a lot of requests to interview him. In fact, even after he was scheduled, people are still saying, “Interview Tom Campbell.” I say, “Yeah, I’m going to. It’s scheduled.” So that should be interesting. So thanks for listening, see you next time.

 

Unresolved speaker — see review notes: .

 

Non-speech: [MUSIC PLAYING]

 

Unresolved speaker — see review notes: Thank you.

 

Non-speech: [MUSIC PLAYING]

 

Support BatGap

Support BatGap with one-time or monthly donations. BatGap Non-Profit is a tax-exempt 501(c)(3).
 

Subscribe to the Podcast

Choose How You Listen

Recent Interviews:

765. Sarah Walker Ting
764. Roger Linden
763. Carmen Acevedo Butcher
762. Dave Markowitz
761. Monica Khosla

Try the BatGap Bot

Your interactive spiritual companion.

BatGap Bot